Test: BIOMD0000000016.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000016.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: DormandPrince
generated code: BIOMD0000000016.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-10
ATOL 1.0E-20
RTOL 1.0E-14
STEP 1.0E-4

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000016.gif

Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL6617161845.png

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: Pt  M  Pn  P1  P0  P2 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  Jarnac  SBToolbox2  Oscill8 Core  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  jsim  BioUML 
timeresult Pt M Pn P1 P0 P2
0.0BioUML1,00000E01,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
0.0ByoDyn1,00000E01,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
0.0Jarnac1,00000E01,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
0.0MathSBML1,00000E01,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
0.0Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
0.0SBToolbox21,00000E01,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
0.0SBWOdeSolver-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
0.0copasi1,00000E01,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner1,00000E01,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
0.0jsim1,00000E-151,00000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
0.0min 1,00000E-15 1,00000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
0.0max 1,00000E0 1,00000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1
0.0mean 1,00000E0 1,00000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML9,13260E-12,19852E-12,65386E-12,26849E-12,27924E-11,93102E-1
0.2ByoDyn9,13261E-12,19852E-12,65387E-12,26850E-12,27924E-11,93100E-1
0.2Jarnac9,13261E-12,19852E-12,65387E-12,26850E-12,27924E-11,93100E-1
0.2MathSBML9,13261E-12,19852E-12,65387E-12,26850E-12,27924E-11,93100E-1
0.2Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
0.2SBToolbox29,13217E-12,19838E-12,65455E-12,26885E-12,27907E-11,92961E-1
0.2SBWOdeSolver-2,19851E-12,65387E-12,26850E-12,27924E-11,93101E-1
0.2copasi9,13261E-12,19852E-12,65387E-12,26850E-12,27924E-11,93100E-1
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner9,13261E-12,19852E-12,65387E-12,26850E-12,27924E-11,93100E-1
0.2jsim1,00000E-152,52000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
0.2min 1,00000E-15 2,52000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
0.2max 9,13261E-1 2,19852E-1 2,65455E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1
0.2mean 9,13261E-1 2,19852E-1 2,65387E-1 2,26850E-1 2,27924E-1 1,93100E-1
0.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML8,45039E-13,25265E-12,63457E-12,03427E-12,15656E-11,62499E-1
0.4ByoDyn8,45040E-13,25264E-12,63457E-12,03427E-12,15656E-11,62500E-1
0.4Jarnac8,45040E-13,25264E-12,63457E-12,03427E-12,15656E-11,62500E-1
0.4MathSBML8,45040E-13,25264E-12,63457E-12,03427E-12,15656E-11,62500E-1
0.4Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
0.4SBToolbox28,44971E-13,25229E-12,63543E-12,03453E-12,15617E-11,62358E-1
0.4SBWOdeSolver-3,25264E-12,63457E-12,03427E-12,15656E-11,62500E-1
0.4copasi8,45040E-13,25264E-12,63457E-12,03427E-12,15656E-11,62500E-1
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner8,45040E-13,25264E-12,63457E-12,03427E-12,15656E-11,62500E-1
0.4jsim1,00000E-154,04000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
0.4min 1,00000E-15 4,04000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
0.4max 8,45040E-1 3,25264E-1 2,63543E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1
0.4mean 8,45040E-1 3,25264E-1 2,63457E-1 2,03427E-1 2,15656E-1 1,62500E-1
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML7,91405E-14,21042E-12,53889E-11,84207E-12,10448E-11,42861E-1
0.6ByoDyn7,91407E-14,21042E-12,53889E-11,84207E-12,10448E-11,42863E-1
0.6Jarnac7,91407E-14,21042E-12,53889E-11,84207E-12,10448E-11,42863E-1
0.6MathSBML7,91407E-14,21042E-12,53889E-11,84207E-12,10448E-11,42863E-1
0.6Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
0.6SBToolbox27,91323E-14,20984E-12,53955E-11,84191E-12,10407E-11,42770E-1
0.6SBWOdeSolver-4,21042E-12,53888E-11,84207E-12,10449E-11,42863E-1
0.6copasi7,91407E-14,21042E-12,53889E-11,84207E-12,10448E-11,42863E-1
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner7,91407E-14,21042E-12,53889E-11,84207E-12,10448E-11,42863E-1
0.6jsim1,00000E-155,56000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
0.6min 1,00000E-15 5,56000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
0.6max 7,91407E-1 4,21042E-1 2,53955E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1
0.6mean 7,91407E-1 4,21042E-1 2,53889E-1 1,84207E-1 2,10448E-1 1,42863E-1
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML7,50135E-15,09812E-12,40961E-11,69949E-12,10653E-11,28572E-1
0.8ByoDyn7,50137E-15,09812E-12,40961E-11,69949E-12,10653E-11,28574E-1
0.8Jarnac7,50137E-15,09812E-12,40961E-11,69949E-12,10653E-11,28574E-1
0.8MathSBML7,50137E-15,09812E-12,40961E-11,69949E-12,10653E-11,28574E-1
0.8Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
0.8SBToolbox27,50014E-15,09746E-12,41035E-11,69899E-12,10581E-11,28500E-1
0.8SBWOdeSolver-5,09812E-12,40961E-11,69949E-12,10653E-11,28574E-1
0.8copasi7,50137E-15,09812E-12,40961E-11,69949E-12,10653E-11,28574E-1
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner7,50137E-15,09812E-12,40961E-11,69949E-12,10653E-11,28574E-1
0.8jsim1,00000E-157,08000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
0.8min 1,00000E-15 7,08000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
0.8max 7,50137E-1 5,09812E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1
0.8mean 7,50137E-1 5,09812E-1 2,40961E-1 1,69949E-1 2,10653E-1 1,28574E-1
0.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.0BioUML7,19792E-15,93183E-12,26822E-11,60227E-12,15154E-11,17589E-1
1.0ByoDyn7,19793E-15,93183E-12,26822E-11,60227E-12,15154E-11,17591E-1
1.0Jarnac7,19793E-15,93183E-12,26822E-11,60227E-12,15154E-11,17591E-1
1.0MathSBML7,19793E-15,93183E-12,26822E-11,60227E-12,15154E-11,17591E-1
1.0Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
1.0SBToolbox27,19628E-15,93094E-12,26892E-11,60149E-12,15059E-11,17528E-1
1.0SBWOdeSolver-5,93183E-12,26822E-11,60228E-12,15154E-11,17591E-1
1.0copasi7,19793E-15,93183E-12,26822E-11,60227E-12,15154E-11,17591E-1
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner7,19793E-15,93183E-12,26822E-11,60227E-12,15154E-11,17591E-1
1.0jsim1,00000E-158,60000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
1.0min 1,00000E-15 8,60000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
1.0max 7,19793E-1 5,93183E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1
1.0mean 7,19793E-1 5,93183E-1 2,26822E-1 1,60227E-1 2,15154E-1 1,17591E-1
1.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.2BioUML6,99257E-16,72221E-12,12691E-11,54347E-12,23132E-11,09088E-1
1.2ByoDyn6,99258E-16,72221E-12,12693E-11,54348E-12,23132E-11,09085E-1
1.2Jarnac6,99258E-16,72221E-12,12693E-11,54348E-12,23132E-11,09085E-1
1.2MathSBML6,99258E-16,72221E-12,12693E-11,54348E-12,23132E-11,09085E-1
1.2Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
1.2SBToolbox26,99057E-16,72107E-12,12753E-11,54256E-12,23024E-11,09026E-1
1.2SBWOdeSolver-6,72220E-12,12693E-11,54348E-12,23132E-11,09086E-1
1.2copasi6,99258E-16,72221E-12,12693E-11,54348E-12,23132E-11,09085E-1
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner6,99258E-16,72221E-12,12693E-11,54348E-12,23132E-11,09085E-1
1.2jsim1,00000E-151,01200E-152,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
1.2min 1,00000E-15 1,01200E-15 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
1.2max 6,99258E-1 6,72221E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1
1.2mean 6,99258E-1 6,72221E-1 2,12693E-1 1,54348E-1 2,23132E-1 1,09085E-1
1.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.4BioUML6,87544E-17,47674E-11,99318E-11,51642E-12,33954E-11,02630E-1
1.4ByoDyn6,87544E-17,47674E-11,99319E-11,51642E-12,33954E-11,02629E-1
1.4Jarnac6,87544E-17,47674E-11,99319E-11,51642E-12,33954E-11,02629E-1
1.4MathSBML6,87544E-17,47674E-11,99319E-11,51642E-12,33954E-11,02629E-1
1.4Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
1.4SBToolbox26,87295E-17,47543E-11,99371E-11,51538E-12,33816E-11,02569E-1
1.4SBWOdeSolver-7,47673E-11,99320E-11,51643E-12,33954E-11,02629E-1
1.4copasi6,87544E-17,47674E-11,99319E-11,51642E-12,33954E-11,02629E-1
1.4edu.kgi.roadRunner6,87544E-17,47674E-11,99319E-11,51642E-12,33954E-11,02629E-1
1.4jsim1,00000E-151,16400E-152,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
1.4min 1,00000E-15 1,16400E-15 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
1.4max 6,87544E-1 7,47674E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1
1.4mean 6,87544E-1 7,47674E-1 1,99319E-1 1,51642E-1 2,33954E-1 1,02629E-1
1.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.6BioUML6,83744E-18,20094E-11,87162E-11,51539E-12,47122E-19,79215E-2
1.6ByoDyn6,83747E-18,20094E-11,87161E-11,51538E-12,47122E-19,79258E-2
1.6Jarnac6,83747E-18,20094E-11,87161E-11,51538E-12,47122E-19,79258E-2
1.6MathSBML6,83747E-18,20094E-11,87161E-11,51538E-12,47122E-19,79258E-2
1.6Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
1.6SBToolbox26,83392E-18,19980E-11,87213E-11,51392E-12,46936E-19,78515E-2
1.6SBWOdeSolver-8,20094E-11,87161E-11,51538E-12,47123E-19,79264E-2
1.6copasi6,83746E-18,20094E-11,87161E-11,51538E-12,47122E-19,79258E-2
1.6edu.kgi.roadRunner6,83747E-18,20094E-11,87161E-11,51538E-12,47122E-19,79258E-2
1.6jsim1,00000E-151,31600E-152,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
1.6min 1,00000E-15 1,31600E-15 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
1.6max 6,83747E-1 8,20094E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1
1.6mean 6,83747E-1 8,20094E-1 1,87161E-1 1,51538E-1 2,47122E-1 9,79258E-2
1.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.8BioUML6,87029E-18,89902E-11,76480E-11,53565E-12,62238E-19,47469E-2
1.8ByoDyn6,87028E-18,89902E-11,76483E-11,53566E-12,62238E-19,47409E-2
1.8Jarnac6,87028E-18,89902E-11,76483E-11,53566E-12,62238E-19,47409E-2
1.8MathSBML6,87028E-18,89902E-11,76483E-11,53566E-12,62238E-19,47409E-2
1.8Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
1.8SBToolbox26,86652E-18,89751E-11,76508E-11,53433E-12,62046E-19,46729E-2
1.8SBWOdeSolver-8,89902E-11,76483E-11,53567E-12,62238E-19,47411E-2
1.8copasi6,87028E-18,89902E-11,76483E-11,53566E-12,62238E-19,47409E-2
1.8edu.kgi.roadRunner6,87028E-18,89902E-11,76483E-11,53566E-12,62238E-19,47409E-2
1.8jsim1,00000E-151,46800E-152,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
1.8min 1,00000E-15 1,46800E-15 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
1.8max 6,87028E-1 8,89902E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,62238E-1 2,50000E-1
1.8mean 6,87028E-1 8,89902E-1 1,76483E-1 1,53566E-1 2,62238E-1 9,47409E-2
1.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.0BioUML6,96620E-19,57430E-11,67421E-11,57349E-12,78981E-19,28694E-2
2.0ByoDyn6,96622E-19,57430E-11,67419E-11,57348E-12,78981E-19,28739E-2
2.0Jarnac6,96622E-19,57430E-11,67419E-11,57348E-12,78981E-19,28739E-2
2.0MathSBML6,96622E-19,57430E-11,67419E-11,57348E-12,78981E-19,28739E-2
2.0Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
2.0SBToolbox26,96164E-19,57276E-11,67422E-11,57194E-12,78754E-19,27994E-2
2.0SBWOdeSolver-9,57429E-11,67420E-11,57348E-12,78982E-19,28740E-2
2.0copasi6,96622E-19,57430E-11,67419E-11,57348E-12,78981E-19,28739E-2
2.0edu.kgi.roadRunner6,96622E-19,57430E-11,67419E-11,57348E-12,78981E-19,28739E-2
2.0jsim1,00000E-151,62000E-152,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
2.0min 1,00000E-15 1,62000E-15 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
2.0max 6,96622E-1 9,57430E-1 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,78982E-1 2,50000E-1
2.0mean 6,96622E-1 9,57430E-1 1,67419E-1 1,57348E-1 2,78981E-1 9,28739E-2
2.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.2BioUML7,11838E-11,02294E01,60007E-11,62574E-12,97095E-19,21617E-2
2.2ByoDyn7,11836E-11,02294E01,60011E-11,62576E-12,97095E-19,21549E-2
2.2Jarnac7,11836E-11,02294E01,60011E-11,62576E-12,97095E-19,21549E-2
2.2MathSBML7,11836E-11,02294E01,60011E-11,62576E-12,97095E-19,21549E-2
2.2Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
2.2SBToolbox27,11316E-11,02277E01,59983E-11,62416E-12,96843E-19,20756E-2
2.2SBWOdeSolver-1,02294E01,60011E-11,62576E-12,97095E-19,21551E-2
2.2copasi7,11836E-11,02294E01,60011E-11,62576E-12,97095E-19,21549E-2
2.2edu.kgi.roadRunner7,11836E-11,02294E01,60011E-11,62576E-12,97095E-19,21549E-2
2.2jsim1,00000E-151,77200E-152,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
2.2min 1,00000E-15 1,77200E-15 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
2.2max 7,11836E-1 1,02294E0 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 2,97095E-1 2,50000E-1
2.2mean 7,11836E-1 1,02294E0 1,60011E-1 1,62576E-1 2,97095E-1 9,21549E-2
2.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.4BioUML7,32049E-11,08666E01,54238E-11,69007E-13,16369E-19,24352E-2
2.4ByoDyn7,32051E-11,08666E01,54237E-11,69005E-13,16370E-19,24398E-2
2.4Jarnac7,32051E-11,08666E01,54237E-11,69005E-13,16370E-19,24398E-2
2.4MathSBML7,32051E-11,08666E01,54237E-11,69005E-13,16370E-19,24398E-2
2.4Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
2.4SBToolbox27,31459E-11,08646E01,54180E-11,68836E-13,16082E-19,23526E-2
2.4SBWOdeSolver-1,08666E01,54237E-11,69005E-13,16370E-19,24400E-2
2.4copasi7,32051E-11,08666E01,54237E-11,69005E-13,16370E-19,24398E-2
2.4edu.kgi.roadRunner7,32051E-11,08666E01,54237E-11,69005E-13,16370E-19,24398E-2
2.4jsim1,00000E-151,92400E-152,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
2.4min 1,00000E-15 1,92400E-15 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
2.4max 7,32051E-1 1,08666E0 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 3,16370E-1 2,50000E-1
2.4mean 7,32051E-1 1,08666E0 1,54237E-1 1,69005E-1 3,16370E-1 9,24398E-2
2.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.6BioUML7,56721E-11,14876E01,50034E-11,76434E-13,36639E-19,36148E-2
2.6ByoDyn7,56720E-11,14876E01,50037E-11,76436E-13,36638E-19,36077E-2
2.6Jarnac7,56720E-11,14876E01,50037E-11,76436E-13,36638E-19,36077E-2
2.6MathSBML7,56720E-11,14876E01,50037E-11,76436E-13,36638E-19,36077E-2
2.6Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
2.6SBToolbox27,56087E-11,14852E01,49954E-11,76279E-13,36332E-19,35210E-2
2.6SBWOdeSolver-1,14876E01,50038E-11,76437E-13,36639E-19,36080E-2
2.6copasi7,56720E-11,14876E01,50037E-11,76436E-13,36638E-19,36077E-2
2.6edu.kgi.roadRunner7,56720E-11,14876E01,50037E-11,76436E-13,36638E-19,36077E-2
2.6jsim1,00000E-152,07600E-152,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
2.6min 1,00000E-15 2,07600E-15 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
2.6max 7,56720E-1 1,14876E0 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 3,36639E-1 2,50000E-1
2.6mean 7,56720E-1 1,14876E0 1,50037E-1 1,76436E-1 3,36638E-1 9,36077E-2
2.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.8BioUML7,85359E-11,20940E01,47331E-11,84713E-13,57765E-19,55511E-2
2.8ByoDyn7,85362E-11,20940E01,47329E-11,84710E-13,57765E-19,55573E-2
2.8Jarnac7,85362E-11,20940E01,47329E-11,84710E-13,57765E-19,55573E-2
2.8MathSBML7,85362E-11,20940E01,47329E-11,84710E-13,57765E-19,55573E-2
2.8Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
2.8SBToolbox27,84574E-11,20916E01,47198E-11,84520E-13,57418E-19,54438E-2
2.8SBWOdeSolver-1,20940E01,47329E-11,84710E-13,57766E-19,55575E-2
2.8copasi7,85362E-11,20940E01,47329E-11,84710E-13,57765E-19,55573E-2
2.8edu.kgi.roadRunner7,85362E-11,20940E01,47329E-11,84710E-13,57765E-19,55573E-2
2.8jsim1,00000E-152,22800E-152,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
2.8min 1,00000E-15 2,22800E-15 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
2.8max 7,85362E-1 1,20940E0 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 3,57766E-1 2,50000E-1
2.8mean 7,85362E-1 1,20940E0 1,47329E-1 1,84710E-1 3,57765E-1 9,55573E-2
2.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.0BioUML8,17561E-11,26871E01,46015E-11,93695E-13,79642E-19,82093E-2
3.0ByoDyn8,17560E-11,26871E01,46017E-11,93697E-13,79642E-19,82043E-2
3.0Jarnac8,17560E-11,26871E01,46017E-11,93697E-13,79642E-19,82043E-2
3.0MathSBML8,17560E-11,26871E01,46017E-11,93697E-13,79642E-19,82043E-2
3.0Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
3.0SBToolbox28,16803E-11,26843E01,45882E-11,93532E-13,79287E-19,81016E-2
3.0SBWOdeSolver-1,26871E01,46017E-11,93697E-13,79642E-19,82046E-2
3.0copasi8,17560E-11,26871E01,46017E-11,93697E-13,79642E-19,82043E-2
3.0edu.kgi.roadRunner8,17560E-11,26871E01,46017E-11,93697E-13,79642E-19,82043E-2
3.0jsim1,00000E-152,38000E-152,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
3.0min 1,00000E-15 2,38000E-15 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
3.0max 8,17560E-1 1,26871E0 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 3,79642E-1 2,50000E-1
3.0mean 8,17560E-1 1,26871E0 1,46017E-1 1,93697E-1 3,79642E-1 9,82043E-2
3.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.2BioUML8,52951E-11,32679E01,46003E-12,03294E-14,02178E-11,01476E-1
3.2ByoDyn8,52952E-11,32679E01,46002E-12,03293E-14,02179E-11,01478E-1
3.2Jarnac8,52952E-11,32679E01,46002E-12,03293E-14,02179E-11,01478E-1
3.2MathSBML8,52952E-11,32679E01,46002E-12,03293E-14,02179E-11,01478E-1
3.2Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
3.2SBToolbox28,52051E-11,32657E01,45820E-12,03103E-14,01785E-11,01352E-1
3.2SBWOdeSolver-1,32679E01,46003E-12,03293E-14,02179E-11,01479E-1
3.2copasi8,52952E-11,32679E01,46002E-12,03293E-14,02179E-11,01478E-1
3.2edu.kgi.roadRunner8,52952E-11,32679E01,46002E-12,03293E-14,02179E-11,01478E-1
3.2jsim1,00000E-152,53200E-152,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
3.2min 1,00000E-15 2,53200E-15 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
3.2max 8,52952E-1 1,32679E0 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 4,02179E-1 2,50000E-1
3.2mean 8,52952E-1 1,32679E0 1,46002E-1 2,03293E-1 4,02179E-1 1,01478E-1
3.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.4BioUML8,91225E-11,38376E01,47189E-12,13416E-14,25305E-11,05315E-1
3.4ByoDyn8,91228E-11,38376E01,47187E-12,13413E-14,25306E-11,05321E-1
3.4Jarnac8,91228E-11,38376E01,47187E-12,13413E-14,25306E-11,05321E-1
3.4MathSBML8,91228E-11,38376E01,47187E-12,13413E-14,25306E-11,05321E-1
3.4Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
3.4SBToolbox28,90257E-11,38355E01,46979E-12,13213E-14,24892E-11,05179E-1
3.4SBWOdeSolver-1,38376E01,47188E-12,13413E-14,25306E-11,05322E-1
3.4copasi8,91228E-11,38376E01,47187E-12,13413E-14,25306E-11,05321E-1
3.4edu.kgi.roadRunner8,91228E-11,38376E01,47187E-12,13413E-14,25306E-11,05321E-1
3.4jsim1,00000E-152,68400E-152,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
3.4min 1,00000E-15 2,68400E-15 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
3.4max 8,91228E-1 1,38376E0 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 4,25306E-1 2,50000E-1
3.4mean 8,91228E-1 1,38376E0 1,47187E-1 2,13413E-1 4,25306E-1 1,05321E-1
3.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.6BioUML9,32124E-11,43969E01,49473E-12,23983E-14,48968E-11,09700E-1
3.6ByoDyn9,32120E-11,43969E01,49479E-12,23989E-14,48967E-11,09685E-1
3.6Jarnac9,32120E-11,43969E01,49479E-12,23989E-14,48967E-11,09685E-1
3.6MathSBML9,32120E-11,43969E01,49479E-12,23989E-14,48967E-11,09685E-1
3.6Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
3.6SBToolbox29,31134E-11,43943E01,49260E-12,23796E-14,48538E-11,09537E-1
3.6SBWOdeSolver-1,43969E01,49480E-12,23989E-14,48967E-11,09685E-1
3.6copasi9,32120E-11,43969E01,49479E-12,23989E-14,48967E-11,09685E-1
3.6edu.kgi.roadRunner9,32120E-11,43969E01,49479E-12,23989E-14,48967E-11,09685E-1
3.6jsim1,00000E-152,83600E-152,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
3.6min 1,00000E-15 2,83600E-15 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
3.6max 9,32120E-1 1,43969E0 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 4,48967E-1 2,50000E-1
3.6mean 9,32120E-1 1,43969E0 1,49479E-1 2,23989E-1 4,48967E-1 1,09685E-1
3.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.8BioUML9,75398E-11,49465E01,52795E-12,34971E-14,73115E-11,14517E-1
3.8ByoDyn9,75401E-11,49465E01,52791E-12,34966E-14,73116E-11,14528E-1
3.8Jarnac9,75401E-11,49465E01,52791E-12,34966E-14,73116E-11,14528E-1
3.8MathSBML9,75401E-11,49465E01,52791E-12,34966E-14,73116E-11,14528E-1
3.8Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
3.8SBToolbox29,74306E-11,49437E01,52528E-12,34757E-14,72666E-11,14361E-1
3.8SBWOdeSolver-1,49465E01,52791E-12,34967E-14,73116E-11,14528E-1
3.8copasi9,75401E-11,49465E01,52791E-12,34966E-14,73116E-11,14528E-1
3.8edu.kgi.roadRunner9,75401E-11,49465E01,52791E-12,34966E-14,73116E-11,14528E-1
3.8jsim1,00000E-152,98800E-152,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
3.8min 1,00000E-15 2,98800E-15 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
3.8max 9,75401E-1 1,49465E0 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 4,73116E-1 2,50000E-1
3.8mean 9,75401E-1 1,49465E0 1,52791E-1 2,34966E-1 4,73116E-1 1,14528E-1
3.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.0BioUML1,02088E01,54872E01,57039E-12,46295E-14,97719E-11,19830E-1
4.0ByoDyn1,02088E01,54872E01,57044E-12,46300E-14,97718E-11,19818E-1
4.0Jarnac1,02088E01,54872E01,57044E-12,46300E-14,97718E-11,19818E-1
4.0MathSBML1,02088E01,54872E01,57044E-12,46300E-14,97718E-11,19818E-1
4.0Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
4.0SBToolbox21,01978E01,54842E01,56778E-12,46092E-14,97254E-11,19642E-1
4.0SBWOdeSolver-1,54872E01,57044E-12,46300E-14,97718E-11,19818E-1
4.0copasi1,02088E01,54872E01,57044E-12,46300E-14,97718E-11,19818E-1
4.0edu.kgi.roadRunner1,02088E01,54872E01,57044E-12,46300E-14,97718E-11,19818E-1
4.0jsim1,00000E-153,14000E-152,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
4.0min 1,00000E-15 3,14000E-15 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
4.0max 1,02088E0 1,54872E0 2,50000E-1 2,50000E-1 4,97718E-1 2,50000E-1
4.0mean 1,02088E0 1,54872E0 1,57044E-1 2,46300E-1 4,97718E-1 1,19818E-1
4.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.2BioUML1,06839E01,60194E01,62168E-12,57952E-15,22745E-11,25527E-1
4.2ByoDyn1,06839E01,60194E01,62167E-12,57952E-15,22745E-11,25527E-1
4.2Jarnac1,06839E01,60194E01,62167E-12,57952E-15,22745E-11,25527E-1
4.2MathSBML1,06839E01,60194E01,62167E-12,57952E-15,22745E-11,25527E-1
4.2Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
4.2SBToolbox21,06719E01,60167E01,61887E-12,57742E-15,22261E-11,25338E-1
4.2SBWOdeSolver-1,60194E01,62168E-12,57953E-15,22745E-11,25527E-1
4.2copasi1,06839E01,60194E01,62167E-12,57952E-15,22745E-11,25527E-1
4.2edu.kgi.roadRunner1,06839E01,60194E01,62167E-12,57952E-15,22745E-11,25527E-1
4.2jsim1,00000E-153,29200E-152,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
4.2min 1,00000E-15 3,29200E-15 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
4.2max 1,06839E0 1,60194E0 2,50000E-1 2,57953E-1 5,22745E-1 2,50000E-1
4.2mean 1,06839E0 1,60194E0 1,62167E-1 2,57952E-1 5,22745E-1 1,25527E-1
4.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.4BioUML1,11780E01,65437E01,68097E-12,69895E-15,48175E-11,31634E-1
4.4ByoDyn1,11780E01,65437E01,68098E-12,69896E-15,48175E-11,31632E-1
4.4Jarnac1,11780E01,65437E01,68098E-12,69896E-15,48175E-11,31632E-1
4.4MathSBML1,11780E01,65437E01,68098E-12,69896E-15,48175E-11,31632E-1
4.4Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
4.4SBToolbox21,11656E01,65416E01,67779E-12,69672E-15,47672E-11,31424E-1
4.4SBWOdeSolver-1,65437E01,68098E-12,69896E-15,48175E-11,31632E-1
4.4copasi1,11780E01,65437E01,68098E-12,69896E-15,48175E-11,31632E-1
4.4edu.kgi.roadRunner1,11780E01,65437E01,68098E-12,69896E-15,48175E-11,31632E-1
4.4jsim1,00000E-153,44400E-152,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
4.4min 1,00000E-15 3,44400E-15 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
4.4max 1,11780E0 1,65437E0 2,50000E-1 2,69896E-1 5,48175E-1 2,50000E-1
4.4mean 1,11780E0 1,65437E0 1,68098E-1 2,69896E-1 5,48175E-1 1,31632E-1
4.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.6BioUML1,16899E01,70605E01,74777E-12,82103E-15,73992E-11,38120E-1
4.6ByoDyn1,16899E01,70605E01,74780E-12,82106E-15,73991E-11,38114E-1
4.6Jarnac1,16899E01,70605E01,74780E-12,82106E-15,73991E-11,38114E-1
4.6MathSBML1,16899E01,70605E01,74780E-12,82106E-15,73991E-11,38114E-1
4.6Oscill8 Core-1,00000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-12,50000E-1
4.6SBToolbox21,16770E01,70580E01,74464E-12,81885E-15,73477E-11,37898E-1
4.6SBWOdeSolver-1,70605E01,74780E-12,82106E-15,73992E-11,38114E-1
4.6copasi1,16899E01,70605E01,74779E-12,82106E-15,73991E-11,38114E-1
4.6edu.kgi.roadRunner1,16899E01,70605E01,74780E-12,82106E-15,73991E-11,38114E-1
4.6jsim1,00000E-153,59600E-152,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-162,50000E-16
4.6min 1,00000E-15 3,59600E-15 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16 2,50000E-16
4.6max 1,16899E0 1,70605E0 2,50000E-1 2,82106E-1 5,73992E-1 2,50000E-1
4.6mean 1,16899E0 1,70605E0 1,74780E-1 2,82106E-1 5,73991E-1 1,38114E-1
4.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.8BioUML1,22187E01,75703E01,82166E-12,94565E-16,00181E-11,44955E-1
4.8ByoDyn1,22187E01,75703E01,82164E-12,94564E-16,00182E-11,44958E-1
4.8