Test: BIOMD0000000009.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000009.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: Imex
generated code: BIOMD0000000009.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 4 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-10
ATOL 1.0E-25
RTOL 1.0E-14
STEP 1.0E-4

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000009.gif

Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL6615048798.png

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: KKPase  PP_K  KK  PP_KK  KPase_PP_K  P_KKK_P_KK  KKPase_PP_KK  KPase_P_K  K  KPase  KKK  E2  PP_KK_K  E1  E2_P_KKK  P_KKK  E1_KKK  P_KKK_KK  KKPase_P_KK  P_KK  P_K  PP_KK_P_K 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  Jarnac  SBToolbox2  VCell  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  jsim  BioUML 
timeresult KKPase PP_K KK PP_KK KPase_PP_K P_KKK_P_KK KKPase_PP_KK KPase_P_K K KPase KKK E2 PP_KK_K E1 E2_P_KKK P_KKK E1_KKK P_KKK_KK KKPase_P_KK P_KK P_K PP_KK_P_K
0.0BioUML3,00000E-40,00000E01,20000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,20000E01,20000E-13,00000E-33,00000E-40,00000E03,00000E-50,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0ByoDyn3,00000E-40,00000E01,20000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,20000E01,20000E-13,00000E-33,00000E-40,00000E03,00000E-50,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0Jarnac3,00000E-40,00000E01,20000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,20000E01,20000E-13,00000E-33,00000E-40,00000E03,00000E-50,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0MathSBML3,00000E-40,00000E01,20000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,20000E01,20000E-13,00000E-33,00000E-40,00000E03,00000E-50,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0SBToolbox23,00000E-40,00000E01,20000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,20000E01,20000E-13,00000E-33,00000E-40,00000E03,00000E-50,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0SBWOdeSolver3,00000E-40,00000E01,20000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,20000E01,20000E-13,00000E-33,00000E-40,00000E03,00000E-50,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0VCell3,00000E-40,00000E01,20000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,20000E01,20000E-13,00000E-33,00000E-40,00000E03,00000E-50,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0copasi3,00000E-40,00000E01,20000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,20000E01,20000E-13,00000E-33,00000E-40,00000E03,00000E-50,00000E00,00000E09,43907E-200,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner3,00000E-40,00000E01,20000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,20000E01,20000E-13,00000E-33,00000E-40,00000E03,00000E-50,00000E00,00000E0-1,97215E-190,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0jsim1,20000E-150,00000E04,80000E-120,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E04,80000E-124,80000E-131,20000E-141,20000E-150,00000E01,20000E-160,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0min 1,20000E-15 0,00000E0 4,80000E-12 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 4,80000E-12 4,80000E-13 1,20000E-14 1,20000E-15 0,00000E0 1,20000E-16 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 -1,97215E-19 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0max 3,00000E-4 0,00000E0 1,20000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,20000E0 1,20000E-1 3,00000E-3 3,00000E-4 0,00000E0 3,00000E-5 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 9,43907E-20 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0mean 3,00000E-4 0,00000E0 1,20000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,20000E0 1,20000E-1 3,00000E-3 3,00000E-4 0,00000E0 3,00000E-5 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML2,99902E-41,92361E-171,19989E08,75491E-106,66547E-185,68884E-108,19012E-132,11488E-91,20000E01,20000E-12,99098E-32,99998E-43,27709E-92,97038E-51,73879E-91,76824E-62,96160E-76,95461E-69,80181E-81,01417E-45,68604E-91,45562E-17
0.2ByoDyn2,99902E-41,90288E-171,19989E08,73784E-106,58949E-185,68425E-108,17353E-132,10964E-91,20000E01,20000E-12,99098E-32,99998E-43,27045E-92,97038E-51,73880E-91,76824E-62,96160E-76,95462E-69,79845E-81,01383E-45,67244E-91,44410E-17
0.2Jarnac2,99902E-4-2,13428E-151,19989E08,73808E-10-6,02154E-165,68427E-108,17377E-132,10973E-91,20000E01,20000E-12,99098E-32,99998E-43,27054E-92,97038E-51,73880E-91,76824E-62,96160E-76,95462E-69,79849E-81,01383E-45,67267E-92,88658E-15
0.2MathSBML2,99902E-42,38234E-171,19989E09,07276E-108,44942E-185,68974E-108,50778E-132,24205E-91,20000E01,20000E-12,99098E-32,99998E-43,40420E-92,97038E-51,73879E-91,76824E-62,96197E-76,95460E-69,79649E-81,01364E-46,00394E-91,66905E-17
0.2SBToolbox22,99900E-4-5,67464E-171,19990E02,01548E-10-2,16924E-171,78185E-101,84156E-133,59684E-101,20000E01,20000E-12,99101E-33,00000E-47,35540E-102,97040E-51,73883E-91,76823E-62,95792E-76,95523E-69,80136E-81,01370E-41,02863E-9-2,89667E-17
0.2SBWOdeSolver2,99902E-41,90675E-171,19989E08,74055E-106,60341E-185,68513E-108,17616E-132,11047E-91,20000E01,20000E-12,99098E-32,99998E-43,27150E-92,97038E-51,73880E-91,76824E-62,96160E-76,95462E-69,79895E-81,01388E-45,67460E-91,44669E-17
0.2VCell2,99902E-41,90352E-171,19989E08,73873E-106,59191E-185,68439E-108,17441E-132,10995E-91,20000E01,20000E-12,99098E-32,99998E-43,27080E-92,97038E-51,73880E-91,76824E-62,96160E-76,95462E-69,79869E-81,01385E-45,67323E-91,44447E-17
0.2copasi2,99902E-4-1,60256E-131,19989E08,73907E-10-5,05423E-145,68425E-108,17480E-132,11021E-91,20000E01,20000E-12,99098E-32,99998E-43,27099E-92,97038E-51,73880E-91,76824E-62,96160E-76,95462E-69,79845E-81,01383E-45,67380E-91,44309E-17
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner2,99902E-49,96971E-161,19989E08,73786E-103,75776E-165,68425E-108,17355E-132,10965E-91,20000E01,20000E-12,99098E-32,99998E-43,27046E-92,97038E-51,73880E-91,76824E-62,96160E-76,95462E-69,79845E-81,01383E-45,67246E-9-2,01948E-16
0.2jsim1,20000E-150,00000E04,80000E-123,14501E-1510,00000E02,09667E-1403,35468E-1765,62123E-2064,80000E-124,80000E-131,20000E-141,20000E-151,34187E-1721,20000E-162,21184E-746,91200E-501,15200E-398,84736E-715,09608E-1062,65421E-811,61025E-1830,00000E0
0.2min 1,20000E-15 -1,60256E-13 4,80000E-12 3,14501E-151 -5,05423E-14 2,09667E-140 3,35468E-176 5,62123E-206 4,80000E-12 4,80000E-13 1,20000E-14 1,20000E-15 1,34187E-172 1,20000E-16 2,21184E-74 6,91200E-50 1,15200E-39 8,84736E-71 5,09608E-106 2,65421E-81 1,61025E-183 -2,01948E-16
0.2max 2,99902E-4 9,96971E-16 1,19990E0 9,07276E-10 3,75776E-16 5,68974E-10 8,50778E-13 2,24205E-9 1,20000E0 1,20000E-1 2,99101E-3 3,00000E-4 3,40420E-9 2,97040E-5 1,73883E-9 1,76824E-6 2,96197E-7 6,95523E-6 9,80136E-8 1,01388E-4 6,00394E-9 2,88658E-15
0.2mean 2,99902E-4 1,90288E-17 1,19989E0 8,73808E-10 6,58949E-18 5,68425E-10 8,17377E-13 2,10973E-9 1,20000E0 1,20000E-1 2,99098E-3 2,99998E-4 3,27054E-9 2,97038E-5 1,73880E-9 1,76824E-6 2,96160E-7 6,95462E-6 9,79845E-8 1,01383E-4 5,67267E-9 1,44410E-17
0.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML2,99599E-48,89247E-151,19958E01,42651E-83,31701E-154,68171E-91,37826E-114,40527E-81,20000E01,20000E-12,98219E-32,99997E-45,52031E-82,97047E-53,49714E-93,52636E-62,95297E-71,39839E-54,01026E-74,08281E-41,14040E-75,07230E-15
0.4ByoDyn2,99599E-48,88816E-151,19958E01,42638E-83,31530E-154,68161E-91,37813E-114,40479E-81,20000E01,20000E-12,98219E-32,99997E-45,51978E-82,97047E-53,49714E-93,52636E-62,95297E-71,39839E-54,01020E-74,08275E-41,14028E-75,07106E-15
0.4Jarnac2,99599E-49,72513E-151,19958E01,42645E-83,59507E-154,68164E-91,37820E-114,40505E-81,20000E01,20000E-12,98219E-32,99997E-45,52005E-82,97047E-53,49714E-93,52636E-62,95297E-71,39839E-54,01023E-74,08278E-41,14034E-72,22045E-15
0.4MathSBML2,99599E-49,47071E-151,19958E01,43710E-83,56088E-154,68318E-91,38882E-114,44784E-81,20000E01,20000E-12,98219E-32,99997E-45,56262E-82,97047E-53,49714E-93,52636E-62,95295E-71,39839E-54,01005E-74,08261E-41,15103E-75,21860E-15
0.4SBToolbox22,99601E-4-6,73012E-151,19960E01,18717E-8-2,64527E-154,09109E-91,14612E-113,63726E-81,20000E01,20000E-12,98222E-33,00000E-44,58655E-82,97050E-53,49720E-93,52640E-62,95302E-71,39850E-54,00734E-74,07846E-49,42484E-8-2,96540E-15
0.4SBWOdeSolver2,99599E-48,89543E-151,19958E01,42659E-83,31806E-154,68194E-91,37833E-114,40552E-81,20000E01,20000E-12,98219E-32,99997E-45,52060E-82,97047E-53,49714E-93,52636E-62,95297E-71,39839E-54,01029E-74,08285E-41,14046E-75,07489E-15
0.4VCell2,99599E-48,88848E-151,19958E01,42640E-83,31542E-154,68163E-91,37815E-114,40487E-81,20000E01,20000E-12,98219E-32,99997E-45,51986E-82,97047E-53,49714E-93,52636E-62,95297E-71,39839E-54,01022E-74,08278E-41,14030E-75,07122E-15
0.4copasi2,99599E-4-2,59038E-141,19958E01,42639E-8-9,06099E-144,68161E-91,37814E-114,40484E-81,20000E01,20000E-12,98219E-32,99997E-45,51982E-82,97047E-53,49714E-93,52636E-62,95297E-71,39839E-54,01020E-74,08275E-41,14029E-75,07193E-15
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner2,99599E-49,06756E-151,19958E01,42638E-83,39543E-154,68161E-91,37813E-114,40479E-81,20000E01,20000E-12,98219E-32,99997E-45,51978E-82,97047E-53,49714E-93,52636E-62,95297E-71,39839E-54,01020E-74,08275E-41,14028E-74,84676E-15
0.4jsim1,20000E-150,00000E04,80000E-128,05122E-1490,00000E02,68374E-1381,71759E-1731,15123E-2024,80000E-124,80000E-131,20000E-141,20000E-156,87038E-1701,20000E-161,76947E-732,76480E-492,30400E-397,07789E-701,63075E-1044,24673E-801,64889E-1800,00000E0
0.4min 1,20000E-15 -2,59038E-14 4,80000E-12 8,05122E-149 -9,06099E-14 2,68374E-138 1,71759E-173 1,15123E-202 4,80000E-12 4,80000E-13 1,20000E-14 1,20000E-15 6,87038E-170 1,20000E-16 1,76947E-73 2,76480E-49 2,30400E-39 7,07789E-70 1,63075E-104 4,24673E-80 1,64889E-180 -2,96540E-15
0.4max 2,99601E-4 9,72513E-15 1,19960E0 1,43710E-8 3,59507E-15 4,68318E-9 1,38882E-11 4,44784E-8 1,20000E0 1,20000E-1 2,98222E-3 3,00000E-4 5,56262E-8 2,97050E-5 3,49720E-9 3,52640E-6 2,95302E-7 1,39850E-5 4,01029E-7 4,08285E-4 1,15103E-7 5,21860E-15
0.4mean 2,99599E-4 8,88848E-15 1,19958E0 1,42639E-8 3,31542E-15 4,68161E-9 1,37814E-11 4,40484E-8 1,20000E0 1,20000E-1 2,98219E-3 2,99997E-4 5,51982E-8 2,97047E-5 3,49714E-9 3,52636E-6 2,95297E-7 1,39839E-5 4,01020E-7 4,08275E-4 1,14029E-7 5,07106E-15
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML2,99100E-42,78220E-131,19907E07,19661E-81,06313E-131,57671E-87,01929E-112,42066E-71,20000E01,20000E-12,97347E-32,99995E-42,81607E-72,97056E-55,23984E-95,26884E-62,94443E-72,09436E-58,99930E-79,12560E-46,19116E-71,42147E-13
0.6ByoDyn2,99100E-42,77967E-131,19907E07,19534E-81,06215E-131,57659E-87,01804E-112,42019E-71,20000E01,20000E-12,97347E-32,99995E-42,81557E-72,97056E-55,23984E-95,26885E-62,94443E-72,09436E-58,99904E-79,12534E-46,18998E-71,42033E-13
0.6Jarnac2,99100E-42,78470E-131,19907E07,19575E-81,06324E-131,57660E-87,01844E-112,42035E-71,20000E01,20000E-12,97347E-32,99995E-42,81573E-72,97056E-55,23984E-95,26885E-62,94443E-72,09436E-58,99913E-79,12542E-46,19038E-71,42553E-13
0.6MathSBML2,99100E-42,92546E-131,19907E07,22046E-81,12205E-131,57655E-87,04301E-112,43027E-71,20000E01,20000E-12,97347E-32,99995E-42,82562E-72,97056E-55,23984E-95,26885E-62,94441E-72,09436E-58,99891E-79,12521E-46,21518E-71,46831E-13
0.6SBToolbox22,99102E-41,01163E-131,19910E06,83498E-83,82650E-141,48590E-86,67310E-112,30298E-71,20000E01,20000E-12,97343E-32,99990E-42,67503E-72,97060E-55,23989E-95,26889E-62,94442E-72,09443E-58,99309E-79,11610E-45,88868E-75,42510E-14
0.6SBWOdeSolver2,99100E-42,78104E-131,19907E07,19603E-81,06268E-131,57666E-87,01869E-112,42043E-71,20000E01,20000E-12,97347E-32,99995E-42,81583E-72,97056E-55,23984E-95,26883E-62,94443E-72,09436E-58,99917E-79,12547E-46,19060E-71,42099E-13
0.6VCell2,99100E-42,77971E-131,19907E07,19538E-81,06216E-131,57659E-87,01808E-112,42020E-71,20000E01,20000E-12,97347E-32,99995E-42,81559E-72,97056E-55,23984E-95,26885E-62,94443E-72,09436E-58,99907E-79,12536E-46,19002E-71,42035E-13
0.6copasi2,99100E-42,45313E-131,19907E07,19534E-81,09667E-131,57659E-87,01804E-112,42019E-71,20000E01,20000E-12,97347E-32,99995E-42,81557E-72,97056E-55,23984E-95,26885E-62,94443E-72,09436E-58,99904E-79,12534E-46,18998E-71,42046E-13
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner2,99100E-42,77705E-131,19907E07,19534E-81,06148E-131,57659E-87,01804E-112,42019E-71,20000E01,20000E-12,97347E-32,99995E-42,81557E-72,97056E-55,23984E-95,26885E-62,94443E-72,09436E-58,99904E-79,12534E-46,18998E-71,42172E-13
0.6jsim1,20000E-150,00000E04,80000E-122,06344E-1470,00000E04,58542E-1376,60301E-1729,95782E-2014,80000E-124,80000E-131,20000E-141,20000E-152,64120E-1681,20000E-165,97197E-736,22080E-493,45600E-392,38879E-691,23835E-1032,14991E-799,50833E-1790,00000E0
0.6min 1,20000E-15 0,00000E0 4,80000E-12 2,06344E-147 0,00000E0 4,58542E-137 6,60301E-172 9,95782E-201 4,80000E-12 4,80000E-13 1,20000E-14 1,20000E-15 2,64120E-168 1,20000E-16 5,97197E-73 6,22080E-49 3,45600E-39 2,38879E-69 1,23835E-103 2,14991E-79 9,50833E-179 0,00000E0
0.6max 2,99102E-4 2,92546E-13 1,19910E0 7,22046E-8 1,12205E-13 1,57666E-8 7,04301E-11 2,43027E-7 1,20000E0 1,20000E-1 2,97347E-3 2,99995E-4 2,82562E-7 2,97060E-5 5,23989E-9 5,26889E-6 2,94443E-7 2,09443E-5 8,99917E-7 9,12547E-4 6,21518E-7 1,46831E-13
0.6mean 2,99100E-4 2,77967E-13 1,19907E0 7,19534E-8 1,06216E-13 1,57659E-8 7,01804E-11 2,42019E-7 1,20000E0 1,20000E-1 2,97347E-3 2,99995E-4 2,81557E-7 2,97056E-5 5,23984E-9 5,26885E-6 2,94443E-7 2,09436E-5 8,99904E-7 9,12534E-4 6,18998E-7 1,42046E-13
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML2,98415E-43,03408E-121,19836E02,25285E-71,17319E-123,69994E-82,20455E-107,91303E-71,20000E01,19999E-12,96484E-32,99993E-48,86466E-72,97064E-56,96702E-96,99584E-62,93596E-72,78310E-51,58470E-61,60609E-32,01195E-61,46226E-12
0.8ByoDyn2,98415E-43,03219E-121,19836E02,25258E-71,17245E-123,69973E-82,20428E-107,91200E-71,20000E01,19999E-12,96484E-32,99993E-48,86356E-72,97064E-56,96702E-96,99585E-62,93596E-72,78310E-51,58467E-61,60606E-32,01169E-61,46143E-12
0.8Jarnac2,98415E-43,03272E-121,19836E02,25272E-71,17264E-123,69977E-82,20442E-107,91255E-71,20000E01,19999E-12,96484E-32,99993E-48,86412E-72,97064E-56,96702E-96,99584E-62,93596E-72,78310E-51,58468E-61,60607E-32,01183E-61,46261E-12
0.8MathSBML2,98415E-43,05749E-121,19836E02,25504E-71,18420E-123,69967E-82,20674E-107,92187E-71,20000E01,19999E-12,96484E-32,99993E-48,87343E-72,97064E-56,96702E-96,99585E-62,93597E-72,78310E-51,58466E-61,60604E-32,01416E-61,46157E-12
0.8SBToolbox22,98413E-42,23974E-121,19840E02,20723E-78,69774E-133,58937E-82,16169E-107,76494E-71,20000E01,20000E-12,96483E-32,99990E-48,68662E-72,97060E-56,96703E-96,99592E-62,93593E-72,78326E-51,58372E-61,60468E-31,97384E-61,05591E-12
0.8SBWOdeSolver2,98415E-43,03324E-121,19836E02,25273E-71,17286E-123,69985E-82,20443E-107,91257E-71,20000E01,19999E-12,96484E-32,99993E-48,86416E-72,97064E-56,96702E-96,99585E-62,93596E-72,78310E-51,58468E-61,60607E-32,01184E-61,46191E-12
0.8VCell2,98415E-43,03221E-121,19836E02,25258E-71,17246E-123,69974E-82,20429E-107,91203E-71,20000E01,19999E-12,96484E-32,99993E-48,86359E-72,97064E-56,96702E-96,99584E-62,93596E-72,78310E-51,58467E-61,60606E-32,01170E-61,46144E-12
0.8copasi2,98415E-42,95942E-121,19836E02,25257E-71,09399E-123,69973E-82,20428E-107,91199E-71,20000E01,19999E-12,96484E-32,99993E-48,86355E-72,97064E-56,96702E-96,99585E-62,93596E-72,78310E-51,58467E-61,60606E-32,01169E-61,46161E-12
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner2,98415E-43,03196E-121,19836E02,25258E-71,17238E-123,69973E-82,20428E-107,91200E-71,20000E01,19999E-12,96484E-32,99993E-48,86356E-72,97064E-56,96702E-96,99585E-62,93596E-72,78310E-51,58467E-61,60606E-32,01169E-61,46170E-12
0.8jsim1,20000E-150,00000E04,80000E-122,06111E-1460,00000E03,43519E-1368,79408E-1712,35771E-1994,80000E-124,80000E-131,20000E-141,20000E-153,51763E-1671,20000E-161,41558E-721,10592E-484,60800E-395,66231E-695,21839E-1036,79477E-791,68846E-1770,00000E0
0.8min 1,20000E-15 0,00000E0 4,80000E-12 2,06111E-146 0,00000E0 3,43519E-136 8,79408E-171 2,35771E-199 4,80000E-12 4,80000E-13 1,20000E-14 1,20000E-15 3,51763E-167 1,20000E-16 1,41558E-72 1,10592E-48 4,60800E-39 5,66231E-69 5,21839E-103 6,79477E-79 1,68846E-177 0,00000E0
0.8max 2,98415E-4 3,05749E-12 1,19840E0 2,25504E-7 1,18420E-12 3,69985E-8 2,20674E-10 7,92187E-7 1,20000E0 1,20000E-1 2,96484E-3 2,99993E-4 8,87343E-7 2,97064E-5 6,96703E-9 6,99592E-6 2,93597E-7 2,78326E-5 1,58468E-6 1,60607E-3 2,01416E-6 1,46261E-12
0.8mean 2,98415E-4 3,03219E-12 1,19836E0 2,25258E-7 1,17245E-12 3,69973E-8 2,20428E-10 7,91200E-7 1,20000E0 1,19999E-1 2,96484E-3 2,99993E-4 8,86356E-7 2,97064E-5 6,96702E-9 6,99585E-6 2,93596E-7 2,78310E-5 1,58467E-6 1,60606E-3 2,01169E-6 1,46157E-12
0.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.0BioUML2,97555E-41,88503E-111,19748E05,43476E-77,34023E-127,13132E-85,32068E-101,95952E-61,19999E01,19998E-12,95628E-32,99991E-42,14564E-62,97072E-58,67884E-98,70749E-62,92757E-73,46439E-52,44494E-62,48090E-34,96488E-68,76232E-12
1.0ByoDyn2,97555E-41,88445E-111,19748E05,43443E-77,33794E-127,13112E-85,32035E-101,95939E-61,19999E01,19998E-12,95628E-32,99991E-42,14550E-62,97072E-58,67884E-98,70750E-62,92757E-73,46439E-52,44492E-62,48088E-34,96456E-68,75983E-12
1.0Jarnac2,97555E-41,88474E-111,19748E05,43481E-77,33907E-127,13121E-85,32073E-101,95954E-61,19999E01,19998E-12,95628E-32,99991E-42,14566E-62,97072E-58,67884E-98,70749E-62,92757E-73,46439E-52,44495E-62,48091E-34,96493E-68,76121E-12
1.0MathSBML2,97555E-41,90055E-111,19748E05,43457E-77,40579E-127,13109E-85,32045E-101,95945E-61,19999E01,19998E-12,95628E-32,99991E-42,14556E-62,97072E-58,67884E-98,70750E-62,92757E-73,46439E-52,44491E-62,48087E-34,96471E-68,80278E-12
1.0SBToolbox22,97555E-41,44779E-111,19750E05,33482E-75,64911E-126,88204E-85,22877E-101,92678E-61,20000E01,20000E-12,95625E-32,99990E-42,10664E-62,97070E-58,67888E-98,70758E-62,92754E-73,46461E-52,44440E-62,47911E-34,88080E-66,66037E-12
1.0SBWOdeSolver2,97555E-41,88495E-111,19748E05,43471E-77,33989E-127,13127E-85,32063E-101,95950E-61,19999E01,19998E-12,95628E-32,99991E-42,14562E-62,97072E-58,67884E-98,70751E-62,92757E-73,46439E-52,44493E-62,48090E-34,96483E-68,76205E-12
1.0VCell2,97555E-41,88446E-111,19748E05,43444E-77,33797E-127,13113E-85,32036E-101,95940E-61,19999E01,19998E-12,95628E-32,99991E-42,14551E-62,97072E-58,67884E-98,70750E-62,92757E-73,46439E-52,44492E-62,48088E-34,96457E-68,75986E-12
1.0copasi2,97555E-41,85352E-111,19748E05,43442E-77,69089E-127,13112E-85,32035E-101,95939E-61,19999E01,19998E-12,95628E-32,99991E-42,14550E-62,97072E-58,67884E-98,70750E-62,92757E-73,46439E-52,44492E-62,48088E-34,96455E-68,75887E-12
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner2,97555E-41,88444E-111,19748E05,43443E-77,33788E-127,13112E-85,32035E-101,95939E-61,19999E01,19998E-12,95628E-32,99991E-42,14550E-62,97072E-58,67884E-98,70750E-62,92757E-73,46439E-52,44492E-62,48088E-34,96456E-68,75992E-12
1.0jsim1,20000E-150,00000E04,80000E-121,22852E-1450,00000E01,63803E-1356,55210E-1702,74474E-1984,80000E-124,80000E-131,20000E-141,20000E-152,62084E-1661,20000E-162,76480E-721,72800E-485,76000E-391,10592E-681,59252E-1021,65888E-781,57250E-1760,00000E0
1.0min 1,20000E-15 0,00000E0 4,80000E-12 1,22852E-145 0,00000E0 1,63803E-135 6,55210E-170 2,74474E-198 4,80000E-12 4,80000E-13 1,20000E-14 1,20000E-15 2,62084E-166 1,20000E-16 2,76480E-72 1,72800E-48 5,76000E-39 1,10592E-68 1,59252E-102 1,65888E-78 1,57250E-176 0,00000E0
1.0max 2,97555E-4 1,90055E-11 1,19750E0 5,43481E-7 7,69089E-12 7,13127E-8 5,32073E-10 1,95954E-6 1,20000E0 1,20000E-1 2,95628E-3 2,99991E-4 2,14566E-6 2,97072E-5 8,67888E-9 8,70758E-6 2,92757E-7 3,46461E-5 2,44495E-6 2,48091E-3 4,96493E-6 8,80278E-12
1.0mean 2,97555E-4 1,88445E-11 1,19748E0 5,43443E-7 7,33797E-12 7,13112E-8 5,32035E-10 1,95939E-6 1,19999E0 1,19998E-1 2,95628E-3 2,99991E-4 2,14550E-6 2,97072E-5 8,67884E-9 8,70750E-6 2,92757E-7 3,46439E-5 2,44492E-6 2,48088E-3 4,96456E-6 8,75986E-12
1.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.2BioUML2,96529E-48,25211E-111,19642E01,11225E-63,22825E-111,21413E-71,08758E-94,08108E-61,19998E01,19996E-12,94779E-32,99990E-44,40090E-62,97081E-51,03754E-81,04039E-52,91925E-74,13800E-53,46999E-63,52923E-31,03166E-53,74271E-11
1.2ByoDyn2,96529E-48,25071E-111,19642E01,11222E-63,22770E-111,21412E-71,08754E-94,08093E-61,19998E01,19996E-12,94779E-32,99990E-44,40075E-62,97081E-51,03754E-81,04039E-52,91925E-74,13800E-53,46998E-63,52921E-31,03162E-53,74212E-11
1.2Jarnac2,96529E-48,25196E-111,19642E01,11229E-63,22820E-111,21413E-71,08761E-94,08122E-61,19998E01,19996E-12,94779E-32,99990E-44,40105E-62,97081E-51,03754E-81,04039E-52,91925E-74,13800E-53,47002E-63,52925E-31,03170E-53,74272E-11
1.2MathSBML2,96529E-48,26487E-111,19642E01,11215E-63,23431E-111,21411E-71,08748E-94,08069E-61,19998E01,19996E-12,94779E-32,99990E-44,40051E-62,97081E-51,03754E-81,04039E-52,91925E-74,13800E-53,46997E-63,52920E-31,03156E-53,74204E-11
1.2SBToolbox22,96527E-45,54908E-111,19641E01,08796E-62,17040E-111,17358E-71,06566E-93,99569E-61,20000E01,20000E-12,94776E-32,99990E-44,30538E-62,97080E-51,03758E-81,04039E-52,91925E-74,13838E-53,47078E-63,52741E-31,00998E-52,52023E-11
1.2SBWOdeSolver2,96529E-48,25244E-111,19642E01,11226E-63,22838E-111,21414E-71,08759E-94,08111E-61,19998E01,19996E-12,94779E-32,99990E-44,40094E-62,97081E-51,03754E-81,04039E-52,91925E-74,13800E-53,47000E-63,52923E-31,03167E-53,74288E-11
1.2VCell2,96529E-48,25073E-111,19642E01,11222E-63,22770E-111,21412E-71,08754E-94,08094E-61,19998E01,19996E-12,94779E-32,99990E-44,40076E-62,97081E-51,03754E-81,04039E-52,91925E-74,13800E-53,46998E-63,52921E-31,03162E-53,74213E-11
1.2copasi2,96529E-48,26804E-111,19642E01,11221E-63,20545E-111,21412E-71,08754E-94,08093E-61,19998E01,19996E-12,94779E-32,99990E-44,40075E-62,97081E-51,03754E-81,04039E-52,91925E-74,13800E-53,46998E-63,52921E-31,03162E-53,74211E-11
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner2,96529E-48,25068E-111,19642E01,11222E-63,22768E-111,21412E-71,08754E-94,08093E-61,19998E01,19996E-12,94779E-32,99990E-44,40075E-62,97081E-51,03754E-81,04039E-52,91925E-74,13800E-53,46998E-63,52921E-31,03162E-53,74214E-11
1.2jsim1,20000E-150,00000E04,80000E-125,28241E-1450,00000E05,86934E-1353,38074E-1692,03936E-1974,80000E-124,80000E-131,20000E-141,20000E-151,35230E-1651,20000E-164,77757E-722,48832E-486,91200E-391,91103E-683,96271E-1023,43985E-789,73653E-1760,00000E0
1.2min 1,20000E-15 0,00000E0 4,80000E-12 5,28241E-145 0,00000E0 5,86934E-135 3,38074E-169 2,03936E-197 4,80000E-12 4,80000E-13 1,20000E-14 1,20000E-15 1,35230E-165 1,20000E-16 4,77757E-72 2,48832E-48 6,91200E-39 1,91103E-68 3,96271E-102 3,43985E-78 9,73653E-176 0,00000E0
1.2max 2,96529E-4 8,26804E-11 1,19642E0 1,11229E-6 3,23431E-11 1,21414E-7 1,08761E-9 4,08122E-6 1,20000E0 1,20000E-1 2,94779E-3 2,99990E-4 4,40105E-6 2,97081E-5 1,03758E-8 1,04039E-5 2,91925E-7 4,13838E-5 3,47078E-6 3,52925E-3 1,03170E-5 3,74288E-11
1.2mean 2,96529E-4 8,25073E-11 1,19642E0 1,11222E-6 3,22770E-11 1,21412E-7 1,08754E-9 4,08093E-6 1,19998E0 1,19996E-1 2,94779E-3 2,99990E-4 4,40075E-6 2,97081E-5 1,03754E-8 1,04039E-5 2,91925E-7 4,13800E-5 3,46998E-6 3,52921E-3 1,03162E-5 3,74212E-11
1.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.4BioUML2,95349E-42,84425E-101,19519E02,03230E-61,11632E-101,89782E-71,98247E-97,55092E-61,19997E01,19992E-12,93938E-32,99988E-48,05397E-62,97089E-51,20569E-81,20853E-52,91100E-74,80374E-54,64902E-64,74344E-31,90572E-51,26722E-10
1.4ByoDyn2,95349E-42,84415E-101,19519E02,03229E-61,11629E-101,89782E-71,98246E-97,55087E-61,19997E01,19992E-12,93938E-32,99988E-48,05391E-62,97089E-51,20569E-81,20853E-52,91100E-74,80374E-54,64902E-64,74343E-31,90571E-51,26718E-10
1.4Jarnac2,95349E-42,84451E-101,19519E02,03240E-61,11643E-101,89784E-71,98257E-97,55132E-61,19997E01,19992E-12,93938E-32,99988E-48,05437E-62,97089E-51,20569E-81,20853E-52,91100E-74,80374E-54,64907E-64,74349E-31,90582E-51,26734E-10
1.4MathSBML2,95349E-42,84604E-101,19519E02,03214E-61,11759E-101,89782E-71,98233E-97,55030E-61,19997E01,19992E-12,93938E-32,99988E-48,05334E-62,97089E-51,20569E-81,20853E-52,91100E-74,80374E-54,64901E-64,74343E-31,90557E-51,26455E-10
1.4SBToolbox22,95348E-42,33692E-101,19521E02,01102E-69,18859E-111,84937E-71,96474E-97,48055E-61,20000E01,19990E-12,93936E-32,99990E-47,97098E-62,97090E-51,20572E-81,20852E-52,91097E-74,80427E-54,64915E-64,74016E-31,88768E-51,03119E-10
1.4SBWOdeSolver2,95349E-42,84464E-101,19519E02,03236E-61,11648E-101,89785E-71,98253E-97,55114E-61,19997E01,19992E-12,939