Test: BIOMD0000000001.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000001.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: Imex
generated code: BIOMD0000000001.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-100
ATOL 1.0E-30
RTOL 1.0E-18
STEP 1.0E-5

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000001.gif

Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL6613849442.png

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: D  kf_1  kf_0  kf_3  IL  A  kf_12  BLL  B  kf_13  DLL  I  ALL  DL  ILL  kf_8  AL  kf_4  BL  kf_7 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  Oscill8 Core  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  BioUML 
timeresult D kf_1 kf_0 kf_3 IL A kf_12 BLL B kf_13 DLL I ALL DL ILL kf_8 AL kf_4 BL kf_7
0.0BioUML0,00000E01,50000E33,00000E33,00000E30,00000E00,00000E03,00000E30,00000E01,66058E-51,50000E30,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,50000E30,00000E01,50000E30,00000E03,00000E3
0.0ByoDyn0,00000E01,50000E33,00000E33,00000E30,00000E00,00000E03,00000E30,00000E01,66058E-51,50000E30,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,50000E30,00000E01,50000E30,00000E03,00000E3
0.0MathSBML0,00000E0---0,00000E00,00000E0-0,00000E01,66058E-21-0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0-0,00000E0-0,00000E0-
0.0Oscill8 Core----0,00000E00,00000E0-0,00000E01,66058E-21-0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0-0,00000E0-0,00000E0-
0.0SBWOdeSolver0,00000E0---0,00000E00,00000E0-0,00000E01,66058E-5-0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0-0,00000E0-0,00000E0-
0.0copasi0,00000E0---0,00000E00,00000E0-0,00000E01,66058E-5-0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0-0,00000E0-0,00000E0-
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner0,00000E0---0,00000E00,00000E0-0,00000E01,66058E-5-0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0-0,00000E0-0,00000E0-
0.0min 0,00000E0 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 3,00000E3 0,00000E0 1,66058E-21 1,50000E3 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,50000E3 0,00000E0 1,50000E3 0,00000E0 3,00000E3
0.0max 0,00000E0 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 3,00000E3 0,00000E0 1,66058E-5 1,50000E3 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,50000E3 0,00000E0 1,50000E3 0,00000E0 3,00000E3
0.0mean 0,00000E0 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 3,00000E3 0,00000E0 1,66058E-5 1,50000E3 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,50000E3 0,00000E0 1,50000E3 0,00000E0 3,00000E3
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML6,36589E-131,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,20465E-85,09750E-113,00000E33,52250E-81,01900E-61,50000E38,95191E-89,62324E-111,49742E-64,77438E-101,34929E-51,50000E31,77667E-81,50000E33,81287E-73,00000E3
0.2ByoDyn6,36572E-131,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,20494E-85,09654E-113,00000E33,52184E-81,01881E-61,50000E38,95167E-89,62363E-111,49714E-64,77425E-101,34934E-51,50000E31,77633E-81,50000E33,81214E-73,00000E3
0.2MathSBML8,68813E-72---1,27497E-641,79342E-38-1,49460E-481,66058E-21-0,00000E03,53323E-542,21470E-601,31135E-849,11364E-78-1,30070E-49-9,96347E-35-
0.2Oscill8 Core----1,99601E-651,79343E-38-1,56925E-481,66058E-21--5,86580E-643,68826E-543,46736E-61-5,36075E-504,00466E-77-1,36566E-49-9,96348E-35-
0.2SBWOdeSolver6,36577E-13---7,20485E-85,09685E-11-3,52206E-81,01887E-6-8,95175E-89,62350E-111,49723E-64,77429E-101,34933E-5-1,77644E-8-3,81238E-7-
0.2copasi6,36572E-13---7,20494E-85,09654E-11-3,52184E-81,01881E-6-8,95167E-89,62362E-111,49714E-64,77425E-101,34934E-5-1,77634E-8-3,81215E-7-
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner6,36574E-29---7,20494E-245,09654E-27-3,52184E-241,01881E-22-8,95170E-249,62363E-271,49714E-224,77427E-261,34934E-21-1,77633E-24-3,81214E-23-
0.2min 8,68813E-72 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 1,99601E-65 1,79342E-38 3,00000E3 1,49460E-48 1,01881E-22 1,50000E3 -5,86580E-64 3,53323E-54 3,46736E-61 -5,36075E-50 9,11364E-78 1,50000E3 1,30070E-49 1,50000E3 9,96347E-35 3,00000E3
0.2max 6,36577E-13 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 7,20494E-8 5,09685E-11 3,00000E3 3,52206E-8 1,01887E-6 1,50000E3 8,95175E-8 9,62363E-11 1,49723E-6 4,77429E-10 1,34934E-5 1,50000E3 1,77644E-8 1,50000E3 3,81238E-7 3,00000E3
0.2mean 6,36572E-13 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 3,60242E-8 2,54827E-11 3,00000E3 1,76092E-8 5,09404E-7 1,50000E3 4,47583E-8 4,81175E-11 7,48569E-7 2,38712E-10 6,74663E-6 1,50000E3 8,88167E-9 1,50000E3 1,90607E-7 3,00000E3
0.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML1,66466E-121,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,94891E-82,37925E-113,00000E31,66236E-84,74523E-71,50000E32,34093E-71,06005E-107,11264E-71,24849E-91,49022E-51,50000E38,34818E-91,50000E31,77851E-73,00000E3
0.4ByoDyn1,66466E-121,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,94900E-82,37896E-113,00000E31,66216E-84,74465E-71,50000E32,34092E-71,06006E-107,11180E-71,24849E-91,49024E-51,50000E38,34717E-91,50000E31,77829E-73,00000E3
0.4MathSBML3,51131E-71---5,15281E-643,58685E-38-5,97816E-481,66058E-21-0,00000E01,41324E-538,95074E-605,29994E-843,68336E-77-5,20259E-49-1,99269E-34-
0.4Oscill8 Core----1,48794E-643,58685E-38-6,12753E-481,66058E-21--4,42913E-631,44007E-532,58476E-60-2,12075E-495,58120E-76-5,33259E-49-1,99270E-34-
0.4SBWOdeSolver1,66466E-12---7,94898E-82,37902E-11-1,66221E-84,74478E-7-2,34092E-71,06005E-107,11199E-71,24849E-91,49023E-5-8,34740E-9-1,77834E-7-
0.4copasi1,66466E-12---7,94900E-82,37896E-11-1,66217E-84,74465E-7-2,34092E-71,06006E-107,11180E-71,24849E-91,49024E-5-8,34718E-9-1,77829E-7-
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner1,66466E-28---7,94900E-242,37896E-27-1,66216E-244,74465E-23-2,34092E-231,06006E-267,11180E-231,24849E-251,49024E-21-8,34717E-25-1,77829E-23-
0.4min 3,51131E-71 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 1,48794E-64 3,58685E-38 3,00000E3 5,97816E-48 4,74465E-23 1,50000E3 -4,42913E-63 1,41324E-53 2,58476E-60 -2,12075E-49 3,68336E-77 1,50000E3 5,20259E-49 1,50000E3 1,99269E-34 3,00000E3
0.4max 1,66466E-12 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 7,94900E-8 2,37902E-11 3,00000E3 1,66221E-8 4,74478E-7 1,50000E3 2,34092E-7 1,06006E-10 7,11199E-7 1,24849E-9 1,49024E-5 1,50000E3 8,34740E-9 1,50000E3 1,77834E-7 3,00000E3
0.4mean 1,66466E-12 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 3,97449E-8 1,18948E-11 3,00000E3 8,31082E-9 2,37232E-7 1,50000E3 1,17046E-7 5,30027E-11 3,55590E-7 6,24245E-10 7,45117E-6 1,50000E3 4,17359E-9 1,50000E3 8,89145E-8 3,00000E3
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML2,72707E-121,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,96544E-82,06131E-113,00000E31,44451E-84,10855E-71,50000E33,83494E-71,06208E-106,19122E-72,04530E-91,49347E-51,50000E37,24568E-91,50000E31,54058E-73,00000E3
0.6ByoDyn2,72707E-121,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,96545E-82,06125E-113,00000E31,44447E-84,10844E-71,50000E33,83494E-71,06208E-106,19105E-72,04530E-91,49348E-51,50000E37,24549E-91,50000E31,54054E-73,00000E3
0.6MathSBML7,92759E-71---1,16336E-635,38027E-38-1,34508E-471,66058E-21-0,00000E03,17976E-532,02083E-591,19659E-838,31609E-77-1,17057E-48-2,98904E-34-
0.6Oscill8 Core----4,90189E-645,38028E-38-1,36749E-471,66058E-21--1,46572E-623,21377E-538,51529E-60-4,74088E-492,69389E-75-1,19008E-48-2,98904E-34-
0.6SBWOdeSolver2,72707E-12---7,96545E-82,06126E-11-1,44448E-84,10845E-7-3,83494E-71,06208E-106,19108E-72,04530E-91,49348E-5-7,24552E-9-1,54054E-7-
0.6copasi2,72707E-12---7,96545E-82,06125E-11-1,44447E-84,10844E-7-3,83494E-71,06208E-106,19106E-72,04530E-91,49348E-5-7,24550E-9-1,54054E-7-
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner2,72707E-28---7,96545E-242,06125E-27-1,44447E-244,10844E-23-3,83495E-231,06208E-266,19105E-232,04531E-251,49348E-21-7,24549E-25-1,54054E-23-
0.6min 7,92759E-71 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 4,90189E-64 5,38027E-38 3,00000E3 1,34508E-47 4,10844E-23 1,50000E3 -1,46572E-62 3,17976E-53 8,51529E-60 -4,74088E-49 8,31609E-77 1,50000E3 1,17057E-48 1,50000E3 2,98904E-34 3,00000E3
0.6max 2,72707E-12 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 7,96545E-8 2,06126E-11 3,00000E3 1,44448E-8 4,10845E-7 1,50000E3 3,83494E-7 1,06208E-10 6,19108E-7 2,04530E-9 1,49348E-5 1,50000E3 7,24552E-9 1,50000E3 1,54054E-7 3,00000E3
0.6mean 2,72707E-12 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 3,98273E-8 1,03063E-11 3,00000E3 7,22235E-9 2,05422E-7 1,50000E3 1,91747E-7 5,31040E-11 3,09553E-7 1,02265E-9 7,46738E-6 1,50000E3 3,62274E-9 1,50000E3 7,70268E-8 3,00000E3
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML3,78429E-121,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,90194E-82,00952E-113,00000E31,40877E-84,00501E-71,50000E35,32166E-71,05360E-106,03936E-72,83822E-91,48159E-51,50000E37,06532E-91,50000E31,50184E-73,00000E3
0.8ByoDyn3,78431E-121,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,90195E-82,00949E-113,00000E31,40874E-84,00494E-71,50000E35,32169E-71,05360E-106,03925E-72,83823E-91,48159E-51,50000E37,06519E-91,50000E31,50182E-73,00000E3
0.8MathSBML1,41176E-70---2,07175E-637,17370E-38-2,39124E-471,66058E-21-0,00000E05,65289E-533,59875E-592,13093E-831,48096E-76-2,08102E-48-3,98539E-34-
0.8Oscill8 Core----1,14784E-637,17371E-38-2,42112E-471,66058E-21--3,43986E-625,68989E-531,99396E-59-8,41147E-498,31062E-75-2,10702E-48-3,98539E-34-
0.8SBWOdeSolver3,78431E-12---7,90195E-82,00949E-11-1,40874E-84,00494E-7-5,32169E-71,05360E-106,03926E-72,83823E-91,48159E-5-7,06520E-9-1,50182E-7-
0.8copasi3,78431E-12---7,90195E-82,00949E-11-1,40874E-84,00494E-7-5,32169E-71,05360E-106,03926E-72,83823E-91,48159E-5-7,06519E-9-1,50182E-7-
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner3,78431E-28---7,90195E-242,00949E-27-1,40874E-244,00494E-23-5,32169E-231,05360E-266,03925E-232,83824E-251,48159E-21-7,06519E-25-1,50182E-23-
0.8min 1,41176E-70 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 1,14784E-63 7,17370E-38 3,00000E3 2,39124E-47 4,00494E-23 1,50000E3 -3,43986E-62 5,65289E-53 1,99396E-59 -8,41147E-49 1,48096E-76 1,50000E3 2,08102E-48 1,50000E3 3,98539E-34 3,00000E3
0.8max 3,78431E-12 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 7,90195E-8 2,00949E-11 3,00000E3 1,40874E-8 4,00494E-7 1,50000E3 5,32169E-7 1,05360E-10 6,03926E-7 2,83823E-9 1,48159E-5 1,50000E3 7,06520E-9 1,50000E3 1,50182E-7 3,00000E3
0.8mean 3,78431E-12 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 3,95098E-8 1,00474E-11 3,00000E3 7,04370E-9 2,00247E-7 1,50000E3 2,66084E-7 5,26799E-11 3,01963E-7 1,41912E-9 7,40793E-6 1,50000E3 3,53260E-9 1,50000E3 7,50908E-8 3,00000E3
0.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.0BioUML4,83203E-121,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,83021E-81,98735E-113,00000E31,39328E-83,96078E-71,50000E36,79504E-71,04403E-105,97313E-73,62402E-91,46814E-51,50000E36,98754E-91,50000E31,48527E-73,00000E3
1.0ByoDyn4,83209E-121,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,83021E-81,98734E-113,00000E31,39327E-83,96075E-71,50000E36,79512E-71,04403E-105,97309E-73,62407E-91,46814E-51,50000E36,98749E-91,50000E31,48526E-73,00000E3
1.0MathSBML2,20815E-70---3,24043E-638,96712E-38-3,73631E-471,66058E-21-0,00000E08,83263E-535,62883E-593,33300E-832,31638E-76-3,25158E-48-4,98173E-34-
1.0Oscill8 Core----2,22542E-638,96713E-38-3,77366E-471,66058E-21--6,67730E-628,86850E-533,86588E-59-1,31103E-481,99952E-74-3,28409E-48-4,98174E-34-
1.0SBWOdeSolver4,83209E-12---7,83021E-81,98733E-11-1,39327E-83,96075E-7-6,79512E-71,04403E-105,97309E-73,62406E-91,46814E-5-6,98749E-9-1,48526E-7-
1.0copasi4,83209E-12---7,83021E-81,98734E-11-1,39327E-83,96075E-7-6,79512E-71,04403E-105,97310E-73,62407E-91,46814E-5-6,98750E-9-1,48526E-7-
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner4,83209E-28---7,83021E-241,98734E-27-1,39327E-243,96075E-23-6,79513E-231,04403E-265,97309E-233,62407E-251,46814E-21-6,98749E-25-1,48526E-23-
1.0min 2,20815E-70 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 2,22542E-63 8,96712E-38 3,00000E3 3,73631E-47 3,96075E-23 1,50000E3 -6,67730E-62 8,83263E-53 3,86588E-59 -1,31103E-48 2,31638E-76 1,50000E3 3,25158E-48 1,50000E3 4,98173E-34 3,00000E3
1.0max 4,83209E-12 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 7,83021E-8 1,98734E-11 3,00000E3 1,39327E-8 3,96075E-7 1,50000E3 6,79512E-7 1,04403E-10 5,97310E-7 3,62407E-9 1,46814E-5 1,50000E3 6,98750E-9 1,50000E3 1,48526E-7 3,00000E3
1.0mean 4,83209E-12 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 3,91511E-8 9,93667E-12 3,00000E3 6,96635E-9 1,98037E-7 1,50000E3 3,39756E-7 5,22015E-11 2,98654E-7 1,81203E-9 7,34069E-6 1,50000E3 3,49374E-9 1,50000E3 7,42628E-8 3,00000E3
1.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.2BioUML5,86999E-121,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,75818E-81,96862E-113,00000E31,38016E-83,92344E-71,50000E38,25467E-71,03443E-105,91688E-74,40249E-91,45463E-51,50000E36,92170E-91,50000E31,47127E-73,00000E3
1.2ByoDyn5,87001E-121,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,75818E-81,96862E-113,00000E31,38016E-83,92344E-71,50000E38,25470E-71,03443E-105,91688E-74,40250E-91,45463E-51,50000E36,92170E-91,50000E31,47127E-73,00000E3
1.2MathSBML3,35495E-70---4,92336E-631,07605E-37-5,38028E-471,66058E-21-9,15298E-951,27190E-528,55217E-591,32554E-819,21228E-75-4,68228E-48-5,97808E-34-
1.2Oscill8 Core----3,82664E-631,07606E-37-5,42511E-471,66058E-21--1,15005E-611,27492E-526,64742E-59-1,89427E-484,10580E-74-4,72129E-48-5,97809E-34-
1.2SBWOdeSolver5,87000E-12---7,75818E-81,96862E-11-1,38016E-83,92344E-7-8,25469E-71,03443E-105,91688E-74,40250E-91,45463E-5-6,92169E-9-1,47127E-7-
1.2copasi5,87001E-12---7,75818E-81,96862E-11-1,38016E-83,92344E-7-8,25470E-71,03443E-105,91687E-74,40250E-91,45463E-5-6,92169E-9-1,47127E-7-
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner5,87001E-28---7,75818E-241,96862E-27-1,38016E-243,92344E-23-8,25470E-231,03443E-265,91688E-234,40251E-251,45463E-21-6,92170E-25-1,47127E-23-
1.2min 3,35495E-70 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 3,82664E-63 1,07605E-37 3,00000E3 5,38028E-47 3,92344E-23 1,50000E3 -1,15005E-61 1,27190E-52 6,64742E-59 -1,89427E-48 9,21228E-75 1,50000E3 4,68228E-48 1,50000E3 5,97808E-34 3,00000E3
1.2max 5,87001E-12 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 7,75818E-8 1,96862E-11 3,00000E3 1,38016E-8 3,92344E-7 1,50000E3 8,25470E-7 1,03443E-10 5,91688E-7 4,40250E-9 1,45463E-5 1,50000E3 6,92170E-9 1,50000E3 1,47127E-7 3,00000E3
1.2mean 5,87000E-12 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 3,87909E-8 9,84308E-12 3,00000E3 6,90078E-9 1,96172E-7 1,50000E3 4,12735E-7 5,17213E-11 2,95844E-7 2,20125E-9 7,27315E-6 1,50000E3 3,46085E-9 1,50000E3 7,35633E-8 3,00000E3
1.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.4BioUML6,89785E-121,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,68673E-81,95044E-113,00000E31,36741E-83,88721E-71,50000E39,70010E-71,02490E-105,86224E-75,17338E-91,44124E-51,50000E36,85778E-91,50000E31,45768E-73,00000E3
1.4ByoDyn6,89811E-121,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,68671E-81,95043E-113,00000E31,36741E-83,88720E-71,50000E39,70046E-71,02490E-105,86223E-75,17358E-91,44123E-51,50000E36,85776E-91,50000E31,45768E-73,00000E3
1.4MathSBML5,03242E-70---7,38502E-631,25540E-37-7,32316E-471,66058E-21-3,69926E-941,73119E-521,28282E-585,22859E-813,63378E-74-6,37310E-48-6,97443E-34-
1.4Oscill8 Core----6,05517E-631,25540E-37-7,37546E-471,66058E-21--1,82439E-611,73322E-521,05187E-58-2,58421E-487,55332E-74-6,41862E-48-6,97444E-34-
1.4SBWOdeSolver6,89810E-12---7,68671E-81,95043E-11-1,36741E-83,88720E-7-9,70046E-71,02490E-105,86223E-75,17358E-91,44123E-5-6,85776E-9-1,45768E-7-
1.4copasi6,89811E-12---7,68671E-81,95043E-11-1,36741E-83,88720E-7-9,70046E-71,02490E-105,86223E-75,17358E-91,44123E-5-6,85776E-9-1,45768E-7-
1.4edu.kgi.roadRunner6,89811E-28---7,68671E-241,95043E-27-1,36741E-243,88720E-23-9,70046E-231,02490E-265,86223E-235,17358E-251,44123E-21-6,85776E-25-1,45768E-23-
1.4min 5,03242E-70 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 6,05517E-63 1,25540E-37 3,00000E3 7,32316E-47 3,88720E-23 1,50000E3 -1,82439E-61 1,73119E-52 1,05187E-58 -2,58421E-48 3,63378E-74 1,50000E3 6,37310E-48 1,50000E3 6,97443E-34 3,00000E3
1.4max 6,89811E-12 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 7,68671E-8 1,95043E-11 3,00000E3 1,36741E-8 3,88720E-7 1,50000E3 9,70046E-7 1,02490E-10 5,86223E-7 5,17358E-9 1,44123E-5 1,50000E3 6,85776E-9 1,50000E3 1,45768E-7 3,00000E3
1.4mean 6,89810E-12 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 3,84336E-8 9,75215E-12 3,00000E3 6,83704E-9 1,94360E-7 1,50000E3 4,85023E-7 5,12448E-11 2,93111E-7 2,58679E-9 7,20615E-6 1,50000E3 3,42888E-9 1,50000E3 7,28838E-8 3,00000E3
1.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.6BioUML7,91529E-121,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,61599E-81,93248E-113,00000E31,35482E-83,85142E-71,50000E31,11309E-61,01547E-105,80827E-75,93646E-91,42797E-51,50000E36,79465E-91,50000E31,44426E-73,00000E3
1.6ByoDyn7,91648E-121,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,61591E-81,93246E-113,00000E31,35481E-83,85138E-71,50000E31,11325E-61,01546E-105,80821E-75,93736E-91,42796E-51,50000E36,79457E-91,50000E31,44424E-73,00000E3
1.6MathSBML7,24058E-70---1,06255E-621,43474E-37-9,56494E-471,66058E-21-8,35199E-942,26115E-521,84571E-581,17426E-808,16092E-74-8,32405E-48-7,97077E-34-
1.6Oscill8 Core----9,01471E-631,43474E-37-9,62471E-471,66058E-21--2,72213E-612,26177E-521,56598E-58-3,37824E-481,28178E-73-8,37607E-48-7,97078E-34-
1.6SBWOdeSolver7,91648E-12---7,61591E-81,93246E-11-1,35481E-83,85138E-7-1,11325E-61,01546E-105,80821E-75,93736E-91,42796E-5-6,79457E-9-1,44424E-7-
1.6copasi7,91648E-12---7,61591E-81,93246E-11-1,35481E-83,85138E-7-1,11325E-61,01546E-105,80821E-75,93736E-91,42796E-5-6,79457E-9-1,44424E-7-
1.6edu.kgi.roadRunner7,91648E-28---7,61591E-241,93246E-27-1,35481E-243,85138E-23-1,11325E-221,01546E-265,80821E-235,93736E-251,42796E-21-6,79457E-25-1,44424E-23-
1.6min 7,24058E-70 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 9,01471E-63 1,43474E-37 3,00000E3 9,56494E-47 3,85138E-23 1,50000E3 -2,72213E-61 2,26115E-52 1,56598E-58 -3,37824E-48 8,16092E-74 1,50000E3 8,32405E-48 1,50000E3 7,97077E-34 3,00000E3
1.6max 7,91648E-12 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 7,61591E-8 1,93246E-11 3,00000E3 1,35481E-8 3,85138E-7 1,50000E3 1,11325E-6 1,01546E-10 5,80821E-7 5,93736E-9 1,42796E-5 1,50000E3 6,79457E-9 1,50000E3 1,44424E-7 3,00000E3
1.6mean 7,91648E-12 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 3,80796E-8 9,66230E-12 3,00000E3 6,77404E-9 1,92569E-7 1,50000E3 5,56625E-7 5,07728E-11 2,90410E-7 2,96868E-9 7,13979E-6 1,50000E3 3,39729E-9 1,50000E3 7,22120E-8 3,00000E3
1.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.8BioUML8,92261E-121,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,54596E-81,91471E-113,00000E31,34236E-83,81600E-71,50000E31,25474E-61,00613E-105,75485E-76,69196E-91,41484E-51,50000E36,73215E-91,50000E31,43098E-73,00000E3
1.8ByoDyn8,92521E-121,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,54578E-81,91466E-113,00000E31,34233E-83,81591E-71,50000E31,25511E-61,00611E-105,75472E-76,69391E-91,41481E-51,50000E36,73199E-91,50000E31,43094E-73,00000E3
1.8MathSBML9,97941E-70---1,46447E-621,61408E-37-1,21056E-461,66058E-21-1,48735E-932,86177E-522,54387E-582,08676E-801,45026E-73-1,05351E-47-8,96712E-34-
1.8Oscill8 Core----1,28089E-621,61408E-37-1,21729E-461,66058E-21--3,87452E-612,86056E-522,22510E-58-4,27682E-482,04475E-73-1,05936E-47-8,96713E-34-
1.8SBWOdeSolver8,92521E-12---7,54578E-81,91466E-11-1,34233E-83,81591E-7-1,25511E-61,00611E-105,75472E-76,69391E-91,41481E-5-6,73199E-9-1,43094E-7-
1.8copasi8,92521E-12---7,54578E-81,91466E-11-1,34233E-83,81591E-7-1,25511E-61,00611E-105,75471E-76,69391E-91,41481E-5-6,73199E-9-1,43094E-7-
1.8edu.kgi.roadRunner8,92521E-28---7,54578E-241,91466E-27-1,34233E-243,81591E-23-1,25511E-221,00611E-265,75472E-236,69391E-251,41481E-21-6,73199E-25-1,43094E-23-
1.8min 9,97941E-70 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 1,28089E-62 1,61408E-37 3,00000E3 1,21056E-46 3,81591E-23 1,50000E3 -3,87452E-61 2,86056E-52 2,22510E-58 -4,27682E-48 1,45026E-73 1,50000E3 1,05351E-47 1,50000E3 8,96712E-34 3,00000E3
1.8max 8,92521E-12 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 7,54578E-8 1,91466E-11 3,00000E3 1,34233E-8 3,81591E-7 1,50000E3 1,25511E-6 1,00611E-10 5,75472E-7 6,69391E-9 1,41481E-5 1,50000E3 6,73199E-9 1,50000E3 1,43094E-7 3,00000E3
1.8mean 8,92521E-12 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 3,77289E-8 9,57330E-12 3,00000E3 6,71165E-9 1,90795E-7 1,50000E3 6,27554E-7 5,03053E-11 2,87736E-7 3,34695E-9 7,07404E-6 1,50000E3 3,36600E-9 1,50000E3 7,15470E-8 3,00000E3
1.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.0BioUML9,92160E-121,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,47651E-81,89708E-113,00000E31,33001E-83,78087E-71,50000E31,39522E-69,96869E-115,70188E-77,44120E-91,40182E-51,50000E36,67018E-91,50000E31,41780E-73,00000E3
2.0ByoDyn9,92439E-121,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,47631E-81,89703E-113,00000E31,32997E-83,78077E-71,50000E31,39562E-69,96843E-115,70173E-77,44330E-91,40178E-51,50000E36,67001E-91,50000E31,41777E-73,00000E3
2.0MathSBML1,32489E-69---1,94426E-621,79342E-37-1,49452E-461,66058E-21-2,32637E-933,53305E-523,37730E-583,26036E-802,26589E-73-1,30063E-47-9,96347E-34-
2.0Oscill8 Core----1,75416E-621,79343E-37-1,50199E-461,66058E-21--5,31286E-613,52959E-523,04722E-58-5,27926E-483,10627E-73-1,30713E-47-9,96348E-34-
2.0SBWOdeSolver9,92439E-12---7,47631E-81,89703E-11-1,32997E-83,78077E-7-1,39562E-69,96843E-115,70173E-77,44329E-91,40178E-5-6,67001E-9-1,41777E-7-
2.0copasi9,92439E-12---7,47631E-81,89703E-11-1,32997E-83,78077E-7-1,39562E-69,96843E-115,70173E-77,44330E-91,40178E-5-6,67001E-9-1,41777E-7-
2.0edu.kgi.roadRunner9,92440E-28---7,47631E-241,89703E-27-1,32997E-243,78077E-23-1,39562E-229,96843E-275,70173E-237,44330E-251,40178E-21-6,67001E-25-1,41777E-23-
2.0min 1,32489E-69 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 1,75416E-62 1,79342E-37 3,00000E3 1,49452E-46 3,78077E-23 1,50000E3 -5,31286E-61 3,52959E-52 3,04722E-58 -5,27926E-48 2,26589E-73 1,50000E3 1,30063E-47 1,50000E3 9,96347E-34 3,00000E3
2.0max 9,92439E-12 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 7,47631E-8 1,89703E-11 3,00000E3 1,32997E-8 3,78077E-7 1,50000E3 1,39562E-6 9,96843E-11 5,70173E-7 7,44330E-9 1,40178E-5 1,50000E3 6,67001E-9 1,50000E3 1,41777E-7 3,00000E3
2.0mean 9,92439E-12 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 3,73816E-8 9,48515E-12 3,00000E3 6,64985E-9 1,89039E-7 1,50000E3 6,97809E-7 4,98422E-11 2,85087E-7 3,72165E-9 7,00890E-6 1,50000E3 3,33500E-9 1,50000E3 7,08883E-8 3,00000E3
2.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.2BioUML1,09068E-111,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,40801E-81,87970E-113,00000E31,31782E-83,74623E-71,50000E31,53377E-69,87737E-115,64964E-78,18009E-91,38898E-51,50000E36,60907E-91,50000E31,40481E-73,00000E3
2.2ByoDyn1,09141E-111,50000E33,00000E33,00000E37,40750E-81,87957E-113,00000E31,31773E-83,74597E-71,50000E31,53480E-69,87669E-115,64925E-78,18559E-91,38888E-51,50000E36,60861E-91,50000E31,40472E-73,00000E3
2.2MathSBML1,72222E-69---2,52733E-621,97277E-37-1,80837E-461,66058E-21-9,25434E-924,27499E-524,39013E-584,98217E-803,46252E-73-1,57376E-47-1,09598E-33-
2.2Oscill8 Core----2,33163E-621,97277E-37-1,81659E-461,66058E-21--7,06842E-614,26887E-524,05037E-58-6,38659E-484,53565E-73-1,58092E-47-1,09598E-33-
2.2SBWOdeSolver1,09141E-11---7,40750E-81,87957E-11-1,31773E-83,74597E-7-1,53480E-69,87669E-115,64925E-78,18559E-91,38888E-5-6,60861E-9-1,40472E-7-
2.2copasi1,09141E-11---7,40750E-81,87957E-11-1,31773E-83,74597E-7-1,53480E-69,87669E-115,64925E-78,18559E-91,38888E-5-6,60861E-9-1,40472E-7-
2.2edu.kgi.roadRunner1,09141E-27---7,40750E-241,87957E-27-1,31773E-243,74597E-23-1,53480E-229,87669E-275,64925E-238,18559E-251,38888E-21-6,60861E-25-1,40472E-23-
2.2min 1,72222E-69 1,50000E3 3,00000E3 3,00000E3 2,33163E-62 1,97277E-37 3,00000E3 1,80837E-46 3,74597E-23 1,50000E3 -7,06842E-61 4,26887E-52 4,05037E-58 -6,38659E-48 3,46252E-73 1,50000E3 1,57376E-47 1,50000E3 1,09598E-33 3,00000E3
2.2max 1,09141E-