Test BIOMD0000000011.xml details

Test: BIOMD0000000011.xml - Ok

test	: BIOMD0000000011.xml
model	: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine	: DormandPrince
generated code	: BIOMD0000000011.java
results	: CSV file
plots	: -
comparison	: comparison with other simulators
status	: Ok
simulation time	: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-10
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000011.gif

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
- no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
- small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
- simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: MEKRAFp MAPK MEKppMEKPH RAFpRAFPH RAFK MAPKMEKpp MEK RAF MEKpMEKPH RAFp MEKPH RAFRAFK MAPKpMAPKPH MAPKppMAPKPH MAPKpMEKpp MEKp MAPKp MAPKpp MAPKPH MEKpRAFp MEKpp RAFPH
Simulators: ByoDyn CVODE copasi edu.kgi.roadRunner Jarnac SBToolbox2 Oscill8 Core SBWOdeSolver MathSBML jsim BioUML

time

result

MEKRAFp

MAPK

MEKppMEKPH

RAFpRAFPH

RAFK

MAPKMEKpp

MEK

RAF

MEKpMEKPH

RAFp

MEKPH

RAFRAFK

MAPKpMAPKPH

MAPKppMAPKPH

MAPKpMEKpp

MEKp

MAPKp

MAPKpp

MAPKPH

MEKpRAFp

MEKpp

RAFPH

0.0

BioUML

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

ByoDyn

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

CVODE

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

Jarnac

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

MathSBML

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

Oscill8 Core

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

1,00000E-1

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

SBToolbox2

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

SBWOdeSolver

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

copasi

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

-2,77556E-17

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,77556E-17

3,00000E-1

-2,77556E-17

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

jsim

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

min

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

-2,77556E-17

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

-2,77556E-17

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

max

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,77556E-17

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

mean

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

1,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

4,00000E-1

0,00000E0

2,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0,00000E0

3,00000E-1

0.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0.2

BioUML

3,13769E-6

3,00000E-1

1,00756E-17

7,10268E-7

9,27462E-2

3,03502E-17

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18626E-9

7,10873E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25382E-3

1,70305E-21

4,41284E-41

2,94375E-36

1,48625E-8

6,10834E-20

3,00425E-39

3,00000E-1

1,01930E-13

2,21935E-16

2,99999E-1

0.2

ByoDyn

3,13769E-6

3,00000E-1

1,00755E-17

7,10268E-7

9,27462E-2

3,03501E-17

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18626E-9

7,10873E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25382E-3

1,70303E-21

4,41240E-41

2,94378E-36

1,48625E-8

6,10833E-20

3,00417E-39

3,00000E-1

1,01930E-13

2,21935E-16

2,99999E-1

0.2

CVODE

3,13770E-6

3,00000E-1

1,03780E-17

7,10269E-7

9,27462E-2

3,12652E-17

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18668E-9

7,10873E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25382E-3

1,89490E-21

6,80806E-41

3,41221E-36

1,48617E-8

6,48776E-20

3,95810E-39

3,00000E-1

1,02293E-13

2,24415E-16

2,99999E-1

0.2

Jarnac

3,13769E-6

3,00000E-1

-3,10862E-14

7,10267E-7

9,27462E-2

-2,58995E-15

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18626E-9

7,10873E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25382E-3

-1,40339E-18

0,00000E0

5,75236E-32

1,48625E-8

-1,82594E-17

2,60902E-15

3,00000E-1

1,01930E-13

-3,03438E-15

2,99999E-1

0.2

MathSBML

3,13851E-6

3,00000E-1

9,24956E-18

7,10461E-7

9,27462E-2

2,78640E-17

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,19591E-9

7,10871E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25381E-3

7,04670E-22

5,56616E-42

5,08408E-36

1,48196E-8

5,73909E-20

6,42071E-39

3,00000E-1

1,09138E-13

3,04922E-16

2,99999E-1

0.2

Oscill8 Core

3,14056E-6

3,00000E-1

9,27462E-2

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18695E-9

7,10857E-5

2,00000E-1

3,34032E-12

3,21225E-21

1,48840E-8

1,11874E-11

3,00000E-1

3,34799E-11

2,99999E-1

0.2

SBToolbox2

3,20043E-6

3,00000E-1

-1,07581E-17

7,24286E-7

9,27456E-2

-3,27801E-17

2,00000E-1

3,92667E-1

1,40308E-9

7,08905E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25471E-3

-2,20362E-20

-4,64983E-38

-2,13865E-34

1,60271E-8

-2,44682E-19

-7,99737E-37

3,00000E-1

2,60526E-14

-9,90077E-18

3,00000E-1

0.2

SBWOdeSolver

3,13811E-6

3,00000E-1

1,00935E-17

7,10361E-7

9,27462E-2

3,04043E-17

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18682E-9

7,10900E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25378E-3

1,70801E-21

4,54649E-41

2,98687E-36

1,48666E-8

6,12240E-20

3,06708E-39

3,00000E-1

1,02033E-13

2,22231E-16

2,99999E-1

0.2

copasi

3,13769E-6

3,00000E-1

2,06837E-17

7,10268E-7

9,27462E-2

-8,65858E-35

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18631E-9

7,10873E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25382E-3

-8,47276E-39

8,47276E-39

8,58763E-35

1,48625E-8

-8,44261E-19

7,09560E-37

3,00000E-1

1,01881E-13

1,96510E-16

2,99999E-1

0.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,13769E-6

3,00000E-1

-2,82370E-17

7,10267E-7

9,27462E-2

2,77556E-17

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18626E-9

7,10873E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25382E-3

1,07460E-18

-8,89253E-16

-7,46453E-33

1,48626E-8

5,11755E-17

7,49401E-16

3,00000E-1

1,01877E-13

5,00630E-16

2,99999E-1

0.2

jsim

3,13769E-6

3,00000E-1

1,00756E-17

7,10268E-7

9,27462E-2

3,03501E-17

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18626E-9

7,10873E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25382E-3

1,70304E-21

4,41251E-41

2,94372E-36

1,48625E-8

6,10833E-20

3,00412E-39

3,00000E-1

1,01930E-13

2,21935E-16

2,99999E-1

0.2

min

3,13769E-6

3,00000E-1

-3,10862E-14

7,10267E-7

9,27456E-2

-2,58995E-15

1,99997E-1

3,92667E-1

1,18626E-9

7,08905E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25378E-3

-1,40339E-18

-8,89253E-16

-7,46453E-33

1,48196E-8

-1,82594E-17

-7,99737E-37

3,00000E-1

2,60526E-14

-3,03438E-15

2,99999E-1

0.2

max

3,20043E-6

3,00000E-1

2,06837E-17

7,24286E-7

9,27462E-2

3,12652E-17

2,00000E-1

3,92671E-1

1,40308E-9

7,10900E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25471E-3

3,34032E-12

8,47276E-39

3,21225E-21

1,60271E-8

1,11874E-11

2,60902E-15

3,00000E-1

1,09138E-13

3,34799E-11

3,00000E-1

0.2

mean

3,13769E-6

3,00000E-1

1,00755E-17

7,10268E-7

9,27462E-2

2,78640E-17

1,99997E-1

3,92671E-1

1,18650E-9

7,10873E-5

2,00000E-1

7,25382E-3

1,70303E-21

4,41240E-41

3,19954E-36

1,48625E-8

6,10833E-20

3,95810E-39

3,00000E-1

1,01930E-13

2,22083E-16

2,99999E-1

0.2

relative error(%)

0,00

0.4

BioUML

2,24421E-5

3,00000E-1

3,60583E-15

5,06006E-6

8,67928E-2

1,09075E-14

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21660E-8

2,53942E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32072E-2

2,50377E-18

4,79936E-35

7,67657E-31

2,02415E-7

4,40374E-17

1,59352E-33

3,00000E-1

1,01230E-11

3,90553E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

ByoDyn

2,24421E-5

3,00000E-1

3,60583E-15

5,06006E-6

8,67928E-2

1,09075E-14

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21660E-8

2,53942E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32072E-2

2,50377E-18

4,79933E-35

7,67655E-31

2,02415E-7

4,40374E-17

1,59351E-33

3,00000E-1

1,01230E-11

3,90553E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

CVODE

2,24421E-5

3,00000E-1

3,61134E-15

5,06006E-6

8,67928E-2

1,09244E-14

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21660E-8

2,53942E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32072E-2

2,52614E-18

5,66908E-35

8,11903E-31

2,02415E-7

4,42151E-17

1,76659E-33

3,00000E-1

1,01240E-11

3,90702E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

Jarnac

2,24421E-5

3,00000E-1

-2,66454E-14

5,06006E-6

8,67928E-2

4,96313E-15

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21660E-8

2,53942E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32072E-2

-1,33223E-17

0,00000E0

-1,29142E-30

2,02415E-7

-4,60469E-17

-4,21885E-15

3,00000E-1

1,01230E-11

3,57193E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

MathSBML

2,24435E-5

3,00000E-1

3,72025E-15

5,06039E-6

8,67928E-2

1,12533E-14

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21473E-8

2,53940E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32072E-2

2,48422E-18

3,31550E-35

9,72023E-31

2,02382E-7

4,53056E-17

2,33508E-33

3,00000E-1

1,01669E-11

3,99956E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

Oscill8 Core

2,24451E-5

3,00000E-1

8,67929E-2

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21862E-8

2,53942E-4

2,00000E-1

5,17202E-12

3,27778E-21

2,02489E-7

4,66921E-12

3,00000E-1

5,88805E-12

2,99995E-1

0.4

SBToolbox2

2,26496E-5

3,00000E-1

5,15730E-15

5,10500E-6

8,67878E-2

1,56454E-14

1,99980E-1

3,86511E-1

3,67512E-8

2,53083E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32122E-2

6,91426E-18

2,98430E-34

1,07359E-30

2,12342E-7

8,42501E-17

4,54343E-33

3,00000E-1

1,02447E-11

4,44409E-14

2,99990E-1

0.4

SBWOdeSolver

2,24433E-5

3,00000E-1

3,60855E-15

5,06034E-6

8,67929E-2

1,09157E-14

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21727E-8

2,53945E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32071E-2

2,50686E-18

4,83839E-35

7,71927E-31

2,02439E-7

4,40802E-17

1,60404E-33

3,00000E-1

1,01274E-11

3,90772E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

copasi

2,24421E-5

3,00000E-1

3,60912E-15

5,06006E-6

8,67928E-2

1,09208E-14

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21661E-8

2,53942E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32072E-2

-3,82510E-35

3,82510E-35

7,61450E-31

2,02415E-7

4,27044E-17

1,60608E-33

3,00000E-1

1,01228E-11

3,90437E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,24421E-5

3,00000E-1

3,79590E-15

5,06006E-6

8,67928E-2

9,54792E-15

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21660E-8

2,53942E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32072E-2

4,01826E-17

-5,14721E-15

8,82665E-30

2,02415E-7

3,33976E-16

4,77396E-15

3,00000E-1

1,01229E-11

4,05385E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

jsim

2,24421E-5

3,00000E-1

3,60583E-15

5,06006E-6

8,67928E-2

1,09075E-14

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21660E-8

2,53942E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32072E-2

2,50377E-18

4,79933E-35

7,67655E-31

2,02415E-7

4,40374E-17

1,59351E-33

3,00000E-1

1,01230E-11

3,90553E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

min

2,24421E-5

3,00000E-1

-2,66454E-14

5,06006E-6

8,67878E-2

4,96313E-15

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21473E-8

2,53083E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32071E-2

-1,33223E-17

-5,14721E-15

-1,29142E-30

2,02382E-7

-4,60469E-17

-4,21885E-15

3,00000E-1

1,01228E-11

3,57193E-14

2,99990E-1

0.4

max

2,26496E-5

3,00000E-1

5,15730E-15

5,10500E-6

8,67929E-2

1,56454E-14

1,99980E-1

3,86511E-1

3,67512E-8

2,53945E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32122E-2

5,17202E-12

2,98430E-34

3,27778E-21

2,12342E-7

4,66921E-12

4,77396E-15

3,00000E-1

1,02447E-11

5,88805E-12

2,99995E-1

0.4

mean

2,24421E-5

3,00000E-1

3,60912E-15

5,06006E-6

8,67928E-2

1,09157E-14

1,99977E-1

3,86511E-1

3,21660E-8

2,53942E-4

2,00000E-1

1,32072E-2

2,50531E-18

4,79933E-35

7,91915E-31

2,02415E-7

4,41477E-17

1,60608E-33

3,00000E-1

1,01230E-11

3,90737E-14

2,99995E-1

0.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0.6

BioUML

6,79132E-5

3,00000E-1

9,88852E-14

1,52531E-5

8,18970E-2

3,00413E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08103E-7

5,12774E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81030E-2

1,57890E-16

1,28387E-31

8,79962E-28

8,78760E-7

1,81987E-15

2,77852E-30

3,00000E-1

1,35534E-10

7,04958E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

ByoDyn

6,79132E-5

3,00000E-1

9,88852E-14

1,52531E-5

8,18970E-2

3,00413E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08103E-7

5,12774E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81030E-2

1,57890E-16

1,28387E-31

8,79962E-28

8,78760E-7

1,81987E-15

2,77851E-30

3,00000E-1

1,35534E-10

7,04958E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

CVODE

6,79132E-5

3,00000E-1

9,89100E-14

1,52531E-5

8,18970E-2

3,00490E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08103E-7

5,12774E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81030E-2

1,58243E-16

1,34079E-31

8,87957E-28

8,78761E-7

1,82141E-15

2,84127E-30

3,00000E-1

1,35535E-10

7,04984E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

Jarnac

6,79132E-5

3,00000E-1

4,02733E-14

1,52531E-5

8,18970E-2

2,90874E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08103E-7

5,12774E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81030E-2

1,02507E-16

-1,11022E-16

7,09382E-28

8,78760E-7

1,61721E-15

-2,11497E-13

3,00000E-1

1,35534E-10

7,00038E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

MathSBML

6,79134E-5

3,00000E-1

9,98177E-14

1,52532E-5

8,18970E-2

3,03267E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08043E-7

5,12774E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81030E-2

1,58345E-16

9,09594E-32

9,93997E-28

8,78845E-7

1,84793E-15

3,64094E-30

3,00000E-1

1,35581E-10

7,08483E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

Oscill8 Core

6,79166E-5

3,00000E-1

8,18971E-2

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08162E-7

5,12775E-4

2,00000E-1

5,45769E-12

2,88381E-21

8,78885E-7

1,20775E-12

3,00000E-1

1,68227E-12

2,99985E-1

0.6

SBToolbox2

6,80708E-5

3,00000E-1

1,05752E-13

1,52849E-5

8,18904E-2

3,21709E-13

1,99930E-1

3,81294E-1

2,19511E-7

5,11799E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81096E-2

2,13018E-16

-9,10750E-31

-1,14933E-27

8,94133E-7

2,15524E-15

-8,67664E-30

3,00000E-1

1,29820E-10

6,97794E-13

2,99981E-1

0.6

SBWOdeSolver

6,79154E-5

3,00000E-1

9,89293E-14

1,52536E-5

8,18971E-2

3,00547E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08129E-7

5,12778E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81029E-2

1,58006E-16

1,29321E-31

8,82986E-28

8,78820E-7

1,82092E-15

2,79244E-30

3,00000E-1

1,35570E-10

7,05188E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

copasi

6,79132E-5

3,00000E-1

9,88929E-14

1,52531E-5

8,18970E-2

3,00490E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08103E-7

5,12774E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81030E-2

1,11437E-16

1,25183E-31

8,98253E-28

8,78760E-7

1,81851E-15

2,95701E-30

3,00000E-1

1,35532E-10

7,04924E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,79132E-5

3,00000E-1

9,94981E-14

1,52531E-5

8,18970E-2

2,99566E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08103E-7

5,12774E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81030E-2

2,77895E-16

-5,44043E-15

1,17358E-27

8,78760E-7

2,05258E-15

5,13478E-15

3,00000E-1

1,35535E-10

7,05606E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

jsim

6,79132E-5

3,00000E-1

9,88852E-14

1,52531E-5

8,18970E-2

3,00413E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08103E-7

5,12774E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81030E-2

1,57890E-16

1,28387E-31

8,79962E-28

8,78760E-7

1,81987E-15

2,77851E-30

3,00000E-1

1,35534E-10

7,04958E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

min

6,79132E-5

3,00000E-1

4,02733E-14

1,52531E-5

8,18904E-2

2,90874E-13

1,99930E-1

3,81294E-1

2,08043E-7

5,11799E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81029E-2

1,02507E-16

-5,44043E-15

-1,14933E-27

8,78760E-7

1,61721E-15

-2,11497E-13

3,00000E-1

1,29820E-10

6,97794E-13

2,99981E-1

0.6

max

6,80708E-5

3,00000E-1

1,05752E-13

1,52849E-5

8,18971E-2

3,21709E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,19511E-7

5,12778E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81096E-2

5,45769E-12

1,34079E-31

2,88381E-21

8,94133E-7

1,20775E-12

5,13478E-15

3,00000E-1

1,35581E-10

1,68227E-12

2,99985E-1

0.6

mean

6,79132E-5

3,00000E-1

9,89100E-14

1,52531E-5

8,18970E-2

3,00490E-13

1,99931E-1

3,81301E-1

2,08103E-7

5,12774E-4

2,00000E-1

1,81030E-2

1,58125E-16

1,25183E-31

8,85471E-28

8,78761E-7

1,82117E-15

2,79244E-30

3,00000E-1

1,35534E-10

7,04971E-13

2,99985E-1

0.6

relative error(%)

0,00

0.8

BioUML

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

9,56642E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78647E-2

2,91900E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,50989E-7

8,22024E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21353E-2

2,76369E-15

2,98326E-29

1,11409E-25

2,39835E-6

2,35323E-14

4,74435E-28

3,00000E-1

8,03161E-10

5,06719E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

ByoDyn

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

9,56642E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78647E-2

2,91900E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,50989E-7

8,22024E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21353E-2

2,76369E-15

2,98326E-29

1,11409E-25

2,39835E-6

2,35323E-14

4,74435E-28

3,00000E-1

8,03161E-10

5,06719E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

CVODE

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

9,56768E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78647E-2

2,91940E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,50989E-7

8,22024E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21353E-2

2,76777E-15

3,15672E-29

1,12893E-25

2,39836E-6

2,35444E-14

4,89919E-28

3,00000E-1

8,03158E-10

5,06723E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

Jarnac

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

8,98503E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78647E-2

2,90386E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,50989E-7

8,22024E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21353E-2

2,63172E-15

-2,60902E-15

1,08255E-25

2,39835E-6

2,31459E-14

-3,50553E-13

3,00000E-1

8,03161E-10

5,06043E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

MathSBML

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

9,60220E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78647E-2

2,93008E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,51016E-7

8,22024E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21353E-2

2,79469E-15

2,80886E-29

1,18472E-25

2,39836E-6

2,36995E-14

5,53159E-28

3,00000E-1

8,03266E-10

5,06336E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

Oscill8 Core

1,44750E-4

3,00000E-1

7,78648E-2

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,51104E-7

8,22025E-4

1,99999E-1

4,99958E-12

2,50746E-21

2,39853E-6

-5,32662E-13

3,00000E-1

5,15459E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

SBToolbox2

1,44810E-4

3,00000E-1

1,01365E-12

3,23947E-5

7,78557E-2

3,09753E-12

1,99851E-1

3,76857E-1

7,74344E-7

8,20942E-4

2,00000E-1

2,21443E-2

3,56736E-15

1,82452E-30

4,90158E-26

2,41964E-6

2,70749E-14

1,52643E-28

3,00000E-1

7,84370E-10

5,06122E-12

2,99970E-1

0.8

SBWOdeSolver

1,44749E-4

3,00000E-1

9,56930E-13

3,23876E-5

7,78648E-2

2,91988E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,51051E-7

8,22027E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21352E-2

2,76509E-15

2,98943E-29

1,11629E-25

2,39846E-6

2,35415E-14

4,75425E-28

3,00000E-1

8,03302E-10

5,06830E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

copasi

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

9,56601E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78647E-2

2,91909E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,50989E-7

8,22024E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21353E-2

2,67449E-15

2,99585E-29

1,11999E-25

2,39835E-6

2,35280E-14

4,82743E-28

3,00000E-1

8,03157E-10

5,06716E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

9,57390E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78647E-2

2,91886E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,50989E-7

8,22024E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21353E-2

2,91686E-15

-3,36095E-15

1,13760E-25

2,39836E-6

2,36207E-14

3,41394E-15

3,00000E-1

8,03157E-10

5,06730E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

jsim

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

9,56642E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78647E-2

2,91900E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,50989E-7

8,22024E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21353E-2

2,76369E-15

2,98326E-29

1,11409E-25

2,39835E-6

2,35323E-14

4,74435E-28

3,00000E-1

8,03161E-10

5,06719E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

min

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

8,98503E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78557E-2

2,90386E-12

1,99851E-1

3,76857E-1

7,50989E-7

8,20942E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21352E-2

2,63172E-15

-3,36095E-15

4,90158E-26

2,39835E-6

-5,32662E-13

-3,50553E-13

3,00000E-1

7,84370E-10

5,06043E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

max

1,44810E-4

3,00000E-1

1,01365E-12

3,23947E-5

7,78648E-2

3,09753E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,74344E-7

8,22027E-4

2,00000E-1

2,21443E-2

4,99958E-12

3,15672E-29

2,50746E-21

2,41964E-6

2,70749E-14

3,41394E-15

3,00000E-1

8,03302E-10

5,15459E-12

2,99970E-1

0.8

mean

1,44746E-4

3,00000E-1

9,56768E-13

3,23869E-5

7,78647E-2

2,91909E-12

1,99852E-1

3,76866E-1

7,50989E-7

8,22024E-4

1,99999E-1

2,21353E-2

2,76643E-15

2,98326E-29

1,11814E-25

2,39836E-6

2,35369E-14

4,75425E-28

3,00000E-1

8,03161E-10

5,06719E-12

2,99968E-1

0.8

relative error(%)

0,00

1.0

BioUML

2,54895E-4

3,00000E-1

5,26210E-12

5,68242E-5

7,45397E-2

1,61271E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97228E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54603E-2

2,40878E-14

1,83659E-27

4,26938E-24

5,08949E-6

1,61910E-13

2,29373E-26

3,00000E-1

3,05649E-9

2,21553E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

ByoDyn

2,54895E-4

3,00000E-1

5,26210E-12

5,68242E-5

7,45397E-2

1,61271E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97228E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54603E-2

2,40878E-14

1,83659E-27

4,26938E-24

5,08949E-6

1,61910E-13

2,29373E-26

3,00000E-1

3,05649E-9

2,21553E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

CVODE

2,54895E-4

3,00000E-1

5,26223E-12

5,68242E-5

7,45397E-2

1,61276E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97228E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54603E-2

2,40978E-14

1,86229E-27

4,28013E-24

5,08949E-6

1,61930E-13

2,30895E-26

3,00000E-1

3,05649E-9

2,21553E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

Jarnac

2,54895E-4

3,00000E-1

5,20925E-12

5,68242E-5

7,45397E-2

1,61063E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97228E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54603E-2

2,38082E-14

-2,38143E-14

4,23706E-24

5,08949E-6

1,61113E-13

-3,43947E-13

3,00000E-1

3,05649E-9

2,21484E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

MathSBML

2,54895E-4

3,00000E-1

5,26520E-12

5,68242E-5

7,45397E-2

1,61374E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97231E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54603E-2

2,42154E-14

1,84185E-27

4,38343E-24

5,08950E-6

1,62341E-13

2,47163E-26

3,00000E-1

3,05655E-9

2,21568E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

Oscill8 Core

2,54899E-4

3,00000E-1

7,45398E-2

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97246E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

4,25389E-12

2,13375E-21

5,08972E-6

-1,19294E-12

3,00000E-1

2,20566E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

SBToolbox2

2,54810E-4

3,00000E-1

5,51656E-12

5,67965E-5

7,45291E-2

1,69326E-11

1,99740E-1

3,73057E-1

2,01175E-6

1,16244E-3

2,00000E-1

2,54709E-2

2,96260E-14

1,83315E-27

3,25888E-24

5,11543E-6

1,81196E-13

1,96722E-26

3,00000E-1

3,00870E-9

2,21812E-11

2,99940E-1

1.0

SBWOdeSolver

2,54898E-4

3,00000E-1

5,26324E-12

5,68250E-5

7,45398E-2

1,61307E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97239E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54602E-2

2,40968E-14

1,83919E-27

4,27457E-24

5,08965E-6

1,61957E-13

2,29684E-26

3,00000E-1

3,05688E-9

2,21588E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

copasi

2,54895E-4

3,00000E-1

5,26205E-12

5,68242E-5

7,45397E-2

1,61271E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97228E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54603E-2

2,40704E-14

1,84380E-27

4,27607E-24

5,08949E-6

1,61903E-13

2,30580E-26

3,00000E-1

3,05649E-9

2,21553E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

2,54895E-4

3,00000E-1

5,26299E-12

5,68242E-5

7,45397E-2

1,61279E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97228E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54603E-2

2,42641E-14

-2,39266E-15

4,34624E-24

5,08949E-6

1,61992E-13

2,44249E-15

3,00000E-1

3,05647E-9

2,21553E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

jsim

2,54895E-4

3,00000E-1

5,26210E-12

5,68242E-5

7,45397E-2

1,61271E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97228E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54603E-2

2,40878E-14

1,83659E-27

4,26938E-24

5,08949E-6

1,61910E-13

2,29373E-26

3,00000E-1

3,05649E-9

2,21553E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

min

2,54810E-4

3,00000E-1

5,20925E-12

5,67965E-5

7,45291E-2

1,61063E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73057E-1

1,97228E-6

1,16244E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54602E-2

2,38082E-14

-2,38143E-14

3,25888E-24

5,08949E-6

-1,19294E-12

-3,43947E-13

3,00000E-1

3,00870E-9

2,20566E-11

2,99940E-1

1.0

max

2,54899E-4

3,00000E-1

5,51656E-12

5,68250E-5

7,45398E-2

1,69326E-11

1,99740E-1

3,73064E-1

2,01175E-6

1,16358E-3

2,00000E-1

2,54709E-2

4,25389E-12

1,86229E-27

2,13375E-21

5,11543E-6

1,81196E-13

2,44249E-15

3,00000E-1

3,05688E-9

2,21812E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

mean

2,54895E-4

3,00000E-1

5,26223E-12

5,68242E-5

7,45397E-2

1,61276E-11

1,99738E-1

3,73064E-1

1,97228E-6

1,16358E-3

1,99998E-1

2,54603E-2

2,40973E-14

1,83659E-27

4,27532E-24

5,08949E-6

1,61920E-13

2,29684E-26

3,00000E-1

3,05649E-9

2,21553E-11

2,99943E-1

1.0

relative error(%)

0,00

1.2

BioUML

3,98186E-4

3,00000E-1

2,03409E-11

8,84561E-5

7,17957E-2

6,26169E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24301E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82043E-2

1,35550E-13

4,91695E-26

7,74821E-23

9,22932E-6

7,50435E-13

5,03192E-25

3,00000E-1

8,81476E-9

7,10962E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

ByoDyn

3,98186E-4

3,00000E-1

2,03409E-11

8,84561E-5

7,17957E-2

6,26169E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24301E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82043E-2

1,35550E-13

4,91695E-26

7,74821E-23

9,22932E-6

7,50435E-13

5,03192E-25

3,00000E-1

8,81476E-9

7,10962E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

CVODE

3,98186E-4

3,00000E-1

2,03410E-11

8,84561E-5

7,17957E-2

6,26174E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24301E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82043E-2

1,35569E-13

4,94164E-26

7,75527E-23

9,22932E-6

7,50464E-13

5,04396E-25

3,00000E-1

8,81476E-9

7,10962E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

Jarnac

3,98186E-4

3,00000E-1

2,02936E-11

8,84561E-5

7,17957E-2

6,25909E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24301E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82043E-2

1,34908E-13

-1,34892E-13

7,72008E-23

9,22932E-6

7,48220E-13

-2,33535E-13

3,00000E-1

8,81476E-9

7,10891E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

MathSBML

3,98186E-4

3,00000E-1

2,03395E-11

8,84562E-5

7,17957E-2

6,26128E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24307E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82043E-2

1,35764E-13

4,75097E-26

7,83100E-23

9,22934E-6

7,50420E-13

5,35876E-25

3,00000E-1

8,81397E-9

7,10665E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

Oscill8 Core

3,98190E-4

3,00000E-1

7,17958E-2

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24329E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

3,52847E-12

1,67889E-21

9,22961E-6

-8,69660E-13

3,00000E-1

7,09431E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

SBToolbox2

3,97937E-4

3,00000E-1

2,08905E-11

8,83892E-5

7,17840E-2

6,43894E-11

1,99591E-1

3,69778E-1

4,29808E-6

1,52369E-3

2,00000E-1

2,82160E-2

1,55672E-13

2,48140E-26

4,59339E-23

9,25677E-6

8,06632E-13

2,92398E-25

3,00000E-1

8,65026E-9

7,06748E-11

2,99910E-1

1.2

SBWOdeSolver

3,98190E-4

3,00000E-1

2,03443E-11

8,84570E-5

7,17958E-2

6,26274E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24320E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82042E-2

1,35589E-13

4,92259E-26

7,75505E-23

9,22954E-6

7,50600E-13

5,03700E-25

3,00000E-1

8,81561E-9

7,11046E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

copasi

3,98186E-4

3,00000E-1

2,03408E-11

8,84561E-5

7,17957E-2

6,26169E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24301E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82043E-2

1,35507E-13

4,94187E-26

7,76472E-23

9,22932E-6

7,50436E-13

5,06197E-25

3,00000E-1

8,81475E-9

7,10961E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

3,98185E-4

3,00000E-1

2,03423E-11

8,84560E-5

7,17957E-2

6,26193E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24302E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82043E-2

1,35843E-13

-2,83872E-15

7,84488E-23

9,22933E-6

7,50749E-13

2,80331E-15

3,00000E-1

8,81464E-9

7,10956E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

jsim

3,98186E-4

3,00000E-1

2,03409E-11

8,84561E-5

7,17957E-2

6,26169E-11

1,99588E-1

3,69784E-1

4,24301E-6

1,52473E-3

1,99996E-1

2,82043E-2

1,35550E-13

4,91695E-26

7,74821E-23

9,22932E-6

7,50435E-13

5,03192E-25

3,00000E-1

8,81476E-9

7,10962E-11

2,99912E-1

1.2

min

3,97937E-4

3,00000E-1

2,02936E-11

8,83892E-5

7,17840E-2

6,25909E-11