Test: BIOMD0000000035.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000035.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: DormandPrince
generated code: BIOMD0000000035.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-100
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000035.gif

Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL6619651140.png

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: DAp  A  C  R  DR  DA  DRp  MR  MA 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  Jarnac  SBToolbox2  Oscill8 Core  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  jsim  BioUML 
timeresult DAp A C R DR DA DRp MR MA
0.0BioUML0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0ByoDyn0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0Jarnac0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0MathSBML0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0Oscill8 Core-0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E0-0,00000E00,00000E0
0.0SBToolbox20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0SBWOdeSolver0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0copasi0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0jsim0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0min 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E0 1,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0max 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E0 1,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0mean 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E0 1,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML4,67900E-15,05048E12,05709E-15,12831E-26,83471E-15,32100E-13,16529E-11,03703E01,39212E1
0.2ByoDyn4,67900E-15,05048E12,05709E-15,12831E-26,83471E-15,32100E-13,16529E-11,03703E01,39212E1
0.2Jarnac4,67900E-15,05048E12,05709E-15,12831E-26,83471E-15,32100E-13,16529E-11,03703E01,39212E1
0.2MathSBML4,67900E-15,05048E12,05709E-15,12831E-26,83471E-15,32100E-13,16529E-11,03703E01,39212E1
0.2Oscill8 Core-5,05101E12,05789E-15,12796E-26,83470E-15,32113E-1-1,03716E01,39215E1
0.2SBToolbox24,68243E-15,05322E12,06059E-15,13351E-26,83241E-15,31757E-13,16759E-11,03796E01,39281E1
0.2SBWOdeSolver4,67887E-15,05101E12,05789E-15,12796E-26,83470E-15,32113E-13,16530E-11,03716E01,39215E1
0.2copasi4,67900E-15,05048E12,05709E-15,12831E-26,83471E-15,32100E-13,16529E-11,03703E01,39212E1
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner4,67900E-15,05048E12,05709E-15,12831E-26,83471E-15,32100E-13,16529E-11,03703E01,39212E1
0.2jsim4,67900E-15,05048E12,05709E-15,12831E-26,83471E-15,32100E-13,16529E-11,03703E01,39212E1
0.2min 4,67887E-1 5,05048E1 2,05709E-1 5,12796E-2 6,83241E-1 5,31757E-1 3,16529E-1 1,03703E0 1,39212E1
0.2max 4,68243E-1 5,05322E1 2,06059E-1 5,13351E-2 6,83471E-1 5,32113E-1 3,16759E-1 1,03796E0 1,39281E1
0.2mean 4,67900E-1 5,05048E1 2,05709E-1 5,12831E-2 6,83471E-1 5,32100E-1 3,16529E-1 1,03703E0 1,39212E1
0.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML8,43605E-12,74365E23,54520E06,35873E-22,70011E-11,56395E-17,29989E-16,27584E03,57085E1
0.4ByoDyn8,43605E-12,74365E23,54520E06,35873E-22,70011E-11,56395E-17,29989E-16,27584E03,57085E1
0.4Jarnac8,43605E-12,74365E23,54520E06,35873E-22,70011E-11,56395E-17,29989E-16,27584E03,57085E1
0.4MathSBML8,43605E-12,74365E23,54520E06,35873E-22,70011E-11,56395E-17,29989E-16,27584E03,57085E1
0.4Oscill8 Core-2,74368E23,54552E06,35872E-22,70025E-11,56406E-1-6,27591E03,57077E1
0.4SBToolbox28,43688E-12,74454E23,54796E06,35962E-22,69896E-11,56312E-17,30104E-16,27842E03,57153E1
0.4SBWOdeSolver8,43594E-12,74368E23,54552E06,35871E-22,70025E-11,56406E-17,29975E-16,27591E03,57077E1
0.4copasi8,43605E-12,74364E23,54520E06,35873E-22,70012E-11,56395E-17,29988E-16,27582E03,57085E1
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner8,43605E-12,74365E23,54520E06,35873E-22,70011E-11,56395E-17,29989E-16,27584E03,57085E1
0.4jsim8,43605E-12,74365E23,54520E06,35873E-22,70011E-11,56395E-17,29989E-16,27584E03,57085E1
0.4min 8,43594E-1 2,74364E2 3,54520E0 6,35871E-2 2,69896E-1 1,56312E-1 7,29975E-1 6,27582E0 3,57077E1
0.4max 8,43688E-1 2,74454E2 3,54796E0 6,35962E-2 2,70025E-1 1,56406E-1 7,30104E-1 6,27842E0 3,57153E1
0.4mean 8,43605E-1 2,74365E2 3,54520E0 6,35873E-2 2,70011E-1 1,56395E-1 7,29989E-1 6,27584E0 3,57085E1
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML9,20980E-15,85207E21,33036E16,83077E-21,46427E-17,90200E-28,53573E-11,33377E14,42479E1
0.6ByoDyn9,20980E-15,85207E21,33036E16,83077E-21,46427E-17,90200E-28,53573E-11,33377E14,42479E1
0.6Jarnac9,20980E-15,85207E21,33036E16,83077E-21,46427E-17,90200E-28,53573E-11,33377E14,42479E1
0.6MathSBML9,20980E-15,85207E21,33036E16,83077E-21,46427E-17,90200E-28,53573E-11,33377E14,42479E1
0.6Oscill8 Core-5,85205E21,33041E16,83079E-21,46432E-17,90229E-2-1,33377E14,42476E1
0.6SBToolbox29,21001E-15,85310E21,33095E16,83151E-21,46384E-17,89961E-28,53616E-11,33404E14,42505E1
0.6SBWOdeSolver9,20977E-15,85205E21,33041E16,83078E-21,46432E-17,90229E-28,53568E-11,33377E14,42476E1
0.6copasi9,20980E-15,85205E21,33036E16,83076E-21,46428E-17,90202E-28,53572E-11,33376E14,42479E1
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner9,20980E-15,85207E21,33036E16,83077E-21,46427E-17,90200E-28,53573E-11,33377E14,42479E1
0.6jsim9,20980E-15,85207E21,33036E16,83076E-21,46427E-17,90200E-28,53573E-11,33377E14,42479E1
0.6min 9,20977E-1 5,85205E2 1,33036E1 6,83076E-2 1,46384E-1 7,89961E-2 8,53568E-1 1,33376E1 4,42476E1
0.6max 9,21001E-1 5,85310E2 1,33095E1 6,83151E-2 1,46432E-1 7,90229E-2 8,53616E-1 1,33404E1 4,42505E1
0.6mean 9,20980E-1 5,85207E2 1,33036E1 6,83077E-2 1,46427E-1 7,90200E-2 8,53573E-1 1,33377E1 4,42479E1
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML9,45869E-18,75135E23,02019E17,55927E-21,02695E-15,41309E-28,97305E-12,04326E14,68482E1
0.8ByoDyn9,45869E-18,75135E23,02019E17,55927E-21,02695E-15,41309E-28,97305E-12,04326E14,68482E1
0.8Jarnac9,45869E-18,75135E23,02019E17,55927E-21,02695E-15,41309E-28,97305E-12,04326E14,68482E1
0.8MathSBML9,45869E-18,75135E23,02019E17,55927E-21,02695E-15,41310E-28,97305E-12,04326E14,68482E1
0.8Oscill8 Core-8,75130E23,02026E17,55929E-21,02697E-15,41320E-2-2,04325E14,68481E1
0.8SBToolbox29,45877E-18,75227E23,02109E17,56016E-21,02674E-15,41186E-28,97326E-12,04353E14,68492E1
0.8SBWOdeSolver9,45868E-18,75130E23,02026E17,55929E-21,02697E-15,41321E-28,97303E-12,04325E14,68481E1
0.8copasi9,45869E-18,75134E23,02019E17,55927E-21,02695E-15,41310E-28,97305E-12,04325E14,68482E1
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner9,45869E-18,75135E23,02019E17,55927E-21,02695E-15,41309E-28,97305E-12,04326E14,68482E1
0.8jsim9,45869E-18,75135E23,02019E17,55927E-21,02695E-15,41310E-28,97305E-12,04326E14,68482E1
0.8min 9,45868E-1 8,75130E2 3,02019E1 7,55927E-2 1,02674E-1 5,41186E-2 8,97303E-1 2,04325E1 4,68481E1
0.8max 9,45877E-1 8,75227E2 3,02109E1 7,56016E-2 1,02697E-1 5,41321E-2 8,97326E-1 2,04353E1 4,68492E1
0.8mean 9,45869E-1 8,75135E2 3,02019E1 7,55927E-2 1,02695E-1 5,41310E-2 8,97305E-1 2,04326E1 4,68482E1
0.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.0BioUML9,57112E-11,11676E35,40131E18,49015E-28,22457E-24,28879E-29,17754E-12,71368E14,77768E1
1.0ByoDyn9,57112E-11,11676E35,40131E18,49015E-28,22457E-24,28879E-29,17754E-12,71368E14,77768E1
1.0Jarnac9,57112E-11,11676E35,40131E18,49015E-28,22457E-24,28879E-29,17754E-12,71368E14,77768E1
1.0MathSBML9,57112E-11,11676E35,40131E18,49015E-28,22457E-24,28879E-29,17754E-12,71368E14,77768E1
1.0Oscill8 Core-1,11675E35,40138E18,49017E-28,22467E-24,28884E-2-2,71367E14,77767E1
1.0SBToolbox29,57120E-11,11681E35,40240E18,49126E-28,22328E-24,28802E-29,17766E-12,71396E14,77780E1
1.0SBWOdeSolver9,57112E-11,11675E35,40138E18,49016E-28,22467E-24,28884E-29,17753E-12,71367E14,77767E1
1.0copasi9,57112E-11,11676E35,40130E18,49015E-28,22458E-24,28879E-29,17754E-12,71368E14,77768E1
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner9,57112E-11,11676E35,40131E18,49015E-28,22457E-24,28879E-29,17754E-12,71368E14,77768E1
1.0jsim9,57112E-11,11676E35,40131E18,49015E-28,22457E-24,28879E-29,17754E-12,71368E14,77768E1
1.0min 9,57112E-1 1,11675E3 5,40130E1 8,49015E-2 8,22328E-2 4,28802E-2 9,17753E-1 2,71367E1 4,77767E1
1.0max 9,57120E-1 1,11681E3 5,40240E1 8,49126E-2 8,22467E-2 4,28884E-2 9,17766E-1 2,71396E1 4,77780E1
1.0mean 9,57112E-1 1,11676E3 5,40131E1 8,49015E-2 8,22457E-2 4,28879E-2 9,17754E-1 2,71368E1 4,77768E1
1.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.2BioUML9,63203E-11,30945E38,42831E19,58199E-27,09801E-23,67965E-29,29020E-13,33474E14,81959E1
1.2ByoDyn9,63203E-11,30945E38,42831E19,58199E-27,09801E-23,67965E-29,29020E-13,33474E14,81959E1
1.2Jarnac9,63203E-11,30945E38,42831E19,58199E-27,09801E-23,67965E-29,29020E-13,33474E14,81959E1
1.2MathSBML9,63203E-11,30945E38,42831E19,58199E-27,09801E-23,67965E-29,29020E-13,33474E14,81959E1
1.2Oscill8 Core-1,30944E38,42839E19,58201E-27,09807E-23,67969E-2-3,33473E14,81959E1
1.2SBToolbox29,63212E-11,30948E38,42956E19,58372E-27,09678E-23,67898E-29,29028E-13,33501E14,81962E1
1.2SBWOdeSolver9,63203E-11,30944E38,42839E19,58200E-27,09807E-23,67968E-29,29019E-13,33473E14,81959E1
1.2copasi9,63203E-11,30945E38,42830E19,58198E-27,09801E-23,67966E-29,29020E-13,33474E14,81959E1
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner9,63203E-11,30945E38,42831E19,58199E-27,09801E-23,67965E-29,29020E-13,33474E14,81959E1
1.2jsim9,63203E-11,30945E38,42831E19,58198E-27,09801E-23,67965E-29,29020E-13,33474E14,81959E1
1.2min 9,63203E-1 1,30944E3 8,42830E1 9,58198E-2 7,09678E-2 3,67898E-2 9,29019E-1 3,33473E1 4,81959E1
1.2max 9,63212E-1 1,30948E3 8,42956E1 9,58372E-2 7,09807E-2 3,67969E-2 9,29028E-1 3,33501E1 4,81962E1
1.2mean 9,63203E-1 1,30945E3 8,42831E1 9,58199E-2 7,09801E-2 3,67965E-2 9,29020E-1 3,33474E1 4,81959E1
1.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.4BioUML9,66846E-11,45855E31,20507E21,08214E-16,41793E-23,31539E-29,35821E-13,90503E14,84224E1
1.4ByoDyn9,66846E-11,45855E31,20507E21,08214E-16,41793E-23,31539E-29,35821E-13,90503E14,84224E1
1.4Jarnac9,66846E-11,45855E31,20507E21,08214E-16,41793E-23,31539E-29,35821E-13,90503E14,84224E1
1.4MathSBML9,66846E-11,45855E31,20507E21,08214E-16,41793E-23,31538E-29,35821E-13,90503E14,84224E1
1.4Oscill8 Core-1,45854E31,20508E21,08214E-16,41797E-23,31540E-2-3,90502E14,84223E1
1.4SBToolbox29,66850E-11,45859E31,20518E21,08229E-16,41724E-23,31500E-29,35824E-13,90526E14,84227E1
1.4SBWOdeSolver9,66846E-11,45854E31,20508E21,08214E-16,41797E-23,31540E-29,35820E-13,90502E14,84223E1
1.4copasi9,66846E-11,45855E31,20507E21,08214E-16,41793E-23,31538E-29,35821E-13,90503E14,84224E1
1.4edu.kgi.roadRunner9,66846E-11,45855E31,20507E21,08214E-16,41793E-23,31539E-29,35821E-13,90503E14,84224E1
1.4jsim9,66846E-11,45855E31,20507E21,08214E-16,41793E-23,31538E-29,35821E-13,90503E14,84224E1
1.4min 9,66846E-1 1,45854E3 1,20507E2 1,08214E-1 6,41724E-2 3,31500E-2 9,35820E-1 3,90502E1 4,84223E1
1.4max 9,66850E-1 1,45859E3 1,20518E2 1,08229E-1 6,41797E-2 3,31540E-2 9,35824E-1 3,90526E1 4,84227E1
1.4mean 9,66846E-1 1,45855E3 1,20507E2 1,08214E-1 6,41793E-2 3,31539E-2 9,35821E-1 3,90503E1 4,84224E1
1.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.6BioUML9,69134E-11,57019E31,62185E21,22086E-15,98836E-23,08662E-29,40116E-14,42621E14,85580E1
1.6ByoDyn9,69134E-11,57019E31,62185E21,22086E-15,98836E-23,08662E-29,40116E-14,42621E14,85580E1
1.6Jarnac9,69134E-11,57019E31,62185E21,22086E-15,98836E-23,08662E-29,40116E-14,42621E14,85580E1
1.6MathSBML9,69134E-11,57019E31,62185E21,22086E-15,98836E-23,08662E-29,40116E-14,42621E14,85580E1
1.6Oscill8 Core-1,57018E31,62186E21,22087E-15,98839E-23,08663E-2-4,42620E14,85580E1
1.6SBToolbox29,69136E-11,57023E31,62196E21,22103E-15,98765E-23,08626E-29,40123E-14,42642E14,85582E1
1.6SBWOdeSolver9,69134E-11,57019E31,62186E21,22087E-15,98838E-23,08663E-29,40116E-14,42621E14,85580E1
1.6copasi9,69134E-11,57019E31,62185E21,22086E-15,98836E-23,08662E-29,40116E-14,42621E14,85580E1
1.6edu.kgi.roadRunner9,69134E-11,57019E31,62185E21,22086E-15,98836E-23,08662E-29,40116E-14,42621E14,85580E1
1.6jsim9,69134E-11,57019E31,62185E21,22086E-15,98836E-23,08662E-29,40116E-14,42621E14,85580E1
1.6min 9,69134E-1 1,57018E3 1,62185E2 1,22086E-1 5,98765E-2 3,08626E-2 9,40116E-1 4,42620E1 4,85580E1
1.6max 9,69136E-1 1,57023E3 1,62196E2 1,22103E-1 5,98839E-2 3,08663E-2 9,40123E-1 4,42642E1 4,85582E1
1.6mean 9,69134E-1 1,57019E3 1,62185E2 1,22086E-1 5,98836E-2 3,08662E-2 9,40116E-1 4,42621E1 4,85580E1
1.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.8BioUML9,70586E-11,65004E32,08838E21,37507E-15,71478E-22,94145E-29,42852E-14,90108E14,86429E1
1.8ByoDyn9,70586E-11,65004E32,08838E21,37507E-15,71478E-22,94145E-29,42852E-14,90108E14,86429E1
1.8Jarnac9,70586E-11,65004E32,08838E21,37507E-15,71478E-22,94145E-29,42852E-14,90108E14,86429E1
1.8MathSBML9,70586E-11,65004E32,08838E21,37507E-15,71478E-22,94145E-29,42852E-14,90108E14,86429E1
1.8Oscill8 Core-1,65003E32,08839E21,37507E-15,71479E-22,94146E-2-4,90107E14,86429E1
1.8SBToolbox29,70589E-11,65011E32,08851E21,37524E-15,71426E-22,94114E-29,42860E-14,90131E14,86433E1
1.8SBWOdeSolver9,70585E-11,65003E32,08839E21,37507E-15,71479E-22,94145E-29,42852E-14,90107E14,86429E1
1.8copasi9,70586E-11,65004E32,08838E21,37507E-15,71478E-22,94145E-29,42852E-14,90107E14,86429E1
1.8edu.kgi.roadRunner9,70586E-11,65004E32,08838E21,37507E-15,71478E-22,94145E-29,42852E-14,90108E14,86429E1
1.8jsim9,70586E-11,65004E32,08838E21,37507E-15,71478E-22,94145E-29,42852E-14,90108E14,86429E1
1.8min 9,70585E-1 1,65003E3 2,08838E2 1,37507E-1 5,71426E-2 2,94114E-2 9,42852E-1 4,90107E1 4,86429E1
1.8max 9,70589E-1 1,65011E3 2,08851E2 1,37524E-1 5,71479E-2 2,94146E-2 9,42860E-1 4,90131E1 4,86433E1
1.8mean 9,70586E-1 1,65004E3 2,08838E2 1,37507E-1 5,71478E-2 2,94145E-2 9,42852E-1 4,90108E1 4,86429E1
1.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.0BioUML9,71476E-11,70304E32,60019E21,54588E-15,54654E-22,85238E-29,44535E-15,33281E14,86960E1
2.0ByoDyn9,71476E-11,70304E32,60019E21,54588E-15,54654E-22,85238E-29,44535E-15,33281E14,86960E1
2.0Jarnac9,71476E-11,70304E32,60019E21,54588E-15,54654E-22,85238E-29,44535E-15,33281E14,86960E1
2.0MathSBML9,71476E-11,70304E32,60019E21,54588E-15,54654E-22,85238E-29,44535E-15,33281E14,86960E1
2.0Oscill8 Core-1,70303E32,60020E21,54589E-15,54656E-22,85239E-2-5,33281E14,86960E1
2.0SBToolbox29,71474E-11,70310E32,60036E21,54602E-15,54618E-22,85218E-29,44538E-15,33306E14,86964E1
2.0SBWOdeSolver9,71476E-11,70304E32,60020E21,54588E-15,54655E-22,85238E-29,44535E-15,33281E14,86960E1
2.0copasi9,71476E-11,70304E32,60019E21,54588E-15,54654E-22,85238E-29,44535E-15,33281E14,86960E1
2.0edu.kgi.roadRunner9,71476E-11,70304E32,60019E21,54588E-15,54654E-22,85238E-29,44535E-15,33281E14,86960E1
2.0jsim9,71476E-11,70304E32,60019E21,54588E-15,54654E-22,85238E-29,44535E-15,33281E14,86960E1
2.0min 9,71474E-1 1,70303E3 2,60019E2 1,54588E-1 5,54618E-2 2,85218E-2 9,44535E-1 5,33281E1 4,86960E1
2.0max 9,71476E-1 1,70310E3 2,60036E2 1,54602E-1 5,54656E-2 2,85239E-2 9,44538E-1 5,33306E1 4,86964E1
2.0mean 9,71476E-1 1,70304E3 2,60019E2 1,54588E-1 5,54654E-2 2,85238E-2 9,44535E-1 5,33281E1 4,86960E1
2.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.2BioUML9,71963E-11,73342E33,15313E21,73476E-15,45447E-22,80370E-29,45455E-15,72468E14,87271E1
2.2ByoDyn9,71963E-11,73342E33,15313E21,73476E-15,45447E-22,80370E-29,45455E-15,72468E14,87271E1
2.2Jarnac9,71963E-11,73342E33,15313E21,73476E-15,45447E-22,80370E-29,45455E-15,72468E14,87271E1
2.2MathSBML9,71963E-11,73342E33,15313E21,73476E-15,45447E-22,80370E-29,45455E-15,72468E14,87271E1
2.2Oscill8 Core-1,73341E33,15314E21,73477E-15,45448E-22,80371E-2-5,72467E14,87271E1
2.2SBToolbox29,71966E-11,73348E33,15329E21,73484E-15,45416E-22,80355E-29,45463E-15,72489E14,87276E1
2.2SBWOdeSolver9,71963E-11,73341E33,15314E21,73476E-15,45447E-22,80370E-29,45455E-15,72468E14,87271E1
2.2copasi9,71963E-11,73342E33,15313E21,73476E-15,45447E-22,80370E-29,45455E-15,72468E14,87271E1
2.2edu.kgi.roadRunner9,71963E-11,73342E33,15313E21,73476E-15,45447E-22,80370E-29,45455E-15,72468E14,87271E1
2.2jsim9,71963E-11,73342E33,15313E21,73476E-15,45447E-22,80370E-29,45455E-15,72468E14,87271E1
2.2min 9,71963E-1 1,73341E3 3,15313E2 1,73476E-1 5,45416E-2 2,80355E-2 9,45455E-1 5,72467E1 4,87271E1
2.2max 9,71966E-1 1,73348E3 3,15329E2 1,73484E-1 5,45448E-2 2,80371E-2 9,45463E-1 5,72489E1 4,87276E1
2.2mean 9,71963E-1 1,73342E3 3,15313E2 1,73476E-1 5,45447E-2 2,80370E-2 9,45455E-1 5,72468E1 4,87271E1
2.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.4BioUML9,72141E-11,74474E33,74337E21,94350E-15,42085E-22,78593E-29,45792E-16,07984E14,87422E1
2.4ByoDyn9,72141E-11,74474E33,74337E21,94350E-15,42085E-22,78593E-29,45792E-16,07984E14,87422E1
2.4Jarnac9,72141E-11,74474E33,74337E21,94350E-15,42085E-22,78593E-29,45792E-16,07984E14,87422E1
2.4MathSBML9,72141E-11,74474E33,74337E21,94350E-15,42085E-22,78593E-29,45792E-16,07984E14,87422E1
2.4Oscill8 Core-1,74473E33,74338E21,94351E-15,42086E-22,78594E-2-6,07983E14,87422E1
2.4SBToolbox29,72140E-11,74485E33,74350E21,94356E-15,42052E-22,78575E-29,45798E-16,08004E14,87420E1
2.4SBWOdeSolver9,72141E-11,74474E33,74337E21,94350E-15,42085E-22,78594E-29,45792E-16,07983E14,87422E1
2.4copasi9,72141E-11,74474E33,74337E21,94350E-15,42085E-22,78594E-29,45792E-16,07984E14,87422E1
2.4edu.kgi.roadRunner9,72141E-11,74474E33,74337E21,94350E-15,42085E-22,78593E-29,45792E-16,07984E14,87422E1
2.4jsim9,72141E-11,74474E33,74337E21,94350E-15,42085E-22,78594E-29,45792E-16,07984E14,87422E1
2.4min 9,72140E-1 1,74473E3 3,74337E2 1,94350E-1 5,42052E-2 2,78575E-2 9,45792E-1 6,07983E1 4,87420E1
2.4max 9,72141E-1 1,74485E3 3,74350E2 1,94356E-1 5,42086E-2 2,78594E-2 9,45798E-1 6,08004E1 4,87422E1
2.4mean 9,72141E-1 1,74474E3 3,74337E2 1,94350E-1 5,42085E-2 2,78593E-2 9,45792E-1 6,07984E1 4,87422E1
2.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.6BioUML9,72068E-11,74001E34,36738E22,17424E-15,43467E-22,79323E-29,45653E-16,40128E14,87446E1
2.6ByoDyn9,72068E-11,74001E34,36738E22,17424E-15,43467E-22,79323E-29,45653E-16,40128E14,87446E1
2.6Jarnac9,72068E-11,74001E34,36738E22,17424E-15,43467E-22,79323E-29,45653E-16,40128E14,87446E1
2.6MathSBML9,72068E-11,74001E34,36738E22,17424E-15,43467E-22,79323E-29,45653E-16,40128E14,87446E1
2.6Oscill8 Core-1,74000E34,36739E22,17424E-15,43468E-22,79324E-2-6,40128E14,87446E1
2.6SBToolbox29,72073E-11,74016E34,36741E22,17383E-15,43416E-22,79297E-29,45655E-16,40162E14,87450E1
2.6SBWOdeSolver9,72068E-11,74001E34,36738E22,17424E-15,43467E-22,79323E-29,45653E-16,40128E14,87446E1
2.6copasi9,72068E-11,74001E34,36738E22,17424E-15,43467E-22,79323E-29,45653E-16,40128E14,87446E1
2.6edu.kgi.roadRunner9,72068E-11,74001E34,36738E22,17424E-15,43467E-22,79323E-29,45653E-16,40128E14,87446E1
2.6jsim9,72068E-11,74001E34,36738E22,17424E-15,43467E-22,79323E-29,45653E-16,40128E14,87446E1
2.6min 9,72068E-1 1,74000E3 4,36738E2 2,17383E-1 5,43416E-2 2,79297E-2 9,45653E-1 6,40128E1 4,87446E1
2.6max 9,72073E-1 1,74016E3 4,36741E2 2,17424E-1 5,43468E-2 2,79324E-2 9,45655E-1 6,40162E1 4,87450E1
2.6mean 9,72068E-1 1,74001E3 4,36738E2 2,17424E-1 5,43467E-2 2,79323E-2 9,45653E-1 6,40128E1 4,87446E1
2.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.8BioUML9,71780E-11,72174E35,02193E22,42952E-15,48906E-22,82198E-29,45109E-16,69181E14,87365E1
2.8ByoDyn9,71780E-11,72174E35,02193E22,42952E-15,48906E-22,82198E-29,45109E-16,69181E14,87365E1
2.8Jarnac9,71780E-11,72174E35,02193E22,42952E-15,48906E-22,82198E-29,45109E-16,69181E14,87365E1
2.8MathSBML9,71780E-11,72174E35,02193E22,42952E-15,48906E-22,82198E-29,45109E-16,69181E14,87365E1
2.8Oscill8 Core-1,72174E35,02194E22,42953E-15,48907E-22,82198E-2-6,69180E14,87365E1
2.8SBToolbox29,71786E-11,72194E35,02185E22,42912E-15,48836E-22,82157E-29,45118E-16,69221E14,87370E1
2.8SBWOdeSolver9,71780E-11,72174E35,02194E22,42953E-15,48906E-22,82198E-29,45109E-16,69180E14,87365E1
2.8copasi9,71780E-11,72174E35,02193E22,42952E-15,48906E-22,82198E-29,45109E-16,69180E14,87365E1
2.8edu.kgi.roadRunner9,71780E-11,72174E35,02193E22,42952E-15,48906E-22,82198E-29,45109E-16,69181E14,87365E1
2.8jsim9,71780E-11,72174E35,02193E22,42952E-15,48906E-22,82198E-29,45109E-16,69181E14,87365E1
2.8min 9,71780E-1 1,72174E3 5,02185E2 2,42912E-1 5,48836E-2 2,82157E-2 9,45109E-1 6,69180E1 4,87365E1
2.8max 9,71786E-1 1,72194E3 5,02194E2 2,42953E-1 5,48907E-2 2,82198E-2 9,45118E-1 6,69221E1 4,87370E1
2.8mean 9,71780E-1 1,72174E3 5,02193E2 2,42952E-1 5,48906E-2 2,82198E-2 9,45109E-1 6,69181E1 4,87365E1
2.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.0BioUML9,71300E-11,69204E35,70406E22,71241E-15,57992E-22,87003E-29,44201E-16,95399E14,87193E1
3.0ByoDyn9,71300E-11,69204E35,70406E22,71241E-15,57992E-22,87003E-29,44201E-16,95399E14,87193E1
3.0Jarnac9,71300E-11,69204E35,70406E22,71241E-15,57992E-22,87003E-29,44201E-16,95399E14,87193E1
3.0MathSBML9,71300E-11,69204E35,70406E22,71241E-15,57992E-22,87003E-29,44201E-16,95399E14,87193E1
3.0Oscill8 Core-1,69204E35,70407E22,71241E-15,57993E-22,87003E-2-6,95398E14,87193E1
3.0SBToolbox29,71306E-11,69231E35,70396E22,71136E-15,57898E-22,86953E-29,44208E-16,95445E14,87193E1
3.0SBWOdeSolver9,71300E-11,69204E35,70407E22,71241E-15,57992E-22,87003E-29,44201E-16,95398E14,87193E1
3.0copasi9,71300E-11,69204E35,70406E22,71241E-15,57992E-22,87003E-29,44201E-16,95398E14,87193E1
3.0edu.kgi.roadRunner9,71300E-11,69204E35,70406E22,71241E-15,57992E-22,87003E-29,44201E-16,95399E14,87193E1
3.0jsim9,71300E-11,69204E35,70406E22,71240E-15,57992E-22,87003E-29,44201E-16,95399E14,87193E1
3.0min 9,71300E-1 1,69204E3 5,70396E2 2,71136E-1 5,57898E-2 2,86953E-2 9,44201E-1 6,95398E1 4,87193E1
3.0max 9,71306E-1 1,69231E3 5,70407E2 2,71241E-1 5,57993E-2 2,87003E-2 9,44208E-1 6,95445E1 4,87193E1
3.0mean 9,71300E-1 1,69204E3 5,70406E2 2,71241E-1 5,57992E-2 2,87003E-2 9,44201E-1 6,95399E1 4,87193E1
3.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.2BioUML9,70637E-11,65269E36,41105E23,02655E-15,70512E-22,93632E-29,42949E-17,19018E14,86936E1
3.2ByoDyn9,70637E-11,65269E36,41105E23,02655E-15,70512E-22,93632E-29,42949E-17,19018E14,86936E1
3.2Jarnac9,70637E-11,65269E36,41105E23,02655E-15,70512E-22,93632E-29,42949E-17,19018E14,86936E1
3.2MathSBML9,70637E-11,65269E36,41105E23,02655E-15,70512E-22,93632E-29,42949E-17,19018E14,86936E1
3.2Oscill8 Core-1,65268E36,41106E23,02656E-15,70513E-22,93632E-2-7,19018E14,86936E1
3.2SBToolbox29,70643E-11,65290E36,41091E23,02552E-15,70413E-22,93578E-29,42962E-17,19062E14,86936E1
3.2SBWOdeSolver9,70637E-11,65269E36,41105E23,02656E-15,70512E-22,93632E-29,42949E-17,19018E14,86936E1
3.2copasi9,70637E-11,65269E36,41105E23,02655E-15,70512E-22,93632E-29,42949E-17,19018E14,86936E1
3.2edu.kgi.roadRunner9,70637E-11,65269E36,41105E23,02655E-15,70512E-22,93632E-29,42949E-17,19018E14,86936E1
3.2jsim9,70637E-11,65269E36,41105E23,02655E-15,70512E-22,93632E-29,42949E-17,19018E14,86936E1
3.2min 9,70637E-1 1,65268E3 6,41091E2 3,02552E-1 5,70413E-2 2,93578E-2 9,42949E-1 7,19018E1 4,86936E1
3.2max 9,70643E-1 1,65290E3 6,41106E2 3,02656E-1 5,70513E-2 2,93632E-2 9,42962E-1 7,19062E1 4,86936E1
3.2mean 9,70637E-1 1,65269E3 6,41105E2 3,02655E-1 5,70512E-2 2,93632E-2 9,42949E-1 7,19018E1 4,86936E1
3.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.4BioUML9,69794E-11,60514E37,14040E23,37639E-15,86411E-23,02061E-29,41359E-17,40255E14,86597E1
3.4ByoDyn9,69794E-11,60514E37,14040E23,37639E-15,86411E-23,02061E-29,41359E-17,40255E14,86597E1
3.4Jarnac9,69794E-11,60514E37,14040E23,37639E-15,86411E-23,02061E-29,41359E-17,40255E14,86597E1
3.4MathSBML9,69794E-11,60514E37,14040E23,37639E-15,86411E-23,02061E-29,41359E-17,40255E14,86597E1
3.4Oscill8 Core-1,60514E37,14041E23,37640E-15,86412E-23,02062E-2-7,40255E14,86597E1
3.4SBToolbox29,69797E-11,60535E37,14032E23,37544E-15,86321E-23,02010E-29,41371E-17,40300E14,86597E1
3.4SBWOdeSolver9,69794E-11,60514E37,14040E23,37639E-15,86410E-23,02061E-29,41359E-17,40255E14,86597E1
3.4copasi9,69794E-11,60514E37,14040E23,37639E-15,86411E-23,02061E-29,41359E-17,40255E14,86597E1
3.4edu.kgi.roadRunner9,69794E-11,60514E37,14040E23,37639E-15,86411E-23,02061E-29,41359E-17,40255E14,86597E1
3.4jsim9,69794E-11,60514E37,14040E23,37639E-15,86411E-23,02061E-29,41359E-17,40255E14,86597E1
3.4min 9,69794E-1 1,60514E3 7,14032E2 3,37544E-1 5,86321E-2