Test: BIOMD0000000048.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000048.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: DormandPrince
generated code: BIOMD0000000048.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-14
ATOL 1.0E-20
RTOL 1.0E-14
STEP 1.0E-4

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000048.gif

Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL6624193277.png

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: ShP  ShGS  RG  PLCgl  PLCg  ShG  RPLCg  RP  RPLCgP  RSh  GS  RShG  R2  R  SOS  RShGS  Shc  RShP  EGF  PLCgP  Grb  RGS  Ra 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  Jarnac  SBToolbox2  VCell  Oscill8 Core  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  jsim  BioUML 
timeresult ShP ShGS RG PLCgl PLCg ShG RPLCg RP RPLCgP RSh GS RShG R2 R SOS RShGS Shc RShP EGF PLCgP Grb RGS Ra
0.0BioUML0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,05000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E23,40000E10,00000E01,50000E20,00000E06,80000E20,00000E08,50000E10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0ByoDyn0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,05000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E23,40000E10,00000E01,50000E20,00000E06,80000E20,00000E08,50000E10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0Jarnac0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,05000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E23,40000E10,00000E01,50000E20,00000E06,80000E20,00000E08,50000E10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0MathSBML0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,05000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E23,40000E10,00000E01,50000E20,00000E06,80000E20,00000E08,50000E10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0Oscill8 Core0,00000E00,00000E0--1,05000E2-0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0-0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E23,40000E1-1,50000E20,00000E0-0,00000E08,50000E10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0SBToolbox20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,05000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E23,40000E10,00000E01,50000E20,00000E06,80000E20,00000E08,50000E10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0SBWOdeSolver0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,05000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E23,40000E10,00000E01,50000E20,00000E06,80000E20,00000E08,50000E10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0VCell0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,05000E20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E23,40000E10,00000E01,50000E20,00000E06,80000E20,00000E08,50000E10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0copasi0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,05000E2-1,20820E-140,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0-4,02734E-150,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E23,40000E10,00000E01,50000E20,00000E06,80000E20,00000E08,50000E10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,05000E28,61646E-150,00000E00,00000E00,00000E04,30823E-150,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E23,40000E10,00000E01,50000E20,00000E06,80000E20,00000E08,50000E10,00000E00,00000E0
0.0jsim0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E03,15000E-100,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E03,00000E-101,02000E-100,00000E04,50000E-100,00000E02,04000E-90,00000E02,55000E-100,00000E00,00000E0
0.0min 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 3,15000E-10 -1,20820E-14 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 -4,02734E-15 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 3,00000E-10 1,02000E-10 0,00000E0 4,50000E-10 0,00000E0 2,04000E-9 0,00000E0 2,55000E-10 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0max 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,05000E2 8,61646E-15 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 4,30823E-15 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E2 3,40000E1 0,00000E0 1,50000E2 0,00000E0 6,80000E2 0,00000E0 8,50000E1 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0mean 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,05000E2 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E2 3,40000E1 0,00000E0 1,50000E2 0,00000E0 6,80000E2 0,00000E0 8,50000E1 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML1,92564E-57,56540E-91,99451E-44,62209E-81,04995E22,63390E-74,78307E-31,64018E-21,81983E-48,50068E-35,77224E-21,61447E-57,13879E-16,73821E13,39423E11,80328E-71,49989E21,98305E-36,47382E21,69310E-68,49421E12,75113E-63,11261E1
0.2ByoDyn1,92564E-57,56537E-91,99451E-44,62209E-81,04995E22,63390E-74,78307E-31,64018E-21,81983E-48,50068E-35,77224E-21,61447E-57,13879E-16,73821E13,39423E11,80328E-71,49989E21,98305E-36,47382E21,69310E-68,49421E12,75113E-63,11261E1
0.2Jarnac1,92573E-57,56626E-91,99452E-44,62263E-81,04995E22,63418E-74,78310E-31,64018E-21,81987E-48,50071E-35,77224E-21,61454E-57,13880E-16,73821E13,39423E11,80347E-71,49989E21,98308E-36,47382E21,69319E-68,49421E12,75119E-63,11260E1
0.2MathSBML1,92561E-57,56573E-91,99451E-44,62208E-81,04995E22,63388E-74,78307E-31,64018E-21,81982E-48,50069E-35,77224E-21,61444E-57,13879E-16,73821E13,39423E11,80326E-71,49989E21,98304E-36,47382E21,69308E-68,49421E12,75112E-63,11261E1
0.2Oscill8 Core2,60056E-272,51616E-26--1,05000E2--1,06138E-38-8,39089E-27-1,60400E-51-1,73400E-13-2,43276E-283,22859E-351,00000E23,40000E1-1,50000E2-7,98494E-26--1,42444E-548,50000E16,18422E-271,22400E-10
0.2SBToolbox21,94228E-57,76853E-91,99646E-44,70543E-81,05000E22,67744E-74,78731E-31,63952E-21,82732E-48,50410E-35,77224E-21,62829E-57,13589E-16,73821E13,39421E11,83047E-71,49990E21,98962E-36,47386E21,70929E-68,49421E12,76218E-63,11266E1
0.2SBWOdeSolver1,92718E-57,57744E-91,99512E-44,62770E-81,04995E22,63695E-74,78449E-31,64039E-21,82081E-48,50288E-35,77224E-21,61575E-57,13938E-16,73823E13,39423E11,80537E-71,49989E21,98403E-36,47382E21,69452E-68,49421E12,75264E-63,11256E1
0.2VCell1,92615E-57,57097E-91,99462E-44,62443E-81,04995E22,63514E-74,78332E-31,64020E-21,82009E-48,50102E-35,77224E-21,61489E-57,13884E-16,73820E13,39423E11,80407E-71,49989E21,98329E-36,47382E21,69359E-68,49421E12,75152E-63,11261E1
0.2copasi1,92564E-57,56549E-91,99451E-44,62210E-81,04995E22,63391E-74,78307E-31,64018E-21,81983E-48,50068E-35,77224E-21,61447E-57,13879E-16,73821E13,39423E11,80328E-71,49989E21,98305E-36,47382E21,69310E-68,49421E12,75113E-63,11261E1
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner1,92564E-57,56533E-91,99451E-44,62205E-81,04995E22,63390E-74,78307E-31,64018E-21,81983E-48,50068E-35,77224E-21,61447E-57,13879E-16,73821E13,39423E11,80328E-71,49989E21,98305E-36,47382E21,69310E-68,49421E12,75113E-63,11261E1
0.2jsim2,72980E-1437,50210E-1933,34204E-1191,59239E-1573,15000E-103,13245E-1688,25681E-1183,64057E-948,25681E-1311,76932E-1171,56060E-366,96100E-1552,42705E-813,00000E-101,02000E-106,44345E-1804,50000E-101,06159E-1292,04000E-92,12318E-1442,55000E-103,66455E-1441,10160E-33
0.2min 2,72980E-143 7,50210E-193 3,34204E-119 1,59239E-157 3,15000E-10 3,13245E-168 -1,06138E-38 -8,39089E-27 -1,60400E-51 1,76932E-117 1,56060E-36 -2,43276E-28 2,42705E-81 3,00000E-10 1,02000E-10 6,44345E-180 4,50000E-10 -7,98494E-26 2,04000E-9 -1,42444E-54 2,55000E-10 3,66455E-144 1,10160E-33
0.2max 1,94228E-5 7,76853E-9 1,99646E-4 4,70543E-8 1,05000E2 2,67744E-7 4,78731E-3 1,64039E-2 1,82732E-4 8,50410E-3 5,77224E-2 1,62829E-5 7,13938E-1 1,00000E2 3,40000E1 1,83047E-7 1,50000E2 1,98962E-3 6,47386E2 1,70929E-6 8,50000E1 2,76218E-6 3,11266E1
0.2mean 1,92564E-5 7,56561E-9 1,99451E-4 4,62210E-8 1,04995E2 2,63391E-7 4,78307E-3 1,64018E-2 1,81983E-4 8,50069E-3 5,77224E-2 1,61447E-5 7,13879E-1 6,73821E1 3,39423E1 1,80328E-7 1,49989E2 1,98305E-3 6,47382E2 1,69310E-6 8,49421E1 2,75113E-6 3,11261E1
0.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML1,10288E-31,92495E-62,87399E-36,34900E-61,04928E23,15398E-56,65662E-21,04429E-15,56569E-39,82221E-21,15282E-19,10356E-43,54762E04,64021E13,38846E12,17105E-51,49848E25,15569E-26,26402E21,08906E-48,48808E18,66693E-54,58422E1
0.4ByoDyn1,10288E-31,92495E-62,87399E-36,34900E-61,04928E23,15398E-56,65662E-21,04429E-15,56569E-39,82221E-21,15282E-19,10356E-43,54762E04,64021E13,38846E12,17105E-51,49848E25,15569E-26,26402E21,08906E-48,48808E18,66693E-54,58422E1
0.4Jarnac1,10293E-31,92523E-62,87402E-36,34965E-61,04928E23,15426E-56,65670E-21,04429E-15,56587E-39,82228E-21,15282E-19,10401E-43,54762E04,64021E13,38846E12,17123E-51,49848E25,15582E-26,26402E21,08913E-48,48808E18,66721E-54,58422E1
0.4MathSBML1,10288E-31,92495E-62,87399E-36,34900E-61,04928E23,15398E-56,65662E-21,04429E-15,56569E-39,82221E-21,15282E-19,10356E-43,54762E04,64021E13,38846E12,17105E-51,49848E25,15569E-26,26402E21,08906E-48,48808E18,66693E-54,58422E1
0.4Oscill8 Core1,04925E-261,02059E-25--1,05000E2--9,64652E-38-3,87729E-26-2,92220E-50-3,46800E-13-8,85316E-282,48744E-341,00000E23,40000E1-1,50000E2-3,73841E-25--6,58210E-548,50000E12,31072E-262,44800E-10
0.4SBToolbox21,10700E-31,95255E-62,87447E-36,41095E-61,04930E23,17953E-56,65706E-21,04390E-15,57502E-39,81947E-21,15285E-19,13668E-43,54663E04,64011E13,38841E12,18714E-51,49850E25,16055E-26,26404E21,09415E-48,48811E18,68224E-54,58453E1
0.4SBWOdeSolver1,10320E-31,92616E-62,87427E-36,35209E-61,04928E23,15537E-56,65723E-21,04431E-15,56677E-39,82284E-21,15282E-19,10616E-43,54767E04,64024E13,38846E12,17201E-51,49848E25,15651E-26,26402E21,08942E-48,48808E18,66868E-54,58418E1
0.4VCell1,10291E-31,92511E-62,87401E-36,34937E-61,04928E23,15414E-56,65666E-21,04429E-15,56578E-39,82225E-21,15282E-19,10380E-43,54762E04,64021E13,38846E12,17115E-51,49848E25,15576E-26,26402E21,08910E-48,48808E18,66707E-54,58422E1
0.4copasi1,10288E-31,92495E-62,87399E-36,34900E-61,04928E23,15398E-56,65662E-21,04429E-15,56569E-39,82221E-21,15282E-19,10356E-43,54762E04,64021E13,38846E12,17104E-51,49848E25,15569E-26,26402E21,08906E-48,48808E18,66693E-54,58422E1
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner1,10288E-31,92495E-62,87399E-36,34900E-61,04928E23,15398E-56,65662E-21,04429E-15,56569E-39,82221E-21,15282E-19,10356E-43,54762E04,64021E13,38846E12,17105E-51,49848E25,15569E-26,26402E21,08906E-48,48808E18,66693E-54,58422E1
0.4jsim3,49415E-1413,84107E-1901,06945E-1174,07650E-1553,15000E-108,01907E-1662,64218E-1165,82491E-935,28436E-1295,66181E-1163,12120E-368,91007E-1531,94164E-803,00000E-101,02000E-101,64952E-1774,50000E-106,79417E-1282,04000E-92,71767E-1422,55000E-102,34531E-1422,20320E-33
0.4min 3,49415E-141 3,84107E-190 1,06945E-117 4,07650E-155 3,15000E-10 8,01907E-166 -9,64652E-38 -3,87729E-26 -2,92220E-50 5,66181E-116 3,12120E-36 -8,85316E-28 1,94164E-80 3,00000E-10 1,02000E-10 1,64952E-177 4,50000E-10 -3,73841E-25 2,04000E-9 -6,58210E-54 2,55000E-10 2,34531E-142 2,20320E-33
0.4max 1,10700E-3 1,95255E-6 2,87447E-3 6,41095E-6 1,05000E2 3,17953E-5 6,65723E-2 1,04431E-1 5,57502E-3 9,82284E-2 1,15285E-1 9,13668E-4 3,54767E0 1,00000E2 3,40000E1 2,18714E-5 1,50000E2 5,16055E-2 6,26404E2 1,09415E-4 8,50000E1 8,68224E-5 4,58453E1
0.4mean 1,10288E-3 1,92495E-6 2,87399E-3 6,34900E-6 1,04928E2 3,15398E-5 6,65662E-2 1,04429E-1 5,56569E-3 9,82221E-2 1,15282E-1 9,10356E-4 3,54762E0 4,64021E1 3,38846E1 2,17105E-5 1,49848E2 5,15569E-2 6,26402E2 1,08906E-4 8,48808E1 8,66693E-5 4,58422E1
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML9,31324E-33,98321E-51,10898E-29,46914E-51,04718E24,12440E-42,47032E-12,41986E-13,35785E-23,05420E-11,72628E-17,55617E-37,40990E03,24972E13,38265E12,86466E-41,49410E22,66619E-16,12497E21,02307E-38,48074E15,41190E-45,04548E1
0.6ByoDyn9,31324E-33,98321E-51,10898E-29,46914E-51,04718E24,12440E-42,47032E-12,41986E-13,35785E-23,05420E-11,72628E-17,55617E-37,40990E03,24972E13,38265E12,86466E-41,49410E22,66619E-16,12497E21,02307E-38,48074E15,41190E-45,04548E1
0.6Jarnac9,31392E-33,98405E-51,10900E-29,47063E-51,04718E24,12493E-42,47035E-12,41985E-13,35800E-23,05421E-11,72628E-17,55670E-37,40989E03,24973E13,38265E12,86503E-41,49410E22,66627E-16,12497E21,02316E-38,48074E15,41217E-45,04547E1
0.6MathSBML9,31324E-33,98319E-51,10898E-29,46911E-51,04718E24,12439E-42,47032E-12,41986E-13,35785E-23,05420E-11,72628E-17,55617E-37,40990E03,24972E13,38265E12,86466E-41,49410E22,66619E-16,12497E21,02307E-38,48074E15,41190E-45,04548E1
0.6Oscill8 Core2,35481E-262,29405E-25--1,05000E2--3,38482E-37-9,00762E-26-1,53592E-49-5,20200E-13-1,92326E-278,29038E-341,00000E23,40000E1-1,50000E2-8,72496E-25--1,52914E-538,50000E15,14931E-263,67200E-10
0.6SBToolbox29,33189E-34,02228E-51,10891E-29,53298E-51,04721E24,14504E-42,46984E-12,41932E-13,36047E-23,05312E-11,72629E-17,57015E-37,40860E03,24953E13,38262E12,87791E-41,49412E22,66656E-16,12494E21,02601E-38,48072E15,41704E-45,04593E1
0.6SBWOdeSolver9,31461E-33,98461E-51,10903E-29,47173E-51,04718E24,12537E-42,47041E-12,41985E-13,35818E-23,05424E-11,72628E-17,55724E-37,40988E03,24975E13,38265E12,86534E-41,49410E22,66637E-16,12497E21,02325E-38,48074E15,41246E-45,04545E1
0.6VCell9,31331E-33,98331E-51,10898E-29,46930E-51,04718E24,12446E-42,47032E-12,41986E-13,35787E-23,05420E-11,72628E-17,55622E-37,40991E03,24972E13,38265E12,86470E-41,49410E22,66620E-16,12497E21,02308E-38,48074E15,41193E-45,04548E1
0.6copasi9,31324E-33,98322E-51,10898E-29,46914E-51,04718E24,12440E-42,47032E-12,41986E-13,35785E-23,05420E-11,72628E-17,55616E-37,40990E03,24972E13,38265E12,86466E-41,49410E22,66619E-16,12497E21,02307E-38,48074E15,41190E-45,04548E1
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner9,31324E-33,98321E-51,10898E-29,46914E-51,04718E24,12440E-42,47032E-12,41986E-13,35785E-23,05420E-11,72628E-17,55617E-37,40990E03,24972E13,38265E12,86466E-41,49410E22,66619E-16,12497E21,02307E-38,48074E15,41190E-45,04548E1
0.6jsim5,97008E-1401,47664E-1888,12116E-1171,04476E-1533,15000E-102,05520E-1642,00640E-1152,94886E-926,01921E-1284,29944E-1154,68180E-361,52237E-1516,55302E-803,00000E-101,02000E-104,22754E-1764,50000E-107,73899E-1272,04000E-94,64339E-1412,55000E-102,67146E-1413,30480E-33
0.6min 5,97008E-140 1,47664E-188 8,12116E-117 1,04476E-153 3,15000E-10 2,05520E-164 -3,38482E-37 -9,00762E-26 -1,53592E-49 4,29944E-115 4,68180E-36 -1,92326E-27 6,55302E-80 3,00000E-10 1,02000E-10 4,22754E-176 4,50000E-10 -8,72496E-25 2,04000E-9 -1,52914E-53 2,55000E-10 2,67146E-141 3,30480E-33
0.6max 9,33189E-3 4,02228E-5 1,10903E-2 9,53298E-5 1,05000E2 4,14504E-4 2,47041E-1 2,41986E-1 3,36047E-2 3,05424E-1 1,72629E-1 7,57015E-3 7,40991E0 1,00000E2 3,40000E1 2,87791E-4 1,50000E2 2,66656E-1 6,12497E2 1,02601E-3 8,50000E1 5,41704E-4 5,04593E1
0.6mean 9,31324E-3 3,98322E-5 1,10898E-2 9,46914E-5 1,04718E2 4,12440E-4 2,47032E-1 2,41985E-1 3,35785E-2 3,05420E-1 1,72628E-1 7,55617E-3 7,40989E0 3,24972E1 3,38265E1 2,86466E-4 1,49410E2 2,66619E-1 6,12497E2 1,02307E-3 8,48074E1 5,41190E-4 5,04548E1
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML3,69101E-23,01643E-42,56883E-25,80373E-41,04340E22,23040E-35,48332E-13,84256E-11,06763E-15,75251E-12,29624E-12,93885E-21,10354E12,30789E13,37667E11,56703E-31,48620E27,33860E-16,03079E24,46532E-38,47094E11,78758E-35,00366E1
0.8ByoDyn3,69101E-23,01643E-42,56883E-25,80373E-41,04340E22,23040E-35,48332E-13,84256E-11,06763E-15,75251E-12,29624E-12,93885E-21,10354E12,30789E13,37667E11,56703E-31,48620E27,33860E-16,03079E24,46532E-38,47094E11,78758E-35,00366E1
0.8Jarnac3,69134E-23,01725E-42,56887E-25,80495E-41,04340E22,23076E-35,48338E-13,84254E-11,06769E-15,75249E-12,29624E-12,93909E-21,10353E12,30792E13,37667E11,56729E-31,48620E27,33881E-16,03079E24,46582E-38,47094E11,78769E-35,00364E1
0.8MathSBML3,69101E-23,01642E-42,56883E-25,80373E-41,04340E22,23040E-35,48332E-13,84256E-11,06763E-15,75251E-12,29624E-12,93885E-21,10354E12,30789E13,37667E11,56703E-31,48620E27,33860E-16,03079E24,46532E-38,47094E11,78758E-35,00366E1
0.8Oscill8 Core4,18524E-264,08029E-25--1,05000E2--8,14596E-37-1,61637E-25-4,93029E-49-6,93600E-13-3,36435E-271,95284E-331,00000E23,40000E1-1,50000E2-1,56836E-24--2,74395E-538,50000E19,10522E-264,89600E-10
0.8SBToolbox23,69492E-23,03755E-42,56832E-25,83195E-41,04342E22,23747E-35,48185E-13,84209E-11,06796E-15,75091E-12,29623E-12,94151E-21,10348E12,30762E13,37663E11,57176E-31,48623E27,33741E-16,03072E24,47307E-38,47095E11,78847E-35,00421E1
0.8SBWOdeSolver3,69133E-23,01710E-42,56888E-25,80475E-41,04340E22,23072E-35,48340E-13,84255E-11,06769E-15,75251E-12,29624E-12,93908E-21,10353E12,30792E13,37667E11,56726E-31,48620E27,33884E-16,03079E24,46578E-38,47094E11,78769E-35,00364E1
0.8VCell3,69103E-23,01646E-42,56884E-25,80378E-41,04340E22,23041E-35,48333E-13,84256E-11,06764E-15,75252E-12,29624E-12,93886E-21,10354E12,30789E13,37667E11,56704E-31,48620E27,33862E-16,03079E24,46534E-38,47094E11,78759E-35,00365E1
0.8copasi3,69101E-23,01642E-42,56883E-25,80373E-41,04340E22,23040E-35,48332E-13,84256E-11,06763E-15,75251E-12,29624E-12,93885E-21,10354E12,30789E13,37667E11,56703E-31,48620E27,33860E-16,03079E24,46532E-38,47094E11,78758E-35,00366E1
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner3,69101E-23,01643E-42,56883E-25,80373E-41,04340E22,23040E-35,48332E-13,84256E-11,06763E-15,75251E-12,29624E-12,93885E-21,10354E12,30789E13,37667E11,56703E-31,48620E27,33860E-16,03079E24,46532E-38,47094E11,78758E-35,00366E1
0.8jsim4,47251E-1391,96663E-1873,42225E-1161,04358E-1523,15000E-102,05288E-1638,45497E-1159,31985E-923,38199E-1271,81178E-1146,24240E-361,14049E-1501,55331E-793,00000E-101,02000E-104,22278E-1754,50000E-104,34827E-1262,04000E-93,47862E-1402,55000E-101,50100E-1404,40640E-33
0.8min 4,47251E-139 1,96663E-187 3,42225E-116 1,04358E-152 3,15000E-10 2,05288E-163 -8,14596E-37 -1,61637E-25 -4,93029E-49 1,81178E-114 6,24240E-36 -3,36435E-27 1,55331E-79 3,00000E-10 1,02000E-10 4,22278E-175 4,50000E-10 -1,56836E-24 2,04000E-9 -2,74395E-53 2,55000E-10 1,50100E-140 4,40640E-33
0.8max 3,69492E-2 3,03755E-4 2,56888E-2 5,83195E-4 1,05000E2 2,23747E-3 5,48340E-1 3,84256E-1 1,06796E-1 5,75252E-1 2,29624E-1 2,94151E-2 1,10354E1 1,00000E2 3,40000E1 1,57176E-3 1,50000E2 7,33884E-1 6,03079E2 4,47307E-3 8,50000E1 1,78847E-3 5,00421E1
0.8mean 3,69101E-2 3,01643E-4 2,56883E-2 5,80373E-4 1,04340E2 2,23040E-3 5,48332E-1 3,84255E-1 1,06763E-1 5,75251E-1 2,29624E-1 2,93885E-2 1,10353E1 2,30789E1 3,37667E1 1,56703E-3 1,48620E2 7,33860E-1 6,03079E2 4,46532E-3 8,47094E1 1,78758E-3 5,00365E1
0.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.0BioUML9,81366E-21,33240E-34,57220E-22,20700E-31,03810E27,53072E-39,32580E-15,06827E-12,42056E-18,42550E-12,86036E-17,65645E-21,38553E11,65969E13,37030E15,36214E-31,47513E21,45574E05,96597E21,29447E-28,45732E14,22251E-34,74692E1
1.0ByoDyn9,81366E-21,33240E-34,57220E-22,20700E-31,03810E27,53072E-39,32580E-15,06827E-12,42056E-18,42550E-12,86036E-17,65645E-21,38553E11,65969E13,37030E15,36214E-31,47513E21,45574E05,96597E21,29447E-28,45732E14,22251E-34,74692E1
1.0Jarnac9,81463E-21,33283E-34,57227E-22,20756E-31,03810E27,53213E-39,32585E-15,06821E-12,42070E-18,42540E-12,86035E-17,65714E-21,38551E11,65972E13,37030E15,36316E-31,47513E21,45577E05,96597E21,29464E-28,45732E14,22282E-34,74691E1
1.0MathSBML9,81366E-21,33240E-34,57220E-22,20700E-31,03810E27,53072E-39,32580E-15,06827E-12,42056E-18,42550E-12,86036E-17,65645E-21,38553E11,65969E13,37030E15,36214E-31,47513E21,45574E05,96597E21,29447E-28,45732E14,22251E-34,74692E1
1.0Oscill8 Core6,54055E-266,37961E-25--1,05000E2--1,60290E-36-2,54161E-25-1,21262E-48-8,67000E-13-5,20294E-273,79981E-331,00000E23,40000E1-1,50000E2-2,46907E-24--4,31464E-538,50000E11,41974E-256,12000E-10
1.0SBToolbox29,81820E-21,33863E-34,57132E-22,21423E-31,03813E27,54462E-39,32354E-15,06801E-12,42060E-18,42430E-12,86039E-17,65893E-21,38551E11,65940E13,37033E15,37168E-31,47516E21,45535E05,96597E21,29572E-28,45728E14,22347E-34,74744E1
1.0SBWOdeSolver9,81417E-21,33260E-34,57224E-22,20727E-31,03810E27,53142E-39,32584E-15,06823E-12,42064E-18,42545E-12,86035E-17,65682E-21,38552E11,65971E13,37030E15,36266E-31,47513E21,45576E05,96597E21,29456E-28,45732E14,22268E-34,74692E1
1.0VCell9,81368E-21,33240E-34,57220E-22,20701E-31,03810E27,53075E-39,32581E-15,06827E-12,42056E-18,42550E-12,86036E-17,65647E-21,38553E11,65969E13,37030E15,36216E-31,47513E21,45574E05,96597E21,29447E-28,45732E14,22252E-34,74692E1
1.0copasi9,81366E-21,33240E-34,57220E-22,20700E-31,03810E27,53072E-39,32580E-15,06827E-12,42056E-18,42550E-12,86036E-17,65645E-21,38553E11,65969E13,37030E15,36214E-31,47513E21,45574E05,96597E21,29447E-28,45732E14,22251E-34,74692E1
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner9,81366E-21,33240E-34,57220E-22,20700E-31,03810E27,53072E-39,32580E-15,06827E-12,42056E-18,42550E-12,86036E-17,65645E-21,38553E11,65969E13,37030E15,36214E-31,47513E21,45574E05,96597E21,29447E-28,45732E14,22251E-34,74692E1
1.0jsim2,13266E-1381,46525E-1861,04439E-1156,22025E-1523,15000E-101,22361E-1622,58025E-1142,27535E-911,29013E-1265,52911E-1147,80300E-365,43828E-1503,03381E-793,00000E-101,02000E-102,51697E-1744,50000E-101,65873E-1252,04000E-91,65873E-1392,55000E-105,72586E-1405,50800E-33
1.0min 2,13266E-138 1,46525E-186 1,04439E-115 6,22025E-152 3,15000E-10 1,22361E-162 -1,60290E-36 -2,54161E-25 -1,21262E-48 5,52911E-114 7,80300E-36 -5,20294E-27 3,03381E-79 3,00000E-10 1,02000E-10 2,51697E-174 4,50000E-10 -2,46907E-24 2,04000E-9 -4,31464E-53 2,55000E-10 5,72586E-140 5,50800E-33
1.0max 9,81820E-2 1,33863E-3 4,57227E-2 2,21423E-3 1,05000E2 7,54462E-3 9,32585E-1 5,06827E-1 2,42070E-1 8,42550E-1 2,86039E-1 7,65893E-2 1,38553E1 1,00000E2 3,40000E1 5,37168E-3 1,50000E2 1,45577E0 5,96597E2 1,29572E-2 8,50000E1 4,22347E-3 4,74744E1
1.0mean 9,81366E-2 1,33240E-3 4,57220E-2 2,20700E-3 1,03810E2 7,53072E-3 9,32580E-1 5,06825E-1 2,42056E-1 8,42550E-1 2,86036E-1 7,65645E-2 1,38553E1 1,65969E1 3,37030E1 5,36214E-3 1,47513E2 1,45574E0 5,96597E2 1,29447E-2 8,45732E1 4,22251E-3 4,74692E1
1.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.2BioUML2,04764E-14,21624E-36,95887E-26,24401E-31,03164E21,90330E-21,35362E06,02661E-14,46732E-11,06985E03,41560E-11,56306E-11,57780E11,20815E13,36323E11,37542E-21,46156E22,37601E05,92081E22,91669E-28,43874E18,13661E-34,41693E1
1.2ByoDyn2,04764E-14,21624E-36,95887E-26,24401E-31,03164E21,90330E-21,35362E06,02661E-14,46732E-11,06985E03,41560E-11,56306E-11,57780E11,20815E13,36323E11,37542E-21,46156E22,37601E05,92081E22,91669E-28,43874E18,13661E-34,41693E1
1.2Jarnac2,04786E-14,21786E-36,95895E-26,24591E-31,03164E21,90371E-21,35362E06,02650E-14,46760E-11,06983E03,41559E-11,56321E-11,57776E11,20820E13,36323E11,37572E-21,46156E22,37606E05,92082E22,91713E-28,43874E18,13731E-34,41693E1
1.2MathSBML2,04764E-14,21624E-36,95887E-26,24401E-31,03164E21,90330E-21,35362E06,02661E-14,46732E-11,06985E03,41560E-11,56306E-11,57780E11,20815E13,36323E11,37542E-21,46156E22,37601E05,92081E22,91669E-28,43874E18,13661E-34,41693E1
1.2Oscill8 Core9,41223E-269,18292E-25--1,05000E2--2,78099E-36-3,66937E-25-2,52410E-48-1,04040E-12-7,44622E-276,54963E-331,00000E23,40000E1-1,50000E2-3,56679E-24--6,22914E-538,50000E12,04023E-257,34400E-10
1.2SBToolbox22,04793E-14,23022E-36,95757E-26,25857E-31,03164E21,90536E-21,35334E06,02662E-14,46690E-11,06979E03,41560E-11,56310E-11,57789E11,20778E13,36325E11,37700E-21,46158E22,37544E05,92082E22,91816E-28,43873E18,13725E-34,41735E1
1.2SBWOdeSolver2,04771E-14,21670E-36,95891E-26,24456E-31,03164E21,90342E-21,35362E06,02656E-14,46741E-11,06985E03,41560E-11,56311E-11,57779E11,20816E13,36323E11,37551E-21,46156E22,37603E05,92082E22,91682E-28,43874E18,13684E-34,41693E1
1.2VCell2,04764E-14,21625E-36,95888E-26,24402E-31,03164E21,90331E-21,35362E06,02661E-14,46733E-11,06985E03,41560E-11,56306E-11,57780E11,20815E13,36323E11,37542E-21,46156E22,37601E05,92081E22,91669E-28,43874E18,13662E-34,41693E1
1.2copasi2,04764E-14,21624E-36,95887E-26,24400E-31,03164E21,90330E-21,35362E06,02661E-14,46732E-11,06985E03,41560E-11,56306E-11,57780E11,20815E13,36323E11,37542E-21,46156E22,37601E05,92081E22,91669E-28,43874E18,13661E-34,41693E1
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner2,04764E-14,21624E-36,95887E-26,24401E-31,03164E21,90330E-21,35362E06,02661E-14,46732E-11,06985E03,41560E-11,56306E-11,57780E11,20815E13,36323E11,37542E-21,46156E22,37601E05,92081E22,91669E-28,43874E18,13661E-34,41693E1
1.2jsim7,64170E-1387,56037E-1862,59877E-1152,67459E-1513,15000E-105,26131E-1626,42049E-1144,71818E-913,85230E-1261,37582E-1139,36360E-361,94863E-1495,24242E-793,00000E-101,02000E-101,08225E-1734,50000E-104,95295E-1252,04000E-95,94354E-1392,55000E-101,70973E-1396,60960E-33
1.2min 7,64170E-138 7,56037E-186 2,59877E-115 2,67459E-151 3,15000E-10 5,26131E-162 -2,78099E-36 -3,66937E-25 -2,52410E-48 1,37582E-113 9,36360E-36 -7,44622E-27 5,24242E-79 3,00000E-10 1,02000E-10 1,08225E-173 4,50000E-10 -3,56679E-24 2,04000E-9 -6,22914E-53 2,55000E-10 1,70973E-139 6,60960E-33
1.2max 2,04793E-1 4,23022E-3 6,95895E-2 6,25857E-3 1,05000E2 1,90536E-2 1,35362E0 6,02662E-1 4,46760E-1 1,06985E0 3,41560E-1 1,56321E-1 1,57789E1 1,00000E2 3,40000E1 1,37700E-2 1,50000E2 2,37606E0 5,92082E2 2,91816E-2 8,50000E1 8,13731E-3 4,41735E1
1.2mean 2,04764E-1 4,21624E-3 6,95887E-2 6,24401E-3 1,03164E2 1,90330E-2 1,35362E0 6,02661E-1 4,46732E-1 1,06985E0 3,41560E-1 1,56306E-1 1,57780E1 1,20815E1 3,36323E1 1,37542E-2 1,46156E2 2,37601E0 5,92081E2 2,91669E-2 8,43874E1 8,13661E-3 4,41693E1
1.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.4BioUML3,63995E-11,06534E-2