Test BIOMD0000000064.xml details

Test: BIOMD0000000064.xml - Ok

test	: BIOMD0000000064.xml
model	: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine	: Imex
generated code	: BIOMD0000000064.java
results	: CSV file
plots	: -
comparison	: comparison with other simulators
status	: Ok
simulation time	: 1 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-15
ATOL 1.0E-8
RTOL 1.0E-5
STEP 1.0E-4

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000064.gif

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
- no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
- small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
- simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: GLCi PYR G6P NADH F16P T_PFK TRIO PEP R_PFK F6P BPG L_PFK ACE NAD P Lambda2 P2G Lambda1 P3G
Simulators: ByoDyn copasi edu.kgi.roadRunner SBToolbox2 VCell SBWOdeSolver MathSBML jsim BioUML

time

result

GLCi

PYR

G6P

NADH

F16P

T_PFK

TRIO

PEP

R_PFK

F6P

BPG

L_PFK

ACE

NAD

Lambda2

P2G

Lambda1

P3G

0.0

BioUML

8,70000E-2

1,85000E0

2,45000E0

3,90000E-1

5,51000E0

1,16022E1

9,60000E-1

7,00000E-2

1,22920E2

6,20000E-1

0,00000E0

2,88610E1

1,70000E-1

1,20000E0

6,31000E0

3,53407E0

1,20000E-1

6,20000E0

9,00000E-1

0.0

ByoDyn

8,70000E-2

1,85000E0

2,45000E0

3,90000E-1

5,51000E0

1,16022E1

9,60000E-1

7,00000E-2

1,22920E2

6,20000E-1

0,00000E0

2,88610E1

1,70000E-1

1,20000E0

6,31000E0

3,53407E0

1,20000E-1

6,20000E0

9,00000E-1

0.0

MathSBML

8,70000E-2

1,85000E0

2,45000E0

3,90000E-1

5,51000E0

9,60000E-1

7,00000E-2

6,20000E-1

0,00000E0

1,70000E-1

1,20000E0

6,31000E0

1,20000E-1

9,00000E-1

0.0

SBToolbox2

8,70000E-2

1,85000E0

2,45000E0

3,90000E-1

5,51000E0

1,16020E1

9,60000E-1

7,00000E-2

1,22920E2

6,20000E-1

0,00000E0

2,88610E1

1,70000E-1

1,20000E0

6,31000E0

3,53410E0

1,20000E-1

6,20000E0

9,00000E-1

0.0

SBWOdeSolver

8,70000E-2

1,85000E0

2,45000E0

3,90000E-1

5,51000E0

9,60000E-1

7,00000E-2

6,20000E-1

0,00000E0

1,70000E-1

1,20000E0

6,31000E0

1,20000E-1

9,00000E-1

0.0

VCell

8,70000E-2

1,85000E0

2,45000E0

3,90000E-1

5,51000E0

9,60000E-1

7,00000E-2

6,20000E-1

0,00000E0

1,70000E-1

1,20000E0

6,31000E0

1,20000E-1

9,00000E-1

0.0

copasi

8,70000E-2

1,85000E0

2,45000E0

3,90000E-1

5,51000E0

9,60000E-1

7,00000E-2

6,20000E-1

0,00000E0

1,70000E-1

1,20000E0

6,31000E0

1,20000E-1

9,00000E-1

0.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

8,70000E-2

1,85000E0

2,45000E0

3,90000E-1

5,51000E0

9,60000E-1

7,00000E-2

6,20000E-1

0,00000E0

1,70000E-1

1,20000E0

6,31000E0

1,20000E-1

9,00000E-1

0.0

jsim

8,70000E-2

1,85000E0

2,45000E0

3,90000E-1

5,51000E0

1,16022E1

9,60000E-1

7,00000E-2

1,22920E2

6,20000E-1

0,00000E0

2,88610E1

1,70000E-1

1,20000E0

6,31000E0

3,53407E0

1,20000E-1

6,20000E0

9,00000E-1

0.0

min

8,70000E-2

1,85000E0

2,45000E0

3,90000E-1

5,51000E0

1,16020E1

9,60000E-1

7,00000E-2

1,22920E2

6,20000E-1

0,00000E0

2,88610E1

1,70000E-1

1,20000E0

6,31000E0

3,53407E0

1,20000E-1

6,20000E0

9,00000E-1

0.0

max

8,70000E-2

1,85000E0

2,45000E0

3,90000E-1

5,51000E0

1,16022E1

9,60000E-1

7,00000E-2

1,22920E2

6,20000E-1

0,00000E0

2,88610E1

1,70000E-1

1,20000E0

6,31000E0

3,53410E0

1,20000E-1

6,20000E0

9,00000E-1

0.0

mean

8,70000E-2

1,85000E0

2,45000E0

3,90000E-1

5,51000E0

1,16022E1

9,60000E-1

7,00000E-2

1,22920E2

6,20000E-1

0,00000E0

2,88610E1

1,70000E-1

1,20000E0

6,31000E0

3,53407E0

1,20000E-1

6,20000E0

9,00000E-1

0.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0.2

BioUML

7,45557E-2

8,46166E0

3,10405E0

6,84296E-2

1,78693E0

1,56069E1

1,39204E0

2,59435E-1

1,27154E2

4,67746E-1

1,88929E-3

6,83824E1

1,10784E-1

1,52157E0

7,51062E0

4,86898E0

1,10778E-1

4,67746E0

7,82720E-1

0.2

ByoDyn

7,45621E-2

8,46365E0

3,10525E0

6,83995E-2

1,78571E0

1,56063E1

1,39159E0

2,59359E-1

1,27154E2

4,67779E-1

1,88831E-3

6,83021E1

1,10804E-1

1,52160E0

7,51045E0

4,86875E0

1,10773E-1

4,67779E0

7,82720E-1

0.2

MathSBML

7,45621E-2

8,46365E0

3,10525E0

6,83995E-2

1,78571E0

1,39159E0

2,59359E-1

4,67779E-1

1,88831E-3

1,10804E-1

1,52160E0

7,51045E0

1,10773E-1

7,82720E-1

0.2

SBToolbox2

7,45618E-2

8,46343E0

3,10561E0

6,83817E-2

1,78531E0

1,56068E1

1,39151E0

2,59385E-1

1,27159E2

4,67801E-1

1,88851E-3

6,82964E1

1,10804E-1

1,52166E0

7,51052E0

4,86878E0

1,10791E-1

4,67801E0

7,82816E-1

0.2

SBWOdeSolver

7,45619E-2

8,46356E0

3,10520E0

6,84008E-2

1,78576E0

1,39161E0

2,59362E-1

4,67778E-1

1,88834E-3

1,10803E-1

1,52160E0

7,51045E0

1,10773E-1

7,82720E-1

0.2

VCell

7,45621E-2

8,46365E0

3,10525E0

6,83995E-2

1,78571E0

1,39159E0

2,59359E-1

4,67779E-1

1,88831E-3

1,10804E-1

1,52160E0

7,51045E0

1,10773E-1

7,82720E-1

0.2

copasi

7,45621E-2

8,46365E0

3,10525E0

6,83995E-2

1,78571E0

1,39159E0

2,59359E-1

4,67779E-1

1,88831E-3

1,10804E-1

1,52160E0

7,51045E0

1,10773E-1

7,82719E-1

0.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,45621E-2

8,46365E0

3,10525E0

6,83995E-2

1,78571E0

1,39159E0

2,59359E-1

4,67779E-1

1,88831E-3

1,10804E-1

1,52160E0

7,51045E0

1,10773E-1

7,82720E-1

0.2

jsim

7,45621E-2

8,46365E0

3,10525E0

6,83996E-2

1,78571E0

1,56063E1

1,39159E0

2,59359E-1

1,27154E2

4,67779E-1

1,88832E-3

6,83023E1

1,10804E-1

1,52160E0

7,51045E0

4,86875E0

1,10773E-1

4,67779E0

7,82720E-1

0.2

min

7,45618E-2

8,46343E0

3,10520E0

6,83817E-2

1,78531E0

1,56063E1

1,39151E0

2,59359E-1

1,27154E2

4,67778E-1

1,88831E-3

6,82964E1

1,10803E-1

1,52160E0

7,51045E0

4,86875E0

1,10773E-1

4,67779E0

7,82719E-1

0.2

max

7,45621E-2

8,46365E0

3,10561E0

6,84008E-2

1,78576E0

1,56068E1

1,39161E0

2,59385E-1

1,27159E2

4,67801E-1

1,88851E-3

6,83023E1

1,10804E-1

1,52166E0

7,51052E0

4,86878E0

1,10791E-1

4,67801E0

7,82816E-1

0.2

mean

7,45621E-2

8,46365E0

3,10525E0

6,83995E-2

1,78571E0

1,56063E1

1,39159E0

2,59359E-1

1,27154E2

4,67779E-1

1,88831E-3

6,83021E1

1,10804E-1

1,52160E0

7,51045E0

4,86875E0

1,10773E-1

4,67779E0

7,82720E-1

0.2

relative error(%)

0,00

0,12

0,00

0.4

BioUML

7,70806E-2

1,04466E1

2,23362E0

4,77009E-2

1,08840E0

1,48130E1

1,06709E0

1,85923E-1

8,23594E1

3,12303E-1

1,16790E-3

2,98801E1

1,62617E-1

1,54230E0

7,29101E0

4,60432E0

8,70667E-2

3,12303E0

6,30664E-1

0.4

ByoDyn

7,70743E-2

1,04497E1

2,23313E0

4,76808E-2

1,08770E0

1,48138E1

1,06682E0

1,85885E-1

8,23331E1

3,12215E-1

1,16719E-3

2,98399E1

1,62668E-1

1,54232E0

7,29127E0

4,60460E0

8,70572E-2

3,12215E0

6,30618E-1

0.4

MathSBML

7,70743E-2

1,04497E1

2,23313E0

4,76808E-2

1,08770E0

1,06682E0

1,85885E-1

3,12215E-1

1,16719E-3

1,62668E-1

1,54232E0

7,29127E0

8,70572E-2

6,30618E-1

0.4

SBToolbox2

7,70710E-2

1,04500E1

2,23315E0

4,76794E-2

1,08759E0

1,48140E1

1,06677E0

1,85874E-1

8,23352E1

3,12209E-1

1,16706E-3

2,98449E1

1,62664E-1

1,54228E0

7,29147E0

4,60478E0

8,70573E-2

3,12209E0

6,30619E-1

0.4

SBWOdeSolver

7,70745E-2

1,04497E1

2,23314E0

4,76813E-2

1,08772E0

1,06683E0

1,85886E-1

3,12217E-1

1,16720E-3

1,62667E-1

1,54232E0

7,29126E0

8,70574E-2

6,30620E-1

0.4

VCell

7,70743E-2

1,04497E1

2,23313E0

4,76808E-2

1,08770E0

1,06682E0

1,85885E-1

3,12215E-1

1,16719E-3

1,62668E-1

1,54232E0

7,29127E0

8,70572E-2

6,30618E-1

0.4

copasi

7,70743E-2

1,04497E1

2,23313E0

4,76808E-2

1,08770E0

1,06682E0

1,85885E-1

3,12215E-1

1,16719E-3

1,62667E-1

1,54232E0

7,29127E0

8,70572E-2

6,30618E-1

0.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

7,70743E-2

1,04497E1

2,23313E0

4,76808E-2

1,08770E0

1,06682E0

1,85885E-1

3,12215E-1

1,16719E-3

1,62668E-1

1,54232E0

7,29127E0

8,70572E-2

6,30618E-1

0.4

jsim

7,70743E-2

1,04497E1

2,23313E0

4,76808E-2

1,08770E0

1,48138E1

1,06682E0

1,85885E-1

8,23332E1

3,12215E-1

1,16719E-3

2,98400E1

1,62667E-1

1,54232E0

7,29127E0

4,60460E0

8,70572E-2

3,12215E0

6,30618E-1

0.4

min

7,70710E-2

1,04497E1

2,23313E0

4,76794E-2

1,08759E0

1,48138E1

1,06677E0

1,85874E-1

8,23331E1

3,12209E-1

1,16706E-3

2,98399E1

1,62664E-1

1,54228E0

7,29126E0

4,60460E0

8,70572E-2

3,12209E0

6,30618E-1

0.4

max

7,70745E-2

1,04500E1

2,23315E0

4,76813E-2

1,08772E0

1,48140E1

1,06683E0

1,85886E-1

8,23352E1

3,12217E-1

1,16720E-3

2,98449E1

1,62668E-1

1,54232E0

7,29147E0

4,60478E0

8,70574E-2

3,12215E0

6,30620E-1

0.4

mean

7,70743E-2

1,04497E1

2,23313E0

4,76808E-2

1,08770E0

1,48138E1

1,06682E0

1,85885E-1

8,23332E1

3,12215E-1

1,16719E-3

2,98400E1

1,62668E-1

1,54232E0

7,29127E0

4,60460E0

8,70572E-2

3,12215E0

6,30618E-1

0.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0,12

0,00

0.6

BioUML

8,29307E-2

1,07290E1

1,56647E0

4,07255E-2

7,91900E-1

1,36354E1

8,98878E-1

1,24716E-1

5,05403E1

2,00863E-1

6,64920E-4

1,28987E1

1,91356E-1

1,54927E0

6,94921E0

4,21181E0

6,50795E-2

2,00863E0

4,85488E-1

0.6

ByoDyn

8,29310E-2

1,07302E1

1,56600E0

4,07184E-2

7,91668E-1

1,36351E1

8,98762E-1

1,24670E-1

5,05158E1

2,00781E-1

6,64380E-4

1,28826E1

1,91390E-1

1,54928E0

6,94915E0

4,21171E0

6,50634E-2

2,00781E0

4,85390E-1

0.6

MathSBML

8,29310E-2

1,07302E1

1,56600E0

4,07184E-2

7,91668E-1

8,98762E-1

1,24670E-1

2,00781E-1

6,64380E-4

1,91390E-1

1,54928E0

6,94915E0

6,50634E-2

4,85390E-1

0.6

SBToolbox2

8,29295E-2

1,07308E1

1,56590E0

4,07171E-2

7,91603E-1

1,36357E1

8,98729E-1

1,24654E-1

5,05115E1

2,00760E-1

6,64227E-4

1,28834E1

1,91399E-1

1,54929E0

6,94920E0

4,21173E0

6,50589E-2

2,00760E0

4,85363E-1

0.6

SBWOdeSolver

8,29311E-2

1,07302E1

1,56602E0

4,07187E-2

7,91680E-1

8,98768E-1

1,24672E-1

2,00785E-1

6,64400E-4

1,91388E-1

1,54928E0

6,94915E0

6,50642E-2

4,85396E-1

0.6

VCell

8,29310E-2

1,07302E1

1,56600E0

4,07184E-2

7,91668E-1

8,98762E-1

1,24670E-1

2,00781E-1

6,64380E-4

1,91390E-1

1,54928E0

6,94915E0

6,50634E-2

4,85390E-1

0.6

copasi

8,29310E-2

1,07303E1

1,56600E0

4,07184E-2

7,91668E-1

8,98761E-1

1,24670E-1

2,00781E-1

6,64379E-4

1,91390E-1

1,54928E0

6,94915E0

6,50634E-2

4,85390E-1

0.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

8,29310E-2

1,07302E1

1,56600E0

4,07184E-2

7,91668E-1

8,98762E-1

1,24670E-1

2,00781E-1

6,64380E-4

1,91390E-1

1,54928E0

6,94915E0

6,50634E-2

4,85390E-1

0.6

jsim

8,29310E-2

1,07302E1

1,56600E0

4,07184E-2

7,91669E-1

1,36351E1

8,98762E-1

1,24670E-1

5,05159E1

2,00781E-1

6,64380E-4

1,28826E1

1,91390E-1

1,54928E0

6,94915E0

4,21171E0

6,50635E-2

2,00781E0

4,85391E-1

0.6

min

8,29295E-2

1,07302E1

1,56590E0

4,07171E-2

7,91603E-1

1,36351E1

8,98729E-1

1,24654E-1

5,05115E1

2,00760E-1

6,64227E-4

1,28826E1

1,91388E-1

1,54928E0

6,94915E0

4,21171E0

6,50589E-2

2,00760E0

4,85363E-1

0.6

max

8,29311E-2

1,07308E1

1,56602E0

4,07187E-2

7,91680E-1

1,36357E1

8,98768E-1

1,24672E-1

5,05159E1

2,00785E-1

6,64400E-4

1,28834E1

1,91399E-1

1,54929E0

6,94920E0

4,21173E0

6,50642E-2

2,00781E0

4,85396E-1

0.6

mean

8,29310E-2

1,07302E1

1,56600E0

4,07184E-2

7,91668E-1

1,36351E1

8,98762E-1

1,24670E-1

5,05158E1

2,00781E-1

6,64380E-4

1,28826E1

1,91390E-1

1,54928E0

6,94915E0

4,21171E0

6,50634E-2

2,00781E0

4,85390E-1

0.6

relative error(%)

0,00

0,12

0,00

0.8

BioUML

8,99736E-2

1,01112E1

1,22913E0

3,86991E-2

6,69323E-1

1,25823E1

8,21584E-1

9,45503E-2

3,50261E1

1,45229E-1

4,50824E-4

7,00794E0

2,00363E-1

1,55130E0

6,62624E0

3,86077E0

5,35891E-2

1,45229E0

4,08191E-1

0.8

ByoDyn

8,99955E-2

1,01115E1

1,22789E0

3,86794E-2

6,68880E-1

1,25788E1

8,21315E-1

9,44463E-2

3,49675E1

1,45020E-1

4,49953E-4

6,98540E0

2,00471E-1

1,55132E0

6,62520E0

3,85961E0

5,35503E-2

1,45020E0

4,07936E-1

0.8

MathSBML

8,99955E-2

1,01115E1

1,22789E0

3,86794E-2

6,68880E-1

8,21315E-1

9,44463E-2

1,45020E-1

4,49953E-4

2,00471E-1

1,55132E0

6,62520E0

5,35503E-2

4,07936E-1

0.8

SBToolbox2

8,99940E-2

1,01121E1

1,22774E0

3,86756E-2

6,68820E-1

1,25784E1

8,21276E-1

9,44269E-2

3,49602E1

1,44988E-1

4,49781E-4

6,98464E0

2,00493E-1

1,55130E0

6,62515E0

3,85961E0

5,35444E-2

1,44988E0

4,07897E-1

0.8

SBWOdeSolver

8,99953E-2

1,01115E1

1,22791E0

3,86797E-2

6,68887E-1

8,21319E-1

9,44478E-2

1,45023E-1

4,49965E-4

2,00469E-1

1,55132E0

6,62522E0

5,35509E-2

4,07940E-1

0.8

VCell

8,99955E-2

1,01115E1

1,22789E0

3,86794E-2

6,68880E-1

8,21315E-1

9,44463E-2

1,45020E-1

4,49953E-4

2,00471E-1

1,55132E0

6,62520E0

5,35503E-2

4,07936E-1

0.8

copasi

8,99955E-2

1,01115E1

1,22789E0

3,86794E-2

6,68880E-1

8,21315E-1

9,44463E-2

1,45020E-1

4,49953E-4

2,00471E-1

1,55132E0

6,62520E0

5,35503E-2

4,07936E-1

0.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

8,99955E-2

1,01115E1

1,22789E0

3,86794E-2

6,68880E-1

8,21315E-1

9,44463E-2

1,45020E-1

4,49953E-4

2,00471E-1

1,55132E0

6,62520E0

5,35503E-2

4,07936E-1

0.8

jsim

8,99955E-2

1,01115E1

1,22789E0

3,86794E-2

6,68881E-1

1,25788E1

8,21315E-1

9,44463E-2

3,49675E1

1,45020E-1

4,49953E-4

6,98541E0

2,00471E-1

1,55132E0

6,62520E0

3,85961E0

5,35503E-2

1,45020E0

4,07937E-1

0.8

min

8,99940E-2

1,01115E1

1,22774E0

3,86756E-2

6,68820E-1

1,25784E1

8,21276E-1

9,44269E-2

3,49602E1

1,44988E-1

4,49781E-4

6,98464E0

2,00469E-1

1,55130E0

6,62515E0

3,85961E0

5,35444E-2

1,44988E0

4,07897E-1

0.8

max

8,99955E-2

1,01121E1

1,22791E0

3,86797E-2

6,68887E-1

1,25788E1

8,21319E-1

9,44478E-2

3,49675E1

1,45023E-1

4,49965E-4

6,98541E0

2,00493E-1

1,55132E0

6,62522E0

3,85961E0

5,35509E-2

1,45020E0

4,07940E-1

0.8

mean

8,99955E-2

1,01115E1

1,22789E0

3,86794E-2

6,68880E-1

1,25788E1

8,21315E-1

9,44463E-2

3,49675E1

1,45020E-1

4,49953E-4

6,98540E0

2,00471E-1

1,55132E0

6,62520E0

3,85961E0

5,35503E-2

1,45020E0

4,07936E-1

0.8

relative error(%)

0,00

0,11

0,17

0,14

0,19

0,32

0,00

0,14

0,00

1.0

BioUML

9,46057E-2

9,36252E0

1,10066E0

3,98228E-2

6,23519E-1

1,20093E1

7,91202E-1

8,19222E-2

2,92362E1

1,24129E-1

3,72786E-4

5,20710E0

1,92920E-1

1,55018E0

6,44325E0

3,66975E0

4,85714E-2

1,24129E0

3,73969E-1

1.0

ByoDyn

9,46498E-2

9,35796E0

1,09943E0

3,98145E-2

6,23084E-1

1,20039E1

7,90919E-1

8,18098E-2

2,91800E1

1,23924E-1

3,72001E-4

5,18983E0

1,92940E-1

1,55019E0

6,44155E0

3,66797E0

4,85277E-2

1,23924E0

3,73676E-1

1.0

MathSBML

9,46498E-2

9,35796E0

1,09943E0

3,98145E-2

6,23084E-1

7,90919E-1

8,18098E-2

1,23924E-1

3,72001E-4

1,92940E-1

1,55019E0

6,44155E0

4,85277E-2

3,73676E-1

1.0

SBToolbox2

9,46539E-2

9,35790E0

1,09917E0

3,98067E-2

6,23013E-1

1,20029E1

7,90879E-1

8,17890E-2

2,91707E1

1,23881E-1

3,71841E-4

5,18803E0

1,92974E-1

1,55021E0

6,44131E0

3,66772E0

4,85211E-2

1,23881E0

3,73631E-1

1.0

SBWOdeSolver

9,46495E-2

9,35799E0

1,09944E0

3,98146E-2

6,23087E-1

7,90921E-1

8,18106E-2

1,23925E-1

3,72006E-4

1,92940E-1

1,55019E0

6,44156E0

4,85280E-2

3,73678E-1

1.0

VCell

9,46498E-2

9,35796E0

1,09943E0

3,98145E-2

6,23084E-1

7,90919E-1

8,18098E-2

1,23924E-1

3,72001E-4

1,92940E-1

1,55019E0

6,44155E0

4,85277E-2

3,73676E-1

1.0

copasi

9,46498E-2

9,35796E0

1,09943E0

3,98145E-2

6,23084E-1

7,90919E-1

8,18098E-2

1,23924E-1

3,72001E-4

1,92940E-1

1,55019E0

6,44155E0

4,85277E-2

3,73676E-1

1.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,46498E-2

9,35796E0

1,09943E0

3,98145E-2

6,23084E-1

7,90919E-1

8,18098E-2

1,23924E-1

3,72001E-4

1,92940E-1

1,55019E0

6,44155E0

4,85277E-2

3,73676E-1

1.0

jsim

9,46496E-2

9,35795E0

1,09943E0

3,98142E-2

6,23084E-1

1,20039E1

7,90919E-1

8,18090E-2

2,91799E1

1,23923E-1

3,71994E-4

5,18985E0

1,92941E-1

1,55019E0

6,44155E0

3,66797E0

4,85275E-2

1,23923E0

3,73675E-1

1.0

min

9,46495E-2

9,35790E0

1,09917E0

3,98067E-2

6,23013E-1

1,20029E1

7,90879E-1

8,17890E-2

2,91707E1

1,23881E-1

3,71841E-4

5,18803E0

1,92940E-1

1,55019E0

6,44131E0

3,66772E0

4,85211E-2

1,23881E0

3,73631E-1

1.0

max

9,46539E-2

9,35799E0

1,09944E0

3,98146E-2

6,23087E-1

1,20039E1

7,90921E-1

8,18106E-2

2,91800E1

1,23925E-1

3,72006E-4

5,18985E0

1,92974E-1

1,55021E0

6,44156E0

3,66797E0

4,85280E-2

1,23924E0

3,73678E-1

1.0

mean

9,46498E-2

9,35796E0

1,09943E0

3,98145E-2

6,23084E-1

1,20039E1

7,90919E-1

8,18098E-2

2,91799E1

1,23924E-1

3,72001E-4

5,18983E0

1,92940E-1

1,55019E0

6,44155E0

3,66797E0

4,85277E-2

1,23923E0

3,73676E-1

1.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0,11

0,00

0,14

0,19

0,16

0,21

0,33

0,00

0,17

0,00

1.2

BioUML

9,67676E-2

8,85139E0

1,05500E0

4,17314E-2

6,07274E-1

1,17661E1

7,80158E-1

7,66283E-2

2,71825E1

1,16617E-1

3,43622E-4

4,62151E0

1,82661E-1

1,54827E0

6,36399E0

3,58869E0

4,64043E-2

1,16617E0

3,59057E-1

1.2

ByoDyn

9,67776E-2

8,84955E0

1,05480E0

4,17371E-2

6,07205E-1

1,17650E1

7,80114E-1

7,66055E-2

2,71729E1

1,16582E-1

3,43461E-4

4,61894E0

1,82630E-1

1,54826E0

6,36365E0

3,58835E0

4,63953E-2

1,16582E0

3,58997E-1

1.2

MathSBML

9,67776E-2

8,84955E0

1,05480E0

4,17371E-2

6,07205E-1

7,80114E-1

7,66055E-2

1,16582E-1

3,43461E-4

1,82630E-1

1,54826E0

6,36365E0

4,63953E-2

3,58997E-1

1.2

SBToolbox2

9,67848E-2

8,84866E0

1,05466E0

4,17334E-2

6,07135E-1

1,17640E1

7,80067E-1

7,65880E-2

2,71651E1

1,16555E-1

3,43346E-4

4,61696E0

1,82633E-1

1,54830E0

6,36339E0

3,58809E0

4,63883E-2

1,16555E0

3,58948E-1

1.2

SBWOdeSolver

9,67774E-2

8,84959E0

1,05480E0

4,17370E-2

6,07207E-1

7,80115E-1

7,66059E-2

1,16582E-1

3,43463E-4

1,82631E-1

1,54826E0

6,36366E0

4,63954E-2

3,58998E-1

1.2

VCell

9,67776E-2

8,84955E0

1,05480E0

4,17371E-2

6,07205E-1

7,80114E-1

7,66055E-2

1,16582E-1

3,43461E-4

1,82630E-1

1,54826E0

6,36365E0

4,63953E-2

3,58997E-1

1.2

copasi

9,67776E-2

8,84955E0

1,05480E0

4,17371E-2

6,07206E-1

7,80114E-1

7,66056E-2

1,16582E-1

3,43461E-4

1,82630E-1

1,54826E0

6,36365E0

4,63953E-2

3,58997E-1

1.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,67776E-2

8,84955E0

1,05480E0

4,17371E-2

6,07205E-1

7,80114E-1

7,66055E-2

1,16582E-1

3,43461E-4

1,82630E-1

1,54826E0

6,36365E0

4,63953E-2

3,58997E-1

1.2

jsim

9,67776E-2

8,84954E0

1,05480E0

4,17369E-2

6,07205E-1

1,17650E1

7,80114E-1

7,66054E-2

2,71729E1

1,16581E-1

3,43460E-4

4,61893E0

1,82630E-1

1,54826E0

6,36365E0

3,58835E0

4,63952E-2

1,16581E0

3,58997E-1

1.2

min

9,67774E-2

8,84866E0

1,05466E0

4,17334E-2

6,07135E-1

1,17640E1

7,80067E-1

7,65880E-2

2,71651E1

1,16555E-1

3,43346E-4

4,61696E0

1,82630E-1

1,54826E0

6,36339E0

3,58809E0

4,63883E-2

1,16555E0

3,58948E-1

1.2

max

9,67848E-2

8,84959E0

1,05480E0

4,17371E-2

6,07207E-1

1,17650E1

7,80115E-1

7,66059E-2

2,71729E1

1,16582E-1

3,43463E-4

4,61894E0

1,82633E-1

1,54830E0

6,36366E0

3,58835E0

4,63954E-2

1,16582E0

3,58998E-1

1.2

mean

9,67776E-2

8,84955E0

1,05480E0

4,17371E-2

6,07205E-1

1,17650E1

7,80114E-1

7,66055E-2

2,71729E1

1,16582E-1

3,43461E-4

4,61893E0

1,82630E-1

1,54826E0

6,36365E0

3,58835E0

4,63953E-2

1,16581E0

3,58997E-1

1.2

relative error(%)

0,00

1.4

BioUML

9,76408E-2

8,59283E0

1,03890E0

4,30784E-2

6,01733E-1

1,16719E1

7,76341E-1

7,44688E-2

2,64521E1

1,13955E-1

3,32559E-4

4,42047E0

1,76192E-1

1,54692E0

6,33301E0

3,55730E0

4,55025E-2

1,13955E0

3,52816E-1

1.4

ByoDyn

9,76709E-2

8,58430E0

1,03833E0

4,31193E-2

6,01540E-1

1,16687E1

7,76210E-1

7,43949E-2

2,64264E1

1,13860E-1

3,32156E-4

4,41348E0

1,75989E-1

1,54688E0

6,33196E0

3,55623E0

4,54718E-2

1,13860E0

3,52606E-1

1.4

MathSBML

9,76710E-2

8,58430E0

1,03833E0

4,31193E-2

6,01540E-1

7,76210E-1

7,43949E-2

1,13860E-1

3,32156E-4

1,75989E-1

1,54688E0

6,33196E0

4,54718E-2

3,52606E-1

1.4

SBToolbox2

9,76771E-2

8,58287E0

1,03817E0

4,31219E-2

6,01494E-1

1,16684E1

7,76177E-1

7,43799E-2

2,64202E1

1,13841E-1

3,32070E-4

4,41198E0

1,75964E-1

1,54690E0

6,33174E0

3,55604E0

4,54662E-2

1,13841E0

3,52568E-1

1.4

SBWOdeSolver

9,76709E-2

8,58432E0

1,03833E0

4,31192E-2

6,01540E-1

7,76210E-1

7,43951E-2

1,13860E-1

3,32157E-4

1,75989E-1

1,54688E0

6,33196E0

4,54719E-2

3,52607E-1

1.4

VCell

9,76709E-2

8,58430E0

1,03833E0

4,31193E-2

6,01540E-1

7,76210E-1

7,43949E-2

1,13860E-1

3,32156E-4

1,75989E-1

1,54688E0

6,33196E0

4,54718E-2

3,52606E-1

1.4

copasi

9,76710E-2

8,58431E0

1,03833E0

4,31193E-2

6,01540E-1

7,76210E-1

7,43949E-2

1,13860E-1

3,32156E-4

1,75989E-1

1,54688E0

6,33196E0

4,54718E-2

3,52606E-1

1.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,76709E-2

8,58430E0

1,03833E0

4,31193E-2

6,01540E-1

7,76210E-1

7,43949E-2

1,13860E-1

3,32156E-4

1,75989E-1

1,54688E0

6,33196E0

4,54718E-2

3,52606E-1

1.4

jsim

9,76710E-2

8,58430E0

1,03833E0

4,31193E-2

6,01540E-1

1,16687E1

7,76210E-1

7,43948E-2

2,64264E1

1,13860E-1

3,32156E-4

4,41348E0

1,75988E-1

1,54688E0

6,33196E0

3,55623E0

4,54718E-2

1,13860E0

3,52606E-1

1.4

min

9,76709E-2

8,58287E0

1,03817E0

4,31192E-2

6,01494E-1

1,16684E1

7,76177E-1

7,43799E-2

2,64202E1

1,13841E-1

3,32070E-4

4,41198E0

1,75964E-1

1,54688E0

6,33174E0

3,55604E0

4,54662E-2

1,13841E0

3,52568E-1

1.4

max

9,76771E-2

8,58432E0

1,03833E0

4,31219E-2

6,01540E-1

1,16687E1

7,76210E-1

7,43951E-2

2,64264E1

1,13860E-1

3,32157E-4

4,41348E0

1,75989E-1

1,54690E0

6,33196E0

3,55623E0

4,54719E-2

1,13860E0

3,52607E-1

1.4

mean

9,76709E-2

8,58430E0

1,03833E0

4,31193E-2

6,01540E-1

1,16687E1

7,76210E-1

7,43949E-2

2,64264E1

1,13860E-1

3,32156E-4

4,41348E0

1,75989E-1

1,54688E0

6,33196E0

3,55623E0

4,54718E-2

1,13860E0

3,52606E-1

1.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0,12

0,16

0,12

0,00

1.6

BioUML

9,80291E-2

8,46953E0

1,03213E0

4,38073E-2

5,99481E-1

1,16307E1

7,74782E-1

7,35038E-2

2,61432E1

1,12832E-1

3,27737E-4

4,33650E0

1,72882E-1

1,54619E0

6,31941E0

3,54356E0

4,50959E-2

1,12832E0

3,49997E-1

1.6

ByoDyn

9,80557E-2

8,46112E0

1,03166E0

4,38556E-2

5,99327E-1

1,16279E1

7,74676E-1

7,34372E-2

2,61218E1

1,12754E-1

3,27390E-4

4,33076E0

1,72660E-1

1,54614E0

6,31849E0

3,54263E0

4,50680E-2

1,12754E0

3,49804E-1

1.6

MathSBML

9,80557E-2

8,46112E0

1,03166E0

4,38556E-2

5,99327E-1

7,74676E-1

7,34372E-2

1,12754E-1

3,27390E-4

1,72660E-1

1,54614E0

6,31849E0

4,50680E-2

3,49804E-1

1.6

SBToolbox2

9,80619E-2

8,45907E0

1,03153E0

4,38628E-2

5,99283E-1

1,16272E1

7,74648E-1

7,34201E-2

2,61166E1

1,12735E-1

3,27306E-4

4,32933E0

1,72609E-1

1,54612E0

6,31826E0

3,54238E0

4,50612E-2

1,12735E0

3,49756E-1

1.6

SBWOdeSolver

9,80556E-2

8,46114E0

1,03166E0

4,38555E-2

5,99327E-1

7,74677E-1

7,34373E-2

1,12754E-1

3,27391E-4

1,72660E-1

1,54614E0

6,31849E0

4,50681E-2

3,49805E-1

1.6

VCell

9,80557E-2

8,46112E0

1,03166E0

4,38556E-2

5,99327E-1

7,74676E-1

7,34372E-2

1,12754E-1

3,27390E-4

1,72660E-1

1,54614E0

6,31849E0

4,50680E-2

3,49804E-1

1.6

copasi

9,80557E-2

8,46112E0

1,03166E0

4,38555E-2

5,99327E-1

7,74676E-1

7,34372E-2

1,12754E-1

3,27390E-4

1,72660E-1

1,54614E0

6,31849E0

4,50680E-2

3,49804E-1

1.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,80557E-2

8,46112E0

1,03166E0

4,38556E-2

5,99327E-1

7,74676E-1

7,34372E-2

1,12754E-1

3,27390E-4

1,72660E-1

1,54614E0

6,31849E0

4,50680E-2

3,49804E-1

1.6

jsim

9,80557E-2

8,46112E0

1,03166E0

4,38556E-2

5,99327E-1

1,16279E1

7,74676E-1

7,34372E-2

2,61218E1

1,12754E-1

3,27390E-4

4,33076E0

1,72660E-1

1,54614E0

6,31849E0

3,54263E0

4,50680E-2

1,12754E0

3,49804E-1

1.6

min

9,80556E-2

8,45907E0

1,03153E0

4,38555E-2

5,99283E-1

1,16272E1

7,74648E-1

7,34201E-2

2,61166E1

1,12735E-1

3,27306E-4

4,32933E0

1,72609E-1

1,54612E0

6,31826E0

3,54238E0

4,50612E-2

1,12735E0

3,49756E-1

1.6

max

9,80619E-2

8,46114E0

1,03166E0

4,38628E-2

5,99327E-1

1,16279E1

7,74677E-1

7,34373E-2

2,61218E1

1,12754E-1

3,27391E-4

4,33076E0

1,72660E-1

1,54614E0

6,31849E0

3,54263E0

4,50681E-2

1,12754E0

3,49805E-1

1.6

mean

9,80557E-2

8,46112E0

1,03166E0

4,38556E-2

5,99327E-1

1,16279E1

7,74676E-1

7,34372E-2

2,61218E1

1,12754E-1

3,27390E-4

4,33076E0

1,72660E-1

1,54614E0

6,31849E0

3,54263E0

4,50680E-2

1,12754E0

3,49804E-1

1.6

relative error(%)

0,00

0,11

0,00

0,11

0,13

0,00

1.8

BioUML

9,82067E-2

8,41242E0

1,02911E0

4,41639E-2

5,98496E-1

1,16120E1

7,74098E-1

7,30649E-2

2,60050E1

1,12331E-1

3,25557E-4

4,29918E0

1,71307E-1

1,54584E0

6,31322E0

3,53732E0

4,49104E-2

1,12331E0

3,48709E-1

1.8

ByoDyn

9,82248E-2

8,40657E0

1,02881E0

4,42004E-2

5,98398E-1

1,16101E1

7,74031E-1

7,30200E-2

2,59909E1

1,12280E-1

3,25326E-4

4,29544E0

1,71146E-1

1,54580E0

6,31260E0

3,53669E0

4,48914E-2

1,12280E0

3,48578E-1

1.8

MathSBML

9,82248E-2

8,40657E0

1,02881E0

4,42004E-2

5,98398E-1

7,74031E-1

7,30200E-2

1,12280E-1

3,25326E-4

1,71146E-1

1,54580E0

6,31260E0

4,48914E-2

3,48578E-1

1.8

SBToolbox2

9,82301E-2

8,40472E0

1,02872E0

4,42098E-2

5,98365E-1

1,16092E1

7,74005E-1

7,30055E-2

2,59867E1

1,12264E-1

3,25253E-4

4,29422E0

1,71099E-1

1,54580E0

6,31244E0

3,53654E0

4,48851E-2

1,12264E0

3,48537E-1

1.8

SBWOdeSolver

9,82247E-2

8,40657E0

1,02881E0

4,42004E-2

5,98398E-1

7,74031E-1

7,30200E-2

1,12280E-1

3,25326E-4

1,71146E-1

1,54580E0

6,31260E0

4,48914E-2

3,48578E-1

1.8

VCell

9,82248E-2

8,40657E0

1,02881E0

4,42004E-2

5,98398E-1

7,74031E-1

7,30200E-2

1,12280E-1

3,25326E-4

1,71146E-1

1,54580E0

6,31260E0

4,48914E-2

3,48578E-1

1.8

copasi

9,82248E-2

8,40656E0

1,02881E0

4,42004E-2

5,98397E-1

7,74031E-1

7,30199E-2

1,12280E-1

3,25326E-4

1,71146E-1

1,54580E0

6,31260E0

4,48914E-2

3,48577E-1

1.8

edu.kgi.roadRunner

9,82248E-2

8,40657E0

1,02881E0

4,42004E-2

5,98398E-1

7,74031E-1

7,30200E-2

1,12280E-1

3,25326E-4

1,71146E-1

1,54580E0

6,31260E0

4,48914E-2

3,48578E-1

1.8

jsim

9,82248E-2

8,40657E0

1,02881E0

4,42004E-2

5,98398E-1

1,16101E1

7,74031E-1

7,30200E-2

2,59909E1

1,12280E-1

3,25326E-4

4,29544E0

1,71146E-1

1,54580E0

6,31260E0

3,53669E0

4,48914E-2

1,12280E0

3,48578E-1

1.8

min

9,82247E-2

8,40472E0

1,02872E0

4,42004E-2

5,98365E-1

1,16092E1

7,74005E-1

7,30055E-2

2,59867E1

1,12264E-1

3,25253E-4

4,29422E0

1,71099E-1

1,54580E0

6,31244E0

3,53654E0

4,48851E-2

1,12264E0

3,48537E-1

1.8

max

9,82301E-2

8,40657E0

1,02881E0

4,42098E-2

5,98398E-1

1,16101E1

7,74031E-1

7,30200E-2

2,59909E1

1,12280E-1

3,25326E-4

4,29544E0

1,71146E-1

1,54580E0

6,31260E0

3,53669E0

4,48914E-2

1,12280E0

3,48578E-1

1.8

mean

9,82248E-2

8,40657E0

1,02881E0

4,42004E-2

5,98398E-1

1,16101E1

7,74031E-1

7,30200E-2

2,59909E1

1,12280E-1

3,25326E-4

4,29544E0

1,71146E-1

1,54580E0

6,31260E0

3,53669E0

4,48914E-2

1,12280E0

3,48578E-1

1.8

relative error(%)

0,00