Simulator comparisons: BioModels release 9

Summary

TestBioUMLByoDyncopasiCVODEedu.kgi.roadRunnerJarnacjsimOscill8 CoreSBWOdeSolverMathSBMLSBToolbox2VCell
passed:1501491339137728810614313410662
no difference:13613412081156675691341155454
small difference:4251400278382
significant difference:1013801861335211146

Legend:
passed   -  total number of results;
no difference   -  (( x >= min * 0.999 ) and ( x <= max * 1.001 )) or x < ZERO and (min < ZERO || max < ZERO);
small difference   -  (x >= min * 0.5) and (x <= max * 1.5);
significant difference   -  otherwise;

Details

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

TestBioUMLByoDyncopasiCVODEedu.kgi.roadRunnerJarnacjsimOscill8 CoreSBWOdeSolverMathSBMLSBToolbox2VCell
BIOMD0000000001.xml0,000,000,00-98,4--1000,00100--
BIOMD0000000002.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
BIOMD0000000003.xml0,000,000,00-0,00-0,00-0,000,000,000,00
BIOMD0000000004.xml0,000,000,00-0,00-0,00-0,000,000,000,00
BIOMD0000000005.xml0,270,000,00-0,000,00-0,00-0,007,4-
BIOMD0000000006.xml0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,93-
BIOMD0000000007.xml0,001000,00-0,00---0,000,00--
BIOMD0000000008.xml0,000,000,00-0,00-0,00-0,000,000,480,00
BIOMD0000000009.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,00100-0,006,00,000,00
BIOMD0000000010.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
BIOMD0000000011.xml0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,320,003,617,3-
BIOMD0000000012.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,000,47-
BIOMD0000000013.xml0,160,000,000,000,000,000,000,00-0,000,36-
BIOMD0000000014.xml0,000,000,000,000,480,000,00-0,000,008,1-
BIOMD0000000015.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00-
BIOMD0000000016.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,00100,01710,000,000,00-
BIOMD0000000017.xml0,000,000,000,000,00-0,002,95E40,000,000,00-
BIOMD0000000018.xml0,000,370,00-0,00-2,61E54,83E30,000,000,00-
BIOMD0000000020.xml0,000,00--------5,9-
BIOMD0000000021.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,003,80,00
BIOMD0000000022.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,001,3-
BIOMD0000000023.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,002,0-
BIOMD0000000024.xml55,3268--782-0,000,00----
BIOMD0000000025.xml1,03E17---100,0-------
BIOMD0000000026.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,00-0,000,000,420,00
BIOMD0000000027.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,23
BIOMD0000000028.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,000,530,00
BIOMD0000000029.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
BIOMD0000000030.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,000,170,00
BIOMD0000000031.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
BIOMD0000000032.xml0,140,000,00-0,00-0,000,000,280,001,20,00
BIOMD0000000033.xml0,000,000,89-0,000,000,000,000,000,7094,91,11E5
BIOMD0000000034.xml2,16E136,26E14--3,16E3-4,26E7-----
BIOMD0000000035.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,000,13-
BIOMD0000000036.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,00-0,000,001,9-
BIOMD0000000037.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,220,000,000,000,002,00,00
BIOMD0000000038.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
BIOMD0000000039.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,006,1-
BIOMD0000000040.xml0,000,00--0,000,000,001470,001967,18E3-
BIOMD0000000041.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,0093,867,71010,000,00-
BIOMD0000000042.xml0,000,000,00-1,16E39980,000,000,000,000,000,00
BIOMD0000000043.xml0,090,091,3-0,090,090,100,371,70,09448-
BIOMD0000000044.xml0,000,000,41-0,000,000,000,001,80,0026,71,56E3
BIOMD0000000045.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,000,22-
BIOMD0000000046.xml0,000,001,2-0,190,000,000,000,004,83E31,44E40,00
BIOMD0000000047.xml0,070,070,07-0,07-0,0795,20,070,070,80-
BIOMD0000000048.xml0,000,00100-0,000,001002,91E40,000,002,50,00
BIOMD0000000049.xml0,000,001,4-1,10,710,005,11E100,0053,81000,00
BIOMD0000000050.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,00-0,000,000,00-0,00
BIOMD0000000051.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,00-88,70,000,000,000,00
BIOMD0000000052.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,120,000,00-0,00
BIOMD0000000053.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,130,001,250,50,00
BIOMD0000000054.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,007700,000,000,31-
BIOMD0000000055.xml0,000,000,00-0,00---0,000,0025,15,28E9
BIOMD0000000056.xml6781,01E30,00-0,00----0,00--
BIOMD0000000057.xml0,000,000,00-0,00-0,001,10E60,000,000,910,00
BIOMD0000000058.xml0,000,000,00-0,00-0,001000,000,001,30,00
BIOMD0000000059.xml0,000,000,00-0,00-0,00-0,000,000,00-
BIOMD0000000060.xml0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,200,00
BIOMD0000000061.xml0,190,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,0014,10,00
BIOMD0000000062.xml0,000,000,00-0,00-0,002,03E50,000,000,00-
BIOMD0000000063.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,00-0,000,000,00-
BIOMD0000000064.xml0,330,000,00-0,00-0,00-0,000,000,000,00
BIOMD0000000065.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,00-0,000,000,970,00
BIOMD0000000066.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,001,1100
BIOMD0000000067.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,000,280,00
BIOMD0000000068.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,00
BIOMD0000000069.xml0,000,000,00-0,00-0,001230,000,007,735,4
BIOMD0000000070.xml7,80,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00-
BIOMD0000000071.xml0,120,00148-0,000,00--0,000,000,00-
BIOMD0000000072.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,002,73E60,000,000,000,66-
BIOMD0000000073.xml0,000,000,00-0,00---0,000,000,300,00
BIOMD0000000074.xml0,000,000,00-0,00---0,230,0045,00,00
BIOMD0000000075.xml1001000,00-0,00---0,150,00--
BIOMD0000000076.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
BIOMD0000000077.xml0,000,000,00-2,0--0,002,20,001,4-
BIOMD0000000078.xml5,22E111000,00-0,00---0,000,00-0,00
BIOMD0000000079.xml0,000,000,00-0,00---0,000,006,50,00
BIOMD0000000080.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,001000,00
BIOMD0000000081.xml0,000,001,44E3-0,00---1,30,002,33E3-
BIOMD0000000082.xml0,130,000,12-0,000,000,000,730,002,06E53,90,00
BIOMD0000000083.xml5,22E111000,00-0,00---0,230,00-0,13
BIOMD0000000084.xml0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,001,3-
BIOMD0000000085.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,00-1750,009,41,58E30,00
BIOMD0000000086.xml0,000,001,25E3-1090,00-5,12E40,0087,11,58E30,00
BIOMD0000000087.xml0,001003,3-75,8--0,000,001,84E4--
BIOMD0000000088.xml0,000,000,00-90,0---0,000,00--
BIOMD0000000089.xml0,000,000,00-0,00---0,000,0016,90,00
BIOMD0000000090.xml0,007900,00-9,79E3-0,001000,000,000,31-
BIOMD0000000091.xml0,100,100,371,20,10100-1,15E80,100,101,1-
BIOMD0000000092.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,001,50,31-
BIOMD0000000093.xml0,000,000,00-1,2-2,56E87700,000,001000,00
BIOMD0000000094.xml0,000,007,2-11,2-7,64E80,000,000,008,30,00
BIOMD0000000095.xml0,000,000,00-0,00--0,000,000,00--
BIOMD0000000096.xml0,000,000,00-0,00--0,000,000,00--
BIOMD0000000097.xml0,000,000,00-0,00--0,000,000,00--
BIOMD0000000098.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,0038,1-
BIOMD0000000099.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,000,780,00
BIOMD0000000100.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,009,1402
BIOMD0000000101.xml0,000,000,00-0,00--0,000,000,00--
BIOMD0000000102.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,499,00,00
BIOMD0000000103.xml0,000,000,00-99,71,07E40,000,000,000,009,00,00
BIOMD0000000104.xml0,000,000,00-0,00--0,003,28E30,000,00-
BIOMD0000000105.xml0,000,000,000,83100-0,000,000,000,42100-
BIOMD0000000106.xml0,000,00105-99,11060,000,000,0023615,42,23E3
BIOMD0000000107.xml0,000,000,00-0,00-0,009800,000,000,28-
BIOMD0000000108.xml0,320,300,00-0,000,000,00-0,0061,81,34,7
BIOMD0000000109.xml0,010,010,01-0,01--1000,010,01--
BIOMD0000000110.xml0,000,000,00-0,001210,001000,000,000,26-
BIOMD0000000111.xml4,72E32670,00-4,52E8--1000,000,00--
BIOMD0000000112.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,00--0,000,000,16-
BIOMD0000000113.xml0,000,002,80E3-0,00--1000,000,00-0,00
BIOMD0000000114.xml0,000,000,00-0,00-0,000,750,000,000,63-
BIOMD0000000115.xml0,000,000,00-0,00-0,003140,000,0013,4-
BIOMD0000000116.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
BIOMD0000000117.xml0,000,000,00-0,00--0,0019,10,00--
BIOMD0000000118.xml0,000,00------0,00-0,00-
BIOMD0000000119.xml0,000,000,00-0,00--16,30,000,000,00-
BIOMD0000000120.xml0,000,000,00-0,00--0,000,000,00--
BIOMD0000000121.xml0,000,000,00-0,00---0,000,00--
BIOMD0000000122.xml0,000,000,00-100,0--2790,000,00--
BIOMD0000000123.xml0,000,000,00-0,000,00100,092,80,000,000,160,00
BIOMD0000000124.xml0,000,000,00-0,00--0,670,000,00--
BIOMD0000000125.xml0,300,000,00-0,00--0,000,000,002,2-
BIOMD0000000126.xml35,855,8577-0,00--1000,640,00--
BIOMD0000000127.xml0,000,00------0,00---
BIOMD0000000128.xml1,81,80,00-0,00--0,190,000,00--
BIOMD0000000129.xml0,000,00------0,00---
BIOMD0000000130.xml0,000,00------0,01---
BIOMD0000000131.xml0,000,00------0,00---
BIOMD0000000132.xml0,000,00------0,00---
BIOMD0000000133.xml0,000,00------0,00---
BIOMD0000000134.xml0,000,00------0,00---
BIOMD0000000135.xml0,000,00------0,00---
BIOMD0000000136.xml0,000,00------0,00---
BIOMD0000000137.xml5001000,00-0,00--100,00,000,00--
BIOMD0000000138.xml0,000,000,00-0,00-0,000,320,000,000,00-
BIOMD0000000139.xml0,000,000,00-0,00--1000,000,00--
BIOMD0000000140.xml0,000,000,00-130--7,86E40,000,00--
BIOMD0000000141.xml0,000,00------0,00---
BIOMD0000000142.xml0,000,00------0,00---
BIOMD0000000143.xml0,100,100,10-0,100,101,26E56,77E40,096,56,00,10
BIOMD0000000144.xml0,002,50,94-0,00--4,42,20,00--
BIOMD0000000145.xml0,000,000,00-0,00-0,002,48E170,000,001,6-
BIOMD0000000146.xml0,000,000,00-4,55E8351247-0,000,002,00,00
BIOMD0000000147.xml0,000,000,00-1000,000,000,000,007,157,1-
BIOMD0000000148.xml1001000,00-0,00--0,001,90,00--
BIOMD0000000149.xml0,000,000,00-0,00--0,000,00100--
BIOMD0000000150.xml31,50,230,00-0,00--100,00,003,73,90,00
BIOMD0000000151.xml0,000,00630-1,33E6-1,06E7-0,007,47E4100-