Test: BIOMD0000000061.xml - Ok


test: BIOMD0000000061.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: Imex
generated code: BIOMD0000000061.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-10
ATOL 1.0E-10
RTOL 1.0E-6
STEP 1.0E-4

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000061.gif


Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL6624167348.JPG


Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: CNX  EtOH  G6P  NADH  GAP  ATP  FBP  AMP  GlycX  ACA  PEP  Glyc  ACAX  BPG  F6P  EtOHX  GlcX  ADP  NAD  DHAP  Pyr  Glc 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  Jarnac  SBToolbox2  VCell  Oscill8 Core  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  jsim  BioUML 
timeresult CNX EtOH G6P NADH GAP ATP FBP AMP GlycX ACA PEP Glyc ACAX BPG F6P EtOHX GlcX ADP NAD DHAP Pyr Glc
0.0BioUML5,20358E01,92379E14,20000E03,30000E-11,15000E-12,10000E04,64000E03,30000E-11,68478E01,48153E04,00000E-24,19600E01,28836E02,70000E-44,90000E-11,64514E16,70000E01,50000E06,50000E-12,95000E08,70000E05,73074E-1
0.0ByoDyn5,20358E01,92379E14,20000E03,30000E-11,15000E-12,10000E04,64000E03,30000E-11,68478E01,48153E04,00000E-24,19600E01,28836E02,70000E-44,90000E-11,64514E16,70000E01,50000E06,50000E-12,95000E08,70000E05,73074E-1
0.0Jarnac5,20358E01,92379E14,20000E03,30000E-11,15000E-12,10000E04,64000E03,30000E-11,68478E01,48153E04,00000E-24,19600E01,28836E02,70000E-44,90000E-11,64514E16,70000E01,50000E06,50000E-12,95000E08,70000E05,73074E-1
0.0MathSBML5,20358E01,92379E14,20000E03,30000E-11,15000E-12,10000E04,64000E03,30000E-11,68478E01,48153E04,00000E-24,19600E01,28836E02,70000E-44,90000E-11,64514E16,70000E01,50000E06,50000E-12,95000E08,70000E05,73074E-1
0.0Oscill8 Core5,20358E01,92379E14,20000E0-1,15000E-1-4,64000E03,30000E-11,68478E01,48153E04,00000E-24,19600E01,28836E02,70000E-44,90000E-11,64514E16,70000E01,50000E06,50000E-12,95000E08,70000E05,73074E-1
0.0SBToolbox25,20360E01,92380E14,20000E03,30000E-11,15000E-12,10000E04,64000E03,30000E-11,68480E01,48150E04,00000E-24,19600E01,28840E02,70000E-44,90000E-11,64510E16,70000E01,50000E06,50000E-12,95000E08,70000E05,73070E-1
0.0SBWOdeSolver5,20358E01,92379E14,20000E03,30000E-11,15000E-12,10000E04,64000E03,30000E-11,68478E01,48153E04,00000E-24,19600E01,28836E02,70000E-44,90000E-11,64514E16,70000E01,50000E06,50000E-12,95000E08,70000E05,73074E-1
0.0VCell5,20358E01,92379E14,20000E03,30000E-11,15000E-12,10000E04,64000E03,30000E-11,68478E01,48153E04,00000E-24,19600E01,28836E02,70000E-44,90000E-11,64514E16,70000E01,50000E06,50000E-12,95000E08,70000E05,73074E-1
0.0copasi5,20358E01,92379E14,20000E03,30000E-11,15000E-12,10000E04,64000E03,30000E-11,68478E01,48153E04,00000E-24,19600E01,28836E02,70000E-44,90000E-11,64514E16,70000E01,50000E06,50000E-12,95000E08,70000E05,73074E-1
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner5,20358E01,92379E14,20000E03,30000E-11,15000E-12,10000E04,64000E03,30000E-11,68478E01,48153E04,00000E-24,19600E01,28836E02,70000E-44,90000E-11,64514E16,70000E01,50000E06,50000E-12,95000E08,70000E05,73074E-1
0.0jsim5,20358E01,92379E14,20000E03,30000E-11,15000E-12,10000E04,64000E03,30000E-11,68478E01,48153E04,00000E-24,19600E01,28836E02,70000E-44,90000E-11,64514E16,70000E01,50000E06,50000E-12,95000E08,70000E05,73074E-1
0.0min 5,20358E0 1,92379E1 4,20000E0 3,30000E-1 1,15000E-1 2,10000E0 4,64000E0 3,30000E-1 1,68478E0 1,48150E0 4,00000E-2 4,19600E0 1,28836E0 2,70000E-4 4,90000E-1 1,64510E1 6,70000E0 1,50000E0 6,50000E-1 2,95000E0 8,70000E0 5,73070E-1
0.0max 5,20360E0 1,92380E1 4,20000E0 3,30000E-1 1,15000E-1 2,10000E0 4,64000E0 3,30000E-1 1,68480E0 1,48153E0 4,00000E-2 4,19600E0 1,28840E0 2,70000E-4 4,90000E-1 1,64514E1 6,70000E0 1,50000E0 6,50000E-1 2,95000E0 8,70000E0 5,73074E-1
0.0mean 5,20358E0 1,92379E1 4,20000E0 3,30000E-1 1,15000E-1 2,10000E0 4,64000E0 3,30000E-1 1,68478E0 1,48153E0 4,00000E-2 4,19600E0 1,28836E0 2,70000E-4 4,90000E-1 1,64514E1 6,70000E0 1,50000E0 6,50000E-1 2,95000E0 8,70000E0 5,73074E-1
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML5,20358E01,92560E14,10898E03,48611E-11,19827E-11,92314E05,00468E04,08747E-11,68482E01,46785E04,04959E-24,21658E01,28796E02,41447E-44,71655E-11,64517E16,66383E01,59811E06,31389E-13,05281E08,77828E02,74248E0
0.2ByoDyn5,20358E01,92560E14,10886E03,48641E-11,19826E-11,92247E05,00447E04,09064E-11,68482E01,46783E04,04962E-24,21645E01,28796E02,41337E-44,71613E-11,64517E16,66382E01,59846E06,31359E-13,05272E08,77798E02,74325E0
0.2Jarnac5,20358E01,92560E14,10886E03,48641E-11,19826E-11,92247E05,00447E04,09064E-11,68482E01,46783E04,04962E-24,21645E01,28796E02,41337E-44,71613E-11,64517E16,66382E01,59846E06,31359E-13,05272E08,77798E02,74325E0
0.2MathSBML5,20358E01,92560E14,10886E03,48641E-11,19826E-11,92247E05,00447E04,09064E-11,68482E01,46783E04,04962E-24,21645E01,28796E02,41337E-44,71613E-11,64517E16,66382E01,59846E06,31359E-13,05272E08,77798E02,74325E0
0.2Oscill8 Core5,20358E01,92560E14,10886E0-1,19826E-1-5,00447E04,09060E-11,68482E01,46783E04,04962E-24,21645E01,28796E02,41339E-44,71614E-11,64517E16,66382E01,59846E06,31360E-13,05272E08,77799E02,74324E0
0.2SBToolbox25,20360E01,92560E14,10923E03,48627E-11,19822E-11,92261E05,00397E04,08968E-11,68480E01,46782E04,04964E-24,21645E01,28800E02,41364E-44,71659E-11,64520E16,66380E01,59835E06,31373E-13,05261E08,77803E02,74433E0
0.2SBWOdeSolver5,20358E01,92560E14,10886E03,48640E-11,19826E-11,92248E05,00447E04,09060E-11,68482E01,46783E04,04962E-24,21645E01,28796E02,41339E-44,71614E-11,64517E16,66382E01,59846E06,31360E-13,05272E08,77799E02,74324E0
0.2VCell5,20358E01,92560E14,10886E03,48641E-11,19826E-11,92247E05,00447E04,09064E-11,68482E01,46783E04,04962E-24,21645E01,28796E02,41337E-44,71613E-11,64517E16,66382E01,59846E06,31359E-13,05272E08,77798E02,74325E0
0.2copasi5,20358E01,92560E14,10886E03,48641E-11,19826E-11,92247E05,00447E04,09064E-11,68482E01,46783E04,04962E-24,21645E01,28796E02,41337E-44,71613E-11,64517E16,66382E01,59846E06,31359E-13,05272E08,77798E02,74325E0
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner5,20358E01,92560E14,10886E03,48641E-11,19826E-11,92247E05,00447E04,09064E-11,68482E01,46783E04,04962E-24,21645E01,28796E02,41337E-44,71613E-11,64517E16,66382E01,59846E06,31359E-13,05272E08,77798E02,74325E0
0.2jsim5,20358E01,92560E14,10881E03,48644E-11,19828E-11,92246E05,00456E04,09066E-11,68482E01,46783E04,04964E-24,21645E01,28796E02,41336E-44,71607E-11,64517E16,66382E01,59847E06,31356E-13,05275E08,77801E02,74323E0
0.2min 5,20358E0 1,92560E1 4,10881E0 3,48627E-1 1,19822E-1 1,92246E0 5,00397E0 4,08968E-1 1,68480E0 1,46782E0 4,04962E-2 4,21645E0 1,28796E0 2,41336E-4 4,71607E-1 1,64517E1 6,66380E0 1,59835E0 6,31356E-1 3,05261E0 8,77798E0 2,74323E0
0.2max 5,20360E0 1,92560E1 4,10923E0 3,48644E-1 1,19828E-1 1,92261E0 5,00456E0 4,09066E-1 1,68482E0 1,46783E0 4,04964E-2 4,21645E0 1,28800E0 2,41364E-4 4,71659E-1 1,64520E1 6,66382E0 1,59847E0 6,31373E-1 3,05275E0 8,77803E0 2,74433E0
0.2mean 5,20358E0 1,92560E1 4,10886E0 3,48641E-1 1,19826E-1 1,92247E0 5,00447E0 4,09064E-1 1,68482E0 1,46783E0 4,04962E-2 4,21645E0 1,28796E0 2,41337E-4 4,71613E-1 1,64517E1 6,66382E0 1,59846E0 6,31359E-1 3,05272E0 8,77798E0 2,74325E0
0.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML5,20358E01,92752E14,02314E03,58244E-11,25864E-11,99207E05,49731E03,77181E-11,68517E01,45692E04,09162E-24,29237E01,28632E02,55711E-44,64986E-11,64534E16,66349E01,56075E06,21756E-13,20522E08,99297E02,80427E0
0.4ByoDyn5,20358E01,92752E14,02204E03,58313E-11,25888E-11,99175E05,49925E03,77301E-11,68517E01,45686E04,09180E-24,29242E01,28632E02,55652E-44,64844E-11,64534E16,66349E01,56095E06,21687E-13,20577E08,99311E02,80459E0
0.4Jarnac5,20358E01,92752E14,02204E03,58313E-11,25888E-11,99175E05,49925E03,77301E-11,68517E01,45686E04,09180E-24,29242E01,28632E02,55652E-44,64844E-11,64534E16,66349E01,56095E06,21687E-13,20577E08,99311E02,80459E0
0.4MathSBML5,20358E01,92752E14,02204E03,58313E-11,25888E-11,99175E05,49925E03,77301E-11,68517E01,45686E04,09180E-24,29242E01,28632E02,55652E-44,64844E-11,64534E16,66349E01,56095E06,21687E-13,20577E08,99311E02,80459E0
0.4Oscill8 Core5,20358E01,92752E14,02206E0-1,25888E-1-5,49921E03,77298E-11,68517E01,45687E04,09180E-24,29242E01,28632E02,55653E-44,64847E-11,64534E16,66349E01,56095E06,21688E-13,20576E08,99310E02,80458E0
0.4SBToolbox25,20360E01,92750E14,02022E03,58477E-11,25904E-11,98912E05,49991E03,78393E-11,68520E01,45680E04,09197E-24,29203E01,28630E02,55131E-44,64503E-11,64530E16,66350E01,56251E06,21523E-13,20574E08,99264E02,80491E0
0.4SBWOdeSolver5,20358E01,92752E14,02206E03,58312E-11,25888E-11,99175E05,49921E03,77300E-11,68517E01,45687E04,09180E-24,29242E01,28632E02,55653E-44,64847E-11,64534E16,66349E01,56095E06,21688E-13,20576E08,99310E02,80458E0
0.4VCell5,20358E01,92752E14,02204E03,58313E-11,25888E-11,99175E05,49925E03,77301E-11,68517E01,45686E04,09180E-24,29242E01,28632E02,55652E-44,64844E-11,64534E16,66349E01,56095E06,21687E-13,20577E08,99311E02,80459E0
0.4copasi5,20358E01,92752E14,02204E03,58313E-11,25888E-11,99175E05,49925E03,77301E-11,68517E01,45687E04,09180E-24,29242E01,28632E02,55652E-44,64844E-11,64534E16,66349E01,56095E06,21687E-13,20577E08,99311E02,80458E0
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner5,20358E01,92752E14,02204E03,58313E-11,25888E-11,99175E05,49925E03,77301E-11,68517E01,45686E04,09180E-24,29242E01,28632E02,55652E-44,64844E-11,64534E16,66349E01,56095E06,21687E-13,20577E08,99311E02,80459E0
0.4jsim5,20358E01,92752E14,02205E03,58313E-11,25888E-11,99176E05,49927E03,77280E-11,68517E01,45687E04,09181E-24,29243E01,28632E02,55650E-44,64844E-11,64534E16,66348E01,56096E06,21687E-13,20578E08,99314E02,80458E0
0.4min 5,20358E0 1,92750E1 4,02022E0 3,58312E-1 1,25888E-1 1,98912E0 5,49921E0 3,77280E-1 1,68517E0 1,45680E0 4,09180E-2 4,29203E0 1,28630E0 2,55131E-4 4,64503E-1 1,64530E1 6,66348E0 1,56095E0 6,21523E-1 3,20574E0 8,99264E0 2,80458E0
0.4max 5,20360E0 1,92752E1 4,02206E0 3,58477E-1 1,25904E-1 1,99176E0 5,49991E0 3,78393E-1 1,68520E0 1,45687E0 4,09197E-2 4,29243E0 1,28632E0 2,55653E-4 4,64847E-1 1,64534E1 6,66350E0 1,56251E0 6,21688E-1 3,20578E0 8,99314E0 2,80491E0
0.4mean 5,20358E0 1,92752E1 4,02204E0 3,58313E-1 1,25888E-1 1,99175E0 5,49925E0 3,77301E-1 1,68517E0 1,45686E0 4,09180E-2 4,29242E0 1,28632E0 2,55652E-4 4,64844E-1 1,64534E1 6,66349E0 1,56095E0 6,21687E-1 3,20577E0 8,99311E0 2,80459E0
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML5,20359E01,92652E14,29511E03,44512E-11,23835E-12,17137E05,34432E03,01375E-11,68600E01,46645E04,07614E-24,35113E01,28483E02,89589E-45,04254E-11,64551E16,66455E01,45725E06,35488E-13,17178E09,16781E02,74197E0
0.6ByoDyn5,20359E01,92652E14,29605E03,44434E-11,23834E-12,17281E05,34432E03,00812E-11,68600E01,46648E04,07607E-24,35136E01,28483E02,89890E-45,04438E-11,64551E16,66455E01,45638E06,35566E-13,17190E09,16815E02,74189E0
0.6Jarnac5,20359E01,92652E14,29605E03,44434E-11,23834E-12,17281E05,34432E03,00812E-11,68600E01,46648E04,07607E-24,35136E01,28483E02,89890E-45,04438E-11,64551E16,66455E01,45638E06,35566E-13,17190E09,16815E02,74189E0
0.6MathSBML5,20359E01,92652E14,29605E03,44434E-11,23834E-12,17281E05,34432E03,00812E-11,68600E01,46648E04,07607E-24,35136E01,28483E02,89890E-45,04438E-11,64551E16,66455E01,45638E06,35566E-13,17190E09,16815E02,74189E0
0.6Oscill8 Core5,20359E01,92652E14,29603E0-1,23834E-1-5,34432E03,00823E-11,68600E01,46648E04,07608E-24,35136E01,28483E02,89884E-45,04434E-11,64551E16,66455E01,45640E06,35565E-13,17190E09,16814E02,74190E0
0.6SBToolbox25,20360E01,92661E14,28892E03,44817E-11,23994E-12,17204E05,35697E03,01094E-11,68600E01,46606E04,07720E-24,35201E01,28481E02,89760E-45,03585E-11,64550E16,66450E01,45686E06,35183E-13,17563E09,17014E02,74397E0
0.6SBWOdeSolver5,20359E01,92652E14,29602E03,44436E-11,23834E-12,17277E05,34435E03,00825E-11,68600E01,46647E04,07608E-24,35136E01,28483E02,89883E-45,04432E-11,64551E16,66455E01,45640E06,35564E-13,17191E09,16815E02,74190E0
0.6VCell5,20359E01,92652E14,29605E03,44434E-11,23834E-12,17281E05,34432E03,00812E-11,68600E01,46648E04,07607E-24,35136E01,28483E02,89890E-45,04438E-11,64551E16,66455E01,45638E06,35566E-13,17190E09,16815E02,74189E0
0.6copasi5,20359E01,92652E14,29606E03,44433E-11,23834E-12,17282E05,34432E03,00809E-11,68600E01,46648E04,07607E-24,35136E01,28483E02,89891E-45,04439E-11,64551E16,66455E01,45638E06,35567E-13,17190E09,16815E02,74189E0
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner5,20359E01,92652E14,29605E03,44434E-11,23834E-12,17281E05,34432E03,00812E-11,68600E01,46648E04,07607E-24,35136E01,28483E02,89890E-45,04438E-11,64551E16,66455E01,45638E06,35566E-13,17190E09,16815E02,74189E0
0.6jsim5,20359E01,92652E14,29607E03,44433E-11,23834E-12,17282E05,34430E03,00806E-11,68600E01,46648E04,07608E-24,35137E01,28483E02,89892E-45,04441E-11,64551E16,66455E01,45637E06,35567E-13,17190E09,16818E02,74189E0
0.6min 5,20359E0 1,92652E1 4,28892E0 3,44433E-1 1,23834E-1 2,17204E0 5,34430E0 3,00806E-1 1,68600E0 1,46606E0 4,07607E-2 4,35136E0 1,28481E0 2,89760E-4 5,03585E-1 1,64550E1 6,66450E0 1,45637E0 6,35183E-1 3,17190E0 9,16814E0 2,74189E0
0.6max 5,20360E0 1,92661E1 4,29607E0 3,44817E-1 1,23994E-1 2,17282E0 5,35697E0 3,01094E-1 1,68600E0 1,46648E0 4,07720E-2 4,35201E0 1,28483E0 2,89892E-4 5,04441E-1 1,64551E1 6,66455E0 1,45686E0 6,35567E-1 3,17563E0 9,17014E0 2,74397E0
0.6mean 5,20359E0 1,92652E1 4,29605E0 3,44434E-1 1,23834E-1 2,17281E0 5,34432E0 3,00812E-1 1,68600E0 1,46648E0 4,07607E-2 4,35136E0 1,28483E0 2,89890E-4 5,04438E-1 1,64551E1 6,66455E0 1,45638E0 6,35566E-1 3,17190E0 9,16815E0 2,74189E0
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML5,20360E01,92612E14,35878E03,46600E-11,22096E-12,05468E05,19444E03,48808E-11,68701E01,46845E04,07093E-24,36056E01,28422E02,65768E-45,05112E-11,64561E16,66507E01,52651E06,33400E-13,11772E09,27668E02,70131E0
0.8ByoDyn5,20360E01,92611E14,35919E03,46585E-11,22086E-12,05455E05,19358E03,48853E-11,68701E01,46847E04,07086E-24,36050E01,28423E02,65733E-45,05148E-11,64561E16,66507E01,52660E06,33415E-13,11745E09,27651E02,70114E0
0.8Jarnac5,20360E01,92611E14,35919E03,46585E-11,22086E-12,05455E05,19358E03,48853E-11,68701E01,46847E04,07086E-24,36050E01,28423E02,65733E-45,05148E-11,64561E16,66507E01,52660E06,33415E-13,11745E09,27651E02,70114E0
0.8MathSBML5,20360E01,92611E14,35919E03,46585E-11,22086E-12,05455E05,19358E03,48853E-11,68701E01,46847E04,07086E-24,36050E01,28423E02,65733E-45,05148E-11,64561E16,66507E01,52660E06,33415E-13,11745E09,27651E02,70114E0
0.8Oscill8 Core5,20360E01,92611E14,35915E0-1,22087E-1-5,19365E03,48850E-11,68701E01,46847E04,07087E-24,36051E01,28423E02,65736E-45,05145E-11,64561E16,66507E01,52659E06,33414E-13,11747E09,27652E02,70116E0
0.8SBToolbox25,20360E01,92609E14,36838E03,45943E-11,21979E-12,06266E05,18550E03,45312E-11,68700E01,46894E04,06990E-24,36136E01,28420E02,67197E-45,06570E-11,64560E16,66510E01,52200E06,34057E-13,11562E09,27764E02,69950E0
0.8SBWOdeSolver5,20360E01,92611E14,35917E03,46585E-11,22086E-12,05457E05,19363E03,48844E-11,68701E01,46847E04,07086E-24,36051E01,28423E02,65739E-45,05148E-11,64561E16,66507E01,52658E06,33415E-13,11746E09,27652E02,70115E0
0.8VCell5,20360E01,92611E14,35919E03,46585E-11,22086E-12,05455E05,19358E03,48853E-11,68701E01,46847E04,07086E-24,36050E01,28423E02,65733E-45,05148E-11,64561E16,66507E01,52660E06,33415E-13,11745E09,27651E02,70114E0
0.8copasi5,20360E01,92611E14,35919E03,46585E-11,22086E-12,05454E05,19356E03,48855E-11,68701E01,46847E04,07086E-24,36050E01,28423E02,65732E-45,05149E-11,64561E16,66507E01,52660E06,33415E-13,11744E09,27651E02,70114E0
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner5,20360E01,92611E14,35919E03,46585E-11,22086E-12,05455E05,19358E03,48853E-11,68701E01,46847E04,07086E-24,36050E01,28423E02,65733E-45,05148E-11,64561E16,66507E01,52660E06,33415E-13,11745E09,27651E02,70114E0
0.8jsim5,20360E01,92611E14,35916E03,46587E-11,22086E-12,05453E05,19361E03,48862E-11,68701E01,46847E04,07086E-24,36051E01,28423E02,65729E-45,05144E-11,64561E16,66507E01,52661E06,33413E-13,11745E09,27654E02,70114E0
0.8min 5,20360E0 1,92609E1 4,35915E0 3,45943E-1 1,21979E-1 2,05453E0 5,18550E0 3,45312E-1 1,68700E0 1,46847E0 4,06990E-2 4,36050E0 1,28420E0 2,65729E-4 5,05144E-1 1,64560E1 6,66507E0 1,52200E0 6,33413E-1 3,11562E0 9,27651E0 2,69950E0
0.8max 5,20360E0 1,92611E1 4,36838E0 3,46587E-1 1,22087E-1 2,06266E0 5,19365E0 3,48862E-1 1,68701E0 1,46894E0 4,07087E-2 4,36136E0 1,28423E0 2,67197E-4 5,06570E-1 1,64561E1 6,66510E0 1,52661E0 6,34057E-1 3,11747E0 9,27764E0 2,70116E0
0.8mean 5,20360E0 1,92611E1 4,35919E0 3,46585E-1 1,22086E-1 2,05455E0 5,19358E0 3,48853E-1 1,68701E0 1,46847E0 4,07086E-2 4,36050E0 1,28423E0 2,65733E-4 5,05148E-1 1,64561E1 6,66507E0 1,52660E0 6,33415E-1 3,11745E0 9,27651E0 2,70114E0
0.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.0BioUML5,20362E01,92807E14,13129E03,60913E-11,27046E-11,97912E05,59395E03,82861E-11,68812E01,45581E04,10514E-24,39777E01,28300E02,54183E-44,76356E-11,64576E16,66447E01,56802E06,19087E-13,23156E09,48348E02,76303E0
1.0ByoDyn5,20362E01,92807E14,13020E03,60985E-11,27062E-11,97831E05,59514E03,83229E-11,68812E01,45576E04,10527E-24,39772E01,28300E02,54049E-44,76201E-11,64576E16,66447E01,56846E06,19015E-13,23187E09,48342E02,76328E0
1.0Jarnac5,20362E01,92807E14,13020E03,60985E-11,27062E-11,97831E05,59514E03,83229E-11,68812E01,45576E04,10527E-24,39772E01,28300E02,54049E-44,76201E-11,64576E16,66447E01,56846E06,19015E-13,23187E09,48342E02,76328E0
1.0MathSBML5,20362E01,92807E14,13020E03,60985E-11,27062E-11,97831E05,59514E03,83228E-11,68812E01,45576E04,10527E-24,39772E01,28300E02,54049E-44,76201E-11,64576E16,66447E01,56846E06,19015E-13,23187E09,48342E02,76328E0
1.0Oscill8 Core5,20362E01,92807E14,13024E0-1,27061E-1-5,59509E03,83214E-11,68812E01,45576E04,10526E-24,39772E01,28300E02,54054E-44,76207E-11,64576E16,66447E01,56844E06,19018E-13,23185E09,48342E02,76327E0
1.0SBToolbox25,20360E01,92800E14,13525E03,60841E-11,26898E-11,97418E05,58088E03,85085E-11,68810E01,45603E04,10438E-24,39643E01,28301E02,53257E-44,76579E-11,64580E16,66450E01,57077E06,19159E-13,22754E09,48050E02,76104E0
1.0SBWOdeSolver5,20362E01,92807E14,13025E03,60982E-11,27061E-11,97834E05,59507E03,83217E-11,68812E01,45576E04,10526E-24,39772E01,28300E02,54054E-44,76207E-11,64576E16,66447E01,56845E06,19018E-13,23185E09,48341E02,76327E0
1.0VCell5,20362E01,92807E14,13020E03,60985E-11,27062E-11,97831E05,59514E03,83229E-11,68812E01,45576E04,10527E-24,39772E01,28300E02,54049E-44,76201E-11,64576E16,66447E01,56846E06,19015E-13,23187E09,48342E02,76328E0
1.0copasi5,20362E01,92807E14,13018E03,60986E-11,27062E-11,97830E05,59516E03,83232E-11,68812E01,45576E04,10527E-24,39772E01,28300E02,54048E-44,76199E-11,64576E16,66447E01,56846E06,19014E-13,23187E09,48342E02,76329E0
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner5,20362E01,92807E14,13020E03,60985E-11,27062E-11,97831E05,59514E03,83229E-11,68812E01,45576E04,10527E-24,39772E01,28300E02,54049E-44,76201E-11,64576E16,66447E01,56846E06,19015E-13,23187E09,48342E02,76328E0
1.0jsim5,20362E01,92807E14,13018E03,60986E-11,27063E-11,97833E05,59519E03,83220E-11,68812E01,45576E04,10527E-24,39773E01,28300E02,54052E-44,76199E-11,64576E16,66447E01,56845E06,19014E-13,23188E09,48346E02,76329E0
1.0min 5,20360E0 1,92800E1 4,13018E0 3,60841E-1 1,26898E-1 1,97418E0 5,58088E0 3,83214E-1 1,68810E0 1,45576E0 4,10438E-2 4,39643E0 1,28300E0 2,53257E-4 4,76199E-1 1,64576E1 6,66447E0 1,56844E0 6,19014E-1 3,22754E0 9,48050E0 2,76104E0
1.0max 5,20362E0 1,92807E1 4,13525E0 3,60986E-1 1,27063E-1 1,97834E0 5,59519E0 3,85085E-1 1,68812E0 1,45603E0 4,10527E-2 4,39773E0 1,28301E0 2,54054E-4 4,76579E-1 1,64580E1 6,66450E0 1,57077E0 6,19159E-1 3,23188E0 9,48346E0 2,76329E0
1.0mean 5,20362E0 1,92807E1 4,13020E0 3,60985E-1 1,27062E-1 1,97831E0 5,59514E0 3,83229E-1 1,68812E0 1,45576E0 4,10527E-2 4,39772E0 1,28300E0 2,54049E-4 4,76201E-1 1,64576E1 6,66447E0 1,56846E0 6,19015E-1 3,23187E0 9,48342E0 2,76328E0
1.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.2BioUML5,20363E01,92791E14,24275E03,52426E-11,27030E-12,14408E05,60525E03,12323E-11,68953E01,45993E04,10117E-24,44584E01,28147E02,85533E-44,96834E-11,64597E16,66483E01,47360E06,27574E-13,24606E09,69895E02,75136E0
1.2ByoDyn5,20363E01,92792E14,24240E03,52434E-11,27044E-12,14451E05,60641E03,12136E-11,68953E01,45991E04,10124E-24,44598E01,28147E02,85618E-44,96815E-11,64597E16,66483E01,47336E06,27566E-13,24643E09,69925E02,75152E0
1.2Jarnac5,20363E01,92792E14,24240E03,52434E-11,27044E-12,14451E05,60641E03,12136E-11,68953E01,45991E04,10124E-24,44598E01,28147E02,85618E-44,96815E-11,64597E16,66483E01,47336E06,27566E-13,24643E09,69925E02,75152E0
1.2MathSBML5,20363E01,92792E14,24240E03,52434E-11,27044E-12,14451E05,60641E03,12136E-11,68953E01,45991E04,10124E-24,44598E01,28147E02,85618E-44,96815E-11,64597E16,66483E01,47336E06,27566E-13,24643E09,69925E02,75152E0
1.2Oscill8 Core5,20363E01,92792E14,24243E0-1,27043E-1-5,60634E03,12147E-11,68953E01,45991E04,10123E-24,44597E01,28147E02,85613E-44,96816E-11,64597E16,66483E01,47337E06,27567E-13,24640E09,69923E02,75151E0
1.2SBToolbox25,20360E01,92801E14,22513E03,53534E-11,27322E-12,13472E05,62838E03,16009E-11,68950E01,45912E04,10327E-24,44581E01,28150E02,83695E-44,94335E-11,64600E16,66479E01,47925E06,26466E-13,25213E09,70047E02,75546E0
1.2SBWOdeSolver5,20363E01,92792E14,24240E03,52435E-11,27043E-12,14447E05,60637E03,12153E-11,68953E01,45991E04,10123E-24,44597E01,28147E02,85612E-44,96812E-11,64597E16,66483E01,47338E06,27565E-13,24641E09,69923E02,75152E0
1.2VCell5,20363E01,92792E14,24240E03,52434E-11,27044E-12,14451E05,60641E03,12136E-11,68953E01,45991E04,10124E-24,44598E01,28147E02,85618E-44,96815E-11,64597E16,66483E01,47336E06,27566E-13,24643E09,69925E02,75152E0
1.2copasi5,20363E01,92792E14,24240E03,52434E-11,27044E-12,14452E05,60644E03,12130E-11,68953E01,45991E04,10124E-24,44598E01,28147E02,85621E-44,96815E-11,64597E16,66483E01,47335E06,27566E-13,24644E09,69926E02,75153E0
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner5,20363E01,92792E14,24240E03,52434E-11,27044E-12,14451E05,60641E03,12136E-11,68953E01,45991E04,10124E-24,44598E01,28147E02,85618E-44,96815E-11,64597E16,66483E01,47336E06,27566E-13,24643E09,69925E02,75152E0
1.2jsim5,20363E01,92792E14,24242E03,52433E-11,27043E-12,14452E05,60640E03,12121E-11,68953E01,45991E04,10125E-24,44599E01,28147E02,85616E-44,96816E-11,64597E16,66483E01,47336E06,27567E-13,24643E09,69929E02,75152E0
1.2min 5,20360E0 1,92792E1 4,22513E0 3,52433E-1 1,27043E-1 2,13472E0 5,60634E0 3,12121E-1 1,68950E0 1,45912E0 4,10123E-2 4,44581E0 1,28147E0 2,83695E-4 4,94335E-1 1,64597E1 6,66479E0 1,47335E0 6,26466E-1 3,24640E0 9,69923E0 2,75151E0
1.2max 5,20363E0 1,92801E1 4,24243E0 3,53534E-1 1,27322E-1 2,14452E0 5,62838E0 3,16009E-1 1,68953E0 1,45991E0 4,10327E-2 4,44599E0 1,28150E0 2,85621E-4 4,96816E-1 1,64600E1 6,66483E0 1,47925E0 6,27567E-1 3,25213E0 9,70047E0 2,75546E0
1.2mean 5,20363E0 1,92792E1 4,24240E0 3,52434E-1 1,27044E-1 2,14451E0 5,60641E0 3,12136E-1 1,68953E0 1,45991E0 4,10124E-2 4,44598E0 1,28147E0 2,85618E-4 4,96815E-1 1,64597E1 6,66483E0 1,47336E0 6,27566E-1 3,24643E0 9,69925E0 2,75152E0
1.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.4BioUML5,20366E01,92654E14,44276E03,43188E-11,22645E-12,14062E05,24576E03,13163E-11,69107E01,47005E04,07442E-24,44324E01,28089E02,82948E-45,19010E-11,64609E16,66560E01,47621E06,36812E-13,13924E09,81053E02,68733E0
1.4ByoDyn5,20366E01,92653E14,44435E03,43094E-11,22616E-12,14125E05,24349E03,12895E-11,69107E01,47013E04,07420E-24,44321E01,28089E02,83052E-45,19220E-11,64609E16,66561E01,47585E06,36906E-13,13859E09,81034E02,68693E0
1.4Jarnac5,20366E01,92653E14,44435E03,43094E-11,22616E-12,14125E05,24349E03,12895E-11,69107E01,47013E04,07420E-24,44321E01,28089E02,83052E-45,19220E-11,64609E16,66561E01,47585E06,36906E-13,13859E09,81034E02,68693E0
1.4MathSBML5,20366E01,92653E14,44435E03,43094E-11,22616E-12,14125E05,24349E03,12895E-11,69107E01,47013E04,07420E-24,44321E01,28089E02,83052E-45,19220E-11,64609E16,66561E01,47585E06,36906E-13,13859E09,81034E02,68693E0
1.4Oscill8 Core5,20366E01,92653E14,44425E0-1,22618E-1-5,24363E03,12911E-11,69107E01,47013E04,07422E-24,44321E01,28089E02,83046E-45,19207E-11,64609E1