Test BIOMD0000000042.xml details

Test: BIOMD0000000042.xml - Ok

test	: BIOMD0000000042.xml
model	: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine	: DormandPrince
generated code	: BIOMD0000000042.java
results	: CSV file
plots	: -
comparison	: comparison with other simulators
status	: Ok
simulation time	: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-100
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000042.gif

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
- no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
- small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
- simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: PYR EtOH NADH GAP ATP AMP FBP DPG ACA PEP F6P ADP NAD P GLC
Simulators: ByoDyn copasi edu.kgi.roadRunner Jarnac SBToolbox2 VCell Oscill8 Core SBWOdeSolver MathSBML jsim BioUML

time

result

PYR

EtOH

NADH

GAP

ATP

AMP

FBP

DPG

ACA

PEP

F6P

ADP

NAD

GLC

0.0

BioUML

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

ByoDyn

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

Jarnac

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

MathSBML

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

Oscill8 Core

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

SBToolbox2

4,22700E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16120E-1

1,90920E-3

4,49060E0

2,61150E-3

7,70140E-3

2,99110E-1

7,38330E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08370E-1

3,62060E0

0,00000E0

1,12820E-2

0.0

SBWOdeSolver

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

VCell

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

copasi

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

jsim

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

min

4,22700E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49060E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38330E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

max

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16120E-1

1,90920E-3

4,49064E0

2,61150E-3

7,70140E-3

2,99110E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08370E-1

3,62060E0

0,00000E0

1,12820E-2

0.0

mean

4,22702E-3

3,39810E-1

6,16118E-1

1,90919E-3

4,49064E0

2,61149E-3

7,70135E-3

2,99109E-1

7,38334E-2

2,11250E-3

6,59390E-1

1,08367E-1

3,62057E0

0,00000E0

1,12817E-2

0.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0.2

BioUML

4,50070E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09510E-1

1,96702E-3

4,46668E0

3,64527E-3

8,31882E-3

2,95447E-1

7,05277E-2

2,19183E-3

6,81694E-1

1,31285E-1

3,62719E0

6,67137E-3

8,85412E-2

0.2

ByoDyn

4,50070E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09510E-1

1,96702E-3

4,46668E0

3,64527E-3

8,31882E-3

2,95447E-1

7,05277E-2

2,19183E-3

6,81694E-1

1,31285E-1

3,62719E0

6,67137E-3

8,85412E-2

0.2

Jarnac

4,78980E-3

3,47863E-1

6,10731E-1

4,33157E-3

4,44435E0

4,74526E-3

3,08750E-2

2,96168E-1

7,06388E-2

2,29101E-3

6,57437E-1

1,52522E-1

3,62596E0

6,57424E-3

8,85422E-2

0.2

MathSBML

4,50070E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09510E-1

1,96702E-3

4,46668E0

3,64527E-3

8,31882E-3

2,95447E-1

7,05277E-2

2,19183E-3

6,81694E-1

1,31285E-1

3,62719E0

6,67137E-3

8,85411E-2

0.2

Oscill8 Core

4,50072E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09510E-1

1,96703E-3

4,46668E0

3,64531E-3

8,31891E-3

2,95447E-1

7,05278E-2

2,19183E-3

6,81694E-1

1,31286E-1

3,62719E0

6,67138E-3

8,85408E-2

0.2

SBToolbox2

4,50154E-3

3,47852E-1

6,09506E-1

1,96764E-3

4,46664E0

3,64464E-3

8,31997E-3

2,95444E-1

7,05298E-2

2,19193E-3

6,81716E-1

1,31306E-1

3,62719E0

6,67200E-3

8,85191E-2

0.2

SBWOdeSolver

4,50072E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09510E-1

1,96703E-3

4,46668E0

3,64531E-3

8,31891E-3

2,95447E-1

7,05278E-2

2,19183E-3

6,81694E-1

1,31286E-1

3,62719E0

6,67138E-3

8,85407E-2

0.2

VCell

4,50070E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09510E-1

1,96702E-3

4,46668E0

3,64527E-3

8,31882E-3

2,95447E-1

7,05277E-2

2,19183E-3

6,81694E-1

1,31285E-1

3,62719E0

6,67137E-3

8,85412E-2

0.2

copasi

4,50070E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09510E-1

1,96702E-3

4,46668E0

3,64527E-3

8,31882E-3

2,95447E-1

7,05277E-2

2,19183E-3

6,81694E-1

1,31285E-1

3,62719E0

6,67137E-3

8,85412E-2

0.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

4,47546E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09399E-1

1,76289E-3

4,46849E0

3,56072E-3

6,50742E-3

2,95379E-1

7,05176E-2

2,18348E-3

6,83655E-1

1,29566E-1

3,62730E0

6,67987E-3

8,85411E-2

0.2

jsim

4,50070E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09510E-1

1,96702E-3

4,46668E0

3,64527E-3

8,31882E-3

2,95447E-1

7,05277E-2

2,19183E-3

6,81694E-1

1,31285E-1

3,62719E0

6,67137E-3

8,85412E-2

0.2

min

4,47546E-3

3,47852E-1

6,09399E-1

1,76289E-3

4,44435E0

3,56072E-3

6,50742E-3

2,95379E-1

7,05176E-2

2,18348E-3

6,57437E-1

1,29566E-1

3,62596E0

6,57424E-3

8,85191E-2

0.2

max

4,78980E-3

3,47863E-1

6,10731E-1

4,33157E-3

4,46849E0

4,74526E-3

3,08750E-2

2,96168E-1

7,06388E-2

2,29101E-3

6,83655E-1

1,52522E-1

3,62730E0

6,67987E-3

8,85422E-2

0.2

mean

4,50070E-3

3,47855E-1

6,09510E-1

1,96702E-3

4,46668E0

3,64527E-3

8,31882E-3

2,95447E-1

7,05277E-2

2,19183E-3

6,81694E-1

1,31285E-1

3,62719E0

6,67137E-3

8,85411E-2

0.2

relative error(%)

0,00

0.4

BioUML

5,55894E-3

3,55461E-1

6,03699E-1

2,49791E-3

4,42310E0

6,30685E-3

1,28291E-2

2,90366E-1

6,85143E-2

2,40942E-3

7,19748E-1

1,72205E-1

3,63300E0

1,36531E-2

1,45195E-1

0.4

ByoDyn

5,55894E-3

3,55461E-1

6,03699E-1

2,49791E-3

4,42310E0

6,30685E-3

1,28291E-2

2,90366E-1

6,85143E-2

2,40942E-3

7,19748E-1

1,72205E-1

3,63300E0

1,36531E-2

1,45195E-1

0.4

Jarnac

7,41739E-3

3,55596E-1

6,15192E-1

1,60733E-2

4,31191E0

1,51333E-2

1,27045E-1

2,98316E-1

6,96342E-2

2,97429E-3

5,93657E-1

2,74568E-1

3,62151E0

1,29176E-2

1,45205E-1

0.4

MathSBML

5,55894E-3

3,55461E-1

6,03699E-1

2,49791E-3

4,42310E0

6,30685E-3

1,28291E-2

2,90366E-1

6,85143E-2

2,40942E-3

7,19748E-1

1,72205E-1

3,63300E0

1,36531E-2

1,45195E-1

0.4

Oscill8 Core

5,55897E-3

3,55461E-1

6,03699E-1

2,49799E-3

4,42310E0

6,30695E-3

1,28296E-2

2,90366E-1

6,85144E-2

2,40942E-3

7,19748E-1

1,72206E-1

3,63300E0

1,36531E-2

1,45194E-1

0.4

SBToolbox2

5,55944E-3

3,55465E-1

6,03700E-1

2,49849E-3

4,42310E0

6,30499E-3

1,28233E-2

2,90362E-1

6,85173E-2

2,40960E-3

7,19773E-1

1,72217E-1

3,63299E0

1,36537E-2

1,45167E-1

0.4

SBWOdeSolver

5,55897E-3

3,55461E-1

6,03699E-1

2,49799E-3

4,42310E0

6,30694E-3

1,28297E-2

2,90366E-1

6,85144E-2

2,40942E-3

7,19748E-1

1,72206E-1

3,63300E0

1,36531E-2

1,45194E-1

0.4

VCell

5,55894E-3

3,55461E-1

6,03699E-1

2,49791E-3

4,42310E0

6,30685E-3

1,28291E-2

2,90366E-1

6,85143E-2

2,40942E-3

7,19748E-1

1,72205E-1

3,63300E0

1,36531E-2

1,45195E-1

0.4

copasi

5,55894E-3

3,55461E-1

6,03699E-1

2,49791E-3

4,42310E0

6,30685E-3

1,28291E-2

2,90366E-1

6,85143E-2

2,40942E-3

7,19748E-1

1,72205E-1

3,63300E0

1,36531E-2

1,45195E-1

0.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

5,43194E-3

3,55450E-1

6,02817E-1

1,56158E-3

4,43006E0

5,87400E-3

5,86986E-3

2,89733E-1

6,84292E-2

2,37314E-3

7,27571E-1

1,65680E-1

3,63389E0

1,37047E-2

1,45194E-1

0.4

jsim

5,55894E-3

3,55461E-1

6,03699E-1

2,49791E-3

4,42310E0

6,30685E-3

1,28291E-2

2,90366E-1

6,85143E-2

2,40942E-3

7,19748E-1

1,72205E-1

3,63300E0

1,36531E-2

1,45195E-1

0.4

min

5,43194E-3

3,55450E-1

6,02817E-1

1,56158E-3

4,31191E0

5,87400E-3

5,86986E-3

2,89733E-1

6,84292E-2

2,37314E-3

5,93657E-1

1,65680E-1

3,62151E0

1,29176E-2

1,45167E-1

0.4

max

7,41739E-3

3,55596E-1

6,15192E-1

1,60733E-2

4,43006E0

1,51333E-2

1,27045E-1

2,98316E-1

6,96342E-2

2,97429E-3

7,27571E-1

2,74568E-1

3,63389E0

1,37047E-2

1,45205E-1

0.4

mean

5,55894E-3

3,55461E-1

6,03699E-1

2,49791E-3

4,42310E0

6,30685E-3

1,28291E-2

2,90366E-1

6,85143E-2

2,40942E-3

7,19748E-1

1,72205E-1

3,63300E0

1,36531E-2

1,45195E-1

0.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0.6

BioUML

7,24317E-3

3,62853E-1

6,00057E-1

4,81432E-3

4,36313E0

1,10990E-2

3,01084E-2

2,84792E-1

6,84748E-2

2,68973E-3

7,51526E-1

2,27376E-1

3,63665E0

2,09863E-2

1,92899E-1

0.6

ByoDyn

7,24317E-3

3,62853E-1

6,00057E-1

4,81432E-3

4,36313E0

1,10990E-2

3,01084E-2

2,84792E-1

6,84748E-2

2,68973E-3

7,51526E-1

2,27376E-1

3,63665E0

2,09863E-2

1,92899E-1

0.6

Jarnac

1,39728E-2

3,63721E-1

6,49553E-1

4,34656E-2

4,08336E0

4,85630E-2

3,30600E-1

3,20422E-1

7,38599E-2

4,44122E-3

4,09509E-1

4,69680E-1

3,58716E0

1,79564E-2

1,92947E-1

0.6

MathSBML

7,24317E-3

3,62853E-1

6,00057E-1

4,81433E-3

4,36313E0

1,10990E-2

3,01084E-2

2,84792E-1

6,84748E-2

2,68973E-3

7,51526E-1

2,27376E-1

3,63665E0

2,09863E-2

1,92899E-1

0.6

Oscill8 Core

7,24322E-3

3,62853E-1

6,00057E-1

4,81466E-3

4,36313E0

1,10993E-2

3,01108E-2

2,84793E-1

6,84749E-2

2,68974E-3

7,51523E-1

2,27378E-1

3,63665E0

2,09863E-2

1,92899E-1

0.6

SBToolbox2

7,24395E-3

3,62858E-1

6,00065E-1

4,81433E-3

4,36312E0

1,10938E-2

3,00854E-2

2,84795E-1

6,84789E-2

2,68992E-3

7,51566E-1

2,27374E-1

3,63660E0

2,09876E-2

1,92876E-1

0.6

SBWOdeSolver

7,24322E-3

3,62853E-1

6,00057E-1

4,81467E-3

4,36313E0

1,10994E-2

3,01108E-2

2,84793E-1

6,84749E-2

2,68974E-3

7,51523E-1

2,27378E-1

3,63665E0

2,09863E-2

1,92899E-1

0.6

VCell

7,24317E-3

3,62853E-1

6,00057E-1

4,81432E-3

4,36313E0

1,10990E-2

3,01084E-2

2,84792E-1

6,84748E-2

2,68973E-3

7,51526E-1

2,27376E-1

3,63665E0

2,09863E-2

1,92899E-1

0.6

copasi

7,24317E-3

3,62853E-1

6,00057E-1

4,81433E-3

4,36313E0

1,10990E-2

3,01084E-2

2,84792E-1

6,84748E-2

2,68973E-3

7,51526E-1

2,27376E-1

3,63665E0

2,09863E-2

1,92899E-1

0.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

6,78417E-3

3,62790E-1

5,96280E-1

1,52655E-3

4,38661E0

9,21364E-3

6,39917E-3

2,81968E-1

6,81073E-2

2,56339E-3

7,78594E-1

2,05781E-1

3,64043E0

2,11938E-2

1,92896E-1

0.6

jsim

7,24317E-3

3,62853E-1

6,00057E-1

4,81432E-3

4,36313E0

1,10990E-2

3,01084E-2

2,84792E-1

6,84748E-2

2,68973E-3

7,51526E-1

2,27376E-1

3,63665E0

2,09863E-2

1,92899E-1

0.6

min

6,78417E-3

3,62790E-1

5,96280E-1

1,52655E-3

4,08336E0

9,21364E-3

6,39917E-3

2,81968E-1

6,81073E-2

2,56339E-3

4,09509E-1

2,05781E-1

3,58716E0

1,79564E-2

1,92876E-1

0.6

max

1,39728E-2

3,63721E-1

6,49553E-1

4,34656E-2

4,38661E0

4,85630E-2

3,30600E-1

3,20422E-1

7,38599E-2

4,44122E-3

7,78594E-1

4,69680E-1

3,64043E0

2,11938E-2

1,92947E-1

0.6

mean

7,24317E-3

3,62853E-1

6,00057E-1

4,81433E-3

4,36313E0

1,10990E-2

3,01084E-2

2,84792E-1

6,84748E-2

2,68973E-3

7,51526E-1

2,27376E-1

3,63665E0

2,09863E-2

1,92899E-1

0.6

relative error(%)

0,00

0.8

BioUML

9,72472E-3

3,70353E-1

6,03170E-1

1,21381E-2

4,26824E0

2,10919E-2

8,33668E-2

2,82556E-1

7,08970E-2

3,12833E-3

7,46347E-1

3,12268E-1

3,63355E0

2,84710E-2

2,35258E-1

0.8

ByoDyn

9,72472E-3

3,70353E-1

6,03170E-1

1,21381E-2

4,26824E0

2,10919E-2

8,33668E-2

2,82556E-1

7,08970E-2

3,12833E-3

7,46347E-1

3,12268E-1

3,63355E0

2,84710E-2

2,35258E-1

0.8

Jarnac

2,44300E-2

3,73737E-1

7,21743E-1

6,91040E-2

3,86554E0

9,84084E-2

5,44825E-1

3,67485E-1

8,65542E-2

6,41064E-3

2,02807E-1

6,37655E-1

3,51497E0

2,09661E-2

2,35383E-1

0.8

MathSBML

9,72472E-3

3,70353E-1

6,03170E-1

1,21381E-2

4,26824E0

2,10919E-2

8,33669E-2

2,82556E-1

7,08970E-2

3,12833E-3

7,46347E-1

3,12268E-1

3,63355E0

2,84710E-2

2,35258E-1

0.8

Oscill8 Core

9,72488E-3

3,70353E-1

6,03171E-1

1,21390E-2

4,26824E0

2,10931E-2

8,33738E-2

2,82557E-1

7,08973E-2

3,12837E-3

7,46339E-1

3,12273E-1

3,63355E0

2,84710E-2

2,35258E-1

0.8

SBToolbox2

9,72613E-3

3,70359E-1

6,03193E-1

1,21396E-2

4,26829E0

2,10805E-2

8,33422E-2

2,82574E-1

7,09037E-2

3,12856E-3

7,46381E-1

3,12280E-1

3,63353E0

2,84713E-2

2,35239E-1

0.8

SBWOdeSolver

9,72488E-3

3,70353E-1

6,03171E-1

1,21390E-2

4,26824E0

2,10931E-2

8,33736E-2

2,82557E-1

7,08973E-2

3,12837E-3

7,46339E-1

3,12273E-1

3,63355E0

2,84710E-2

2,35258E-1

0.8

VCell

9,72472E-3

3,70353E-1

6,03170E-1

1,21381E-2

4,26824E0

2,10919E-2

8,33668E-2

2,82556E-1

7,08970E-2

3,12833E-3

7,46347E-1

3,12268E-1

3,63355E0

2,84710E-2

2,35258E-1

0.8

copasi

9,72473E-3

3,70353E-1

6,03170E-1

1,21381E-2

4,26824E0

2,10919E-2

8,33669E-2

2,82556E-1

7,08970E-2

3,12833E-3

7,46347E-1

3,12268E-1

3,63355E0

2,84710E-2

2,35258E-1

0.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

8,24164E-3

3,70096E-1

5,90001E-1

1,90417E-3

4,34006E0

1,35910E-2

9,42189E-3

2,72556E-1

6,96131E-2

2,72713E-3

8,31415E-1

2,47955E-1

3,64672E0

2,91890E-2

2,35246E-1

0.8

jsim

9,72472E-3

3,70353E-1

6,03170E-1

1,21381E-2

4,26824E0

2,10919E-2

8,33668E-2

2,82556E-1

7,08970E-2

3,12833E-3

7,46347E-1

3,12268E-1

3,63355E0

2,84710E-2

2,35258E-1

0.8

min

8,24164E-3

3,70096E-1

5,90001E-1

1,90417E-3

3,86554E0

1,35910E-2

9,42189E-3

2,72556E-1

6,96131E-2

2,72713E-3

2,02807E-1

2,47955E-1

3,51497E0

2,09661E-2

2,35239E-1

0.8

max

2,44300E-2

3,73737E-1

7,21743E-1

6,91040E-2

4,34006E0

9,84084E-2

5,44825E-1

3,67485E-1

8,65542E-2

6,41064E-3

8,31415E-1

6,37655E-1

3,64672E0

2,91890E-2

2,35383E-1

0.8

mean

9,72473E-3

3,70353E-1

6,03170E-1

1,21381E-2

4,26824E0

2,10919E-2

8,33668E-2

2,82556E-1

7,08970E-2

3,12833E-3

7,46347E-1

3,12268E-1

3,63355E0

2,84710E-2

2,35258E-1

0.8

relative error(%)

0,00

1.0

BioUML

1,39435E-2

3,78475E-1

6,23708E-1

2,90904E-2

4,11044E0

4,44999E-2

2,07636E-1

2,92201E-1

7,67154E-2

3,97716E-3

6,60179E-1

4,46665E-1

3,61302E0

3,55107E-2

2,73967E-1

1.0

ByoDyn

1,39435E-2

3,78475E-1

6,23708E-1

2,90904E-2

4,11044E0

4,44999E-2

2,07636E-1

2,92201E-1

7,67154E-2

3,97716E-3

6,60179E-1

4,46665E-1

3,61302E0

3,55107E-2

2,73967E-1

1.0

Jarnac

3,74792E-2

3,87791E-1

8,18418E-1

8,56090E-2

3,72342E0

1,42020E-1

6,96290E-1

4,26892E-1

1,08689E-1

8,48794E-3

5,44437E-2

7,36165E-1

3,41831E0

2,20956E-2

2,74192E-1

1.0

MathSBML

1,39435E-2

3,78475E-1

6,23708E-1

2,90904E-2

4,11044E0

4,44999E-2

2,07636E-1

2,92201E-1

7,67154E-2

3,97716E-3

6,60179E-1

4,46665E-1

3,61302E0

3,55107E-2

2,73967E-1

1.0

Oscill8 Core

1,39438E-2

3,78475E-1

6,23711E-1

2,90911E-2

4,11043E0

4,45022E-2

2,07643E-1

2,92203E-1

7,67160E-2

3,97722E-3

6,60171E-1

4,46667E-1

3,61301E0

3,55106E-2

2,73967E-1

1.0

SBToolbox2

1,39466E-2

3,78477E-1

6,23753E-1

2,91027E-2

4,11034E0

4,44916E-2

2,07699E-1

2,92236E-1

7,67251E-2

3,97790E-3

6,60106E-1

4,46760E-1

3,61297E0

3,55102E-2

2,73944E-1

1.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,39438E-2

3,78475E-1

6,23711E-1

2,90910E-2

4,11043E0

4,45019E-2

2,07642E-1

2,92203E-1

7,67160E-2

3,97722E-3

6,60172E-1

4,46666E-1

3,61301E0

3,55106E-2

2,73967E-1

1.0

VCell

1,39435E-2

3,78475E-1

6,23708E-1

2,90904E-2

4,11044E0

4,44999E-2

2,07636E-1

2,92201E-1

7,67154E-2

3,97716E-3

6,60179E-1

4,46665E-1

3,61302E0

3,55107E-2

2,73967E-1

1.0

copasi

1,39435E-2

3,78475E-1

6,23708E-1

2,90904E-2

4,11044E0

4,44999E-2

2,07636E-1

2,92201E-1

7,67154E-2

3,97716E-3

6,60179E-1

4,46664E-1

3,61302E0

3,55107E-2

2,73967E-1

1.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,69991E-3

3,77580E-1

5,84727E-1

3,13931E-3

4,28894E0

1,92951E-2

1,75166E-2

2,62518E-1

7,27633E-2

2,87518E-3

8,81079E-1

2,93363E-1

3,65200E0

3,76830E-2

2,73928E-1

1.0

jsim

1,39435E-2

3,78475E-1

6,23708E-1

2,90904E-2

4,11044E0

4,44999E-2

2,07636E-1

2,92201E-1

7,67154E-2

3,97716E-3

6,60179E-1

4,46665E-1

3,61302E0

3,55107E-2

2,73967E-1

1.0

min

9,69991E-3

3,77580E-1

5,84727E-1

3,13931E-3

3,72342E0

1,92951E-2

1,75166E-2

2,62518E-1

7,27633E-2

2,87518E-3

5,44437E-2

2,93363E-1

3,41831E0

2,20956E-2

2,73928E-1

1.0

max

3,74792E-2

3,87791E-1

8,18418E-1

8,56090E-2

4,28894E0

1,42020E-1

6,96290E-1

4,26892E-1

1,08689E-1

8,48794E-3

8,81079E-1

7,36165E-1

3,65200E0

3,76830E-2

2,74192E-1

1.0

mean

1,39435E-2

3,78475E-1

6,23708E-1

2,90904E-2

4,11044E0

4,44999E-2

2,07636E-1

2,92201E-1

7,67154E-2

3,97716E-3

6,60179E-1

4,46665E-1

3,61302E0

3,55107E-2

2,73967E-1

1.0

relative error(%)

0,00

1.2

BioUML

2,10581E-2

3,88156E-1

6,73300E-1

5,23467E-2

3,91303E0

8,63867E-2

3,88929E-1

3,22252E-1

8,77241E-2

5,38815E-3

5,02254E-1

6,02176E-1

3,56343E0

4,12750E-2

3,09993E-1

1.2

ByoDyn

2,10581E-2

3,88156E-1

6,73300E-1

5,23467E-2

3,91303E0

8,63867E-2

3,88929E-1

3,22252E-1

8,77241E-2

5,38815E-3

5,02254E-1

6,02176E-1

3,56343E0

4,12750E-2

3,09993E-1

1.2

Jarnac

4,97967E-2

4,08317E-1

9,20873E-1

8,98542E-2

3,69484E0

1,53162E-1

7,24497E-1

4,86214E-1

1,37968E-1

1,00162E-2

3,26084E-2

7,53598E-1

3,31586E0

2,24317E-2

3,10294E-1

1.2

MathSBML

2,10581E-2

3,88156E-1

6,73300E-1

5,23467E-2

3,91303E0

8,63867E-2

3,88929E-1

3,22252E-1

8,77241E-2

5,38815E-3

5,02253E-1

6,02176E-1

3,56343E0

4,12750E-2

3,09993E-1

1.2

Oscill8 Core

2,10585E-2

3,88156E-1

6,73304E-1

5,23462E-2

3,91304E0

8,63880E-2

3,88930E-1

3,22255E-1

8,77251E-2

5,38821E-3

5,02251E-1

6,02173E-1

3,56343E0

4,12748E-2

3,09993E-1

1.2

SBToolbox2

2,10628E-2

3,88165E-1

6,73374E-1

5,23706E-2

3,91289E0

8,63841E-2

3,89044E-1

3,22301E-1

8,77390E-2

5,38923E-3

5,02102E-1

6,02311E-1

3,56338E0

4,12731E-2

3,09971E-1

1.2

SBWOdeSolver

2,10585E-2

3,88156E-1

6,73304E-1

5,23461E-2

3,91304E0

8,63878E-2

3,88930E-1

3,22254E-1

8,77250E-2

5,38820E-3

5,02252E-1

6,02173E-1

3,56343E0

4,12748E-2

3,09993E-1

1.2

VCell

2,10581E-2

3,88156E-1

6,73300E-1

5,23467E-2

3,91303E0

8,63867E-2

3,88929E-1

3,22252E-1

8,77241E-2

5,38815E-3

5,02254E-1

6,02176E-1

3,56343E0

4,12750E-2

3,09993E-1

1.2

copasi

2,10581E-2

3,88156E-1

6,73300E-1

5,23467E-2

3,91303E0

8,63866E-2

3,88929E-1

3,22252E-1

8,77241E-2

5,38815E-3

5,02254E-1

6,02176E-1

3,56343E0

4,12750E-2

3,09993E-1

1.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,12137E-2

3,85441E-1

5,82143E-1

6,01265E-3

4,22903E0

2,71094E-2

3,54623E-2

2,53653E-1

7,73566E-2

3,04200E-3

9,20589E-1

3,45461E-1

3,65459E0

4,66111E-2

3,09892E-1

1.2

jsim

2,10581E-2

3,88156E-1

6,73300E-1

5,23467E-2

3,91303E0

8,63867E-2

3,88929E-1

3,22252E-1

8,77241E-2

5,38815E-3

5,02254E-1

6,02176E-1

3,56343E0

4,12750E-2

3,09993E-1

1.2

min

1,12137E-2

3,85441E-1

5,82143E-1

6,01265E-3

3,69484E0

2,71094E-2

3,54623E-2

2,53653E-1

7,73566E-2

3,04200E-3

3,26084E-2

3,45461E-1

3,31586E0

2,24317E-2

3,09892E-1

1.2

max

4,97967E-2

4,08317E-1

9,20873E-1

8,98542E-2

4,22903E0

1,53162E-1

7,24497E-1

4,86214E-1

1,37968E-1

1,00162E-2

9,20589E-1

7,53598E-1

3,65459E0

4,66111E-2

3,10294E-1

1.2

mean

2,10581E-2

3,88156E-1

6,73300E-1

5,23467E-2

3,91303E0

8,63867E-2

3,88929E-1

3,22252E-1

8,77241E-2

5,38815E-3

5,02254E-1

6,02176E-1

3,56343E0

4,12750E-2

3,09993E-1

1.2

relative error(%)

0,00

1.4

BioUML

3,13741E-2

4,00920E-1

7,51146E-1

7,32357E-2

3,72656E0

1,38440E-1

5,80116E-1

3,69927E-1

1,05706E-1

7,25552E-3

3,23523E-1

7,36596E-1

3,48559E0

4,53090E-2

3,43942E-1

1.4

ByoDyn

3,13741E-2

4,00920E-1

7,51146E-1

7,32357E-2

3,72656E0

1,38440E-1

5,80116E-1

3,69927E-1

1,05706E-1

7,25552E-3

3,23523E-1

7,36596E-1

3,48559E0

4,53090E-2

3,43942E-1

1.4

Jarnac

5,99927E-2

4,37225E-1

1,01641E0

9,09190E-2

3,69138E0

1,54637E-1

7,34175E-1

5,38516E-1

1,69789E-1

1,12294E-2

3,21195E-2

7,55578E-1

3,22033E0

2,27036E-2

3,44266E-1

1.4

MathSBML

3,13742E-2

4,00920E-1

7,51146E-1

7,32357E-2

3,72656E0

1,38440E-1

5,80116E-1

3,69927E-1

1,05706E-1

7,25552E-3

3,23523E-1

7,36596E-1

3,48559E0

4,53090E-2

3,43942E-1

1.4

Oscill8 Core

3,13746E-2

4,00921E-1

7,51149E-1

7,32350E-2

3,72656E0

1,38440E-1

5,80112E-1

3,69928E-1

1,05707E-1

7,25555E-3

3,23526E-1

7,36590E-1

3,48559E0

4,53088E-2

3,43942E-1

1.4

SBToolbox2

3,13777E-2

4,00936E-1

7,51238E-1

7,32631E-2

3,72640E0

1,38439E-1

5,80261E-1

3,69996E-1

1,05727E-1

7,25655E-3

3,23329E-1

7,36751E-1

3,48552E0

4,53049E-2

3,43928E-1

1.4

SBWOdeSolver

3,13745E-2

4,00921E-1

7,51149E-1

7,32350E-2

3,72656E0

1,38440E-1

5,80112E-1

3,69927E-1

1,05707E-1

7,25554E-3

3,23526E-1

7,36591E-1

3,48559E0

4,53088E-2

3,43942E-1

1.4

VCell

3,13741E-2

4,00920E-1

7,51146E-1

7,32357E-2

3,72656E0

1,38440E-1

5,80116E-1

3,69927E-1

1,05706E-1

7,25552E-3

3,23523E-1

7,36596E-1

3,48559E0

4,53090E-2

3,43942E-1

1.4

copasi

3,13741E-2

4,00920E-1

7,51146E-1

7,32357E-2

3,72656E0

1,38440E-1

5,80116E-1

3,69927E-1

1,05706E-1

7,25552E-3

3,23523E-1

7,36596E-1

3,48559E0

4,53090E-2

3,43942E-1

1.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,30078E-2

3,93900E-1

5,85426E-1

1,17497E-2

4,15269E0

3,87536E-2

7,17317E-2

2,48903E-1

8,33372E-2

3,29378E-3

9,38714E-1

4,10147E-1

3,65131E0

5,58189E-2

3,43739E-1

1.4

jsim

3,13742E-2

4,00920E-1

7,51146E-1

7,32357E-2

3,72656E0

1,38440E-1

5,80116E-1

3,69927E-1

1,05706E-1

7,25552E-3

3,23523E-1

7,36596E-1

3,48559E0

4,53090E-2

3,43942E-1

1.4

min

1,30078E-2

3,93900E-1

5,85426E-1

1,17497E-2

3,69138E0

3,87536E-2

7,17317E-2

2,48903E-1

8,33372E-2

3,29378E-3

3,21195E-2

4,10147E-1

3,22033E0

2,27036E-2

3,43739E-1

1.4

max

5,99927E-2

4,37225E-1

1,01641E0

9,09190E-2

4,15269E0

1,54637E-1

7,34175E-1

5,38516E-1

1,69789E-1

1,12294E-2

9,38714E-1

7,55578E-1

3,65131E0

5,58189E-2

3,44266E-1

1.4

mean

3,13742E-2

4,00920E-1

7,51146E-1

7,32357E-2

3,72656E0

1,38440E-1

5,80116E-1

3,69927E-1

1,05706E-1

7,25552E-3

3,23523E-1

7,36596E-1

3,48559E0

4,53090E-2

3,43942E-1

1.4

relative error(%)

0,00

1.6

BioUML

4,43617E-2

4,18842E-1

8,48025E-1

8,91495E-2

3,58205E0

1,87435E-1

7,46175E-1

4,26215E-1

1,31227E-1

9,33008E-3

1,63490E-1

8,32104E-1

3,38872E0

4,76065E-2

3,76216E-1

1.6

ByoDyn

4,43617E-2

4,18842E-1

8,48025E-1

8,91495E-2

3,58205E0

1,87435E-1

7,46175E-1

4,26215E-1

1,31227E-1

9,33008E-3

1,63490E-1

8,32104E-1

3,38872E0

4,76065E-2

3,76216E-1

1.6

Jarnac

6,85508E-2

4,75550E-1

1,10267E0

9,18987E-2

3,69660E0

1,53198E-1

7,44322E-1

5,84271E-1

2,00725E-1

1,22321E-2

3,26291E-2

7,51792E-1

3,13408E0

2,29768E-2

3,76509E-1

1.6

MathSBML

4,43617E-2

4,18842E-1

8,48025E-1

8,91495E-2

3,58205E0

1,87435E-1

7,46175E-1

4,26215E-1

1,31227E-1

9,33008E-3

1,63490E-1

8,32104E-1

3,38872E0

4,76065E-2

3,76216E-1

1.6

Oscill8 Core

4,43619E-2

4,18843E-1

8,48026E-1

8,91483E-2

3,58207E0

1,87431E-1

7,46162E-1

4,26215E-1

1,31228E-1

9,33004E-3

1,63504E-1

8,32094E-1

3,38872E0

4,76063E-2

3,76216E-1

1.6

SBToolbox2

4,43591E-2

4,18860E-1

8,48119E-1

8,91817E-2

3,58180E0

1,87474E-1

7,46506E-1

4,26288E-1

1,31250E-1

9,33137E-3

1,63100E-1

8,32350E-1

3,38862E0

4,76015E-2

3,76197E-1

1.6

SBWOdeSolver

4,43619E-2

4,18843E-1

8,48026E-1

8,91485E-2

3,58206E0

1,87432E-1

7,46164E-1

4,26215E-1

1,31228E-1

9,33004E-3

1,63502E-1

8,32095E-1

3,38872E0

4,76063E-2

3,76216E-1

1.6

VCell

4,43617E-2

4,18842E-1

8,48025E-1

8,91495E-2

3,58205E0

1,87435E-1

7,46175E-1

4,26215E-1

1,31227E-1

9,33008E-3

1,63490E-1

8,32104E-1

3,38872E0

4,76065E-2

3,76216E-1

1.6

copasi

4,43617E-2

4,18842E-1

8,48025E-1

8,91494E-2

3,58205E0

1,87435E-1

7,46175E-1

4,26215E-1

1,31227E-1

9,33008E-3

1,63490E-1

8,32104E-1

3,38872E0

4,76065E-2

3,76216E-1

1.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,55393E-2

4,03272E-1

5,99663E-1

2,17970E-2

4,04977E0

5,74283E-2

1,38844E-1

2,52536E-1

9,09553E-2

3,74106E-3

9,19390E-1

4,94396E-1

3,63708E0

6,50148E-2

3,75881E-1

1.6

jsim

4,43617E-2

4,18842E-1

8,48025E-1

8,91494E-2

3,58205E0

1,87435E-1

7,46175E-1

4,26215E-1

1,31227E-1

9,33008E-3

1,63490E-1

8,32104E-1

3,38872E0

4,76065E-2

3,76216E-1

1.6

min

1,55393E-2

4,03272E-1

5,99663E-1

2,17970E-2

3,58180E0

5,74283E-2

1,38844E-1

2,52536E-1

9,09553E-2

3,74106E-3

3,26291E-2

4,94396E-1

3,13408E0

2,29768E-2

3,75881E-1

1.6

max

6,85508E-2

4,75550E-1

1,10267E0

9,18987E-2

4,04977E0

1,87474E-1

7,46506E-1

5,84271E-1

2,00725E-1

1,22321E-2

9,19390E-1

8,32350E-1

3,63708E0

6,50148E-2

3,76509E-1

1.6

mean

4,43617E-2

4,18842E-1

8,48025E-1

8,91495E-2

3,58205E0

1,87435E-1

7,46175E-1

4,26215E-1

1,31227E-1

9,33008E-3

1,63490E-1

8,32104E-1

3,38872E0

4,76065E-2

3,76216E-1

1.6

relative error(%)

0,00

1.8

BioUML

5,83238E-2

4,44318E-1

9,52752E-1

9,81286E-2

3,51466E0

2,14665E-1

8,37128E-1

4,83433E-1

1,62918E-1

1,11794E-2

7,67805E-2

8,72259E-1

3,28400E0

4,86221E-2

4,07089E-1

1.8

ByoDyn

5,83238E-2

4,44318E-1

9,52752E-1

9,81286E-2

3,51466E0

2,14665E-1

8,37128E-1

4,83433E-1

1,62918E-1

1,11794E-2

7,67805E-2

8,72259E-1

3,28400E0

4,86221E-2

4,07089E-1

1.8

Jarnac

7,57338E-2

5,23554E-1

1,17945E0

9,29317E-2

3,70823E0

1,49685E-1

7,55325E-1

6,24988E-1

2,28776E-1

1,30575E-2

3,33580E-2

7,43675E-1

3,05730E0

2,32558E-2

4,07311E-1

1.8

MathSBML

5,83238E-2

4,44318E-1

9,52752E-1

9,81286E-2

3,51466E0

2,14665E-1

8,37128E-1

4,83433E-1

1,62918E-1

1,11794E-2

7,67805E-2

8,72258E-1

3,28400E0

4,86221E-2

4,07089E-1

1.8

Oscill8 Core

5,83235E-2

4,44319E-1

9,52751E-1

9,81274E-2

3,51468E0

2,14660E-1

8,37116E-1

4,83432E-1

1,62918E-1

1,11793E-2

7,67936E-2

8,72252E-1

3,28400E0

4,86220E-2

4,07088E-1

1.8

SBToolbox2

5,83306E-2

4,44350E-1

9,52859E-1

9,81529E-2

3,51453E0

2,14728E-1

8,37357E-1

4,83510E-1

1,62938E-1

1,11824E-2

7,64914E-2

8,72340E-1

3,28385E0

4,86151E-2

4,07068E-1

1.8

SBWOdeSolver

5,83235E-2

4,44319E-1

9,52751E-1

9,81275E-2

3,51467E0

2,14660E-1

8,37116E-1

4,83432E-1

1,62918E-1

1,11793E-2

7,67929E-2

8,72252E-1

3,28400E0

4,86220E-2

4,07088E-1

1.8

VCell

5,83238E-2

4,44318E-1

9,52752E-1

9,81286E-2

3,51466E0

2,14665E-1

8,37128E-1

4,83433E-1

1,62918E-1

1,11794E-2

7,67805E-2

8,72259E-1

3,28400E0

4,86221E-2

4,07089E-1

1.8

copasi

5,83238E-2

4,44318E-1

9,52752E-1

9,81286E-2

3,51466E0

2,14665E-1

8,37128E-1

4,83433E-1

1,62918E-1

1,11794E-2

7,67805E-2

8,72259E-1

3,28400E0

4,86221E-2

4,07089E-1

1.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,95250E-2

4,14082E-1

6,31015E-1

3,65272E-2

3,91559E0

8,70292E-2

2,46183E-1

2,69137E-1

1,00931E-1

4,52326E-3

8,49854E-1

5,98966E-1

3,60574E0

7,37512E-2

4,06618E-1

1.8

jsim

5,83238E-2

4,44318E-1

9,52752E-1

9,81286E-2

3,51466E0

2,14665E-1

8,37128E-1

4,83433E-1

1,62918E-1

1,11794E-2

7,67805E-2

8,72259E-1

3,28400E0

4,86221E-2

4,07089E-1

1.8

min

1,95250E-2

4,14082E-1

6,31015E-1

3,65272E-2

3,51453E0

8,70292E-2

2,46183E-1

2,69137E-1

1,00931E-1

4,52326E-3

3,33580E-2

5,98966E-1

3,05730E0

2,32558E-2

4,06618E-1

1.8

max

7,57338E-2

5,23554E-1

1,17945E0

9,81529E-2

3,91559E0

2,14728E-1

8,37357E-1

6,24988E-1

2,28776E-1

1,30575E-2

8,49854E-1

8,72340E-1

3,60574E0

7,37512E-2

4,07311E-1

1.8

mean

5,83238E-2

4,44318E-1

9,52752E-1

9,81286E-2

3,51466E0

2,14665E-1

8,37128E-1

4,83433E-1

1,62918E-1

1,11794E-2

7,67805E-2

8,72259E-1

3,28400E0

4,86221E-2

4,07089E-1

1.8

relative error(%)

0,00

2.0

BioUML

7,08457E-2

4,79472E-1

1,05352E0

1,00884E-1

3,51042E0

2,17705E-1

8,61502E-1

5,35864E-1

1,97343E-1

1,25619E-2

5,83609E-2

8,73458E-1

3,18324E0

4,91611E-2

4,36747E-1

2.0

ByoDyn

7,08457E-2

4,79472E-1

1,05352E0

1,00884E-1

3,51042E0

2,17705E-1

8,61502E-1

5,35864E-1

1,97343E-1

1,25619E-2

5,83609E-2

8,73458E-1

3,18324E0

4,91611E-2

4,36747E-1

2.0

Jarnac

8,16906E-2

5,80885E-1

1,24722E0

9,40005E-2

3,72476E0

1,44642E-1

7,66955E-1

6,61974E-1

2,52913E-1

1,37361E-2

3,42751E-2

7,32183E-1

2,98954E0

2,35423E-2

4,36885E-1

2.0

MathSBML

7,08457E-2

4,79472E-1

1,05352E0

1,00884E-1

3,51042E0

2,17705E-1

8,61502E-1

5,35864E-1

1,97343E-1

1,25619E-2

5,83609E-2

8,73458E-1

3,18324E0

4,91611E-2

4,36747E-1

2.0

Oscill8 Core

7,08453E-2

4,79474E-1

1,05352E0

1,00883E-1

3,51042E0

2,17703E-1

8,61500E-1

5,35862E-1

1,97342E-1

1,25618E-2

5,83636E-2

8,73456E-1

3,18324E0

4,91611E-2

4,36747E-1

2.0

SBToolbox2

7,08564E-2

4,79506E-1

1,05364E0

1,00888E-1

3,51040E0

2,17710E-1

8,61538E-1

5,35938E-1

1,97366E-1

1,25640E-2

5,82722E-2

8,73440E-1

3,18316E0