Test BIOMD0000000013.xml details

Test: BIOMD0000000013.xml - Ok

test	: BIOMD0000000013.xml
model	: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine	: Imex
generated code	: BIOMD0000000013.java
results	: CSV file
plots	: -
comparison	: comparison with other simulators
status	: Ok
simulation time	: 23 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-10
ATOL 1.0E-12
RTOL 1.0E-6
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000013.gif

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
- no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
- small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
- simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: BPGA_ch G6P_ch G1P_ch Pi_ch Ru5P_ch F6P_ch R5P_ch ADP_ch GAP_ch X5P_ch S7P_ch ATP_ch PGA_ch DHAP_ch SBP_ch RuBP_ch E4P_ch FBP_ch
Simulators: ByoDyn CVODE copasi edu.kgi.roadRunner Jarnac SBToolbox2 Oscill8 Core MathSBML jsim BioUML

time

result

BPGA_ch

G6P_ch

G1P_ch

Pi_ch

Ru5P_ch

F6P_ch

R5P_ch

ADP_ch

GAP_ch

X5P_ch

S7P_ch

ATP_ch

PGA_ch

DHAP_ch

SBP_ch

RuBP_ch

E4P_ch

FBP_ch

0.0

BioUML

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

ByoDyn

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

CVODE

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

Jarnac

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

MathSBML

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

Oscill8 Core

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

SBToolbox2

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36480E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35480E0

2,93450E-1

1,56490E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

copasi

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

jsim

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

min

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36480E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

max

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35480E0

2,93450E-1

1,56490E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

mean

1,48250E-1

3,13960E0

1,82060E-1

1,56620E0

2,35000E-3

1,36481E0

5,99000E-3

1,49000E-3

1,33400E-2

3,63000E-3

5,41000E-3

4,98060E-1

3,35479E0

2,93450E-1

1,56486E0

3,36440E-1

4,10210E-1

2,77600E-2

0.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0.2

BioUML

1,76547E-2

3,66959E0

2,12836E-1

1,10960E0

1,48879E-3

1,59548E0

3,72199E-3

6,01394E-3

1,17915E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25859E-4

4,93536E-1

6,93965E-1

2,59412E-1

2,39832E0

4,19077E-1

7,11172E-1

2,17177E-2

0.2

ByoDyn

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10943E0

1,48879E-3

1,59534E0

3,72198E-3

6,01437E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25867E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94022E-1

2,59408E-1

2,39804E0

4,19052E-1

7,11100E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

CVODE

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10943E0

1,48879E-3

1,59534E0

3,72198E-3

6,01437E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25867E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94021E-1

2,59408E-1

2,39804E0

4,19052E-1

7,11100E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

Jarnac

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10943E0

1,48879E-3

1,59534E0

3,72198E-3

6,01437E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25867E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94022E-1

2,59408E-1

2,39804E0

4,19052E-1

7,11100E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

MathSBML

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10943E0

1,48879E-3

1,59534E0

3,72198E-3

6,01437E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25867E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94022E-1

2,59408E-1

2,39804E0

4,19052E-1

7,11100E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

Oscill8 Core

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10947E0

1,48879E-3

1,59533E0

3,72198E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25871E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94013E-1

2,59407E-1

2,39803E0

4,19049E-1

7,11097E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

SBToolbox2

1,76584E-2

3,66949E0

2,12835E-1

1,10900E0

1,48913E-3

1,59544E0

3,72272E-3

6,01519E-3

1,17922E-2

2,22249E-3

8,26125E-4

4,93531E-1

6,94250E-1

2,59426E-1

2,39805E0

4,19134E-1

7,11051E-1

2,17199E-2

0.2

copasi

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10943E0

1,48879E-3

1,59534E0

3,72198E-3

6,01437E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25868E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94022E-1

2,59408E-1

2,39804E0

4,19052E-1

7,11100E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10943E0

1,48879E-3

1,59534E0

3,72198E-3

6,01437E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25867E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94022E-1

2,59408E-1

2,39804E0

4,19052E-1

7,11100E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

jsim

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10943E0

1,48879E-3

1,59534E0

3,72198E-3

6,01437E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25867E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94021E-1

2,59408E-1

2,39804E0

4,19052E-1

7,11100E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

min

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10900E0

1,48879E-3

1,59533E0

3,72198E-3

6,01437E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25867E-4

4,93531E-1

6,94013E-1

2,59407E-1

2,39803E0

4,19049E-1

7,11051E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

max

1,76584E-2

3,66949E0

2,12835E-1

1,10947E0

1,48913E-3

1,59544E0

3,72272E-3

6,01519E-3

1,17922E-2

2,22249E-3

8,26125E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94250E-1

2,59426E-1

2,39805E0

4,19134E-1

7,11100E-1

2,17199E-2

0.2

mean

1,76548E-2

3,66927E0

2,12818E-1

1,10943E0

1,48879E-3

1,59534E0

3,72198E-3

6,01437E-3

1,17913E-2

2,22209E-3

8,25867E-4

4,93536E-1

6,94022E-1

2,59408E-1

2,39804E0

4,19052E-1

7,11100E-1

2,17170E-2

0.2

relative error(%)

0,00

0.4

BioUML

1,74529E-2

3,53265E0

2,04894E-1

9,34447E-1

1,43138E-3

1,53593E0

3,57845E-3

6,27977E-3

1,15335E-2

2,13640E-3

7,80514E-4

4,93270E-1

7,16747E-1

2,53736E-1

2,29751E0

3,96436E-1

6,96515E-1

2,07779E-2

0.4

ByoDyn

1,74538E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,34049E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53551E0

3,57810E-3

6,28097E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80438E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16919E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29665E0

3,96335E-1

6,96321E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

CVODE

1,74538E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,34049E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53551E0

3,57810E-3

6,28097E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80438E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16919E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29665E0

3,96335E-1

6,96321E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

Jarnac

1,74538E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,34049E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53551E0

3,57810E-3

6,28097E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80438E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16919E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29665E0

3,96335E-1

6,96321E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

MathSBML

1,74538E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,34049E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53551E0

3,57810E-3

6,28097E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80438E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16919E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29665E0

3,96335E-1

6,96321E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

Oscill8 Core

1,74538E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,34052E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53550E0

3,57810E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80438E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16918E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29665E0

3,96335E-1

6,96321E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

SBToolbox2

1,74531E-2

3,53194E0

2,04850E-1

9,33654E-1

1,43115E-3

1,53564E0

3,57793E-3

6,28148E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13608E-3

7,80383E-4

4,93270E-1

7,16957E-1

2,53698E-1

2,29678E0

3,96323E-1

6,96393E-1

2,07723E-2

0.4

copasi

1,74538E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,34049E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53551E0

3,57810E-3

6,28097E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80437E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16919E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29665E0

3,96335E-1

6,96322E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,74538E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,34049E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53551E0

3,57810E-3

6,28097E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80438E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16919E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29665E0

3,96335E-1

6,96321E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

jsim

1,74538E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,34049E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53551E0

3,57810E-3

6,28096E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80438E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16918E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29665E0

3,96335E-1

6,96322E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

min

1,74531E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,33654E-1

1,43115E-3

1,53550E0

3,57793E-3

6,28096E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13608E-3

7,80383E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16918E-1

2,53698E-1

2,29665E0

3,96323E-1

6,96321E-1

2,07723E-2

0.4

max

1,74538E-2

3,53194E0

2,04850E-1

9,34052E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53564E0

3,57810E-3

6,28148E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80438E-4

4,93270E-1

7,16957E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29678E0

3,96335E-1

6,96393E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

mean

1,74538E-2

3,53166E0

2,04836E-1

9,34049E-1

1,43124E-3

1,53551E0

3,57810E-3

6,28097E-3

1,15324E-2

2,13619E-3

7,80438E-4

4,93269E-1

7,16919E-1

2,53712E-1

2,29665E0

3,96335E-1

6,96321E-1

2,07739E-2

0.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0.6

BioUML

1,74293E-2

3,36130E0

1,94955E-1

9,03395E-1

1,40725E-3

1,46143E0

3,51814E-3

6,34631E-3

1,13499E-2

2,10039E-3

7,66657E-4

4,93204E-1

7,23460E-1

2,49697E-1

2,15330E0

3,75021E-1

6,63359E-1

2,01215E-2

0.6

ByoDyn

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02984E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46076E0

3,51766E-3

6,34749E-3

1,13481E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66566E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15194E0

3,74833E-1

6,63043E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

CVODE

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02984E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46076E0

3,51766E-3

6,34749E-3

1,13481E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66566E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15194E0

3,74833E-1

6,63043E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

Jarnac

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02984E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46076E0

3,51766E-3

6,34749E-3

1,13481E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66566E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15194E0

3,74833E-1

6,63043E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

MathSBML

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02984E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46076E0

3,51766E-3

6,34749E-3

1,13481E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66566E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15194E0

3,74833E-1

6,63043E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

Oscill8 Core

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02984E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46077E0

3,51766E-3

1,13481E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66566E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15194E0

3,74834E-1

6,63043E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

SBToolbox2

1,74291E-2

3,35971E0

1,94860E-1

9,02830E-1

1,40697E-3

1,46072E0

3,51737E-3

6,34766E-3

1,13485E-2

2,09990E-3

7,66448E-4

4,93200E-1

7,23616E-1

2,49661E-1

2,15193E0

3,74813E-1

6,63080E-1

2,01149E-2

0.6

copasi

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02983E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46077E0

3,51766E-3

6,34749E-3

1,13481E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66565E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15194E0

3,74833E-1

6,63044E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02984E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46076E0

3,51766E-3

6,34749E-3

1,13481E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66566E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15194E0

3,74833E-1

6,63043E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

jsim

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02984E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46077E0

3,51766E-3

6,34748E-3

1,13481E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66565E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15194E0

3,74834E-1

6,63044E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

min

1,74291E-2

3,35971E0

1,94860E-1

9,02830E-1

1,40697E-3

1,46072E0

3,51737E-3

6,34748E-3

1,13481E-2

2,09990E-3

7,66448E-4

4,93200E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15193E0

3,74813E-1

6,63043E-1

2,01149E-2

0.6

max

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02984E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46077E0

3,51766E-3

6,34766E-3

1,13485E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66566E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23616E-1

2,49661E-1

2,15194E0

3,74834E-1

6,63080E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

mean

1,74296E-2

3,35976E0

1,94866E-1

9,02984E-1

1,40706E-3

1,46076E0

3,51766E-3

6,34749E-3

1,13481E-2

2,10011E-3

7,66566E-4

4,93203E-1

7,23607E-1

2,49658E-1

2,15194E0

3,74833E-1

6,63043E-1

2,01153E-2

0.6

relative error(%)

0,00

0.8

BioUML

1,74123E-2

3,19002E0

1,85021E-1

8,79871E-1

1,38493E-3

1,38697E0

3,46235E-3

6,40040E-3

1,11674E-2

2,06708E-3

7,54687E-4

4,93150E-1

7,28991E-1

2,45682E-1

2,01028E0

3,54085E-1

6,29418E-1

1,94797E-2

0.8

ByoDyn

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79449E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

6,40151E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53831E-1

6,29002E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

CVODE

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79449E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

6,40151E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53831E-1

6,29002E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

Jarnac

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79449E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

6,40151E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53831E-1

6,29002E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

MathSBML

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79449E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

6,40151E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53831E-1

6,29002E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

Oscill8 Core

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79449E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53831E-1

6,29002E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

SBToolbox2

1,74138E-2

3,18830E0

1,84920E-1

8,79931E-1

1,38480E-3

1,38620E0

3,46187E-3

6,40070E-3

1,11648E-2

2,06686E-3

7,54703E-4

4,93150E-1

7,29091E-1

2,45618E-1

2,00836E0

3,53854E-1

6,28992E-1

1,94688E-2

0.8

copasi

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79449E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

6,40151E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53831E-1

6,29002E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79449E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

6,40151E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53831E-1

6,29002E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

jsim

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79450E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

6,40151E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53831E-1

6,29003E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

min

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79449E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

6,40070E-3

1,11648E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29091E-1

2,45618E-1

2,00836E0

3,53831E-1

6,28992E-1

1,94688E-2

0.8

max

1,74138E-2

3,18830E0

1,84920E-1

8,79931E-1

1,38480E-3

1,38620E0

3,46187E-3

6,40151E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06686E-3

7,54703E-4

4,93150E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53854E-1

6,29003E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

mean

1,74118E-2

3,18805E0

1,84907E-1

8,79449E-1

1,38472E-3

1,38611E0

3,46181E-3

6,40151E-3

1,11652E-2

2,06676E-3

7,54602E-4

4,93148E-1

7,29101E-1

2,45634E-1

2,00855E0

3,53831E-1

6,29002E-1

1,94720E-2

0.8

relative error(%)

0,00

1.0

BioUML

1,73935E-2

3,02053E0

1,75191E-1

8,56251E-1

1,36326E-3

1,31327E0

3,40816E-3

6,45788E-3

1,09836E-2

2,03473E-3

7,43505E-4

4,93092E-1

7,34831E-1

2,41640E-1

1,87062E0

3,33621E-1

5,95489E-1

1,88440E-2

1.0

ByoDyn

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55932E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31234E0

3,40739E-3

6,45857E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34893E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95053E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

CVODE

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55932E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31234E0

3,40739E-3

6,45857E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34893E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95053E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

Jarnac

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55932E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31234E0

3,40739E-3

6,45857E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34893E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95053E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

MathSBML

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55932E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31234E0

3,40739E-3

6,45857E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34893E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95053E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

Oscill8 Core

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55932E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31234E0

3,40739E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34893E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95053E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

SBToolbox2

1,73931E-2

3,01853E0

1,75078E-1

8,56091E-1

1,36291E-3

1,31237E0

3,40737E-3

6,45790E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03426E-3

7,43334E-4

4,93090E-1

7,34810E-1

2,41581E-1

1,86878E0

3,33350E-1

5,95087E-1

1,88342E-2

1.0

copasi

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55932E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31234E0

3,40739E-3

6,45857E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34893E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95053E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55932E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31234E0

3,40739E-3

6,45857E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34893E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95053E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

jsim

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55933E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31234E0

3,40739E-3

6,45857E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34892E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95054E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

min

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55932E-1

1,36291E-3

1,31234E0

3,40737E-3

6,45790E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03426E-3

7,43334E-4

4,93090E-1

7,34810E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86878E0

3,33350E-1

5,95053E-1

1,88342E-2

1.0

max

1,73931E-2

3,01853E0

1,75078E-1

8,56091E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31237E0

3,40739E-3

6,45857E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34893E-1

2,41581E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95087E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

mean

1,73931E-2

3,01839E0

1,75066E-1

8,55932E-1

1,36295E-3

1,31234E0

3,40739E-3

6,45857E-3

1,09809E-2

2,03427E-3

7,43354E-4

4,93091E-1

7,34893E-1

2,41580E-1

1,86879E0

3,33356E-1

5,95053E-1

1,88346E-2

1.0

relative error(%)

0,00

1.2

BioUML

1,73734E-2

2,85300E0

1,65474E-1

8,32318E-1

1,34200E-3

1,24043E0

3,35501E-3

6,51932E-3

1,07977E-2

2,00300E-3

7,32929E-4

4,93031E-1

7,41056E-1

2,37549E-1

1,73459E0

3,13693E-1

5,61696E-1

1,82113E-2

1.2

ByoDyn

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,32049E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

6,51990E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93030E-1

7,41102E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13422E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

CVODE

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,32049E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

6,51990E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93030E-1

7,41102E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13422E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

Jarnac

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,32049E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

6,51990E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93030E-1

7,41102E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13422E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

MathSBML

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,32049E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

6,51990E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93030E-1

7,41102E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13422E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

Oscill8 Core

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,32049E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93030E-1

7,41102E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13422E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

SBToolbox2

1,73701E-2

2,85000E0

1,65298E-1

8,33232E-1

1,34123E-3

1,23913E0

3,35320E-3

6,51416E-3

1,07952E-2

2,00188E-3

7,32276E-4

4,93040E-1

7,40318E-1

2,37504E-1

1,73292E0

3,13329E-1

5,61295E-1

1,82038E-2

1.2

copasi

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,32049E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

6,51990E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93030E-1

7,41102E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13422E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,32049E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

6,51990E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93030E-1

7,41102E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13422E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

jsim

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,32050E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

6,51990E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93030E-1

7,41101E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13422E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

min

1,73701E-2

2,85000E0

1,65298E-1

8,32049E-1

1,34123E-3

1,23913E0

3,35320E-3

6,51416E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00188E-3

7,32276E-4

4,93030E-1

7,40318E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13329E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

max

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,33232E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

6,51990E-3

1,07952E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93040E-1

7,41102E-1

2,37504E-1

1,73292E0

3,13422E-1

5,61295E-1

1,82038E-2

1.2

mean

1,73729E-2

2,85086E0

1,65350E-1

8,32049E-1

1,34171E-3

1,23950E0

3,35429E-3

6,51990E-3

1,07951E-2

2,00257E-3

7,32789E-4

4,93030E-1

7,41102E-1

2,37492E-1

1,73284E0

3,13422E-1

5,61262E-1

1,82026E-2

1.2

relative error(%)

0,00

1.4

BioUML

1,73513E-2

2,68739E0

1,55868E-1

8,07906E-1

1,32128E-3

1,16843E0

3,30321E-3

6,58586E-3

1,06099E-2

1,97208E-3

7,23070E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47771E-1

2,33417E-1

1,60230E0

2,94263E-1

5,28041E-1

1,75832E-2

1.4

ByoDyn

1,73509E-2

2,68547E0

1,55758E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

6,58609E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22930E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33367E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

CVODE

1,73509E-2

2,68547E0

1,55758E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

6,58609E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22930E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33367E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

Jarnac

1,73509E-2

2,68547E0

1,55758E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

6,58609E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22930E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33367E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

MathSBML

1,73509E-2

2,68547E0

1,55758E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

6,58609E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22930E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33367E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

Oscill8 Core

1,73509E-2

2,68547E0

1,55758E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22930E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33367E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

SBToolbox2

1,73523E-2

2,68588E0

1,55779E-1

8,06895E-1

1,32115E-3

1,16780E0

3,30279E-3

6,58962E-3

1,06093E-2

1,97184E-3

7,22973E-4

4,92960E-1

7,48236E-1

2,33398E-1

1,60130E0

2,94126E-1

5,27762E-1

1,75802E-2

1.4

copasi

1,73509E-2

2,68547E0

1,55758E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

6,58609E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22930E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33367E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,73509E-2

2,68547E0

1,55758E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

6,58609E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22930E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33367E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

jsim

1,73510E-2

2,68548E0

1,55758E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

6,58609E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22929E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33368E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

min

1,73509E-2

2,68547E0

1,55758E-1

8,06895E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

6,58609E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22929E-4

4,92960E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33367E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

max

1,73523E-2

2,68588E0

1,55779E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32115E-3

1,16780E0

3,30279E-3

6,58962E-3

1,06093E-2

1,97184E-3

7,22973E-4

4,92964E-1

7,48236E-1

2,33398E-1

1,60130E0

2,94126E-1

5,27762E-1

1,75802E-2

1.4

mean

1,73509E-2

2,68547E0

1,55758E-1

8,07755E-1

1,32101E-3

1,16760E0

3,30254E-3

6,58609E-3

1,06076E-2

1,97168E-3

7,22930E-4

4,92964E-1

7,47781E-1

2,33367E-1

1,60080E0

2,94041E-1

5,27661E-1

1,75758E-2

1.4

relative error(%)

0,00

1.6

BioUML

1,73275E-2

2,52359E0

1,46368E-1

7,82988E-1

1,30103E-3

1,09721E0

3,25258E-3

6,65815E-3

1,04197E-2

1,94185E-3

7,13894E-4

4,92892E-1

7,55052E-1

2,29232E-1

1,47376E0

2,75379E-1

4,94547E-1

1,69585E-2

1.6

ByoDyn

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83016E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

6,65779E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13804E-4

4,92892E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94285E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

CVODE

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83016E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

6,65779E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13804E-4

4,92892E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94285E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

Jarnac

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83016E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

6,65779E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13804E-4

4,92892E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94285E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

MathSBML

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83016E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

6,65779E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13804E-4

4,92892E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94285E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

Oscill8 Core

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83016E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13805E-4

4,92892E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94285E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

SBToolbox2

1,73283E-2

2,52250E0

1,46305E-1

7,83178E-1

1,30106E-3

1,09676E0

3,25252E-3

6,65769E-3

1,04206E-2

1,94184E-3

7,13822E-4

4,92890E-1

7,55040E-1

2,29245E-1

1,47332E0

2,75312E-1

4,94369E-1

1,69611E-2

1.6

copasi

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83016E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

6,65779E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13804E-4

4,92892E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94285E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83016E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

6,65779E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13804E-4

4,92892E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94285E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

jsim

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83017E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

6,65779E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13804E-4

4,92892E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94286E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

min

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83016E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

6,65769E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13804E-4

4,92890E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94285E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

max

1,73283E-2

2,52250E0

1,46305E-1

7,83178E-1

1,30106E-3

1,09676E0

3,25252E-3

6,65779E-3

1,04206E-2

1,94184E-3

7,13822E-4

4,92892E-1

7,55040E-1

2,29245E-1

1,47332E0

2,75312E-1

4,94369E-1

1,69611E-2

1.6

mean

1,73270E-2

2,52225E0

1,46291E-1

7,83016E-1

1,30086E-3

1,09663E0

3,25217E-3

6,65779E-3

1,04183E-2

1,94160E-3

7,13804E-4

4,92892E-1

7,54988E-1

2,29203E-1

1,47279E0

2,75227E-1

4,94285E-1

1,69541E-2

1.6

relative error(%)

0,00

1.8

BioUML

1,73007E-2

2,36227E0