Test: BIOMD0000000055.xml - Ok


test: BIOMD0000000055.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: DormandPrince
generated code: BIOMD0000000055.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-100
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000055.gif


Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL0737170531.JPG


Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: cLc  cYc  cXc  cPn  cYm  cTn  cTm  cXm  cXn  cTc  cLm  cLn  cYn 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  SBToolbox2  VCell  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  BioUML 
timeresult cLc cYc cXc cPn cYm cTn cTm cXm cXn cTc cLm cLn cYn
0.0BioUML1,50000E-24,00000E-31,34000E08,35000E-13,70000E-24,00000E-14,56000E-18,00000E-24,00000E-18,70000E05,39000E-18,55000E-21,30000E-2
0.0ByoDyn1,50000E-24,00000E-31,34000E08,35000E-13,70000E-24,00000E-14,56000E-18,00000E-24,00000E-18,70000E05,39000E-18,55000E-21,30000E-2
0.0MathSBML1,50000E-24,00000E-31,34000E08,35000E-13,70000E-24,00000E-14,56000E-18,00000E-24,00000E-18,70000E05,39000E-18,55000E-21,30000E-2
0.0SBToolbox21,50000E-24,00000E-31,34000E08,35000E-13,70000E-24,00000E-14,56000E-18,00000E-24,00000E-18,70000E05,39000E-18,55000E-21,30000E-2
0.0SBWOdeSolver1,50000E-24,00000E-31,34000E08,35000E-13,70000E-24,00000E-14,56000E-18,00000E-24,00000E-18,70000E05,39000E-18,55000E-21,30000E-2
0.0VCell1,50000E-24,00000E-31,34000E08,35000E-13,70000E-24,00000E-14,56000E-18,00000E-24,00000E-18,70000E05,39000E-18,55000E-21,30000E-2
0.0copasi1,50000E-24,00000E-31,34000E08,35000E-13,70000E-24,00000E-14,56000E-18,00000E-24,00000E-18,70000E05,39000E-18,55000E-21,30000E-2
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner1,50000E-24,00000E-31,34000E08,35000E-13,70000E-24,00000E-14,56000E-18,00000E-24,00000E-18,70000E05,39000E-18,55000E-21,30000E-2
0.0min 1,50000E-2 4,00000E-3 1,34000E0 8,35000E-1 3,70000E-2 4,00000E-1 4,56000E-1 8,00000E-2 4,00000E-1 8,70000E0 5,39000E-1 8,55000E-2 1,30000E-2
0.0max 1,50000E-2 4,00000E-3 1,34000E0 8,35000E-1 3,70000E-2 4,00000E-1 4,56000E-1 8,00000E-2 4,00000E-1 8,70000E0 5,39000E-1 8,55000E-2 1,30000E-2
0.0mean 1,50000E-2 4,00000E-3 1,34000E0 8,35000E-1 3,70000E-2 4,00000E-1 4,56000E-1 8,00000E-2 4,00000E-1 8,70000E0 5,39000E-1 8,55000E-2 1,30000E-2
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML2,35777E-27,27119E-31,33106E06,02966E-11,52019E-13,73825E-14,58767E-17,50099E-23,97851E-18,24625E08,73836E-19,82556E-21,39100E-2
0.2ByoDyn2,35777E-27,27119E-31,33106E06,02966E-11,52019E-13,73825E-14,58767E-17,50099E-23,97851E-18,24625E08,73836E-19,82556E-21,39100E-2
0.2MathSBML2,35777E-27,27119E-31,33106E06,02966E-11,52019E-13,73825E-14,58767E-17,50099E-23,97851E-18,24625E08,73836E-19,82556E-21,39100E-2
0.2SBToolbox22,35777E-27,26425E-31,33101E06,02942E-11,52044E-13,73828E-14,58777E-17,50098E-23,97852E-18,24624E08,73880E-19,82291E-21,39103E-2
0.2SBWOdeSolver2,35777E-27,27121E-31,33106E06,02967E-11,52017E-13,73825E-14,58767E-17,50099E-23,97851E-18,24625E08,73833E-19,82559E-21,39101E-2
0.2VCell1,98757E-25,91898E-31,33105E07,13860E-19,79709E-23,72262E-14,58891E-17,49753E-23,97851E-18,24582E07,20568E-19,33228E-21,36921E-2
0.2copasi2,35777E-27,27119E-31,33106E06,02966E-11,52019E-13,73825E-14,58767E-17,50099E-23,97851E-18,24625E08,73836E-19,82556E-21,39100E-2
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner2,35777E-27,27119E-31,33106E06,02966E-11,52019E-13,73825E-14,58767E-17,50099E-23,97851E-18,24625E08,73836E-19,82556E-21,39100E-2
0.2min 1,98757E-2 5,91898E-3 1,33101E0 6,02942E-1 9,79709E-2 3,72262E-1 4,58767E-1 7,49753E-2 3,97851E-1 8,24582E0 7,20568E-1 9,33228E-2 1,36921E-2
0.2max 2,35777E-2 7,27121E-3 1,33106E0 7,13860E-1 1,52044E-1 3,73828E-1 4,58891E-1 7,50099E-2 3,97852E-1 8,24625E0 8,73880E-1 9,82559E-2 1,39103E-2
0.2mean 2,35777E-2 7,27119E-3 1,33106E0 6,02966E-1 1,52019E-1 3,73825E-1 4,58767E-1 7,50099E-2 3,97851E-1 8,24625E0 8,73836E-1 9,82556E-2 1,39100E-2
0.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML3,02396E-21,19986E-21,32058E04,29030E-11,82055E-13,46186E-14,64459E-17,02858E-23,95318E-17,81840E01,08705E01,26541E-11,65786E-2
0.4ByoDyn3,02396E-21,19986E-21,32058E04,29030E-11,82055E-13,46186E-14,64459E-17,02858E-23,95318E-17,81840E01,08705E01,26541E-11,65786E-2
0.4MathSBML3,02396E-21,19986E-21,32058E04,29030E-11,82055E-13,46186E-14,64459E-17,02858E-23,95318E-17,81840E01,08705E01,26541E-11,65786E-2
0.4SBToolbox23,02424E-21,19884E-21,32062E04,28950E-11,82102E-13,46185E-14,64513E-17,02863E-23,95316E-17,81843E01,08717E01,26488E-11,65730E-2
0.4SBWOdeSolver3,02395E-21,19986E-21,32058E04,29032E-11,82053E-13,46186E-14,64460E-17,02858E-23,95318E-17,81840E01,08705E01,26541E-11,65786E-2
0.4VCell2,40499E-28,76493E-31,32054E06,12533E-11,22670E-13,44104E-14,64226E-17,01878E-23,95315E-17,81720E08,59752E-11,09967E-11,53932E-2
0.4copasi3,02396E-21,19986E-21,32058E04,29030E-11,82055E-13,46186E-14,64459E-17,02858E-23,95318E-17,81840E01,08705E01,26541E-11,65786E-2
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner3,02396E-21,19986E-21,32058E04,29030E-11,82055E-13,46186E-14,64459E-17,02858E-23,95318E-17,81840E01,08705E01,26541E-11,65786E-2
0.4min 2,40499E-2 8,76493E-3 1,32054E0 4,28950E-1 1,22670E-1 3,44104E-1 4,64226E-1 7,01878E-2 3,95315E-1 7,81720E0 8,59752E-1 1,09967E-1 1,53932E-2
0.4max 3,02424E-2 1,19986E-2 1,32062E0 6,12533E-1 1,82102E-1 3,46186E-1 4,64513E-1 7,02863E-2 3,95318E-1 7,81843E0 1,08717E0 1,26541E-1 1,65786E-2
0.4mean 3,02396E-2 1,19986E-2 1,32058E0 4,29030E-1 1,82055E-1 3,46186E-1 4,64459E-1 7,02858E-2 3,95318E-1 7,81840E0 1,08705E0 1,26541E-1 1,65786E-2
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML3,43689E-21,53019E-21,30869E03,01197E-11,70876E-13,19784E-14,76838E-16,57194E-23,92378E-17,41921E01,21405E01,57281E-12,07031E-2
0.6ByoDyn3,43689E-21,53019E-21,30869E03,01197E-11,70876E-13,19784E-14,76838E-16,57194E-23,92378E-17,41921E01,21405E01,57281E-12,07031E-2
0.6MathSBML3,43689E-21,53019E-21,30869E03,01197E-11,70876E-13,19784E-14,76838E-16,57194E-23,92378E-17,41921E01,21405E01,57281E-12,07031E-2
0.6SBToolbox23,43785E-21,52959E-21,30874E03,00968E-11,71014E-13,19776E-14,76943E-16,57205E-23,92380E-17,41935E01,21442E01,57191E-12,06824E-2
0.6SBWOdeSolver3,43688E-21,53018E-21,30869E03,01200E-11,70875E-13,19784E-14,76839E-16,57195E-23,92378E-17,41921E01,21405E01,57280E-12,07031E-2
0.6VCell2,72721E-21,11209E-21,30861E05,28535E-11,26136E-13,17578E-14,74573E-16,55601E-23,92368E-17,41619E09,65295E-11,29385E-11,80393E-2
0.6copasi3,43689E-21,53019E-21,30869E03,01197E-11,70876E-13,19784E-14,76838E-16,57194E-23,92378E-17,41921E01,21405E01,57281E-12,07031E-2
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner3,43689E-21,53019E-21,30869E03,01197E-11,70876E-13,19784E-14,76838E-16,57194E-23,92378E-17,41921E01,21405E01,57281E-12,07031E-2
0.6min 2,72721E-2 1,11209E-2 1,30861E0 3,00968E-1 1,26136E-1 3,17578E-1 4,74573E-1 6,55601E-2 3,92368E-1 7,41619E0 9,65295E-1 1,29385E-1 1,80393E-2
0.6max 3,43785E-2 1,53019E-2 1,30874E0 5,28535E-1 1,71014E-1 3,19784E-1 4,76943E-1 6,57205E-2 3,92380E-1 7,41935E0 1,21442E0 1,57281E-1 2,07031E-2
0.6mean 3,43689E-2 1,53019E-2 1,30869E0 3,01197E-1 1,70876E-1 3,19784E-1 4,76838E-1 6,57194E-2 3,92378E-1 7,41921E0 1,21405E0 1,57281E-1 2,07031E-2
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML3,66560E-21,67154E-21,29550E02,09031E-11,44953E-12,95757E-14,95728E-16,13058E-23,89033E-17,05349E01,28005E01,84280E-12,53891E-2
0.8ByoDyn3,66560E-21,67154E-21,29550E02,09031E-11,44953E-12,95757E-14,95728E-16,13058E-23,89033E-17,05349E01,28005E01,84280E-12,53891E-2
0.8MathSBML3,66560E-21,67154E-21,29550E02,09031E-11,44953E-12,95757E-14,95728E-16,13058E-23,89033E-17,05349E01,28005E01,84280E-12,53891E-2
0.8SBToolbox23,66686E-21,67204E-21,29546E02,08722E-11,45043E-12,95741E-14,95845E-16,13073E-23,89034E-17,05379E01,28043E01,84222E-12,53603E-2
0.8SBWOdeSolver3,66559E-21,67152E-21,29550E02,09033E-11,44953E-12,95757E-14,95728E-16,13058E-23,89033E-17,05350E01,28004E01,84279E-12,53891E-2
0.8VCell2,97111E-21,25868E-21,29535E04,59509E-11,18941E-12,93511E-14,90491E-16,10952E-23,89011E-17,04661E01,04384E01,48393E-12,12202E-2
0.8copasi3,66560E-21,67154E-21,29550E02,09031E-11,44953E-12,95757E-14,95728E-16,13058E-23,89033E-17,05349E01,28005E01,84280E-12,53891E-2
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner3,66560E-21,67154E-21,29550E02,09031E-11,44953E-12,95757E-14,95728E-16,13058E-23,89033E-17,05349E01,28005E01,84280E-12,53891E-2
0.8min 2,97111E-2 1,25868E-2 1,29535E0 2,08722E-1 1,18941E-1 2,93511E-1 4,90491E-1 6,10952E-2 3,89011E-1 7,04661E0 1,04384E0 1,48393E-1 2,12202E-2
0.8max 3,66686E-2 1,67204E-2 1,29550E0 4,59509E-1 1,45043E-1 2,95757E-1 4,95845E-1 6,13073E-2 3,89034E-1 7,05379E0 1,28043E0 1,84280E-1 2,53891E-2
0.8mean 3,66560E-2 1,67154E-2 1,29550E0 2,09031E-1 1,44953E-1 2,95757E-1 4,95728E-1 6,13058E-2 3,89033E-1 7,05349E0 1,28005E0 1,84280E-1 2,53891E-2
0.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.0BioUML3,76250E-21,66568E-21,28107E01,43715E-11,17109E-12,74547E-15,18555E-15,70828E-23,85298E-16,72458E01,30338E02,05185E-12,98632E-2
1.0ByoDyn3,76250E-21,66568E-21,28107E01,43715E-11,17109E-12,74547E-15,18555E-15,70828E-23,85298E-16,72458E01,30338E02,05185E-12,98632E-2
1.0MathSBML3,76250E-21,66568E-21,28107E01,43715E-11,17109E-12,74547E-15,18555E-15,70828E-23,85298E-16,72458E01,30338E02,05185E-12,98632E-2
1.0SBToolbox23,76416E-21,66739E-21,28108E01,43325E-11,17184E-12,74539E-15,18601E-15,70856E-23,85300E-16,72486E01,30396E02,05171E-12,98309E-2
1.0SBWOdeSolver3,76249E-21,66567E-21,28107E01,43718E-11,17110E-12,74547E-15,18555E-15,70828E-23,85298E-16,72459E01,30338E02,05184E-12,98631E-2
1.0VCell3,15065E-21,32236E-21,28085E04,03252E-11,07479E-12,72205E-15,10557E-15,68288E-23,85259E-16,71168E01,10062E01,65469E-12,45126E-2
1.0copasi3,76250E-21,66568E-21,28107E01,43715E-11,17109E-12,74547E-15,18555E-15,70828E-23,85298E-16,72458E01,30338E02,05185E-12,98632E-2
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner3,76250E-21,66568E-21,28107E01,43715E-11,17109E-12,74547E-15,18555E-15,70828E-23,85298E-16,72458E01,30338E02,05185E-12,98632E-2
1.0min 3,15065E-2 1,32236E-2 1,28085E0 1,43325E-1 1,07479E-1 2,72205E-1 5,10557E-1 5,68288E-2 3,85259E-1 6,71168E0 1,10062E0 1,65469E-1 2,45126E-2
1.0max 3,76416E-2 1,66739E-2 1,28108E0 4,03252E-1 1,17184E-1 2,74547E-1 5,18601E-1 5,70856E-2 3,85300E-1 6,72486E0 1,30396E0 2,05185E-1 2,98632E-2
1.0mean 3,76250E-2 1,66568E-2 1,28107E0 1,43715E-1 1,17109E-1 2,74547E-1 5,18555E-1 5,70828E-2 3,85298E-1 6,72458E0 1,30338E0 2,05185E-1 2,98632E-2
1.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.2BioUML3,76671E-21,57041E-21,26552E09,80946E-29,26099E-22,56210E-15,42842E-15,31005E-23,81194E-16,43334E01,29731E02,19530E-13,36542E-2
1.2ByoDyn3,76671E-21,57041E-21,26552E09,80946E-29,26099E-22,56210E-15,42842E-15,31005E-23,81194E-16,43334E01,29731E02,19530E-13,36542E-2
1.2MathSBML3,76671E-21,57041E-21,26552E09,80946E-29,26099E-22,56210E-15,42842E-15,31005E-23,81194E-16,43334E01,29731E02,19530E-13,36542E-2
1.2SBToolbox23,76809E-21,57203E-21,26550E09,77484E-29,26148E-22,56202E-15,42834E-15,31032E-23,81195E-16,43364E01,29780E02,19563E-13,36296E-2
1.2SBWOdeSolver3,76670E-21,57040E-21,26552E09,80964E-29,26106E-22,56211E-15,42842E-15,31005E-23,81194E-16,43335E01,29731E02,19529E-13,36541E-2
1.2VCell3,27747E-21,32461E-21,26519E03,57738E-19,52372E-22,53683E-15,32746E-15,28055E-23,81133E-16,41284E01,13982E01,79969E-12,76019E-2
1.2copasi3,76671E-21,57041E-21,26552E09,80946E-29,26099E-22,56210E-15,42842E-15,31005E-23,81194E-16,43334E01,29731E02,19530E-13,36542E-2
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner3,76671E-21,57041E-21,26552E09,80946E-29,26099E-22,56210E-15,42842E-15,31005E-23,81194E-16,43334E01,29731E02,19530E-13,36542E-2
1.2min 3,27747E-2 1,32461E-2 1,26519E0 9,77484E-2 9,26099E-2 2,53683E-1 5,32746E-1 5,28055E-2 3,81133E-1 6,41284E0 1,13982E0 1,79969E-1 2,76019E-2
1.2max 3,76809E-2 1,57203E-2 1,26552E0 3,57738E-1 9,52372E-2 2,56211E-1 5,42842E-1 5,31032E-2 3,81195E-1 6,43364E0 1,29780E0 2,19563E-1 3,36542E-2
1.2mean 3,76671E-2 1,57041E-2 1,26552E0 9,80946E-2 9,26099E-2 2,56210E-1 5,42842E-1 5,31005E-2 3,81194E-1 6,43334E0 1,29731E0 2,19530E-1 3,36542E-2
1.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.4BioUML3,70688E-21,43337E-21,24894E06,65945E-27,29985E-22,40589E-15,66993E-14,94033E-23,76746E-16,17874E01,27134E02,27758E-13,65632E-2
1.4ByoDyn3,70688E-21,43337E-21,24894E06,65945E-27,29985E-22,40589E-15,66993E-14,94033E-23,76746E-16,17874E01,27134E02,27758E-13,65632E-2
1.4MathSBML3,70688E-21,43337E-21,24894E06,65945E-27,29985E-22,40589E-15,66993E-14,94033E-23,76746E-16,17874E01,27134E02,27758E-13,65632E-2
1.4SBToolbox23,70819E-21,43482E-21,24893E06,62736E-27,29578E-22,40581E-15,66923E-14,94059E-23,76752E-16,17887E01,27174E02,27831E-13,65476E-2
1.4SBWOdeSolver3,70687E-21,43337E-21,24894E06,65960E-27,29992E-22,40590E-15,66993E-14,94034E-23,76746E-16,17875E01,27134E02,27757E-13,65630E-2
1.4VCell3,36118E-21,28798E-21,24851E03,21158E-18,39099E-22,37805E-15,55305E-14,90660E-23,76659E-16,14968E01,16479E01,91714E-13,03004E-2
1.4copasi3,70687E-21,43337E-21,24894E06,65945E-27,29984E-22,40589E-15,66993E-14,94033E-23,76746E-16,17874E01,27134E02,27758E-13,65632E-2
1.4edu.kgi.roadRunner3,70688E-21,43337E-21,24894E06,65945E-27,29985E-22,40589E-15,66993E-14,94033E-23,76746E-16,17874E01,27134E02,27758E-13,65632E-2
1.4min 3,36118E-2 1,28798E-2 1,24851E0 6,62736E-2 7,29578E-2 2,37805E-1 5,55305E-1 4,90660E-2 3,76659E-1 6,14968E0 1,16479E0 1,91714E-1 3,03004E-2
1.4max 3,70819E-2 1,43482E-2 1,24894E0 3,21158E-1 8,39099E-2 2,40590E-1 5,66993E-1 4,94059E-2 3,76752E-1 6,17887E0 1,27174E0 2,27831E-1 3,65632E-2
1.4mean 3,70688E-2 1,43337E-2 1,24894E0 6,65945E-2 7,29985E-2 2,40589E-1 5,66993E-1 4,94033E-2 3,76746E-1 6,17874E0 1,27134E0 2,27758E-1 3,65632E-2
1.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.6BioUML3,60370E-21,28658E-21,23146E04,50333E-25,81602E-22,27419E-15,90208E-14,60225E-23,71985E-15,95867E01,23216E02,30709E-13,85770E-2
1.6ByoDyn3,60370E-21,28658E-21,23146E04,50333E-25,81602E-22,27419E-15,90208E-14,60225E-23,71985E-15,95867E01,23216E02,30709E-13,85770E-2
1.6MathSBML3,60370E-21,28658E-21,23146E04,50333E-25,81602E-22,27419E-15,90208E-14,60225E-23,71985E-15,95867E01,23216E02,30709E-13,85770E-2
1.6SBToolbox23,60474E-21,28745E-21,23144E04,47776E-25,80952E-22,27408E-15,90099E-14,60248E-23,71988E-15,95873E01,23245E02,30795E-13,85690E-2
1.6SBWOdeSolver3,60369E-21,28658E-21,23146E04,50344E-25,81608E-22,27419E-15,90207E-14,60226E-23,71985E-15,95867E01,23216E02,30708E-13,85768E-2
1.6VCell3,40966E-21,23068E-21,23091E02,91931E-17,41789E-22,24330E-15,77027E-14,56392E-23,71869E-15,92043E01,17825E02,00770E-13,25251E-2
1.6copasi3,60370E-21,28658E-21,23146E04,50333E-25,81601E-22,27419E-15,90208E-14,60225E-23,71985E-15,95867E01,23216E02,30709E-13,85770E-2
1.6edu.kgi.roadRunner3,60370E-21,28658E-21,23146E04,50333E-25,81602E-22,27419E-15,90208E-14,60225E-23,71985E-15,95867E01,23216E02,30709E-13,85770E-2
1.6min 3,40966E-2 1,23068E-2 1,23091E0 4,47776E-2 5,80952E-2 2,24330E-1 5,77027E-1 4,56392E-2 3,71869E-1 5,92043E0 1,17825E0 2,00770E-1 3,25251E-2
1.6max 3,60474E-2 1,28745E-2 1,23146E0 2,91931E-1 7,41789E-2 2,27419E-1 5,90208E-1 4,60248E-2 3,71988E-1 5,95873E0 1,23245E0 2,30795E-1 3,85770E-2
1.6mean 3,60370E-2 1,28658E-2 1,23146E0 4,50333E-2 5,81602E-2 2,27419E-1 5,90208E-1 4,60225E-2 3,71985E-1 5,95867E0 1,23216E0 2,30709E-1 3,85770E-2
1.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.8BioUML3,47191E-21,14845E-21,21320E03,03689E-24,73667E-22,16406E-16,12194E-14,29738E-23,66945E-15,77055E01,18447E02,29348E-13,97876E-2
1.8ByoDyn3,47191E-21,14845E-21,21320E03,03689E-24,73666E-22,16406E-16,12194E-14,29738E-23,66945E-15,77055E01,18447E02,29348E-13,97876E-2
1.8MathSBML3,47191E-21,14845E-21,21320E03,03689E-24,73667E-22,16406E-16,12194E-14,29738E-23,66945E-15,77055E01,18447E02,29348E-13,97876E-2
1.8SBToolbox23,47270E-21,14879E-21,21326E03,01608E-24,72899E-22,16392E-16,12067E-14,29749E-23,66947E-15,77045E01,18475E02,29447E-13,97853E-2
1.8SBWOdeSolver3,47191E-21,14845E-21,21320E03,03697E-24,73672E-22,16407E-16,12194E-14,29738E-23,66945E-15,77056E01,18446E02,29348E-13,97875E-2
1.8VCell3,42941E-21,16558E-21,21253E02,68694E-16,61908E-22,12977E-15,97218E-14,25401E-23,66795E-15,72245E01,18239E02,07332E-13,42665E-2
1.8copasi3,47191E-21,14845E-21,21320E03,03689E-24,73666E-22,16406E-16,12194E-14,29738E-23,66945E-15,77055E01,18447E02,29348E-13,97876E-2
1.8edu.kgi.roadRunner3,47191E-21,14845E-21,21320E03,03689E-24,73667E-22,16406E-16,12194E-14,29738E-23,66945E-15,77055E01,18447E02,29348E-13,97876E-2
1.8min 3,42941E-2 1,14845E-2 1,21253E0 3,01608E-2 4,72899E-2 2,12977E-1 5,97218E-1 4,25401E-2 3,66795E-1 5,72245E0 1,18239E0 2,07332E-1 3,42665E-2
1.8max 3,47270E-2 1,16558E-2 1,21326E0 2,68694E-1 6,61908E-2 2,16407E-1 6,12194E-1 4,29749E-2 3,66947E-1 5,77056E0 1,18475E0 2,29447E-1 3,97876E-2
1.8mean 3,47191E-2 1,14845E-2 1,21320E0 3,03689E-2 4,73667E-2 2,16406E-1 6,12194E-1 4,29738E-2 3,66945E-1 5,77055E0 1,18447E0 2,29348E-1 3,97876E-2
1.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.0BioUML3,32194E-21,02777E-21,19430E02,04404E-23,97678E-22,07270E-16,32939E-14,02590E-23,61660E-15,61171E01,13151E02,24622E-14,03329E-2
2.0ByoDyn3,32194E-21,02777E-21,19430E02,04404E-23,97678E-22,07270E-16,32939E-14,02590E-23,61660E-15,61171E01,13151E02,24622E-14,03329E-2
2.0MathSBML3,32194E-21,02777E-21,19430E02,04404E-23,97678E-22,07270E-16,32939E-14,02590E-23,61660E-15,61171E01,13151E02,24622E-14,03329E-2
2.0SBToolbox23,32256E-21,02772E-21,19430E02,02794E-23,96912E-22,07254E-16,32798E-14,02586E-23,61664E-15,61146E01,13166E02,24710E-14,03334E-2
2.0SBWOdeSolver3,32194E-21,02777E-21,19430E02,04410E-23,97683E-22,07270E-16,32939E-14,02591E-23,61660E-15,61171E01,13151E02,24622E-14,03328E-2
2.0VCell3,42579E-21,10083E-21,19348E02,50289E-15,98382E-22,03459E-16,15574E-13,97703E-23,61473E-15,55275E01,17900E02,11650E-13,55592E-2
2.0copasi3,32194E-21,02777E-21,19430E02,04403E-23,97678E-22,07270E-16,32939E-14,02590E-23,61660E-15,61171E01,13151E02,24622E-14,03329E-2
2.0edu.kgi.roadRunner3,32194E-21,02777E-21,19430E02,04404E-23,97678E-22,07270E-16,32939E-14,02590E-23,61660E-15,61171E01,13151E02,24622E-14,03329E-2
2.0min 3,32194E-2 1,02772E-2 1,19348E0 2,02794E-2 3,96912E-2 2,03459E-1 6,15574E-1 3,97703E-2 3,61473E-1 5,55275E0 1,13151E0 2,11650E-1 3,55592E-2
2.0max 3,42579E-2 1,10083E-2 1,19430E0 2,50289E-1 5,98382E-2 2,07270E-1 6,32939E-1 4,02591E-2 3,61664E-1 5,61171E0 1,17900E0 2,24710E-1 4,03334E-2
2.0mean 3,32194E-2 1,02777E-2 1,19430E0 2,04404E-2 3,97678E-2 2,07270E-1 6,32939E-1 4,02590E-2 3,61660E-1 5,61171E0 1,13151E0 2,24622E-1 4,03329E-2
2.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.2BioUML3,16116E-29,27301E-31,17488E01,37396E-23,45956E-21,99760E-16,52556E-13,78698E-23,56168E-15,47956E01,07557E02,17381E-14,03601E-2
2.2ByoDyn3,16116E-29,27301E-31,17488E01,37396E-23,45956E-21,99760E-16,52556E-13,78698E-23,56168E-15,47956E01,07557E02,17381E-14,03600E-2
2.2MathSBML3,16116E-29,27301E-31,17488E01,37396E-23,45956E-21,99760E-16,52556E-13,78698E-23,56168E-15,47956E01,07557E02,17381E-14,03600E-2
2.2SBToolbox23,16153E-29,26981E-31,17492E01,36188E-23,45262E-21,99735E-16,52419E-13,78686E-23,56172E-15,47912E01,07572E02,17460E-14,03620E-2
2.2SBWOdeSolver3,16116E-29,27306E-31,17488E01,37401E-23,45960E-21,99760E-16,52556E-13,78699E-23,56168E-15,47956E01,07557E02,17381E-14,03600E-2
2.2VCell3,40313E-21,04104E-21,17389E02,35784E-15,49052E-21,95511E-16,32045E-13,73203E-23,55939E-15,40826E01,16950E02,13995E-13,64604E-2
2.2copasi3,16116E-29,27301E-31,17488E01,37396E-23,45956E-21,99760E-16,52556E-13,78698E-23,56168E-15,47956E01,07557E02,17381E-14,03601E-2
2.2edu.kgi.roadRunner3,16116E-29,27301E-31,17488E01,37396E-23,45956E-21,99760E-16,52556E-13,78698E-23,56168E-15,47956E01,07557E02,17381E-14,03601E-2
2.2min 3,16116E-2 9,26981E-3 1,17389E0 1,36188E-2 3,45262E-2 1,95511E-1 6,32045E-1 3,73203E-2 3,55939E-1 5,40826E0 1,07557E0 2,13995E-1 3,64604E-2
2.2max 3,40313E-2 1,04104E-2 1,17492E0 2,35784E-1 5,49052E-2 1,99760E-1 6,52556E-1 3,78699E-2 3,56172E-1 5,47956E0 1,16950E0 2,17460E-1 4,03620E-2
2.2mean 3,16116E-2 9,27301E-3 1,17488E0 1,37396E-2 3,45956E-2 1,99760E-1 6,52556E-1 3,78698E-2 3,56168E-1 5,47956E0 1,07557E0 2,17381E-1 4,03600E-2
2.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.4BioUML2,99477E-28,46505E-31,15504E09,22719E-33,12279E-21,93662E-16,71203E-13,57904E-23,50505E-15,37169E01,01821E02,08354E-14,00050E-2
2.4ByoDyn2,99477E-28,46505E-31,15504E09,22719E-33,12279E-21,93662E-16,71203E-13,57904E-23,50505E-15,37169E01,01821E02,08354E-14,00050E-2
2.4MathSBML2,99477E-28,46505E-31,15504E09,22719E-33,12279E-21,93662E-16,71203E-13,57904E-23,50505E-15,37169E01,01821E02,08354E-14,00050E-2
2.4SBToolbox22,99502E-28,46014E-31,15504E09,13436E-33,11659E-21,93635E-16,71062E-13,57883E-23,50510E-15,37115E01,01830E02,08418E-14,00070E-2
2.4SBWOdeSolver2,99477E-28,46509E-31,15504E09,22752E-33,12282E-21,93662E-16,71203E-13,57904E-23,50505E-15,37169E01,01821E02,08354E-14,00050E-2
2.4VCell3,36511E-29,88425E-31,15387E02,24362E-15,11667E-21,88896E-16,46740E-13,51729E-23,50228E-15,28603E01,15512E02,14635E-13,70354E-2
2.4copasi2,99477E-28,46505E-31,15504E09,22719E-33,12279E-21,93662E-16,71203E-13,57904E-23,50505E-15,37169E01,01821E02,08354E-14,00050E-2
2.4edu.kgi.roadRunner2,99477E-28,46505E-31,15504E09,22719E-33,12279E-21,93662E-16,71203E-13,57904E-23,50505E-15,37169E01,01821E02,08354E-14,00050E-2
2.4min 2,99477E-2 8,46014E-3 1,15387E0 9,13436E-3 3,11659E-2 1,88896E-1 6,46740E-1 3,51729E-2 3,50228E-1 5,28603E0 1,01821E0 2,08354E-1 3,70354E-2
2.4max 3,36511E-2 9,88425E-3 1,15504E0 2,24362E-1 5,11667E-2 1,93662E-1 6,71203E-1 3,57904E-2 3,50510E-1 5,37169E0 1,15512E0 2,14635E-1 4,00070E-2
2.4mean 2,99477E-2 8,46505E-3 1,15504E0 9,22719E-3 3,12279E-2 1,93662E-1 6,71203E-1 3,57904E-2 3,50505E-1 5,37169E0 1,01821E0 2,08354E-1 4,00050E-2
2.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.6BioUML2,82647E-27,83275E-31,13490E06,19297E-32,91889E-21,88795E-16,89041E-13,40007E-23,44704E-15,28591E09,60550E-11,98139E-13,93844E-2
2.6ByoDyn2,82647E-27,83275E-31,13490E06,19298E-32,91889E-21,88795E-16,89041E-13,40007E-23,44704E-15,28591E09,60550E-11,98139E-13,93844E-2
2.6MathSBML2,82647E-27,83275E-31,13490E06,19297E-32,91889E-21,88795E-16,89041E-13,40007E-23,44704E-15,28591E09,60550E-11,98139E-13,93844E-2
2.6SBToolbox22,82658E-27,82713E-31,13496E06,12568E-32,91375E-21,88765E-16,88904E-13,39976E-23,44708E-15,28529E09,60579E-11,98188E-13,93854E-2
2.6SBWOdeSolver2,82647E-27,83278E-31,13490E06,19321E-32,91891E-21,88795E-16,89041E-13,40008E-23,44704E-15,28591E09,60550E-11,98139E-13,93843E-2
2.6VCell3,31476E-29,43726E-31,13352E02,15384E-14,84037E-21,83410E-16,59854E-13,33057E-23,44374E-15,18334E01,13682E02,13829E-13,73491E-2
2.6copasi2,82647E-27,83275E-31,13490E06,19297E-32,91889E-21,88795E-16,89041E-13,40007E-23,44704E-15,28591E09,60550E-11,98139E-13,93844E-2
2.6edu.kgi.roadRunner2,82647E-27,83275E-31,13490E06,19297E-32,91889E-21,88795E-16,89041E-13,40007E-23,44704E-15,28591E09,60550E-11,98139E-13,93844E-2
2.6min 2,82647E-2 7,82713E-3 1,13352E0 6,12568E-3 2,91375E-2 1,83410E-1 6,59854E-1 3,33057E-2 3,44374E-1 5,18334E0 9,60550E-1 1,98139E-1 3,73491E-2
2.6max 3,31476E-2 9,43726E-3 1,13496E0 2,15384E-1 4,84037E-2 1,88795E-1 6,89041E-1 3,40008E-2 3,44708E-1 5,28591E0 1,13682E0 2,13829E-1 3,93854E-2
2.6mean 2,82647E-2 7,83275E-3 1,13490E0 6,19297E-3 2,91889E-2 1,88795E-1 6,89041E-1 3,40007E-2 3,44704E-1 5,28591E0 9,60550E-1 1,98139E-1 3,93844E-2
2.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.8BioUML2,65890E-27,34991E-31,11456E04,15479E-32,81272E-21,85009E-17,06216E-13,24787E-23,38798E-15,22022E09,03377E-11,87215E-13,85928E-2
2.8ByoDyn2,65890E-27,34991E-31,11456E04,15480E-32,81272E-21,85009E-17,06216E-13,24787E-23,38798E-15,22022E09,03377E-11,87215E-13,85928E-2
2.8MathSBML2,65890E-27,34991E-31,11456E04,15477E-32,81272E-21,85009E-17,06216E-13,24787E-23,38798E-15,22022E09,03377E-11,87215E-13,85928E-2
2.8SBToolbox22,65895E-27,34405E-31,11458E04,10430E-32,80832E-21,84975E-17,06085E-13,24746E-23,38804E-15,21948E09,03385E-11,87254E-13,85920E-2
2.8SBWOdeSolver2,65890E-27,34994E-31,11456E04,15496E-32,81273E-21,85009E-17,06216E-13,24788E-23,38798E-15,22023E09,03377E-11,87215E-13,85927E-2
2.8VCell3,25451E-29,06771E-31,11295E02,08360E-14,64258E-21,78881E-16,71622E-13,16938E-23,38409E-15,09779E01,11538E02,11809E-13,74604E-2
2.8copasi2,65891E-27,34991E-31,11456E04,15479E-32,81272E-21,85009E-17,06216E-13,24787E-23,38798E-15,22022E09,03377E-11,87215E-13,85928E-2
2.8edu.kgi.roadRunner2,65890E-27,34991E-31,11456E04,15479E-32,81272E-21,85009E-17,06216E-13,24787E-23,38798E-15,22022E09,03377E-11,87215E-13,85928E-2
2.8min 2,65890E-2 7,34405E-3 1,11295E0 4,10430E-3 2,80832E-2 1,78881E-1 6,71622E-1 3,16938E-2 3,38409E-1 5,09779E0 9,03377E-1 1,87215E-1 3,74604E-2
2.8max 3,25451E-2 9,06771E-3 1,11458E0 2,08360E-1 4,64258E-2 1,85009E-1 7,06216E-1 3,24788E-2 3,38804E-1 5,22023E0 1,11538E0 2,11809E-1 3,85928E-2
2.8mean 2,65890E-2 7,34991E-3 1,11456E0 4,15479E-3 2,81272E-2 1,85009E-1 7,06216E-1 3,24787E-2 3,38798E-1 5,22022E0 9,03377E-1 1,87215E-1 3,85928E-2
2.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.0BioUML2,49398E-26,99081E-31,09411E02,78663E-32,77888E-21,82177E-17,22854E-13,12020E-23,32817E-15,17285E08,47256E-11,75953E-13,77045E-2
3.0ByoDyn2,49398E-26,99081E-31,09411E02,78663E-32,77887E-21,82177E-17,22854E-13,12020E-23,32817E-15,17285E08,47256E-11,75953E-13,77045E-2
3.0MathSBML2,49398E-2