Test: BIOMD0000000004.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000004.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: DormandPrince
generated code: BIOMD0000000004.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-100
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000004.gif

Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL6614389071.png

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: V3  MI  C  V1  M  XI  X 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  SBToolbox2  VCell  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  jsim  BioUML 
timeresult V3 MI C V1 M XI X
0.0BioUML1,00000E-29,90000E-11,00000E-25,88235E-21,00000E-29,90000E-11,00000E-2
0.0ByoDyn1,00000E-29,90000E-11,00000E-25,88235E-21,00000E-29,90000E-11,00000E-2
0.0MathSBML-9,90000E-11,00000E-2-1,00000E-29,90000E-11,00000E-2
0.0SBToolbox21,00000E-29,90000E-11,00000E-25,88240E-21,00000E-29,90000E-11,00000E-2
0.0SBWOdeSolver-9,90000E-11,00000E-2-1,00000E-29,90000E-11,00000E-2
0.0VCell-9,90000E-11,00000E-2-1,00000E-29,90000E-11,00000E-2
0.0copasi-9,90000E-11,00000E-2-1,00000E-29,90000E-11,00000E-2
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,90000E-11,00000E-2-1,00000E-29,90000E-11,00000E-2
0.0jsim1,00000E-29,90000E-11,00000E-25,88235E-21,00000E-29,90000E-11,00000E-2
0.0min 1,00000E-2 9,90000E-1 1,00000E-2 5,88235E-2 1,00000E-2 9,90000E-1 1,00000E-2
0.0max 1,00000E-2 9,90000E-1 1,00000E-2 5,88240E-2 1,00000E-2 9,90000E-1 1,00000E-2
0.0mean 1,00000E-2 9,90000E-1 1,00000E-2 5,88235E-2 1,00000E-2 9,90000E-1 1,00000E-2
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML3,04783E-49,99695E-11,49578E-28,71397E-23,04783E-49,99997E-12,98239E-6
0.2ByoDyn3,04783E-49,99695E-11,49578E-28,71397E-23,04783E-49,99997E-12,98239E-6
0.2MathSBML-9,99695E-11,49578E-2-3,04782E-49,99997E-12,98207E-6
0.2SBToolbox23,04725E-49,99700E-11,49580E-28,71399E-23,04725E-41,00000E02,98591E-6
0.2SBWOdeSolver-9,99695E-11,49578E-2-3,04783E-49,99997E-12,98238E-6
0.2VCell-9,99695E-11,49578E-2-3,04783E-49,99997E-12,98238E-6
0.2copasi-9,99695E-11,49578E-2-3,04783E-49,99997E-12,98239E-6
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,99695E-11,49578E-2-3,04783E-49,99997E-12,98239E-6
0.2jsim3,04783E-49,99695E-11,49578E-28,71397E-23,04783E-49,99997E-12,98239E-6
0.2min 3,04725E-4 9,99695E-1 1,49578E-2 8,71397E-2 3,04725E-4 9,99997E-1 2,98207E-6
0.2max 3,04783E-4 9,99700E-1 1,49580E-2 8,71399E-2 3,04783E-4 1,00000E0 2,98591E-6
0.2mean 3,04783E-4 9,99695E-1 1,49578E-2 8,71397E-2 3,04783E-4 9,99997E-1 2,98239E-6
0.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML4,10669E-49,99589E-11,99228E-21,14956E-14,10669E-49,99996E-14,03632E-6
0.4ByoDyn4,10669E-49,99589E-11,99228E-21,14956E-14,10669E-49,99996E-14,03632E-6
0.4MathSBML-9,99589E-11,99228E-2-4,10669E-49,99996E-14,03632E-6
0.4SBToolbox24,10567E-49,99590E-11,99230E-21,14955E-14,10567E-41,00000E04,03497E-6
0.4SBWOdeSolver-9,99589E-11,99228E-2-4,10669E-49,99996E-14,03631E-6
0.4VCell-9,99589E-11,99228E-2-4,10669E-49,99996E-14,03632E-6
0.4copasi-9,99589E-11,99228E-2-4,10669E-49,99996E-14,03632E-6
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,99589E-11,99228E-2-4,10669E-49,99996E-14,03632E-6
0.4jsim4,10669E-49,99589E-11,99228E-21,14956E-14,10669E-49,99996E-14,03631E-6
0.4min 4,10567E-4 9,99589E-1 1,99228E-2 1,14955E-1 4,10567E-4 9,99996E-1 4,03497E-6
0.4max 4,10669E-4 9,99590E-1 1,99230E-2 1,14956E-1 4,10669E-4 1,00000E0 4,03632E-6
0.4mean 4,10669E-4 9,99589E-1 1,99228E-2 1,14956E-1 4,10669E-4 9,99996E-1 4,03632E-6
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML5,18521E-49,99481E-12,48779E-21,42192E-15,18521E-49,99995E-15,11042E-6
0.6ByoDyn5,18521E-49,99481E-12,48779E-21,42192E-15,18521E-49,99995E-15,11042E-6
0.6MathSBML-9,99481E-12,48779E-2-5,18521E-49,99995E-15,11042E-6
0.6SBToolbox25,18364E-49,99481E-12,48781E-21,42189E-15,18364E-49,99990E-15,10885E-6
0.6SBWOdeSolver-9,99481E-12,48779E-2-5,18522E-49,99995E-15,11042E-6
0.6VCell-9,99481E-12,48779E-2-5,18521E-49,99995E-15,11042E-6
0.6copasi-9,99481E-12,48779E-2-5,18521E-49,99995E-15,11042E-6
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,99481E-12,48779E-2-5,18521E-49,99995E-15,11042E-6
0.6jsim5,18522E-49,99481E-12,48779E-21,42192E-15,18522E-49,99995E-15,11042E-6
0.6min 5,18364E-4 9,99481E-1 2,48779E-2 1,42189E-1 5,18364E-4 9,99990E-1 5,10885E-6
0.6max 5,18522E-4 9,99481E-1 2,48781E-2 1,42192E-1 5,18522E-4 9,99995E-1 5,11042E-6
0.6mean 5,18521E-4 9,99481E-1 2,48779E-2 1,42192E-1 5,18521E-4 9,99995E-1 5,11042E-6
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML6,28394E-49,99372E-12,98230E-21,68866E-16,28394E-49,99994E-16,20511E-6
0.8ByoDyn6,28394E-49,99372E-12,98230E-21,68866E-16,28394E-49,99994E-16,20511E-6
0.8MathSBML-9,99372E-12,98230E-2-6,28395E-49,99994E-16,20512E-6
0.8SBToolbox26,28226E-49,99371E-12,98233E-21,68865E-16,28226E-49,99990E-16,20348E-6
0.8SBWOdeSolver-9,99372E-12,98230E-2-6,28395E-49,99994E-16,20511E-6
0.8VCell-9,99372E-12,98230E-2-6,28394E-49,99994E-16,20511E-6
0.8copasi-9,99372E-12,98230E-2-6,28394E-49,99994E-16,20511E-6
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,99372E-12,98230E-2-6,28394E-49,99994E-16,20511E-6
0.8jsim6,28394E-49,99372E-12,98230E-21,68866E-16,28394E-49,99994E-16,20511E-6
0.8min 6,28226E-4 9,99371E-1 2,98230E-2 1,68865E-1 6,28226E-4 9,99990E-1 6,20348E-6
0.8max 6,28394E-4 9,99372E-1 2,98233E-2 1,68866E-1 6,28395E-4 9,99994E-1 6,20512E-6
0.8mean 6,28394E-4 9,99372E-1 2,98230E-2 1,68866E-1 6,28394E-4 9,99994E-1 6,20511E-6
0.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.0BioUML7,40344E-49,99260E-13,47582E-21,94994E-17,40344E-49,99993E-17,32098E-6
1.0ByoDyn7,40344E-49,99260E-13,47582E-21,94994E-17,40344E-49,99993E-17,32098E-6
1.0MathSBML-9,99260E-13,47582E-2-7,40345E-49,99993E-17,32098E-6
1.0SBToolbox27,40166E-49,99260E-13,47583E-21,94991E-17,40166E-49,99990E-17,31927E-6
1.0SBWOdeSolver-9,99260E-13,47582E-2-7,40344E-49,99993E-17,32098E-6
1.0VCell-9,99260E-13,47582E-2-7,40344E-49,99993E-17,32098E-6
1.0copasi-9,99260E-13,47582E-2-7,40344E-49,99993E-17,32098E-6
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,99260E-13,47582E-2-7,40344E-49,99993E-17,32098E-6
1.0jsim7,40344E-49,99260E-13,47582E-21,94994E-17,40344E-49,99993E-17,32098E-6
1.0min 7,40166E-4 9,99260E-1 3,47582E-2 1,94991E-1 7,40166E-4 9,99990E-1 7,31927E-6
1.0max 7,40344E-4 9,99260E-1 3,47583E-2 1,94994E-1 7,40345E-4 9,99993E-1 7,32098E-6
1.0mean 7,40344E-4 9,99260E-1 3,47582E-2 1,94994E-1 7,40344E-4 9,99993E-1 7,32098E-6
1.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.2BioUML8,54431E-49,99146E-13,96835E-22,20593E-18,54431E-49,99992E-18,45864E-6
1.2ByoDyn8,54431E-49,99146E-13,96835E-22,20593E-18,54431E-49,99992E-18,45864E-6
1.2MathSBML-9,99146E-13,96835E-2-8,54431E-49,99992E-18,45865E-6
1.2SBToolbox28,54259E-49,99150E-13,96835E-22,20598E-18,54259E-49,99990E-18,45700E-6
1.2SBWOdeSolver-9,99146E-13,96835E-2-8,54431E-49,99992E-18,45865E-6
1.2VCell-9,99146E-13,96835E-2-8,54431E-49,99992E-18,45864E-6
1.2copasi-9,99146E-13,96835E-2-8,54431E-49,99992E-18,45864E-6
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,99146E-13,96835E-2-8,54431E-49,99992E-18,45864E-6
1.2jsim8,54431E-49,99146E-13,96835E-22,20593E-18,54431E-49,99992E-18,45864E-6
1.2min 8,54259E-4 9,99146E-1 3,96835E-2 2,20593E-1 8,54259E-4 9,99990E-1 8,45700E-6
1.2max 8,54431E-4 9,99150E-1 3,96835E-2 2,20598E-1 8,54431E-4 9,99992E-1 8,45865E-6
1.2mean 8,54431E-4 9,99146E-1 3,96835E-2 2,20593E-1 8,54431E-4 9,99992E-1 8,45864E-6
1.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.4BioUML9,70715E-49,99029E-14,45989E-22,45679E-19,70715E-49,99990E-19,61874E-6
1.4ByoDyn9,70715E-49,99029E-14,45989E-22,45679E-19,70715E-49,99990E-19,61874E-6
1.4MathSBML-9,99029E-14,45989E-2-9,70715E-49,99990E-19,61875E-6
1.4SBToolbox29,70557E-49,99030E-14,45987E-22,45676E-19,70557E-49,99990E-19,61710E-6
1.4SBWOdeSolver-9,99029E-14,45989E-2-9,70715E-49,99990E-19,61875E-6
1.4VCell-9,99029E-14,45989E-2-9,70715E-49,99990E-19,61874E-6
1.4copasi-9,99029E-14,45989E-2-9,70715E-49,99990E-19,61874E-6
1.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,99029E-14,45989E-2-9,70715E-49,99990E-19,61874E-6
1.4jsim9,70715E-49,99029E-14,45989E-22,45679E-19,70715E-49,99990E-19,61874E-6
1.4min 9,70557E-4 9,99029E-1 4,45987E-2 2,45676E-1 9,70557E-4 9,99990E-1 9,61710E-6
1.4max 9,70715E-4 9,99030E-1 4,45989E-2 2,45679E-1 9,70715E-4 9,99990E-1 9,61875E-6
1.4mean 9,70715E-4 9,99029E-1 4,45989E-2 2,45679E-1 9,70715E-4 9,99990E-1 9,61874E-6
1.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.6BioUML1,08926E-39,98911E-14,95045E-22,70268E-11,08926E-39,99989E-11,08019E-5
1.6ByoDyn1,08926E-39,98911E-14,95045E-22,70268E-11,08926E-39,99989E-11,08019E-5
1.6MathSBML-9,98911E-14,95045E-2-1,08926E-39,99989E-11,08019E-5
1.6SBToolbox21,08914E-39,98912E-14,95046E-22,70265E-11,08914E-39,99990E-11,08004E-5
1.6SBWOdeSolver-9,98911E-14,95045E-2-1,08926E-39,99989E-11,08020E-5
1.6VCell-9,98911E-14,95045E-2-1,08926E-39,99989E-11,08019E-5
1.6copasi-9,98911E-14,95045E-2-1,08926E-39,99989E-11,08019E-5
1.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,98911E-14,95045E-2-1,08926E-39,99989E-11,08019E-5
1.6jsim1,08926E-39,98911E-14,95045E-22,70268E-11,08926E-39,99989E-11,08019E-5
1.6min 1,08914E-3 9,98911E-1 4,95045E-2 2,70265E-1 1,08914E-3 9,99989E-1 1,08004E-5
1.6max 1,08926E-3 9,98912E-1 4,95046E-2 2,70268E-1 1,08926E-3 9,99990E-1 1,08020E-5
1.6mean 1,08926E-3 9,98911E-1 4,95045E-2 2,70268E-1 1,08926E-3 9,99989E-1 1,08019E-5
1.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.8BioUML1,21013E-39,98790E-15,44001E-22,94373E-11,21013E-39,99988E-11,20089E-5
1.8ByoDyn1,21013E-39,98790E-15,44001E-22,94373E-11,21013E-39,99988E-11,20089E-5
1.8MathSBML-9,98790E-15,44001E-2-1,21013E-39,99988E-11,20090E-5
1.8SBToolbox21,20990E-39,98792E-15,43999E-22,94374E-11,20990E-39,99990E-11,20070E-5
1.8SBWOdeSolver-9,98790E-15,44001E-2-1,21013E-39,99988E-11,20089E-5
1.8VCell-9,98790E-15,44001E-2-1,21013E-39,99988E-11,20089E-5
1.8copasi-9,98790E-15,44001E-2-1,21013E-39,99988E-11,20089E-5
1.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,98790E-15,44001E-2-1,21013E-39,99988E-11,20089E-5
1.8jsim1,21013E-39,98790E-15,44001E-22,94373E-11,21013E-39,99988E-11,20089E-5
1.8min 1,20990E-3 9,98790E-1 5,43999E-2 2,94373E-1 1,20990E-3 9,99988E-1 1,20070E-5
1.8max 1,21013E-3 9,98792E-1 5,44001E-2 2,94374E-1 1,21013E-3 9,99990E-1 1,20090E-5
1.8mean 1,21013E-3 9,98790E-1 5,44001E-2 2,94373E-1 1,21013E-3 9,99988E-1 1,20089E-5
1.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.0BioUML1,33340E-39,98667E-15,92860E-23,18009E-11,33340E-39,99987E-11,32404E-5
2.0ByoDyn1,33340E-39,98667E-15,92860E-23,18009E-11,33340E-39,99987E-11,32404E-5
2.0MathSBML-9,98667E-15,92860E-2-1,33340E-39,99987E-11,32405E-5
2.0SBToolbox21,33316E-39,98670E-15,92862E-23,18006E-11,33316E-39,99990E-11,32386E-5
2.0SBWOdeSolver-9,98667E-15,92860E-2-1,33340E-39,99987E-11,32404E-5
2.0VCell-9,98667E-15,92860E-2-1,33340E-39,99987E-11,32404E-5
2.0copasi-9,98667E-15,92860E-2-1,33340E-39,99987E-11,32404E-5
2.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,98667E-15,92860E-2-1,33340E-39,99987E-11,32404E-5
2.0jsim1,33340E-39,98667E-15,92860E-23,18009E-11,33340E-39,99987E-11,32404E-5
2.0min 1,33316E-3 9,98667E-1 5,92860E-2 3,18006E-1 1,33316E-3 9,99987E-1 1,32386E-5
2.0max 1,33340E-3 9,98670E-1 5,92862E-2 3,18009E-1 1,33340E-3 9,99990E-1 1,32405E-5
2.0mean 1,33340E-3 9,98667E-1 5,92860E-2 3,18009E-1 1,33340E-3 9,99987E-1 1,32404E-5
2.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.2BioUML1,45914E-39,98541E-16,41620E-23,41189E-11,45914E-39,99986E-11,44972E-5
2.2ByoDyn1,45914E-39,98541E-16,41620E-23,41189E-11,45914E-39,99986E-11,44972E-5
2.2MathSBML-9,98541E-16,41620E-2-1,45914E-39,99986E-11,44972E-5
2.2SBToolbox21,45889E-39,98542E-16,41623E-23,41187E-11,45889E-39,99990E-11,44949E-5
2.2SBWOdeSolver-9,98541E-16,41620E-2-1,45914E-39,99986E-11,44972E-5
2.2VCell-9,98541E-16,41620E-2-1,45914E-39,99986E-11,44972E-5
2.2copasi-9,98541E-16,41620E-2-1,45914E-39,99986E-11,44972E-5
2.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,98541E-16,41620E-2-1,45914E-39,99986E-11,44972E-5
2.2jsim1,45914E-39,98541E-16,41620E-23,41189E-11,45914E-39,99986E-11,44972E-5
2.2min 1,45889E-3 9,98541E-1 6,41620E-2 3,41187E-1 1,45889E-3 9,99986E-1 1,44949E-5
2.2max 1,45914E-3 9,98542E-1 6,41623E-2 3,41189E-1 1,45914E-3 9,99990E-1 1,44972E-5
2.2mean 1,45914E-3 9,98541E-1 6,41620E-2 3,41189E-1 1,45914E-3 9,99986E-1 1,44972E-5
2.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.4BioUML1,58742E-39,98413E-16,90282E-23,63927E-11,58742E-39,99984E-11,57800E-5
2.4ByoDyn1,58742E-39,98413E-16,90282E-23,63927E-11,58742E-39,99984E-11,57800E-5
2.4MathSBML-9,98413E-16,90282E-2-1,58741E-39,99984E-11,57799E-5
2.4SBToolbox21,58714E-39,98412E-16,90284E-23,63929E-11,58714E-39,99980E-11,57774E-5
2.4SBWOdeSolver-9,98413E-16,90282E-2-1,58742E-39,99984E-11,57800E-5
2.4VCell-9,98413E-16,90282E-2-1,58742E-39,99984E-11,57800E-5
2.4copasi-9,98413E-16,90282E-2-1,58742E-39,99984E-11,57800E-5
2.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,98413E-16,90282E-2-1,58742E-39,99984E-11,57800E-5
2.4jsim1,58742E-39,98413E-16,90282E-23,63927E-11,58742E-39,99984E-11,57800E-5
2.4min 1,58714E-3 9,98412E-1 6,90282E-2 3,63927E-1 1,58714E-3 9,99980E-1 1,57774E-5
2.4max 1,58742E-3 9,98413E-1 6,90284E-2 3,63929E-1 1,58742E-3 9,99984E-1 1,57800E-5
2.4mean 1,58742E-3 9,98413E-1 6,90282E-2 3,63927E-1 1,58742E-3 9,99984E-1 1,57800E-5
2.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.6BioUML1,71831E-39,98282E-17,38847E-23,86234E-11,71831E-39,99983E-11,70897E-5
2.6ByoDyn1,71831E-39,98282E-17,38847E-23,86234E-11,71831E-39,99983E-11,70897E-5
2.6MathSBML-9,98282E-17,38847E-2-1,71830E-39,99983E-11,70896E-5
2.6SBToolbox21,71798E-39,98283E-17,38848E-23,86234E-11,71798E-39,99980E-11,70868E-5
2.6SBWOdeSolver-9,98282E-17,38847E-2-1,71831E-39,99983E-11,70897E-5
2.6VCell-9,98282E-17,38847E-2-1,71831E-39,99983E-11,70897E-5
2.6copasi-9,98282E-17,38847E-2-1,71831E-39,99983E-11,70897E-5
2.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,98282E-17,38847E-2-1,71831E-39,99983E-11,70897E-5
2.6jsim1,71831E-39,98282E-17,38847E-23,86234E-11,71831E-39,99983E-11,70897E-5
2.6min 1,71798E-3 9,98282E-1 7,38847E-2 3,86234E-1 1,71798E-3 9,99980E-1 1,70868E-5
2.6max 1,71831E-3 9,98283E-1 7,38848E-2 3,86234E-1 1,71831E-3 9,99983E-1 1,70897E-5
2.6mean 1,71831E-3 9,98282E-1 7,38847E-2 3,86234E-1 1,71831E-3 9,99983E-1 1,70897E-5
2.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.8BioUML1,85191E-39,98148E-17,87314E-24,08124E-11,85191E-39,99982E-11,84271E-5
2.8ByoDyn1,85191E-39,98148E-17,87314E-24,08124E-11,85191E-39,99982E-11,84271E-5
2.8MathSBML-9,98148E-17,87314E-2-1,85190E-39,99982E-11,84269E-5
2.8SBToolbox21,85160E-39,98150E-17,87312E-24,08125E-11,85160E-39,99980E-11,84240E-5
2.8SBWOdeSolver-9,98148E-17,87314E-2-1,85191E-39,99982E-11,84271E-5
2.8VCell-9,98148E-17,87314E-2-1,85191E-39,99982E-11,84271E-5
2.8copasi-9,98148E-17,87314E-2-1,85191E-39,99982E-11,84271E-5
2.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,98148E-17,87314E-2-1,85191E-39,99982E-11,84271E-5
2.8jsim1,85191E-39,98148E-17,87314E-24,08124E-11,85191E-39,99982E-11,84271E-5
2.8min 1,85160E-3 9,98148E-1 7,87312E-2 4,08124E-1 1,85160E-3 9,99980E-1 1,84240E-5
2.8max 1,85191E-3 9,98150E-1 7,87314E-2 4,08125E-1 1,85191E-3 9,99982E-1 1,84271E-5
2.8mean 1,85191E-3 9,98148E-1 7,87314E-2 4,08124E-1 1,85191E-3 9,99982E-1 1,84271E-5
2.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.0BioUML1,98829E-39,98012E-18,35683E-24,29607E-11,98829E-39,99980E-11,97930E-5
3.0ByoDyn1,98829E-39,98012E-18,35683E-24,29607E-11,98829E-39,99980E-11,97930E-5
3.0MathSBML-9,98012E-18,35683E-2-1,98828E-39,99980E-11,97929E-5
3.0SBToolbox21,98793E-39,98013E-18,35684E-24,29609E-11,98793E-39,99980E-11,97893E-5
3.0SBWOdeSolver-9,98012E-18,35683E-2-1,98829E-39,99980E-11,97930E-5
3.0VCell-9,98012E-18,35683E-2-1,98829E-39,99980E-11,97930E-5
3.0copasi-9,98012E-18,35683E-2-1,98829E-39,99980E-11,97930E-5
3.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,98012E-18,35683E-2-1,98829E-39,99980E-11,97930E-5
3.0jsim1,98829E-39,98012E-18,35683E-24,29607E-11,98829E-39,99980E-11,97930E-5
3.0min 1,98793E-3 9,98012E-1 8,35683E-2 4,29607E-1 1,98793E-3 9,99980E-1 1,97893E-5
3.0max 1,98829E-3 9,98013E-1 8,35684E-2 4,29609E-1 1,98829E-3 9,99980E-1 1,97930E-5
3.0mean 1,98829E-3 9,98012E-1 8,35683E-2 4,29607E-1 1,98829E-3 9,99980E-1 1,97930E-5
3.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.2BioUML2,12754E-39,97872E-18,83955E-24,50694E-12,12754E-39,99979E-12,11884E-5
3.2ByoDyn2,12754E-39,97872E-18,83955E-24,50694E-12,12754E-39,99979E-12,11884E-5
3.2MathSBML-9,97872E-18,83955E-2-2,12753E-39,99979E-12,11883E-5
3.2SBToolbox22,12723E-39,97873E-18,83956E-24,50694E-12,12723E-39,99980E-12,11853E-5
3.2SBWOdeSolver-9,97872E-18,83955E-2-2,12755E-39,99979E-12,11885E-5
3.2VCell-9,97872E-18,83955E-2-2,12754E-39,99979E-12,11884E-5
3.2copasi-9,97872E-18,83955E-2-2,12754E-39,99979E-12,11884E-5
3.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,97872E-18,83955E-2-2,12754E-39,99979E-12,11884E-5
3.2jsim2,12754E-39,97872E-18,83955E-24,50694E-12,12754E-39,99979E-12,11884E-5
3.2min 2,12723E-3 9,97872E-1 8,83955E-2 4,50694E-1 2,12723E-3 9,99979E-1 2,11853E-5
3.2max 2,12754E-3 9,97873E-1 8,83956E-2 4,50694E-1 2,12755E-3 9,99980E-1 2,11885E-5
3.2mean 2,12754E-3 9,97872E-1 8,83955E-2 4,50694E-1 2,12754E-3 9,99979E-1 2,11884E-5
3.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.4BioUML2,26975E-39,97730E-19,32130E-24,71397E-12,26975E-39,99977E-12,26144E-5
3.4ByoDyn2,26975E-39,97730E-19,32130E-24,71397E-12,26975E-39,99977E-12,26144E-5
3.4MathSBML-9,97730E-19,32130E-2-2,26974E-39,99977E-12,26143E-5
3.4SBToolbox22,26945E-39,97733E-19,32131E-24,71400E-12,26945E-39,99980E-12,26105E-5
3.4SBWOdeSolver-9,97730E-19,32130E-2-2,26975E-39,99977E-12,26144E-5
3.4VCell-9,97730E-19,32130E-2-2,26975E-39,99977E-12,26144E-5
3.4copasi-9,97730E-19,32130E-2-2,26975E-39,99977E-12,26143E-5
3.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,97730E-19,32130E-2-2,26975E-39,99977E-12,26144E-5
3.4jsim2,26975E-39,97730E-19,32130E-24,71397E-12,26975E-39,99977E-12,26144E-5
3.4min 2,26945E-3 9,97730E-1 9,32130E-2 4,71397E-1 2,26945E-3 9,99977E-1 2,26105E-5
3.4max 2,26975E-3 9,97733E-1 9,32131E-2 4,71400E-1 2,26975E-3 9,99980E-1 2,26144E-5
3.4mean 2,26975E-3 9,97730E-1 9,32130E-2 4,71397E-1 2,26975E-3 9,99977E-1 2,26144E-5
3.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.6BioUML2,41502E-39,97585E-19,80208E-24,91726E-12,41502E-39,99976E-12,40717E-5
3.6ByoDyn2,41502E-39,97585E-19,80208E-24,91726E-12,41502E-39,99976E-12,40717E-5
3.6MathSBML-9,97585E-19,80208E-2-2,41501E-39,99976E-12,40716E-5
3.6SBToolbox22,41467E-39,97584E-19,80206E-24,91726E-12,41467E-39,99980E-12,40684E-5
3.6SBWOdeSolver-9,97585E-19,80208E-2-2,41502E-39,99976E-12,40717E-5
3.6VCell-9,97585E-19,80208E-2-2,41502E-39,99976E-12,40717E-5
3.6copasi-9,97585E-19,80208E-2-2,41502E-39,99976E-12,40717E-5
3.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,97585E-19,80208E-2-2,41502E-39,99976E-12,40717E-5
3.6jsim2,41502E-39,97585E-19,80208E-24,91726E-12,41502E-39,99976E-12,40717E-5
3.6min 2,41467E-3 9,97584E-1 9,80206E-2 4,91726E-1 2,41467E-3 9,99976E-1 2,40684E-5
3.6max 2,41502E-3 9,97585E-1 9,80208E-2 4,91726E-1 2,41502E-3 9,99980E-1 2,40717E-5
3.6mean 2,41502E-3 9,97585E-1 9,80208E-2 4,91726E-1 2,41502E-3 9,99976E-1 2,40717E-5
3.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.8BioUML2,56344E-39,97437E-11,02819E-15,11691E-12,56344E-39,99974E-12,55616E-5
3.8ByoDyn2,56344E-39,97437E-11,02819E-15,11691E-12,56344E-39,99974E-12,55616E-5
3.8MathSBML-9,97437E-11,02819E-1-2,56344E-39,99974E-12,55616E-5
3.8SBToolbox22,56305E-39,97434E-11,02819E-15,11694E-12,56305E-39,99970E-12,55575E-5
3.8SBWOdeSolver-9,97437E-11,02819E-1-2,56344E-39,99974E-12,55616E-5
3.8VCell-9,97437E-11,02819E-1-2,56344E-39,99974E-12,55616E-5
3.8copasi-9,97437E-11,02819E-1-2,56344E-39,99974E-12,55616E-5
3.8edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,97437E-11,02819E-1-2,56344E-39,99974E-12,55616E-5
3.8jsim2,56344E-39,97437E-11,02819E-15,11691E-12,56344E-39,99974E-12,55616E-5
3.8min 2,56305E-3 9,97434E-1 1,02819E-1 5,11691E-1 2,56305E-3 9,99970E-1 2,55575E-5
3.8max 2,56344E-3 9,97437E-1 1,02819E-1 5,11694E-1 2,56344E-3 9,99974E-1 2,55616E-5
3.8mean 2,56344E-3 9,97437E-1 1,02819E-1 5,11691E-1 2,56344E-3 9,99974E-1 2,55616E-5
3.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.0BioUML2,71512E-39,97285E-11,07607E-15,31301E-12,71512E-39,99973E-12,70851E-5
4.0ByoDyn2,71512E-39,97285E-11,07607E-15,31301E-12,71512E-39,99973E-12,70851E-5
4.0MathSBML-9,97285E-11,07607E-1-2,71512E-39,99973E-12,70851E-5
4.0SBToolbox22,71466E-39,97284E-11,07604E-15,31302E-12,71466E-39,99970E-12,70802E-5
4.0SBWOdeSolver-9,97285E-11,07607E-1-2,71513E-39,99973E-12,70851E-5
4.0VCell-9,97285E-11,07607E-1-2,71512E-39,99973E-12,70851E-5
4.0copasi-9,97285E-11,07607E-1-2,71512E-39,99973E-12,70851E-5
4.0edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,97285E-11,07607E-1-2,71512E-39,99973E-12,70851E-5
4.0jsim2,71512E-39,97285E-11,07607E-15,31301E-12,71512E-39,99973E-12,70851E-5
4.0min 2,71466E-3 9,97284E-1 1,07604E-1 5,31301E-1 2,71466E-3 9,99970E-1 2,70802E-5
4.0max 2,71512E-3 9,97285E-1 1,07607E-1 5,31302E-1 2,71513E-3 9,99973E-1 2,70851E-5
4.0mean 2,71512E-3 9,97285E-1 1,07607E-1 5,31301E-1 2,71512E-3 9,99973E-1 2,70851E-5
4.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.2BioUML2,87017E-39,97130E-11,12386E-15,50565E-12,87017E-39,99971E-12,86433E-5
4.2ByoDyn2,87017E-39,97130E-11,12386E-15,50565E-12,87017E-39,99971E-12,86433E-5
4.2MathSBML-9,97130E-11,12386E-1-2,87017E-39,99971E-12,86433E-5
4.2SBToolbox22,86968E-39,97130E-11,12389E-15,50567E-12,86968E-39,99970E-12,86378E-5
4.2SBWOdeSolver-9,97130E-11,12386E-1-2,87017E-39,99971E-12,86433E-5
4.2VCell-9,97130E-11,12386E-1-2,87017E-39,99971E-12,86433E-5
4.2copasi-9,97130E-11,12386E-1-2,87017E-39,99971E-12,86433E-5
4.2edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,97130E-11,12386E-1-2,87017E-39,99971E-12,86433E-5
4.2jsim2,87017E-39,97130E-11,12386E-15,50565E-12,87017E-39,99971E-12,86433E-5
4.2min 2,86968E-3 9,97130E-1 1,12386E-1 5,50565E-1 2,86968E-3 9,99970E-1 2,86378E-5
4.2max 2,87017E-3 9,97130E-1 1,12389E-1 5,50567E-1 2,87017E-3 9,99971E-1 2,86433E-5
4.2mean 2,87017E-3 9,97130E-1 1,12386E-1 5,50565E-1 2,87017E-3 9,99971E-1 2,86433E-5
4.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.4BioUML3,02869E-39,96971E-11,17155E-15,69494E-13,02869E-39,99970E-13,02374E-5
4.4ByoDyn3,02869E-39,96971E-11,17155E-15,69494E-13,02869E-39,99970E-13,02374E-5
4.4MathSBML-9,96971E-11,17155E-1-3,02869E-39,99970E-13,02374E-5
4.4SBToolbox23,02818E-39,96974E-11,17154E-15,69496E-13,02818E-39,99970E-13,02324E-5
4.4SBWOdeSolver-9,96971E-11,17155E-1-3,02869E-39,99970E-13,02374E-5
4.4VCell-9,96971E-11,17155E-1-3,02869E-39,99970E-13,02374E-5
4.4copasi-9,96971E-11,17155E-1-3,02869E-39,99970E-13,02374E-5
4.4edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,96971E-11,17155E-1-3,02869E-39,99970E-13,02374E-5
4.4jsim3,02869E-39,96971E-11,17155E-15,69494E-13,02869E-39,99970E-13,02374E-5
4.4min 3,02818E-3 9,96971E-1 1,17154E-1 5,69494E-1 3,02818E-3 9,99970E-1 3,02324E-5
4.4max 3,02869E-3 9,96974E-1 1,17155E-1 5,69496E-1 3,02869E-3 9,99970E-1 3,02374E-5
4.4mean 3,02869E-3 9,96971E-1 1,17155E-1 5,69494E-1 3,02869E-3 9,99970E-1 3,02374E-5
4.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.6BioUML3,19081E-39,96809E-11,21915E-15,88095E-13,19081E-39,99968E-13,18687E-5
4.6ByoDyn3,19081E-39,96809E-11,21915E-15,88095E-13,19081E-39,99968E-13,18687E-5
4.6MathSBML-9,96809E-11,21915E-1-3,19082E-39,99968E-13,18687E-5
4.6SBToolbox23,19027E-39,96810E-11,21914E-15,88097E-13,19027E-39,99970E-13,18633E-5
4.6SBWOdeSolver-9,96809E-11,21915E-1-3,19081E-39,99968E-13,18687E-5
4.6VCell-9,96809E-11,21915E-1-3,19081E-39,99968E-13,18687E-5
4.6copasi-9,96809E-11,21915E-1-3,19081E-39,99968E-13,18687E-5
4.6edu.kgi.roadRunner-9,96809E-11,21915E-1-3,19081E-39,99968E-13,18687E-5
4.6jsim3,19081E-39,96809E-11,21915E-15,88095E-13,19081E-39,99968E-13,18687E-5
4.6min 3,19027E-3 9,96809E-1 1,21914E-1 5,88095E-1 3,19027E-3 9,99968E-1 3,18633E-5
4.6max 3,19081E-3 9,96810E-1 1,21915E-1 5,88097E-1 3,19082E-3 9,99970E-1 3,18687E-5
4.6mean 3,19081E-3 9,96809E-1 1,21915E-1 5,88095E-1 3,19081E-3 9,99968E-1 3,18687E-5