Test: BIOMD0000000032.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000032.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: Imex
generated code: BIOMD0000000032.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 1 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-10
ATOL 1.0E-7
RTOL 1.0E-6
STEP 1.0E-4

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000032.gif

Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL6618819961.JPG

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: Ste11  Ste12  Gabc  Sst2  Cdc28  Bar1aex  alpha  Ste2a  Gbc  Ste12a  Bar1a  Fus3PP  Ste2  Bar1  Ste20  Fus3  Far1U  Far1  complexG  complexF  complexE  complexD  GaGDP  complexC  complexB  complexA  complexN  Ste5  complexM  Far1PP  complexL  Ste7  complexK  complexI  complexH  GaGTP 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  SBToolbox2  VCell  Oscill8 Core  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  jsim  BioUML 
timeresult Ste11 Ste12 Gabc Sst2 Cdc28 Bar1aex alpha Ste2a Gbc Ste12a Bar1a Fus3PP Ste2 Bar1 Ste20 Fus3 Far1U Far1 complexG complexF complexE complexD GaGDP complexC complexB complexA complexN Ste5 complexM Far1PP complexL Ste7 complexK complexI complexH GaGTP
0.0BioUML1,58332E22,00000E21,66667E30,00000E03,00000E20,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,66667E32,00000E21,00000E36,86400E20,00000E05,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E02,35725E27,78754E11,05943E20,00000E01,58332E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E03,63997E10,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0ByoDyn1,58332E22,00000E21,66667E30,00000E03,00000E20,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,66667E32,00000E21,00000E36,86400E20,00000E05,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E02,35725E27,78754E11,05943E20,00000E01,58332E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E03,63997E10,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0MathSBML1,58332E22,00000E21,66667E30,00000E03,00000E20,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,66667E32,00000E21,00000E36,86400E20,00000E05,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E02,35725E27,78754E11,05943E20,00000E01,58332E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E03,63997E10,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0Oscill8 Core--1,66667E30,00000E0--1,00000E20,00000E00,00000E0-0,00000E00,00000E01,66667E32,00000E2-6,86400E2-5,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E02,35725E27,78754E1-0,00000E01,58332E2-0,00000E00,00000E0-0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0-
0.0SBToolbox21,58330E22,00000E21,66670E30,00000E03,00000E20,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,66670E32,00000E21,00000E36,86400E20,00000E05,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E02,35720E27,78750E11,05940E20,00000E01,58330E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E03,64000E10,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0SBWOdeSolver1,58332E22,00000E21,66667E30,00000E03,00000E20,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,66667E32,00000E21,00000E36,86400E20,00000E05,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E02,35725E27,78754E11,05943E20,00000E01,58332E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E03,63997E10,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0VCell1,58332E22,00000E21,66667E30,00000E03,00000E20,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,66667E32,00000E21,00000E36,86400E20,00000E05,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E02,35725E27,78754E11,05943E20,00000E01,58332E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E03,63997E10,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0copasi1,58332E22,00000E21,66667E30,00000E03,00000E20,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,66667E32,00000E21,00000E36,86400E20,00000E05,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E02,35725E27,78754E11,05943E20,00000E01,58332E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E03,63997E10,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner1,58332E22,00000E21,66667E30,00000E03,00000E20,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E02,84217E-140,00000E00,00000E01,66667E32,00000E21,00000E36,86400E20,00000E05,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E02,35725E27,78754E11,05943E20,00000E01,58332E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E03,63997E10,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0jsim1,58332E22,00000E21,66667E30,00000E03,00000E20,00000E01,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,66667E32,00000E21,00000E36,86400E20,00000E05,00000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E02,35725E27,78754E11,05943E20,00000E01,58332E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E03,63997E10,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0min 1,58330E2 2,00000E2 1,66667E3 0,00000E0 3,00000E2 0,00000E0 1,00000E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,66667E3 2,00000E2 1,00000E3 6,86400E2 0,00000E0 5,00000E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 2,35720E2 7,78750E1 1,05940E2 0,00000E0 1,58330E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 3,63997E1 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0max 1,58332E2 2,00000E2 1,66670E3 0,00000E0 3,00000E2 0,00000E0 1,00000E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 2,84217E-14 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,66670E3 2,00000E2 1,00000E3 6,86400E2 0,00000E0 5,00000E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 2,35725E2 7,78754E1 1,05943E2 0,00000E0 1,58332E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 3,64000E1 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0mean 1,58332E2 2,00000E2 1,66667E3 0,00000E0 3,00000E2 0,00000E0 1,00000E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,66667E3 2,00000E2 1,00000E3 6,86400E2 0,00000E0 5,00000E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 2,35725E2 7,78754E1 1,05943E2 0,00000E0 1,58332E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 3,63997E1 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML1,52739E21,91405E21,64468E31,92325E-33,00000E21,52921E-39,99999E13,62975E18,80695E08,59538E05,52301E08,64643E-21,62158E31,94475E29,86858E26,75693E23,49382E21,50618E21,74190E-11,33641E08,33592E04,25081E-22,99645E-42,29269E27,32044E11,04808E21,83804E-51,52739E24,70469E-72,82628E-53,22799E-23,43429E18,07905E-11,55761E08,97203E-12,19907E1
0.2ByoDyn1,52740E21,91420E21,64468E31,90808E-33,00000E21,52289E-39,99999E13,62981E18,80660E08,58045E05,50792E08,63514E-21,62158E31,94491E29,86862E26,75708E23,49403E21,50597E21,74167E-11,33625E08,33528E04,25072E-22,99638E-42,29271E27,32053E11,04808E21,82482E-51,52740E24,65888E-72,81156E-53,22511E-23,43425E18,07192E-11,55632E08,97032E-12,19873E1
0.2MathSBML1,52740E21,91420E21,64468E31,90808E-33,00000E21,52289E-39,99999E13,62981E18,80660E08,58045E05,50792E08,63514E-21,62158E31,94491E29,86862E26,75708E23,49403E21,50597E21,74167E-11,33625E08,33528E04,25072E-22,99638E-42,29271E27,32053E11,04808E21,82482E-51,52740E24,65891E-72,81156E-53,22511E-23,43425E18,07192E-11,55632E08,97032E-12,19873E1
0.2Oscill8 Core--1,64468E31,91230E-3--9,99999E13,62980E18,80672E0-5,51050E08,63816E-21,62158E31,94488E2-6,75704E2-1,50602E21,74174E-11,33630E08,33547E04,25076E-22,99634E-42,29270E27,32051E1-1,82839E-51,52740E2-2,81556E-53,22589E-2-8,07380E-11,55666E08,97079E-1-
0.2SBToolbox21,52737E21,91409E21,64464E31,91065E-33,00000E21,53242E-31,00000E23,62980E18,80643E08,59323E05,52658E08,64023E-21,62154E31,94470E29,86859E26,75700E23,49404E21,50596E21,74167E-11,33627E08,33520E04,25074E-22,99707E-42,29272E27,32051E11,04810E21,83399E-51,52737E24,67562E-72,81384E-53,22628E-23,43431E18,07543E-11,55697E08,97005E-12,19879E1
0.2SBWOdeSolver1,52740E21,91416E21,64468E31,91238E-33,00000E21,52465E-39,99999E13,62980E18,80669E08,58441E05,51200E08,63825E-21,62158E31,94486E29,86861E26,75704E23,49398E21,50602E21,74173E-11,33629E08,33544E04,25074E-22,99636E-42,29271E27,32051E11,04808E21,82851E-51,52740E24,67192E-72,81565E-53,22587E-23,43426E18,07377E-11,55665E08,97075E-12,19882E1
0.2VCell1,52740E21,91420E21,64468E31,90808E-33,00000E21,52289E-39,99999E13,62981E18,80660E08,58045E05,50792E08,63514E-21,62158E31,94491E29,86862E26,75708E23,49403E21,50597E21,74167E-11,33625E08,33528E04,25072E-22,99638E-42,29271E27,32053E11,04808E21,82483E-51,52740E24,65891E-72,81156E-53,22511E-23,43425E18,07192E-11,55632E08,97032E-12,19873E1
0.2copasi1,52740E21,91420E21,64468E31,90808E-33,00000E21,52289E-39,99999E13,62981E18,80660E08,58045E05,50792E08,63514E-21,62158E31,94491E29,86862E26,75708E23,49403E21,50597E21,74167E-11,33625E08,33528E04,25072E-22,99638E-42,29271E27,32053E11,04808E21,82482E-51,52740E24,65888E-72,81156E-53,22511E-23,43425E18,07192E-11,55632E08,97032E-12,19873E1
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner1,52740E21,91420E21,64468E31,90809E-33,00000E21,52289E-39,99999E13,62981E18,80660E08,58045E05,50792E08,63514E-21,62158E31,94491E29,86862E26,75708E23,49403E21,50597E21,74167E-11,33625E08,33528E04,25072E-22,99638E-42,29271E27,32053E11,04808E21,82483E-51,52740E24,65894E-72,81157E-53,22511E-23,43425E18,07192E-11,55632E08,97032E-12,19873E1
0.2jsim1,52740E21,91420E21,64468E31,90808E-33,00000E21,52289E-39,99999E13,62981E18,80660E08,58045E05,50792E08,63514E-21,62158E31,94491E29,86862E26,75708E23,49403E21,50597E21,74167E-11,33625E08,33528E04,25072E-22,99431E-42,29271E27,32053E11,04808E21,82482E-51,52740E24,65888E-72,81156E-53,22511E-23,43425E18,07192E-11,55632E08,97032E-12,19873E1
0.2min 1,52737E2 1,91409E2 1,64464E3 1,90808E-3 3,00000E2 1,52289E-3 9,99999E1 3,62980E1 8,80643E0 8,58045E0 5,50792E0 8,63514E-2 1,62154E3 1,94470E2 9,86859E2 6,75700E2 3,49398E2 1,50596E2 1,74167E-1 1,33625E0 8,33520E0 4,25072E-2 2,99431E-4 2,29270E2 7,32051E1 1,04808E2 1,82482E-5 1,52737E2 4,65888E-7 2,81156E-5 3,22511E-2 3,43425E1 8,07192E-1 1,55632E0 8,97005E-1 2,19873E1
0.2max 1,52740E2 1,91420E2 1,64468E3 1,91238E-3 3,00000E2 1,53242E-3 1,00000E2 3,62981E1 8,80672E0 8,59323E0 5,52658E0 8,64023E-2 1,62158E3 1,94491E2 9,86862E2 6,75708E2 3,49404E2 1,50602E2 1,74174E-1 1,33630E0 8,33547E0 4,25076E-2 2,99707E-4 2,29272E2 7,32053E1 1,04810E2 1,83399E-5 1,52740E2 4,67562E-7 2,81565E-5 3,22628E-2 3,43431E1 8,07543E-1 1,55697E0 8,97079E-1 2,19882E1
0.2mean 1,52740E2 1,91420E2 1,64468E3 1,90808E-3 3,00000E2 1,52289E-3 9,99999E1 3,62981E1 8,80660E0 8,58045E0 5,50792E0 8,63514E-2 1,62158E3 1,94491E2 9,86862E2 6,75708E2 3,49403E2 1,50597E2 1,74167E-1 1,33625E0 8,33528E0 4,25072E-2 2,99638E-4 2,29271E2 7,32053E1 1,04808E2 1,82483E-5 1,52740E2 4,65891E-7 2,81156E-5 3,22511E-2 3,43425E1 8,07192E-1 1,55632E0 8,97032E-1 2,19873E1
0.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML1,41226E21,80196E11,58718E34,70039E02,99973E21,26635E-19,99770E16,60452E12,27551E11,81980E21,52271E29,18180E01,58167E34,76023E19,43370E24,98650E24,54632E24,52820E15,88472E-14,42445E02,44754E19,84791E-26,89852E-41,93694E26,01891E11,08351E22,72873E-21,41226E21,91891E-35,67554E-24,23672E-13,93885E18,18148E01,50779E13,45847E07,94847E1
0.4ByoDyn1,41226E21,80143E11,58718E34,70004E02,99973E21,26634E-19,99770E16,60452E12,27551E11,81986E21,52272E29,17786E01,58167E34,76010E19,43370E24,98649E24,54632E24,52819E15,88472E-14,42446E02,44754E19,84793E-26,89830E-41,93694E26,01891E11,08351E22,72682E-21,41226E21,91740E-35,66874E-24,23668E-13,93886E18,18145E01,50779E13,45848E07,94847E1
0.4MathSBML1,41226E21,80143E11,58718E34,70004E02,99973E21,26634E-19,99770E16,60452E12,27551E11,81986E21,52272E29,17786E01,58167E34,76010E19,43370E24,98649E24,54632E24,52819E15,88472E-14,42446E02,44754E19,84793E-26,89830E-41,93694E26,01891E11,08351E22,72682E-21,41226E21,91740E-35,66874E-24,23668E-13,93886E18,18145E01,50779E13,45848E07,94847E1
0.4Oscill8 Core--1,58718E34,70422E0--9,99770E16,60451E12,27548E1-1,52251E29,24355E01,58167E34,76219E1-4,98676E2-4,52832E15,88466E-14,42440E02,44750E19,84767E-26,90121E-41,93694E26,01896E1-2,76730E-21,41226E2-5,81144E-24,23719E-1-8,18189E01,50787E13,45845E0-
0.4SBToolbox21,41223E21,80571E11,58714E34,70783E02,99970E21,26737E-19,99771E16,60451E12,27547E11,81948E21,52283E29,22937E01,58168E34,75915E19,43369E24,98639E24,54629E24,52806E15,88459E-14,42437E02,44744E19,84758E-26,90317E-41,93697E26,01886E11,08348E22,74936E-21,41223E21,93482E-35,74060E-24,23740E-13,93899E18,18186E01,50787E13,45844E07,94849E1
0.4SBWOdeSolver1,41226E21,81083E11,58718E34,70420E02,99972E21,26650E-19,99770E16,60449E12,27547E11,81892E21,52252E29,24345E01,58167E34,76214E19,43370E24,98676E24,54629E24,52832E15,88463E-14,42439E02,44749E19,84763E-26,90120E-41,93694E26,01896E11,08351E22,76728E-21,41226E21,94950E-35,81135E-24,23718E-13,93876E18,18186E01,50786E13,45844E07,94848E1
0.4VCell1,41226E21,80143E11,58718E34,70004E02,99973E21,26634E-19,99770E16,60452E12,27551E11,81986E21,52272E29,17786E01,58167E34,76010E19,43370E24,98649E24,54632E24,52819E15,88472E-14,42446E02,44754E19,84793E-26,89830E-41,93694E26,01891E11,08351E22,72682E-21,41226E21,91740E-35,66875E-24,23668E-13,93886E18,18145E01,50779E13,45848E07,94847E1
0.4copasi1,41226E21,80143E11,58718E34,70004E02,99973E21,26634E-19,99770E16,60452E12,27551E11,81986E21,52272E29,17785E01,58167E34,76010E19,43370E24,98649E24,54632E24,52818E15,88472E-14,42446E02,44754E19,84793E-26,89830E-41,93694E26,01891E11,08351E22,72683E-21,41226E21,91741E-35,66875E-24,23668E-13,93886E18,18145E01,50779E13,45848E07,94847E1
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner1,41226E21,80144E11,58718E34,70004E02,99973E21,26634E-19,99770E16,60452E12,27551E11,81986E21,52272E29,17790E01,58167E34,76010E19,43370E24,98649E24,54632E24,52818E15,88472E-14,42446E02,44754E19,84793E-26,89828E-41,93694E26,01891E11,08351E22,72689E-21,41226E21,91745E-35,66896E-24,23668E-13,93886E18,18145E01,50779E13,45848E07,94847E1
0.4jsim1,41226E21,80143E11,58718E34,70004E02,99973E21,26634E-19,99770E16,60452E12,27551E11,81986E21,52272E29,17786E01,58167E34,76010E19,43370E24,98649E24,54632E24,52819E15,88472E-14,42446E02,44754E19,84793E-26,89694E-41,93694E26,01891E11,08351E22,72682E-21,41226E21,91740E-35,66874E-24,23668E-13,93886E18,18145E01,50779E13,45848E07,94847E1
0.4min 1,41223E2 1,80143E1 1,58714E3 4,70004E0 2,99970E2 1,26634E-1 9,99770E1 6,60449E1 2,27547E1 1,81892E2 1,52251E2 9,17785E0 1,58167E3 4,75915E1 9,43369E2 4,98639E2 4,54629E2 4,52806E1 5,88459E-1 4,42437E0 2,44744E1 9,84758E-2 6,89694E-4 1,93694E2 6,01886E1 1,08348E2 2,72682E-2 1,41223E2 1,91740E-3 5,66874E-2 4,23668E-1 3,93876E1 8,18145E0 1,50779E1 3,45844E0 7,94847E1
0.4max 1,41226E2 1,81083E1 1,58718E3 4,70783E0 2,99973E2 1,26737E-1 9,99771E1 6,60452E1 2,27551E1 1,81986E2 1,52283E2 9,24355E0 1,58168E3 4,76219E1 9,43370E2 4,98676E2 4,54632E2 4,52832E1 5,88472E-1 4,42446E0 2,44754E1 9,84793E-2 6,90317E-4 1,93697E2 6,01896E1 1,08351E2 2,76730E-2 1,41226E2 1,94950E-3 5,81144E-2 4,23740E-1 3,93899E1 8,18189E0 1,50787E1 3,45848E0 7,94849E1
0.4mean 1,41226E2 1,80143E1 1,58718E3 4,70004E0 2,99973E2 1,26634E-1 9,99770E1 6,60452E1 2,27551E1 1,81986E2 1,52272E2 9,17786E0 1,58167E3 4,76010E1 9,43370E2 4,98649E2 4,54632E2 4,52819E1 5,88472E-1 4,42446E0 2,44754E1 9,84793E-2 6,89830E-4 1,93694E2 6,01891E1 1,08351E2 2,72683E-2 1,41226E2 1,91741E-3 5,66875E-2 4,23668E-1 3,93886E1 8,18145E0 1,50779E1 3,45848E0 7,94847E1
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML1,25763E21,00516E01,52289E33,97222E12,87493E25,00674E-19,97927E19,03289E13,13575E11,98995E21,97618E21,10203E21,54610E31,88085E08,88922E23,82964E24,79494E24,80242E08,16550E-16,08437E03,17490E11,14140E-13,55505E-31,51826E24,63728E11,11219E21,25073E11,25763E21,22853E01,96758E01,55337E04,06090E12,33593E14,24325E15,08322E01,43775E2
0.6ByoDyn1,25763E21,00513E01,52289E33,97224E12,87492E25,00674E-19,97927E19,03290E13,13579E11,98995E21,97619E21,10203E21,54610E31,88041E08,88921E23,82965E24,79495E24,80119E08,16562E-16,08445E03,17494E11,14141E-13,55503E-31,51825E24,63728E11,11219E21,25080E11,25763E21,22860E01,96754E01,55335E04,06089E12,33592E14,24325E15,08330E01,43776E2
0.6MathSBML1,25763E21,00513E01,52289E33,97224E12,87492E25,00674E-19,97927E19,03290E13,13579E11,98995E21,97619E21,10203E21,54610E31,88041E08,88921E23,82965E24,79495E24,80119E08,16562E-16,08445E03,17494E11,14141E-13,55503E-31,51825E24,63728E11,11219E21,25080E11,25763E21,22860E01,96754E01,55335E04,06089E12,33592E14,24325E15,08330E01,43776E2
0.6Oscill8 Core--1,52289E33,97220E1--9,97927E19,03289E13,13573E1-1,97618E21,10204E21,54611E31,88135E0-3,82964E2-4,80380E08,16540E-16,08430E03,17486E11,14139E-13,55510E-31,51826E24,63728E1-1,25066E11,25763E2-1,96762E01,55341E0-2,33594E14,24327E15,08315E0-
0.6SBToolbox21,25764E21,00510E01,52287E33,97236E12,87495E25,00775E-19,97928E19,03291E13,13572E11,98998E21,97620E21,10205E21,54610E31,87907E08,88920E23,82966E24,79493E24,79984E08,16543E-16,08437E03,17486E11,14142E-13,55512E-31,51822E24,63731E11,11215E21,25088E11,25764E21,22867E01,96803E01,55334E04,06093E12,33587E14,24321E15,08317E01,43775E2
0.6SBWOdeSolver1,25763E21,00521E01,52289E33,97220E12,87493E25,00674E-19,97927E19,03287E13,13572E11,98995E21,97618E21,10203E21,54610E31,88131E08,88922E23,82964E24,79494E24,80381E08,16537E-16,08428E03,17485E11,14138E-13,55511E-31,51826E24,63729E11,11219E21,25065E11,25763E21,22845E01,96762E01,55340E04,06091E12,33593E14,24325E15,08314E01,43774E2
0.6VCell1,25763E21,00513E01,52289E33,97224E12,87492E25,00674E-19,97927E19,03290E13,13579E11,98995E21,97619E21,10203E21,54610E31,88041E08,88921E23,82965E24,79495E24,80119E08,16562E-16,08445E03,17494E11,14141E-13,55503E-31,51825E24,63728E11,11219E21,25080E11,25763E21,22860E01,96754E01,55335E04,06089E12,33592E14,24325E15,08330E01,43776E2
0.6copasi1,25763E21,00514E01,52289E33,97224E12,87492E25,00674E-19,97927E19,03290E13,13579E11,98995E21,97619E21,10203E21,54610E31,88041E08,88921E23,82965E24,79495E24,80119E08,16562E-16,08445E03,17494E11,14141E-13,55503E-31,51825E24,63728E11,11219E21,25079E11,25763E21,22860E01,96754E01,55335E04,06089E12,33592E14,24325E15,08330E01,43776E2
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner1,25763E21,00512E01,52289E33,97224E12,87492E25,00674E-19,97927E19,03290E13,13579E11,98995E21,97619E21,10203E21,54610E31,88039E08,88921E23,82965E24,79495E24,80119E08,16561E-16,08445E03,17494E11,14141E-13,55503E-31,51825E24,63728E11,11219E21,25079E11,25763E21,22860E01,96755E01,55335E04,06089E12,33592E14,24325E15,08330E01,43776E2
0.6jsim1,25763E21,00513E01,52289E33,97224E12,87492E25,00674E-19,97927E19,03290E13,13579E11,98995E21,97619E21,10203E21,54610E31,88041E08,88921E23,82965E24,79495E24,80119E08,16562E-16,08445E03,17494E11,14141E-13,55492E-31,51825E24,63728E11,11219E21,25080E11,25763E21,22860E01,96754E01,55335E04,06089E12,33592E14,24325E15,08330E01,43776E2
0.6min 1,25763E2 1,00510E0 1,52287E3 3,97220E1 2,87492E2 5,00674E-1 9,97927E1 9,03287E1 3,13572E1 1,98995E2 1,97618E2 1,10203E2 1,54610E3 1,87907E0 8,88920E2 3,82964E2 4,79493E2 4,79984E0 8,16537E-1 6,08428E0 3,17485E1 1,14138E-1 3,55492E-3 1,51822E2 4,63728E1 1,11215E2 1,25065E1 1,25763E2 1,22845E0 1,96754E0 1,55334E0 4,06089E1 2,33587E1 4,24321E1 5,08314E0 1,43774E2
0.6max 1,25764E2 1,00521E0 1,52289E3 3,97236E1 2,87495E2 5,00775E-1 9,97928E1 9,03291E1 3,13579E1 1,98998E2 1,97620E2 1,10205E2 1,54611E3 1,88135E0 8,88922E2 3,82966E2 4,79495E2 4,80381E0 8,16562E-1 6,08445E0 3,17494E1 1,14142E-1 3,55512E-3 1,51826E2 4,63731E1 1,11219E2 1,25088E1 1,25764E2 1,22867E0 1,96803E0 1,55341E0 4,06093E1 2,33594E1 4,24327E1 5,08330E0 1,43776E2
0.6mean 1,25763E2 1,00513E0 1,52289E3 3,97224E1 2,87492E2 5,00674E-1 9,97927E1 9,03290E1 3,13579E1 1,98995E2 1,97619E2 1,10203E2 1,54610E3 1,88041E0 8,88921E2 3,82965E2 4,79495E2 4,80119E0 8,16562E-1 6,08445E0 3,17494E1 1,14141E-1 3,55503E-3 1,51825E2 4,63728E1 1,11219E2 1,25080E1 1,25763E2 1,22860E0 1,96754E0 1,55335E0 4,06089E1 2,33592E1 4,24325E1 5,08330E0 1,43776E2
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML1,12645E25,74370E-11,48297E36,87488E12,83107E28,96851E-19,93752E11,10013E22,98301E11,99426E21,98093E21,93005E21,51425E31,01037E08,47939E23,01934E24,81106E21,47300E-17,14588E-15,29992E02,68013E19,12969E-27,72389E-31,20871E23,59367E11,14331E21,68927E11,12645E21,71518E01,38910E-13,32530E04,10395E13,97093E17,16209E14,58990E01,83690E2
0.8ByoDyn1,12644E25,74352E-11,48297E36,87493E12,83107E28,96851E-19,93752E11,10013E22,98309E11,99426E21,98093E21,93007E21,51425E31,01034E08,47937E23,01932E24,81106E21,47096E-17,14601E-15,30002E02,68017E19,12981E-27,72369E-31,20870E23,59363E11,14331E21,68930E11,12644E21,71521E01,38772E-13,32531E04,10393E13,97098E17,16219E14,59000E01,83693E2
0.8MathSBML1,12644E25,74352E-11,48297E36,87493E12,83107E28,96851E-19,93752E11,10013E22,98309E11,99426E21,98093E21,93007E21,51425E31,01034E08,47937E23,01932E24,81106E21,47096E-17,14601E-15,30002E02,68017E19,12981E-27,72369E-31,20870E23,59363E11,14331E21,68930E11,12644E21,71521E01,38772E-13,32531E04,10393E13,97098E17,16219E14,59000E01,83693E2
0.8Oscill8 Core--1,48297E36,87489E1--9,93752E11,10013E22,98304E1-1,98093E21,93006E21,51425E31,01036E0-3,01934E2-1,47274E-17,14591E-15,29995E02,68014E19,12975E-27,72397E-31,20871E23,59366E1-1,68928E11,12645E2-1,38892E-13,32535E0-3,97094E17,16213E14,58993E0-
0.8SBToolbox21,12645E25,74313E-11,48300E36,87506E12,83103E28,96955E-19,93751E11,10010E22,98317E11,99429E21,98092E21,93007E21,51422E31,01020E08,47937E23,01939E24,81109E21,46358E-17,14616E-15,30009E02,68021E19,12997E-27,72276E-31,20868E23,59365E11,14334E21,68947E11,12645E21,71536E01,38313E-13,32493E04,10392E13,97092E17,16204E14,59005E01,83696E2
0.8SBWOdeSolver1,12645E25,74374E-11,48297E36,87489E12,83107E28,96851E-19,93752E11,10013E22,98302E11,99426E21,98093E21,93005E21,51425E31,01036E08,47939E23,01934E24,81106E21,47267E-17,14590E-15,29994E02,68013E19,12972E-27,72399E-31,20871E23,59367E11,14331E21,68927E11,12645E21,71518E01,38886E-13,32533E04,10395E13,97093E17,16210E14,58992E01,83690E2
0.8VCell1,12644E25,74352E-11,48297E36,87493E12,83107E28,96851E-19,93752E11,10013E22,98309E11,99426E21,98093E21,93007E21,51425E31,01034E08,47937E23,01932E24,81106E21,47096E-17,14601E-15,30002E02,68017E19,12981E-27,72369E-31,20870E23,59363E11,14331E21,68930E11,12644E21,71521E01,38772E-13,32531E04,10393E13,97098E17,16219E14,59000E01,83693E2
0.8copasi1,12644E25,74351E-11,48297E36,87493E12,83107E28,96851E-19,93752E11,10013E22,98309E11,99426E21,98093E21,93007E21,51425E31,01034E08,47937E23,01932E24,81106E21,47096E-17,14601E-15,30002E02,68017E19,12981E-27,72369E-31,20870E23,59363E11,14331E21,68930E11,12644E21,71521E01,38772E-13,32531E04,10393E13,97098E17,16219E14,59000E01,83693E2
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner1,12644E25,73992E-11,48297E36,87493E12,83107E28,96851E-19,93752E11,10013E22,98309E11,99426E21,98093E21,93007E21,51425E31,01034E08,47937E23,01932E24,81106E21,47096E-17,14601E-15,30002E02,68017E19,12981E-27,72369E-31,20870E23,59363E11,14331E21,68930E11,12644E21,71521E01,38771E-13,32531E04,10393E13,97098E17,16219E14,59000E01,83693E2
0.8jsim