Test: BIOMD0000000030.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000030.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: DormandPrince
generated code: BIOMD0000000030.java
results: CSV file
plots: -
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-100
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000030.gif

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: Mpp_MKP_Y  M_MAPKK_Y  M_MKP_Y  M_MKP_T  M  MpT_MKP_T  MpT_MKP_Y  Mpp_MKP_T  MpY_MKP_Y  MAPKK  MpT  Mpp  MKP  MpT_MAPKK  MpY_MAPKK  MpY_MKP_T  M_MAPKK_T  MpY 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  Jarnac  SBToolbox2  VCell  Oscill8 Core  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  jsim  BioUML 
timeresult Mpp_MKP_Y M_MAPKK_Y M_MKP_Y M_MKP_T M MpT_MKP_T MpT_MKP_Y Mpp_MKP_T MpY_MKP_Y MAPKK MpT Mpp MKP MpT_MAPKK MpY_MAPKK MpY_MKP_T M_MAPKK_T MpY
0.0BioUML0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E08,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,80000E20,00000E00,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0ByoDyn0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E08,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,80000E20,00000E00,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0Jarnac0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E08,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,80000E20,00000E00,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0MathSBML0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E08,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,80000E20,00000E00,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0Oscill8 Core0,00000E00,00000E0-0,00000E0-0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,80000E20,00000E00,00000E01,00000E20,00000E0-0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0SBToolbox20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E08,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,80000E20,00000E00,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0SBWOdeSolver0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E08,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,80000E20,00000E00,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0VCell0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E08,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,80000E20,00000E00,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0copasi0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E08,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,80000E20,00000E00,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E08,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,80000E20,00000E00,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0jsim0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E08,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,80000E20,00000E00,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0min 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 8,00000E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,80000E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0max 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 8,00000E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,80000E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0mean 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 8,00000E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,80000E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML1,10699E-38,59706E11,89638E11,16579E15,97150E27,72675E-37,97242E-31,10699E-37,74087E-38,05535E01,22665E-14,35075E-36,93447E11,73784E-31,73785E-37,97244E-38,59706E11,22666E-1
0.2ByoDyn1,10699E-38,59706E11,89638E11,16579E15,97150E27,72675E-37,97242E-31,10699E-37,74087E-38,05535E01,22665E-14,35075E-36,93447E11,73784E-31,73785E-37,97244E-38,59706E11,22666E-1
0.2Jarnac1,10699E-38,59706E11,89638E11,16579E15,97150E27,72675E-37,97242E-31,10699E-37,74087E-38,05535E01,22665E-14,35075E-36,93447E11,73784E-31,73785E-37,97244E-38,59706E11,22666E-1
0.2MathSBML1,10699E-38,59706E11,89638E11,16579E15,97150E27,72675E-37,97242E-31,10699E-37,74087E-38,05535E01,22665E-14,35075E-36,93447E11,73784E-31,73785E-37,97244E-38,59706E11,22666E-1
0.2Oscill8 Core1,10702E-38,59704E1-1,16578E1-7,72696E-37,97265E-31,10702E-37,74108E-38,05581E01,22665E-14,35080E-36,93449E11,73788E-3-7,97267E-38,59704E11,22665E-1
0.2SBToolbox21,10887E-38,59759E11,89635E11,16580E15,97138E27,72722E-37,97310E-31,10887E-37,74138E-38,04467E01,22655E-14,35427E-36,93446E11,73808E-31,73808E-37,97311E-38,59759E11,22655E-1
0.2SBWOdeSolver1,10704E-38,59704E11,89637E11,16578E15,97151E27,72696E-37,97266E-31,10704E-37,74108E-38,05582E01,22665E-14,35076E-36,93449E11,73788E-31,73789E-37,97267E-38,59704E11,22665E-1
0.2VCell1,10699E-38,59706E11,89638E11,16579E15,97150E27,72675E-37,97242E-31,10699E-37,74087E-38,05535E01,22665E-14,35075E-36,93447E11,73784E-31,73785E-37,97244E-38,59706E11,22666E-1
0.2copasi1,10699E-38,59706E11,89638E11,16579E15,97150E27,72675E-37,97242E-31,10699E-37,74087E-38,05534E01,22665E-14,35075E-36,93447E11,73784E-31,73785E-37,97244E-38,59706E11,22666E-1
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner1,10699E-38,59706E11,89638E11,16579E15,97150E27,72675E-37,97242E-31,10699E-37,74087E-38,05538E01,22665E-14,35076E-36,93447E11,73785E-31,73785E-37,97243E-38,59706E11,22666E-1
0.2jsim1,10699E-38,59706E11,89638E11,16579E15,97150E27,72675E-37,97242E-31,10699E-37,74087E-38,05535E01,22665E-14,35075E-36,93447E11,73784E-31,73785E-37,97244E-38,59706E11,22666E-1
0.2min 1,10699E-3 8,59704E1 1,89635E1 1,16578E1 5,97138E2 7,72675E-3 7,97242E-3 1,10699E-3 7,74087E-3 8,04467E0 1,22655E-1 4,35075E-3 6,93446E1 1,73784E-3 1,73785E-3 7,97243E-3 8,59704E1 1,22655E-1
0.2max 1,10887E-3 8,59759E1 1,89638E1 1,16580E1 5,97151E2 7,72722E-3 7,97310E-3 1,10887E-3 7,74138E-3 8,05582E0 1,22665E-1 4,35427E-3 6,93449E1 1,73808E-3 1,73808E-3 7,97311E-3 8,59759E1 1,22666E-1
0.2mean 1,10699E-3 8,59706E1 1,89638E1 1,16579E1 5,97150E2 7,72675E-3 7,97242E-3 1,10699E-3 7,74087E-3 8,05535E0 1,22665E-1 4,35075E-3 6,93447E1 1,73784E-3 1,73785E-3 7,97244E-3 8,59706E1 1,22666E-1
0.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML4,47637E-38,62436E13,07427E11,90209E15,77121E22,46709E-22,63901E-24,47637E-32,47669E-27,50641E02,49662E-11,17262E-25,01253E13,17775E-33,17783E-32,63906E-28,62436E12,49671E-1
0.4ByoDyn4,47637E-38,62436E13,07427E11,90209E15,77121E22,46709E-22,63901E-24,47637E-32,47669E-27,50641E02,49662E-11,17262E-25,01253E13,17775E-33,17783E-32,63906E-28,62436E12,49671E-1
0.4Jarnac4,47637E-38,62436E13,07427E11,90209E15,77121E22,46709E-22,63901E-24,47637E-32,47669E-27,50641E02,49662E-11,17262E-25,01253E13,17775E-33,17783E-32,63906E-28,62436E12,49671E-1
0.4MathSBML4,47637E-38,62436E13,07427E11,90209E15,77121E22,46709E-22,63901E-24,47637E-32,47669E-27,50641E02,49662E-11,17262E-25,01253E13,17775E-33,17783E-32,63906E-28,62436E12,49671E-1
0.4Oscill8 Core4,47646E-38,62436E1-1,90208E1-2,46708E-22,63902E-24,47646E-32,47669E-27,50641E02,49661E-11,17266E-25,01256E13,17776E-3-2,63906E-28,62436E12,49671E-1
0.4SBToolbox24,48326E-38,62442E13,07437E11,90218E15,77122E22,46797E-22,63993E-24,48326E-32,47764E-27,50553E02,49637E-11,17178E-25,01226E13,17586E-33,17596E-32,64003E-28,62442E12,49647E-1
0.4SBWOdeSolver4,47646E-38,62436E13,07425E11,90208E15,77121E22,46708E-22,63902E-24,47646E-32,47669E-27,50641E02,49661E-11,17265E-25,01256E13,17776E-33,17785E-32,63906E-28,62436E12,49671E-1
0.4VCell4,47637E-38,62436E13,07427E11,90209E15,77121E22,46709E-22,63901E-24,47637E-32,47669E-27,50641E02,49662E-11,17262E-25,01253E13,17775E-33,17783E-32,63906E-28,62436E12,49671E-1
0.4copasi4,47636E-38,62436E13,07427E11,90209E15,77121E22,46709E-22,63901E-24,47636E-32,47669E-27,50641E02,49662E-11,17262E-25,01253E13,17775E-33,17783E-32,63906E-28,62436E12,49671E-1
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner4,47637E-38,62436E13,07427E11,90209E15,77121E22,46708E-22,63901E-24,47637E-32,47669E-27,50642E02,49662E-11,17262E-25,01253E13,17775E-33,17784E-32,63905E-28,62436E12,49671E-1
0.4jsim4,47637E-38,62436E13,07427E11,90209E15,77121E22,46708E-22,63901E-24,47637E-32,47670E-27,50641E02,49662E-11,17262E-25,01253E13,17775E-33,17783E-32,63906E-28,62436E12,49671E-1
0.4min 4,47636E-3 8,62436E1 3,07425E1 1,90208E1 5,77121E2 2,46708E-2 2,63901E-2 4,47636E-3 2,47669E-2 7,50553E0 2,49637E-1 1,17178E-2 5,01226E1 3,17586E-3 3,17596E-3 2,63905E-2 8,62436E1 2,49647E-1
0.4max 4,48326E-3 8,62442E1 3,07437E1 1,90218E1 5,77122E2 2,46797E-2 2,63993E-2 4,48326E-3 2,47764E-2 7,50642E0 2,49662E-1 1,17266E-2 5,01256E1 3,17776E-3 3,17785E-3 2,64003E-2 8,62442E1 2,49671E-1
0.4mean 4,47637E-3 8,62436E1 3,07427E1 1,90209E1 5,77121E2 2,46709E-2 2,63901E-2 4,47637E-3 2,47669E-2 7,50641E0 2,49662E-1 1,17262E-2 5,01253E1 3,17775E-3 3,17783E-3 2,63906E-2 8,62436E1 2,49671E-1
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML9,82183E-38,61551E13,86391E12,40727E15,64011E24,12022E-24,57583E-29,82183E-34,14500E-27,67973E03,68737E-12,54704E-23,70944E15,06546E-35,06588E-34,57603E-28,61551E13,68775E-1
0.6ByoDyn9,82183E-38,61551E13,86391E12,40727E15,64011E24,12022E-24,57583E-29,82183E-34,14500E-27,67973E03,68737E-12,54704E-23,70944E15,06546E-35,06588E-34,57603E-28,61551E13,68775E-1
0.6Jarnac9,82183E-38,61551E13,86391E12,40727E15,64011E24,12022E-24,57583E-29,82183E-34,14500E-27,67973E03,68737E-12,54704E-23,70944E15,06546E-35,06588E-34,57603E-28,61551E13,68775E-1
0.6MathSBML9,82183E-38,61551E13,86391E12,40727E15,64011E24,12022E-24,57583E-29,82183E-34,14500E-27,67973E03,68737E-12,54704E-23,70944E15,06546E-35,06588E-34,57603E-28,61551E13,68775E-1
0.6Oscill8 Core9,82196E-38,61551E1-2,40726E1-4,12020E-24,57581E-29,82196E-34,14497E-27,67973E03,68737E-12,54709E-23,70947E15,06546E-3-4,57601E-28,61551E13,68775E-1
0.6SBToolbox29,83403E-38,61552E13,86415E12,40743E15,64003E24,12237E-24,57806E-29,83403E-34,14712E-27,67974E03,68696E-12,54436E-23,70904E15,06436E-35,06476E-34,57826E-28,61552E13,68726E-1
0.6SBWOdeSolver9,82196E-38,61551E13,86390E12,40726E15,64011E24,12020E-24,57581E-29,82196E-34,14497E-27,67973E03,68737E-12,54709E-23,70947E15,06546E-35,06589E-34,57601E-28,61551E13,68775E-1
0.6VCell9,82183E-38,61551E13,86391E12,40727E15,64011E24,12022E-24,57583E-29,82183E-34,14500E-27,67973E03,68737E-12,54704E-23,70944E15,06546E-35,06588E-34,57603E-28,61551E13,68775E-1
0.6copasi9,82183E-38,61551E13,86391E12,40727E15,64011E24,12022E-24,57583E-29,82183E-34,14500E-27,67973E03,68737E-12,54703E-23,70944E15,06546E-35,06588E-34,57603E-28,61551E13,68775E-1
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner9,82184E-38,61551E13,86391E12,40727E15,64011E24,12023E-24,57583E-29,82184E-34,14500E-27,67975E03,68737E-12,54703E-23,70944E15,06547E-35,06589E-34,57603E-28,61551E13,68775E-1
0.6jsim9,82183E-38,61551E13,86391E12,40727E15,64011E24,12022E-24,57583E-29,82183E-34,14500E-27,67973E03,68737E-12,54704E-23,70944E15,06546E-35,06588E-34,57603E-28,61551E13,68775E-1
0.6min 9,82183E-3 8,61551E1 3,86390E1 2,40726E1 5,64003E2 4,12020E-2 4,57581E-2 9,82183E-3 4,14497E-2 7,67973E0 3,68696E-1 2,54436E-2 3,70904E1 5,06436E-3 5,06476E-3 4,57601E-2 8,61551E1 3,68726E-1
0.6max 9,83403E-3 8,61552E1 3,86415E1 2,40743E1 5,64011E2 4,12237E-2 4,57806E-2 9,83403E-3 4,14712E-2 7,67975E0 3,68737E-1 2,54709E-2 3,70947E1 5,06547E-3 5,06589E-3 4,57826E-2 8,61552E1 3,68775E-1
0.6mean 9,82183E-3 8,61551E1 3,86391E1 2,40727E1 5,64011E2 4,12022E-2 4,57583E-2 9,82183E-3 4,14500E-2 7,67973E0 3,68737E-1 2,54704E-2 3,70944E1 5,06546E-3 5,06588E-3 4,57603E-2 8,61551E1 3,68775E-1
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML1,70760E-28,60885E14,39941E12,76108E15,54916E25,42638E-26,25935E-21,70760E-25,47035E-27,80894E04,86512E-14,66347E-22,81268E16,99215E-36,99334E-36,25989E-28,60885E14,86608E-1
0.8ByoDyn1,70760E-28,60885E14,39941E12,76108E15,54916E25,42638E-26,25935E-21,70760E-25,47035E-27,80894E04,86512E-14,66347E-22,81268E16,99215E-36,99334E-36,25989E-28,60885E14,86608E-1
0.8Jarnac1,70760E-28,60885E14,39941E12,76108E15,54916E25,42638E-26,25935E-21,70760E-25,47035E-27,80894E04,86512E-14,66347E-22,81268E16,99215E-36,99334E-36,25989E-28,60885E14,86608E-1
0.8MathSBML1,70760E-28,60885E14,39941E12,76108E15,54916E25,42638E-26,25935E-21,70760E-25,47035E-27,80894E04,86512E-14,66347E-22,81268E16,99215E-36,99334E-36,25989E-28,60885E14,86608E-1
0.8Oscill8 Core1,70761E-28,60885E1-2,76107E1-5,42634E-26,25932E-21,70761E-25,47031E-27,80894E04,86512E-14,66355E-22,81270E16,99215E-3-6,25986E-28,60885E14,86608E-1
0.8SBToolbox21,70948E-28,60882E14,39983E12,76131E15,54910E25,42963E-26,26280E-21,70948E-25,47364E-27,80905E04,86448E-14,65871E-22,81200E16,99085E-36,99204E-36,26340E-28,60882E14,86548E-1
0.8SBWOdeSolver1,70761E-28,60885E14,39939E12,76107E15,54916E25,42634E-26,25932E-21,70761E-25,47031E-27,80894E04,86512E-14,66355E-22,81270E16,99216E-36,99335E-36,25986E-28,60885E14,86608E-1
0.8VCell1,70760E-28,60885E14,39941E12,76108E15,54916E25,42638E-26,25935E-21,70760E-25,47035E-27,80894E04,86512E-14,66347E-22,81268E16,99215E-36,99334E-36,25989E-28,60885E14,86608E-1
0.8copasi1,70760E-28,60885E14,39941E12,76108E15,54916E25,42638E-26,25935E-21,70760E-25,47035E-27,80894E04,86512E-14,66347E-22,81268E16,99215E-36,99334E-36,25989E-28,60885E14,86608E-1
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner1,70760E-28,60885E14,39941E12,76108E15,54916E25,42638E-26,25935E-21,70760E-25,47035E-27,80894E04,86512E-14,66347E-22,81268E16,99214E-36,99333E-36,25989E-28,60885E14,86608E-1
0.8jsim1,70760E-28,60885E14,39941E12,76108E15,54916E25,42638E-26,25935E-21,70760E-25,47035E-27,80894E04,86512E-14,66347E-22,81268E16,99215E-36,99334E-36,25989E-28,60885E14,86608E-1
0.8min 1,70760E-2 8,60882E1 4,39939E1 2,76107E1 5,54910E2 5,42634E-2 6,25932E-2 1,70760E-2 5,47031E-2 7,80894E0 4,86448E-1 4,65871E-2 2,81200E1 6,99085E-3 6,99204E-3 6,25986E-2 8,60882E1 4,86548E-1
0.8max 1,70948E-2 8,60885E1 4,39983E1 2,76131E1 5,54916E2 5,42963E-2 6,26280E-2 1,70948E-2 5,47364E-2 7,80905E0 4,86512E-1 4,66355E-2 2,81270E1 6,99216E-3 6,99335E-3 6,26340E-2 8,60885E1 4,86608E-1
0.8mean 1,70760E-2 8,60885E1 4,39941E1 2,76108E1 5,54916E2 5,42638E-2 6,25935E-2 1,70760E-2 5,47035E-2 7,80894E0 4,86512E-1 4,66347E-2 2,81268E1 6,99215E-3 6,99334E-3 6,25989E-2 8,60885E1 4,86608E-1
0.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.0BioUML2,58281E-28,60398E14,76435E13,01317E15,48510E26,34736E-27,60289E-22,58281E-26,41160E-27,90250E06,04619E-17,61461E-22,18935E18,94332E-38,94578E-37,60395E-28,60398E16,04805E-1
1.0ByoDyn2,58281E-28,60398E14,76435E13,01317E15,48510E26,34736E-27,60289E-22,58281E-26,41160E-27,90250E06,04619E-17,61461E-22,18935E18,94332E-38,94578E-37,60395E-28,60398E16,04805E-1
1.0Jarnac2,58281E-28,60398E14,76435E13,01317E15,48510E26,34736E-27,60289E-22,58281E-26,41160E-27,90250E06,04619E-17,61461E-22,18935E18,94332E-38,94578E-37,60395E-28,60398E16,04805E-1
1.0MathSBML2,58281E-28,60398E14,76435E13,01317E15,48510E26,34736E-27,60289E-22,58281E-26,41160E-27,90250E06,04619E-17,61461E-22,18935E18,94332E-38,94578E-37,60395E-28,60398E16,04805E-1
1.0Oscill8 Core2,58283E-28,60398E1-3,01316E1-6,34732E-27,60285E-22,58283E-26,41156E-27,90249E06,04619E-17,61471E-22,18937E18,94332E-3-7,60391E-28,60398E16,04805E-1
1.0SBToolbox22,58562E-28,60402E14,76479E13,01343E15,48507E26,35145E-27,60739E-22,58562E-26,41574E-27,90260E06,04539E-17,60731E-22,18861E18,94180E-38,94420E-37,60849E-28,60402E16,04728E-1
1.0SBWOdeSolver2,58283E-28,60398E14,76434E13,01316E15,48511E26,34732E-27,60285E-22,58283E-26,41156E-27,90249E06,04619E-17,61471E-22,18937E18,94332E-38,94578E-37,60391E-28,60398E16,04805E-1
1.0VCell2,58281E-28,60398E14,76435E13,01317E15,48510E26,34736E-27,60289E-22,58281E-26,41160E-27,90250E06,04619E-17,61461E-22,18935E18,94332E-38,94578E-37,60395E-28,60398E16,04805E-1
1.0copasi2,58281E-28,60398E14,76435E13,01317E15,48510E26,34735E-27,60288E-22,58281E-26,41160E-27,90250E06,04619E-17,61461E-22,18935E18,94332E-38,94578E-37,60394E-28,60398E16,04805E-1
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner2,58281E-28,60398E14,76435E13,01317E15,48510E26,34736E-27,60289E-22,58281E-26,41161E-27,90250E06,04619E-17,61461E-22,18935E18,94332E-38,94578E-37,60395E-28,60398E16,04805E-1
1.0jsim2,58281E-28,60398E14,76435E13,01317E15,48510E26,34736E-27,60289E-22,58281E-26,41160E-27,90250E06,04619E-17,61461E-22,18935E18,94332E-38,94578E-37,60395E-28,60398E16,04805E-1
1.0min 2,58281E-2 8,60398E1 4,76434E1 3,01316E1 5,48507E2 6,34732E-2 7,60285E-2 2,58281E-2 6,41156E-2 7,90249E0 6,04539E-1 7,60731E-2 2,18861E1 8,94180E-3 8,94420E-3 7,60391E-2 8,60398E1 6,04728E-1
1.0max 2,58562E-2 8,60402E1 4,76479E1 3,01343E1 5,48511E2 6,35145E-2 7,60739E-2 2,58562E-2 6,41574E-2 7,90260E0 6,04619E-1 7,61471E-2 2,18937E1 8,94332E-3 8,94578E-3 7,60849E-2 8,60402E1 6,04805E-1
1.0mean 2,58281E-2 8,60398E1 4,76435E1 3,01317E1 5,48510E2 6,34736E-2 7,60289E-2 2,58281E-2 6,41160E-2 7,90250E0 6,04619E-1 7,61461E-2 2,18935E1 8,94332E-3 8,94578E-3 7,60395E-2 8,60398E1 6,04805E-1
1.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.2BioUML3,56931E-28,60038E15,01294E13,19568E15,43940E26,93822E-28,62275E-23,56931E-27,02165E-27,97049E07,22712E-11,14847E-11,75304E11,09072E-21,09114E-28,62448E-28,60038E17,23018E-1
1.2ByoDyn3,56931E-28,60038E15,01294E13,19568E15,43940E26,93822E-28,62275E-23,56931E-27,02165E-27,97049E07,22712E-11,14847E-11,75304E11,09072E-21,09114E-28,62448E-28,60038E17,23018E-1
1.2Jarnac3,56931E-28,60038E15,01294E13,19568E15,43940E26,93822E-28,62275E-23,56931E-27,02165E-27,97049E07,22712E-11,14847E-11,75304E11,09072E-21,09114E-28,62448E-28,60038E17,23018E-1
1.2MathSBML3,56931E-28,60038E15,01294E13,19568E15,43940E26,93822E-28,62275E-23,56931E-27,02165E-27,97049E07,22712E-11,14847E-11,75304E11,09072E-21,09114E-28,62448E-28,60038E17,23018E-1
1.2Oscill8 Core3,56932E-28,60038E1-3,19567E1-6,93818E-28,62271E-23,56932E-27,02162E-27,97049E07,22712E-11,14848E-11,75305E11,09072E-2-8,62444E-28,60038E17,23018E-1
1.2SBToolbox23,57290E-28,60041E15,01346E13,19596E15,43933E26,94275E-28,62791E-23,57290E-27,02624E-27,97055E07,22623E-11,14750E-11,75220E11,09052E-21,09101E-28,62961E-28,60041E17,22932E-1
1.2SBWOdeSolver3,56932E-28,60038E15,01293E13,19567E15,43940E26,93819E-28,62271E-23,56932E-27,02162E-27,97049E07,22712E-11,14848E-11,75305E11,09072E-21,09114E-28,62444E-28,60038E17,23018E-1
1.2VCell3,56931E-28,60038E15,01294E13,19568E15,43940E26,93822E-28,62275E-23,56931E-27,02165E-27,97049E07,22712E-11,14847E-11,75304E11,09072E-21,09114E-28,62448E-28,60038E17,23018E-1
1.2copasi3,56931E-28,60038E15,01294E13,19568E15,43940E26,93821E-28,62274E-23,56931E-27,02164E-27,97049E07,22713E-11,14847E-11,75303E11,09072E-21,09114E-28,62447E-28,60038E17,23019E-1
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner3,56931E-28,60038E15,01294E13,19568E15,43940E26,93822E-28,62276E-23,56931E-27,02166E-27,97049E07,22712E-11,14847E-11,75304E11,09072E-21,09114E-28,62448E-28,60038E17,23018E-1
1.2jsim3,56931E-28,60038E15,01294E13,19568E15,43940E26,93822E-28,62275E-23,56931E-27,02165E-27,97049E07,22712E-11,14847E-11,75304E11,09072E-21,09114E-28,62448E-28,60038E17,23018E-1
1.2min 3,56931E-2 8,60038E1 5,01293E1 3,19567E1 5,43933E2 6,93818E-2 8,62271E-2 3,56931E-2 7,02162E-2 7,97049E0 7,22623E-1 1,14750E-1 1,75220E1 1,09052E-2 1,09101E-2 8,62444E-2 8,60038E1 7,22932E-1
1.2max 3,57290E-2 8,60041E1 5,01346E1 3,19596E1 5,43940E2 6,94275E-2 8,62791E-2 3,57290E-2 7,02624E-2 7,97055E0 7,22713E-1 1,14848E-1 1,75305E1 1,09072E-2 1,09114E-2 8,62961E-2 8,60041E1 7,23019E-1
1.2mean 3,56931E-2 8,60038E1 5,01294E1 3,19568E1 5,43940E2 6,93822E-2 8,62275E-2 3,56931E-2 7,02165E-2 7,97049E0 7,22712E-1 1,14847E-1 1,75304E1 1,09072E-2 1,09114E-2 8,62448E-2 8,60038E1 7,23018E-1
1.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.4BioUML4,64171E-28,59770E15,18126E13,32997E15,40638E27,28008E-29,37433E-24,64171E-27,38039E-28,02023E08,39770E-11,63226E-11,44608E11,28628E-21,28693E-29,37683E-28,59770E18,40222E-1
1.4ByoDyn4,64171E-28,59770E15,18126E13,32997E15,40638E27,28008E-29,37433E-24,64171E-27,38039E-28,02023E08,39770E-11,63226E-11,44608E11,28628E-21,28693E-29,37683E-28,59770E18,40222E-1
1.4Jarnac4,64171E-28,59770E15,18126E13,32997E15,40638E27,28008E-29,37433E-24,64171E-27,38039E-28,02023E08,39770E-11,63226E-11,44608E11,28628E-21,28693E-29,37683E-28,59770E18,40222E-1
1.4MathSBML4,64171E-28,59770E15,18126E13,32997E15,40638E27,28008E-29,37433E-24,64171E-27,38039E-28,02023E08,39770E-11,63226E-11,44608E11,28628E-21,28693E-29,37683E-28,59770E18,40222E-1
1.4Oscill8 Core4,64172E-28,59770E1-3,32996E1-7,28005E-29,37430E-24,64172E-27,38036E-28,02023E08,39770E-11,63228E-11,44609E11,28628E-2-9,37680E-28,59770E18,40222E-1
1.4SBToolbox24,64622E-28,59771E15,18173E13,33029E15,40630E27,28456E-29,37971E-24,64622E-27,38495E-28,02031E08,39685E-11,63098E-11,44531E11,28613E-21,28674E-29,38228E-28,59771E18,40135E-1
1.4SBWOdeSolver4,64172E-28,59770E15,18125E13,32996E15,40638E27,28005E-29,37430E-24,64172E-27,38036E-28,02023E08,39770E-11,63227E-11,44609E11,28628E-21,28693E-29,37680E-28,59770E18,40222E-1
1.4VCell4,64171E-28,59770E15,18126E13,32997E15,40638E27,28008E-29,37433E-24,64171E-27,38039E-28,02023E08,39770E-11,63226E-11,44608E11,28628E-21,28693E-29,37683E-28,59770E18,40222E-1
1.4copasi4,64171E-28,59770E15,18126E13,32997E15,40638E27,28007E-29,37432E-24,64171E-27,38038E-28,02023E08,39770E-11,63226E-11,44608E11,28628E-21,28693E-29,37681E-28,59770E18,40222E-1
1.4edu.kgi.roadRunner4,64171E-28,59770E15,18126E13,32997E15,40638E27,28008E-29,37433E-24,64171E-27,38039E-28,02023E08,39770E-11,63226E-11,44608E11,28628E-21,28693E-29,37683E-28,59770E18,40222E-1
1.4jsim4,64171E-28,59770E15,18126E13,32997E15,40638E27,28008E-29,37433E-24,64171E-27,38039E-28,02023E08,39770E-11,63226E-11,44608E11,28628E-21,28693E-29,37683E-28,59770E18,40222E-1
1.4min 4,64171E-2 8,59770E1 5,18125E1 3,32996E1 5,40630E2 7,28005E-2 9,37430E-2 4,64171E-2 7,38036E-2 8,02023E0 8,39685E-1 1,63098E-1 1,44531E1 1,28613E-2 1,28674E-2 9,37680E-2 8,59770E1 8,40135E-1
1.4max 4,64622E-2 8,59771E1 5,18173E1 3,33029E1 5,40638E2 7,28456E-2 9,37971E-2 4,64622E-2 7,38495E-2 8,02031E0 8,39770E-1 1,63228E-1 1,44609E1 1,28628E-2 1,28693E-2 9,38228E-2 8,59771E1 8,40222E-1
1.4mean 4,64171E-2 8,59770E1 5,18126E1 3,32997E1 5,40638E2 7,28008E-2 9,37433E-2 4,64171E-2 7,38039E-2 8,02023E0 8,39770E-1 1,63226E-1 1,44608E1 1,28628E-2 1,28693E-2 9,37683E-2 8,59770E1 8,40222E-1
1.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.6BioUML5,78916E-28,59567E15,29375E13,43053E15,38218E27,45250E-29,92322E-25,78916E-27,56686E-28,05694E09,54659E-12,21357E-11,22928E11,47883E-21,47974E-29,92655E-28,59567E19,55278E-1
1.6ByoDyn5,78916E-28,59567E15,29375E13,43053E15,38218E27,45250E-29,92322E-25,78916E-27,56686E-28,05694E09,54659E-12,21357E-11,22928E11,47883E-21,47974E-29,92655E-28,59567E19,55278E-1
1.6Jarnac5,78916E-28,59567E15,29375E13,43053E15,38218E27,45250E-29,92322E-25,78916E-27,56686E-28,05694E09,54659E-12,21357E-11,22928E11,47883E-21,47974E-29,92655E-28,59567E19,55278E-1
1.6MathSBML5,78916E-28,59567E15,29375E13,43053E15,38218E27,45250E-29,92322E-25,78916E-27,56686E-28,05694E09,54659E-12,21357E-11,22928E11,47883E-21,47974E-29,92655E-28,59567E19,55278