Test BIOMD0000000070.xml details

Test: BIOMD0000000070.xml - Ok

test	: BIOMD0000000070.xml
model	: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine	: Imex
generated code	: BIOMD0000000070.java
results	: CSV file
plots	: -
comparison	: comparison with other simulators
status	: Ok
simulation time	: 174 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-10
ATOL 1.0E-10
RTOL 1.0E-4
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000070.gif

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
- no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
- small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
- simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: MgATP ATPf Gri13P2 Gri3P Sed7P MgGri23P2 PEP P2NADP Gri23P2f DHAP P2NADPH GlcA6P MgAMP P2f Phi Fru16P2 NADH GSH Rul5P P1NADPH GSSG NADPf Glcin Gri2P AMPf Glc6P ADPf NAD MgADP Fru6P P1f E4P Lac Mgf GraP Pyr Xul5P NADPHf P1NADP Rib5P
Simulators: ByoDyn copasi edu.kgi.roadRunner Jarnac SBToolbox2 Oscill8 Core SBWOdeSolver MathSBML jsim BioUML

time

result

MgATP

ATPf

Gri13P2

Gri3P

Sed7P

MgGri23P2

PEP

P2NADP

Gri23P2f

DHAP

P2NADPH

GlcA6P

MgAMP

P2f

Phi

Fru16P2

NADH

GSH

Rul5P

P1NADPH

GSSG

NADPf

Glcin

Gri2P

AMPf

Glc6P

ADPf

NAD

MgADP

Fru6P

P1f

E4P

Lac

Mgf

GraP

Pyr

Xul5P

NADPHf

P1NADP

Rib5P

0.0

BioUML

1,40000E0

2,50000E-1

5,00000E-4

6,58000E-2

1,54000E-2

5,00000E-1

1,09000E-2

0,00000E0

2,06010E0

1,49200E-1

2,40000E-2

2,50000E-2

0,00000E0

9,99200E-1

9,70000E-3

2,00000E-4

3,11360E0

4,70000E-3

2,40000E-2

4,00000E-4

0,00000E0

4,56630E0

0,00000E0

3,94000E-2

8,40000E-3

2,50000E-1

6,53000E-2

1,00000E-1

1,53000E-2

0,00000E0

6,30000E-3

1,68030E0

8,00000E-1

6,10000E-3

8,40000E-2

1,27000E-2

4,00000E-3

0,00000E0

1,40000E-2

0.0

ByoDyn

1,40000E0

2,50000E-1

5,00000E-4

6,58000E-2

1,54000E-2

5,00000E-1

1,09000E-2

0,00000E0

2,06010E0

1,49200E-1

2,40000E-2

2,50000E-2

0,00000E0

9,99200E-1

9,70000E-3

2,00000E-4

3,11360E0

4,70000E-3

2,40000E-2

4,00000E-4

0,00000E0

4,56630E0

0,00000E0

3,94000E-2

8,40000E-3

2,50000E-1

6,53000E-2

1,00000E-1

1,53000E-2

0,00000E0

6,30000E-3

1,68030E0

8,00000E-1

6,10000E-3

8,40000E-2

1,27000E-2

4,00000E-3

0,00000E0

1,40000E-2

0.0

Jarnac

1,40000E0

2,50000E-1

5,00000E-4

6,58000E-2

1,54000E-2

5,00000E-1

1,09000E-2

0,00000E0

2,06010E0

1,49200E-1

2,40000E-2

2,50000E-2

0,00000E0

9,99200E-1

9,70000E-3

2,00000E-4

3,11360E0

4,70000E-3

2,40000E-2

4,00000E-4

0,00000E0

4,56630E0

0,00000E0

3,94000E-2

8,40000E-3

2,50000E-1

6,53000E-2

1,00000E-1

1,53000E-2

0,00000E0

6,30000E-3

1,68030E0

8,00000E-1

6,10000E-3

8,40000E-2

1,27000E-2

4,00000E-3

0,00000E0

1,40000E-2

0.0

MathSBML

1,40000E0

2,50000E-1

5,00000E-4

6,58000E-2

1,54000E-2

5,00000E-1

1,09000E-2

0,00000E0

2,06010E0

1,49200E-1

2,40000E-2

2,50000E-2

0,00000E0

9,99200E-1

9,70000E-3

2,00000E-4

3,11360E0

4,70000E-3

2,40000E-2

4,00000E-4

0,00000E0

4,56630E0

0,00000E0

3,94000E-2

8,40000E-3

2,50000E-1

6,53000E-2

1,00000E-1

1,53000E-2

0,00000E0

6,30000E-3

1,68030E0

8,00000E-1

6,10000E-3

8,40000E-2

1,27000E-2

4,00000E-3

0,00000E0

1,40000E-2

0.0

Oscill8 Core

1,40000E0

5,00000E-4

6,58000E-2

1,54000E-2

1,09000E-2

0,00000E0

2,06010E0

1,49200E-1

2,50000E-2

0,00000E0

9,99200E-1

9,70000E-3

2,00000E-4

3,11360E0

4,70000E-3

0,00000E0

4,56630E0

0,00000E0

3,94000E-2

8,40000E-3

2,50000E-1

1,00000E-1

1,53000E-2

0,00000E0

6,30000E-3

1,68030E0

8,00000E-1

6,10000E-3

8,40000E-2

1,27000E-2

4,00000E-3

0,00000E0

1,40000E-2

0.0

SBToolbox2

1,40000E0

2,50000E-1

5,00000E-4

6,58000E-2

1,54000E-2

5,00000E-1

1,09000E-2

0,00000E0

2,06010E0

1,49200E-1

2,40000E-2

2,50000E-2

0,00000E0

9,99200E-1

9,70000E-3

2,00000E-4

3,11360E0

4,70000E-3

2,40000E-2

4,00000E-4

0,00000E0

4,56630E0

0,00000E0

3,94000E-2

8,40000E-3

2,50000E-1

6,53000E-2

1,00000E-1

1,53000E-2

0,00000E0

6,30000E-3

1,68030E0

8,00000E-1

6,10000E-3

8,40000E-2

1,27000E-2

4,00000E-3

0,00000E0

1,40000E-2

0.0

SBWOdeSolver

1,40000E0

2,50000E-1

5,00000E-4

6,58000E-2

1,54000E-2

5,00000E-1

1,09000E-2

0,00000E0

2,06010E0

1,49200E-1

2,40000E-2

2,50000E-2

0,00000E0

9,99200E-1

9,70000E-3

2,00000E-4

3,11360E0

4,70000E-3

2,40000E-2

4,00000E-4

0,00000E0

4,56630E0

0,00000E0

3,94000E-2

8,40000E-3

2,50000E-1

6,53000E-2

1,00000E-1

1,53000E-2

0,00000E0

6,30000E-3

1,68030E0

8,00000E-1

6,10000E-3

8,40000E-2

1,27000E-2

4,00000E-3

0,00000E0

1,40000E-2

0.0

copasi

1,40000E0

2,50000E-1

5,00000E-4

6,58000E-2

1,54000E-2

5,00000E-1

1,09000E-2

0,00000E0

2,06010E0

1,49200E-1

2,40000E-2

2,50000E-2

0,00000E0

9,99200E-1

9,70000E-3

2,00000E-4

3,11360E0

4,70000E-3

2,40000E-2

4,00000E-4

0,00000E0

4,56630E0

0,00000E0

3,94000E-2

8,40000E-3

2,50000E-1

6,53000E-2

1,00000E-1

1,53000E-2

0,00000E0

6,30000E-3

1,68030E0

8,00000E-1

6,10000E-3

8,40000E-2

1,27000E-2

4,00000E-3

0,00000E0

1,40000E-2

0.0

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,40000E0

2,50000E-1

5,00000E-4

6,58000E-2

1,54000E-2

5,00000E-1

1,09000E-2

0,00000E0

2,06010E0

1,49200E-1

2,40000E-2

2,50000E-2

0,00000E0

9,99200E-1

9,70000E-3

2,00000E-4

3,11360E0

4,70000E-3

2,40000E-2

4,00000E-4

0,00000E0

4,56630E0

0,00000E0

3,94000E-2

8,40000E-3

2,50000E-1

6,53000E-2

1,00000E-1

1,53000E-2

0,00000E0

6,30000E-3

1,68030E0

8,00000E-1

6,10000E-3

8,40000E-2

1,27000E-2

4,00000E-3

0,00000E0

1,40000E-2

0.0

jsim

1,40000E0

2,50000E-1

5,00000E-4

6,58000E-2

1,54000E-2

5,00000E-1

1,09000E-2

0,00000E0

2,06010E0

1,49200E-1

2,40000E-2

2,50000E-2

0,00000E0

9,99200E-1

9,70000E-3

2,00000E-4

3,11360E0

4,70000E-3

2,40000E-2

4,00000E-4

0,00000E0

4,56630E0

0,00000E0

3,94000E-2

8,40000E-3

2,50000E-1

6,53000E-2

1,00000E-1

1,53000E-2

0,00000E0

6,30000E-3

1,68030E0

8,00000E-1

6,10000E-3

8,40000E-2

1,27000E-2

4,00000E-3

0,00000E0

1,40000E-2

0.0

min

1,40000E0

2,50000E-1

5,00000E-4

6,58000E-2

1,54000E-2

5,00000E-1

1,09000E-2

0,00000E0

2,06010E0

1,49200E-1

2,40000E-2

2,50000E-2

0,00000E0

9,99200E-1

9,70000E-3

2,00000E-4

3,11360E0

4,70000E-3

2,40000E-2

4,00000E-4

0,00000E0

4,56630E0

0,00000E0

3,94000E-2

8,40000E-3

2,50000E-1

6,53000E-2

1,00000E-1

1,53000E-2

0,00000E0

6,30000E-3

1,68030E0

8,00000E-1

6,10000E-3

8,40000E-2

1,27000E-2

4,00000E-3

0,00000E0

1,40000E-2

0.0

max

1,40000E0

2,50000E-1

5,00000E-4

6,58000E-2

1,54000E-2

5,00000E-1

1,09000E-2

0,00000E0

2,06010E0

1,49200E-1

2,40000E-2

2,50000E-2

0,00000E0

9,99200E-1

9,70000E-3

2,00000E-4

3,11360E0

4,70000E-3

2,40000E-2

4,00000E-4

0,00000E0

4,56630E0

0,00000E0

3,94000E-2

8,40000E-3

2,50000E-1

6,53000E-2

1,00000E-1

1,53000E-2

0,00000E0

6,30000E-3

1,68030E0

8,00000E-1

6,10000E-3

8,40000E-2

1,27000E-2

4,00000E-3

0,00000E0

1,40000E-2

0.0

mean

1,40000E0

2,50000E-1

5,00000E-4

6,58000E-2

1,54000E-2

5,00000E-1

1,09000E-2

0,00000E0

2,06010E0

1,49200E-1

2,40000E-2

2,50000E-2

0,00000E0

9,99200E-1

9,70000E-3

2,00000E-4

3,11360E0

4,70000E-3

2,40000E-2

4,00000E-4

0,00000E0

4,56630E0

0,00000E0

3,94000E-2

8,40000E-3

2,50000E-1

6,53000E-2

1,00000E-1

1,53000E-2

0,00000E0

6,30000E-3

1,68030E0

8,00000E-1

6,10000E-3

8,40000E-2

1,27000E-2

4,00000E-3

0,00000E0

1,40000E-2

0.0

relative error(%)

0,00

0.2

BioUML

1,43231E0

1,80095E-1

4,81831E-4

6,48909E-2

1,83480E-2

6,56587E-1

1,08172E-2

1,84812E-3

1,91143E0

1,49521E-1

2,13176E-2

2,73851E-2

2,36020E-3

8,66703E-4

9,99526E-1

9,70588E-3

1,56345E-4

3,11403E0

4,82036E-3

2,38967E-2

1,86001E-4

2,13234E-5

4,58261E0

6,85853E-2

4,30129E-2

8,33469E-3

1,80539E-1

6,53437E-2

1,36028E-1

1,67277E-2

4,85780E-5

6,81545E-3

1,68030E0

5,72624E-1

6,07456E-3

8,39856E-2

1,30086E-2

4,91922E-3

5,17928E-6

1,43177E-2

0.2

ByoDyn

1,43238E0

1,80100E-1

4,81826E-4

6,48896E-2

1,83514E-2

6,56596E-1

1,08172E-2

1,84641E-3

1,91143E0

1,49518E-1

2,12843E-2

2,73877E-2

2,36025E-3

8,69288E-4

9,99529E-1

9,70547E-3

1,56344E-4

3,11403E0

4,81922E-3

2,39459E-2

1,86466E-4

2,12405E-5

4,58262E0

6,85859E-2

4,30155E-2

8,33456E-3

1,80543E-1

6,53437E-2

1,36032E-1

1,67287E-2

4,88997E-5

6,81658E-3

1,68030E0

5,72632E-1

6,07444E-3

8,39856E-2

1,30056E-2

4,89695E-3

5,19327E-6

1,43146E-2

0.2

Jarnac

1,43238E0

1,80100E-1

4,81826E-4

6,48896E-2

1,83514E-2

6,56596E-1

1,08172E-2

1,84641E-3

1,91143E0

1,49518E-1

2,12843E-2

2,73877E-2

2,36025E-3

8,69288E-4

9,99529E-1

9,70547E-3

1,56344E-4

3,11403E0

4,81922E-3

2,39459E-2

1,86466E-4

2,12405E-5

4,58262E0

6,85859E-2

4,30155E-2

8,33456E-3

1,80543E-1

6,53437E-2

1,36032E-1

1,67287E-2

4,88997E-5

6,81658E-3

1,68030E0

5,72632E-1

6,07444E-3

8,39856E-2

1,30056E-2

4,89695E-3

5,19327E-6

1,43146E-2

0.2

MathSBML

1,43238E0

1,80100E-1

4,81826E-4

6,48896E-2

1,83514E-2

6,56596E-1

1,08172E-2

1,84641E-3

1,91143E0

1,49518E-1

2,12843E-2

2,73877E-2

2,36025E-3

8,69288E-4

9,99529E-1

9,70548E-3

1,56344E-4

3,11403E0

4,81922E-3

2,39459E-2

1,86466E-4

2,12405E-5

4,58262E0

6,85859E-2

4,30155E-2

8,33456E-3

1,80543E-1

6,53437E-2

1,36032E-1

1,67287E-2

4,88997E-5

6,81658E-3

1,68030E0

5,72632E-1

6,07444E-3

8,39856E-2

1,30056E-2

4,89695E-3

5,19327E-6

1,43146E-2

0.2

Oscill8 Core

1,43238E0

4,81826E-4

6,48896E-2

1,83514E-2

1,08172E-2

1,84641E-3

1,91143E0

1,49518E-1

2,73876E-2

2,36025E-3

9,99529E-1

9,70550E-3

1,56344E-4

3,11403E0

4,81924E-3

2,12405E-5

4,58262E0

6,85859E-2

4,30156E-2

8,33456E-3

1,80543E-1

1,36032E-1

1,67287E-2

4,88997E-5

6,81659E-3

1,68030E0

5,72633E-1

6,07445E-3

8,39856E-2

1,30056E-2

4,89695E-3

5,19327E-6

1,43147E-2

0.2

SBToolbox2

1,43241E0

1,80111E-1

4,81868E-4

6,48886E-2

1,83417E-2

6,56587E-1

1,08169E-2

1,84645E-3

1,91140E0

1,49532E-1

2,12841E-2

2,73893E-2

2,35981E-3

8,69291E-4

9,99530E-1

9,70568E-3

1,56340E-4

3,11400E0

4,81743E-3

2,39460E-2

1,86470E-4

2,12404E-5

4,58260E0

6,85725E-2

4,30092E-2

8,33453E-3

1,80527E-1

6,53440E-2

1,36018E-1

1,67263E-2

4,89000E-5

6,81640E-3

1,68030E0

5,72619E-1

6,07490E-3

8,39860E-2

1,30006E-2

4,89690E-3

5,19335E-6

1,43087E-2

0.2

SBWOdeSolver

1,43238E0

1,80100E-1

4,81826E-4

6,48896E-2

1,83515E-2

6,56596E-1

1,08172E-2

1,84641E-3

1,91143E0

1,49518E-1

2,12843E-2

2,73876E-2

2,36025E-3

8,69288E-4

9,99529E-1

9,70550E-3

1,56344E-4

3,11403E0

4,81924E-3

2,39459E-2

1,86466E-4

2,12405E-5

4,58262E0

6,85859E-2

4,30156E-2

8,33456E-3

1,80543E-1

6,53437E-2

1,36032E-1

1,67287E-2

4,88997E-5

6,81659E-3

1,68030E0

5,72633E-1

6,07445E-3

8,39856E-2

1,30056E-2

4,89695E-3

5,19327E-6

1,43147E-2

0.2

copasi

1,43238E0

1,80100E-1

4,81826E-4

6,48896E-2

1,83514E-2

6,56596E-1

1,08172E-2

1,84641E-3

1,91143E0

1,49518E-1

2,12843E-2

2,73877E-2

2,36025E-3

8,69288E-4

9,99529E-1

9,70548E-3

1,56344E-4

3,11403E0

4,81922E-3

2,39459E-2

1,86466E-4

2,12405E-5

4,58262E0

6,85859E-2

4,30155E-2

8,33456E-3

1,80543E-1

6,53437E-2

1,36032E-1

1,67287E-2

4,88997E-5

6,81657E-3

1,68030E0

5,72632E-1

6,07444E-3

8,39856E-2

1,30056E-2

4,89695E-3

5,19327E-6

1,43146E-2

0.2

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,43238E0

1,80100E-1

4,81826E-4

6,48896E-2

1,83514E-2

6,56596E-1

1,08172E-2

1,84641E-3

1,91143E0

1,49518E-1

2,12843E-2

2,73877E-2

2,36025E-3

8,69288E-4

9,99529E-1

9,70547E-3

1,56344E-4

3,11403E0

4,81922E-3

2,39459E-2

1,86466E-4

2,12405E-5

4,58262E0

6,85859E-2

4,30155E-2

8,33456E-3

1,80543E-1

6,53437E-2

1,36032E-1

1,67287E-2

4,88997E-5

6,81658E-3

1,68030E0

5,72632E-1

6,07444E-3

8,39856E-2

1,30056E-2

4,89695E-3

5,19327E-6

1,43146E-2

0.2

jsim

1,43238E0

1,80100E-1

4,81825E-4

6,48895E-2

1,83512E-2

6,56596E-1

1,08172E-2

1,84641E-3

1,91143E0

1,49518E-1

2,12843E-2

2,73877E-2

2,36025E-3

8,69288E-4

9,99529E-1

9,70545E-3

1,56344E-4

3,11403E0

4,81923E-3

2,39459E-2

1,86466E-4

2,12405E-5

4,58262E0

6,85859E-2

4,30154E-2

8,33455E-3

1,80543E-1

6,53437E-2

1,36032E-1

1,67287E-2

4,88997E-5

6,81653E-3

1,68030E0

5,72632E-1

6,07443E-3

8,39856E-2

1,30056E-2

4,89695E-3

5,19327E-6

1,43146E-2

0.2

min

1,43238E0

1,80100E-1

4,81825E-4

6,48886E-2

1,83417E-2

6,56587E-1

1,08169E-2

1,84641E-3

1,91140E0

1,49518E-1

2,12841E-2

2,73876E-2

2,35981E-3

8,69288E-4

9,99529E-1

9,70545E-3

1,56340E-4

3,11400E0

4,81743E-3

2,39459E-2

1,86466E-4

2,12404E-5

4,58260E0

6,85725E-2

4,30092E-2

8,33453E-3

1,80527E-1

6,53437E-2

1,36018E-1

1,67263E-2

4,88997E-5

6,81640E-3

1,68030E0

5,72619E-1

6,07443E-3

8,39856E-2

1,30006E-2

4,89690E-3

5,19327E-6

1,43087E-2

0.2

max

1,43241E0

1,80111E-1

4,81868E-4

6,48896E-2

1,83515E-2

6,56596E-1

1,08172E-2

1,84645E-3

1,91143E0

1,49532E-1

2,12843E-2

2,73893E-2

2,36025E-3

8,69291E-4

9,99530E-1

9,70568E-3

1,56344E-4

3,11403E0

4,81924E-3

2,39460E-2

1,86470E-4

2,12405E-5

4,58262E0

6,85859E-2

4,30156E-2

8,33456E-3

1,80543E-1

6,53440E-2

1,36032E-1

1,67287E-2

4,89000E-5

6,81659E-3

1,68030E0

5,72633E-1

6,07490E-3

8,39860E-2

1,30056E-2

4,89695E-3

5,19335E-6

1,43147E-2

0.2

mean

1,43238E0

1,80100E-1

4,81826E-4

6,48896E-2

1,83514E-2

6,56596E-1

1,08172E-2

1,84641E-3

1,91143E0

1,49518E-1

2,12843E-2

2,73877E-2

2,36025E-3

8,69288E-4

9,99529E-1

9,70548E-3

1,56344E-4

3,11403E0

4,81922E-3

2,39459E-2

1,86466E-4

2,12405E-5

4,58262E0

6,85859E-2

4,30155E-2

8,33456E-3

1,80543E-1

6,53437E-2

1,36032E-1

1,67287E-2

4,88997E-5

6,81658E-3

1,68030E0

5,72632E-1

6,07444E-3

8,39856E-2

1,30056E-2

4,89695E-3

5,19327E-6

1,43146E-2

0.2

relative error(%)

0,00

0,16

0,00

0,30

0,00

0,21

0,25

0,39

0,00

0,66

0,00

0,45

0,27

0,00

0.4

BioUML

1,42679E0

1,79125E-1

4,78784E-4

6,56388E-2

1,64967E-2

6,59228E-1

1,09146E-2

1,90918E-3

1,91617E0

1,48852E-1

2,12637E-2

2,65255E-2

2,43771E-3

8,59767E-4

9,99030E-1

9,65774E-3

1,56524E-4

3,11403E0

4,73833E-3

2,38542E-2

1,85332E-4

2,22058E-5

4,57820E0

7,07289E-2

4,06894E-2

8,42508E-3

1,82843E-1

6,53435E-2

1,37976E-1

1,58137E-2

4,82255E-5

6,47461E-3

1,68031E0

5,73505E-1

6,04721E-3

8,39861E-2

1,27875E-2

4,94639E-3

5,35443E-6

1,40593E-2

0.4

ByoDyn

1,42685E0

1,79135E-1

4,78784E-4

6,56395E-2

1,65136E-2

6,59225E-1

1,09145E-2

1,90942E-3

1,91618E0

1,48852E-1

2,12233E-2

2,65457E-2

2,43787E-3

8,67284E-4

9,99030E-1

9,65804E-3

1,56525E-4

3,11403E0

4,73260E-3

2,39457E-2

1,86564E-4

2,20161E-5

4,57820E0

7,07343E-2

4,06924E-2

8,42513E-3

1,82855E-1

6,53435E-2

1,37983E-1

1,58148E-2

4,89267E-5

6,48166E-3

1,68031E0

5,73499E-1

6,04724E-3

8,39862E-2

1,27720E-2

4,89419E-3

5,38588E-6

1,40428E-2

0.4

Jarnac

1,42685E0

1,79135E-1

4,78784E-4

6,56395E-2

1,65136E-2

6,59225E-1

1,09145E-2

1,90942E-3

1,91618E0

1,48852E-1

2,12233E-2

2,65457E-2

2,43787E-3

8,67284E-4

9,99030E-1

9,65804E-3

1,56525E-4

3,11403E0

4,73260E-3

2,39457E-2

1,86564E-4

2,20161E-5

4,57820E0

7,07343E-2

4,06924E-2

8,42513E-3

1,82855E-1

6,53435E-2

1,37983E-1

1,58148E-2

4,89267E-5

6,48166E-3

1,68031E0

5,73499E-1

6,04724E-3

8,39862E-2

1,27720E-2

4,89419E-3

5,38588E-6

1,40428E-2

0.4

MathSBML

1,42685E0

1,79135E-1

4,78784E-4

6,56395E-2

1,65136E-2

6,59225E-1

1,09145E-2

1,90942E-3

1,91618E0

1,48852E-1

2,12233E-2

2,65457E-2

2,43787E-3

8,67284E-4

9,99030E-1

9,65804E-3

1,56525E-4

3,11403E0

4,73260E-3

2,39457E-2

1,86564E-4

2,20161E-5

4,57820E0

7,07343E-2

4,06924E-2

8,42513E-3

1,82855E-1

6,53435E-2

1,37983E-1

1,58148E-2

4,89267E-5

6,48166E-3

1,68031E0

5,73499E-1

6,04724E-3

8,39862E-2

1,27720E-2

4,89419E-3

5,38589E-6

1,40428E-2

0.4

Oscill8 Core

1,42685E0

4,78784E-4

6,56395E-2

1,65137E-2

1,09145E-2

1,90942E-3

1,91618E0

1,48852E-1

2,65457E-2

2,43787E-3

9,99030E-1

9,65804E-3

1,56525E-4

3,11403E0

4,73260E-3

2,20161E-5

4,57820E0

7,07343E-2

4,06925E-2

8,42513E-3

1,82855E-1

1,37983E-1

1,58148E-2

4,89267E-5

6,48167E-3

1,68031E0

5,73499E-1

6,04724E-3

8,39862E-2

1,27720E-2

4,89419E-3

5,38588E-6

1,40428E-2

0.4

SBToolbox2

1,42681E0

1,79131E-1

4,78793E-4

6,56450E-2

1,65065E-2

6,59236E-1

1,09149E-2

1,90918E-3

1,91619E0

1,48860E-1

2,12231E-2

2,65510E-2

2,43820E-3

8,67294E-4

9,99021E-1

9,65874E-3

1,56530E-4

3,11400E0

4,73136E-3

2,39460E-2

1,86560E-4

2,20135E-5

4,57822E0

7,07432E-2

4,06800E-2

8,42578E-3

1,82867E-1

6,53430E-2

1,37988E-1

1,58102E-2

4,89269E-5

6,48180E-3

1,68030E0

5,73509E-1

6,04743E-3

8,39860E-2

1,27682E-2

4,89420E-3

5,38523E-6

1,40392E-2

0.4

SBWOdeSolver

1,42685E0

1,79135E-1

4,78784E-4

6,56395E-2

1,65137E-2

6,59225E-1

1,09145E-2

1,90942E-3

1,91618E0

1,48852E-1

2,12233E-2

2,65457E-2

2,43787E-3

8,67284E-4

9,99030E-1

9,65804E-3

1,56525E-4

3,11403E0

4,73260E-3

2,39457E-2

1,86564E-4

2,20161E-5

4,57820E0

7,07343E-2

4,06925E-2

8,42513E-3

1,82855E-1

6,53435E-2

1,37983E-1

1,58148E-2

4,89267E-5

6,48167E-3

1,68031E0

5,73499E-1

6,04724E-3

8,39862E-2

1,27720E-2

4,89419E-3

5,38588E-6

1,40428E-2

0.4

copasi

1,42685E0

1,79135E-1

4,78784E-4

6,56395E-2

1,65136E-2

6,59225E-1

1,09145E-2

1,90942E-3

1,91618E0

1,48852E-1

2,12233E-2

2,65457E-2

2,43787E-3

8,67284E-4

9,99030E-1

9,65805E-3

1,56525E-4

3,11403E0

4,73260E-3

2,39457E-2

1,86564E-4

2,20161E-5

4,57820E0

7,07343E-2

4,06924E-2

8,42513E-3

1,82855E-1

6,53435E-2

1,37983E-1

1,58148E-2

4,89267E-5

6,48166E-3

1,68031E0

5,73499E-1

6,04724E-3

8,39862E-2

1,27720E-2

4,89419E-3

5,38589E-6

1,40428E-2

0.4

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,42685E0

1,79135E-1

4,78784E-4

6,56395E-2

1,65136E-2

6,59225E-1

1,09145E-2

1,90942E-3

1,91618E0

1,48852E-1

2,12233E-2

2,65457E-2

2,43787E-3

8,67284E-4

9,99030E-1

9,65804E-3

1,56525E-4

3,11403E0

4,73260E-3

2,39457E-2

1,86564E-4

2,20161E-5

4,57820E0

7,07343E-2

4,06924E-2

8,42513E-3

1,82855E-1

6,53435E-2

1,37983E-1

1,58148E-2

4,89267E-5

6,48166E-3

1,68031E0

5,73499E-1

6,04724E-3

8,39862E-2

1,27720E-2

4,89419E-3

5,38588E-6

1,40428E-2

0.4

jsim

1,42685E0

1,79135E-1

4,78784E-4

6,56395E-2

1,65135E-2

6,59225E-1

1,09145E-2

1,90943E-3

1,91618E0

1,48852E-1

2,12233E-2

2,65457E-2

2,43787E-3

8,67284E-4

9,99030E-1

9,65804E-3

1,56525E-4

3,11403E0

4,73260E-3

2,39457E-2

1,86564E-4

2,20161E-5

4,57820E0

7,07344E-2

4,06923E-2

8,42513E-3

1,82855E-1

6,53435E-2

1,37983E-1

1,58148E-2

4,89267E-5

6,48164E-3

1,68031E0

5,73499E-1

6,04724E-3

8,39862E-2

1,27720E-2

4,89419E-3

5,38589E-6

1,40428E-2

0.4

min

1,42681E0

1,79131E-1

4,78784E-4

6,56395E-2

1,65065E-2

6,59225E-1

1,09145E-2

1,90918E-3

1,91618E0

1,48852E-1

2,12231E-2

2,65457E-2

2,43787E-3

8,67284E-4

9,99021E-1

9,65804E-3

1,56525E-4

3,11400E0

4,73136E-3

2,39457E-2

1,86560E-4

2,20135E-5

4,57820E0

7,07343E-2

4,06800E-2

8,42513E-3

1,82855E-1

6,53430E-2

1,37983E-1

1,58102E-2

4,89267E-5

6,48164E-3

1,68030E0

5,73499E-1

6,04724E-3

8,39860E-2

1,27682E-2

4,89419E-3

5,38523E-6

1,40392E-2

0.4

max

1,42685E0

1,79135E-1

4,78793E-4

6,56450E-2

1,65137E-2

6,59236E-1

1,09149E-2

1,90943E-3

1,91619E0

1,48860E-1

2,12233E-2

2,65510E-2

2,43820E-3

8,67294E-4

9,99030E-1

9,65874E-3

1,56530E-4

3,11403E0

4,73260E-3

2,39460E-2

1,86564E-4

2,20161E-5

4,57822E0

7,07432E-2

4,06925E-2

8,42578E-3

1,82867E-1

6,53435E-2

1,37988E-1

1,58148E-2

4,89269E-5

6,48180E-3

1,68031E0

5,73509E-1

6,04743E-3

8,39862E-2

1,27720E-2

4,89420E-3

5,38589E-6

1,40428E-2

0.4

mean

1,42685E0

1,79135E-1

4,78784E-4

6,56395E-2

1,65136E-2

6,59225E-1

1,09145E-2

1,90942E-3

1,91618E0

1,48852E-1

2,12233E-2

2,65457E-2

2,43787E-3

8,67284E-4

9,99030E-1

9,65804E-3

1,56525E-4

3,11403E0

4,73260E-3

2,39457E-2

1,86564E-4

2,20161E-5

4,57820E0

7,07343E-2

4,06924E-2

8,42513E-3

1,82855E-1

6,53435E-2

1,37983E-1

1,58148E-2

4,89267E-5

6,48166E-3

1,68031E0

5,73499E-1

6,04724E-3

8,39862E-2

1,27720E-2

4,89419E-3

5,38588E-6

1,40428E-2

0.4

relative error(%)

0,00

0,19

0,00

0,87

0,00

0,12

0,38

0,66

0,86

0,00

1,4

0,11

0,00

0,12

1,1

0,57

0,12

0.6

BioUML

1,42452E0

1,78842E-1

4,77767E-4

6,59552E-2

1,56977E-2

6,60919E-1

1,09541E-2

1,96055E-3

1,92112E0

1,48649E-1

2,12016E-2

2,56316E-2

2,46838E-3

8,63464E-4

9,98811E-1

9,64454E-3

1,56596E-4

3,11403E0

4,72234E-3

2,39478E-2

1,86211E-4

2,27056E-5

4,57143E0

7,16200E-2

3,97531E-2

8,46299E-3

1,83846E-1

6,53434E-2

1,38730E-1

1,54455E-2

4,87654E-5

6,31018E-3

1,68031E0

5,73496E-1

6,03893E-3

8,39866E-2

1,27445E-2

4,91081E-3

5,53626E-6

1,40078E-2

0.6

ByoDyn

1,42448E0

1,78854E-1

4,77776E-4

6,59545E-2

1,57065E-2

6,60884E-1

1,09539E-2

1,95931E-3

1,92119E0

1,48652E-1

2,11750E-2

2,56439E-2

2,46818E-3

8,65697E-4

9,98811E-1

9,64486E-3

1,56596E-4

3,11403E0

4,71960E-3

2,39455E-2

1,86641E-4

2,26328E-5

4,57144E0

7,16207E-2

3,97542E-2

8,46290E-3

1,83853E-1

6,53434E-2

1,38723E-1

1,54459E-2

4,89482E-5

6,31389E-3

1,68031E0

5,73444E-1

6,03903E-3

8,39867E-2

1,27372E-2

4,89201E-3

5,53916E-6

1,39998E-2

0.6

Jarnac

1,42448E0

1,78854E-1

4,77776E-4

6,59545E-2

1,57065E-2

6,60884E-1

1,09539E-2

1,95931E-3

1,92119E0

1,48652E-1

2,11750E-2

2,56439E-2

2,46818E-3

8,65697E-4

9,98811E-1

9,64486E-3

1,56596E-4

3,11403E0

4,71960E-3

2,39455E-2

1,86641E-4

2,26328E-5

4,57144E0

7,16207E-2

3,97542E-2

8,46290E-3

1,83853E-1

6,53434E-2

1,38723E-1

1,54459E-2

4,89482E-5

6,31389E-3

1,68031E0

5,73444E-1

6,03903E-3

8,39867E-2

1,27372E-2

4,89201E-3

5,53916E-6

1,39998E-2

0.6

MathSBML

1,42448E0

1,78854E-1

4,77776E-4

6,59545E-2

1,57065E-2

6,60884E-1

1,09539E-2

1,95931E-3

1,92119E0

1,48652E-1

2,11750E-2

2,56439E-2

2,46818E-3

8,65697E-4

9,98811E-1

9,64486E-3

1,56596E-4

3,11403E0

4,71960E-3

2,39455E-2

1,86641E-4

2,26328E-5

4,57144E0

7,16207E-2

3,97542E-2

8,46290E-3

1,83853E-1

6,53434E-2

1,38723E-1

1,54459E-2

4,89482E-5

6,31389E-3

1,68031E0

5,73444E-1

6,03903E-3

8,39867E-2

1,27372E-2

4,89201E-3

5,53917E-6

1,39998E-2

0.6

Oscill8 Core

1,42448E0

4,77776E-4

6,59545E-2

1,57066E-2

1,09539E-2

1,95931E-3

1,92119E0

1,48652E-1

2,56439E-2

2,46818E-3

9,98811E-1

9,64486E-3

1,56596E-4

3,11403E0

4,71960E-3

2,26328E-5

4,57144E0

7,16207E-2

3,97542E-2

8,46290E-3

1,83853E-1

1,38722E-1

1,54459E-2

4,89482E-5

6,31390E-3

1,68031E0

5,73444E-1

6,03903E-3

8,39867E-2

1,27372E-2

4,89201E-3

5,53916E-6

1,39998E-2

0.6

SBToolbox2

1,42450E0

1,78851E-1

4,77772E-4

6,59574E-2

1,56996E-2

6,60886E-1

1,09539E-2

1,95938E-3

1,92118E0

1,48651E-1

2,11751E-2

2,56433E-2

2,46845E-3

8,65694E-4

9,98810E-1

9,64482E-3

1,56599E-4

3,11400E0

4,71942E-3

2,39460E-2

1,86640E-4

2,26335E-5

4,57142E0

7,16283E-2

3,97458E-2

8,46323E-3

1,83858E-1

6,53430E-2

1,38729E-1

1,54427E-2

4,89479E-5

6,31262E-3

1,68030E0

5,73451E-1

6,03901E-3

8,39870E-2

1,27371E-2

4,89201E-3

5,53933E-6

1,39991E-2

0.6

SBWOdeSolver

1,42448E0

1,78854E-1

4,77776E-4

6,59545E-2

1,57066E-2

6,60884E-1

1,09539E-2

1,95931E-3

1,92119E0

1,48652E-1

2,11750E-2

2,56439E-2

2,46818E-3

8,65697E-4

9,98811E-1

9,64486E-3

1,56596E-4

3,11403E0

4,71960E-3

2,39455E-2

1,86641E-4

2,26328E-5

4,57144E0

7,16207E-2

3,97542E-2

8,46290E-3

1,83853E-1

6,53434E-2

1,38722E-1

1,54459E-2

4,89482E-5

6,31390E-3

1,68031E0

5,73444E-1

6,03903E-3

8,39867E-2

1,27372E-2

4,89201E-3

5,53916E-6

1,39998E-2

0.6

copasi

1,42448E0

1,78854E-1

4,77776E-4

6,59545E-2

1,57065E-2

6,60884E-1

1,09539E-2

1,95931E-3

1,92119E0

1,48652E-1

2,11750E-2

2,56439E-2

2,46818E-3

8,65697E-4

9,98811E-1

9,64486E-3

1,56596E-4

3,11403E0

4,71960E-3

2,39455E-2

1,86641E-4

2,26328E-5

4,57144E0

7,16207E-2

3,97542E-2

8,46290E-3

1,83853E-1

6,53434E-2

1,38723E-1

1,54459E-2

4,89482E-5

6,31389E-3

1,68031E0

5,73444E-1

6,03903E-3

8,39867E-2

1,27372E-2

4,89201E-3

5,53917E-6

1,39998E-2

0.6

edu.kgi.roadRunner

1,42448E0

1,78854E-1

4,77776E-4

6,59545E-2

1,57065E-2

6,60884E-1

1,09539E-2

1,95931E-3

1,92119E0

1,48652E-1

2,11750E-2

2,56439E-2

2,46818E-3

8,65697E-4

9,98811E-1

9,64486E-3

1,56596E-4

3,11403E0

4,71960E-3

2,39455E-2

1,86641E-4

2,26328E-5

4,57144E0

7,16207E-2

3,97542E-2

8,46290E-3

1,83853E-1

6,53434E-2

1,38723E-1

1,54459E-2

4,89482E-5

6,31389E-3

1,68031E0

5,73444E-1

6,03903E-3

8,39867E-2

1,27372E-2

4,89201E-3

5,53916E-6

1,39998E-2

0.6

jsim

1,42448E0

1,78854E-1

4,77776E-4

6,59545E-2

1,57065E-2

6,60884E-1

1,09540E-2

1,95931E-3

1,92119E0

1,48652E-1

2,11750E-2

2,56438E-2

2,46818E-3

8,65697E-4

9,98811E-1

9,64486E-3

1,56596E-4

3,11403E0

4,71960E-3

2,39455E-2

1,86641E-4

2,26328E-5

4,57144E0

7,16207E-2

3,97542E-2

8,46290E-3

1,83853E-1

6,53434E-2

1,38723E-1

1,54459E-2

4,89482E-5

6,31388E-3

1,68031E0

5,73444E-1

6,03903E-3

8,39867E-2

1,27372E-2

4,89201E-3

5,53917E-6

1,39998E-2

0.6

min

1,42448E0

1,78851E-1

4,77772E-4

6,59545E-2

1,56996E-2

6,60884E-1

1,09539E-2

1,95931E-3

1,92118E0

1,48651E-1

2,11750E-2

2,56433E-2

2,46818E-3

8,65694E-4

9,98810E-1

9,64482E-3

1,56596E-4

3,11400E0

4,71942E-3

2,39455E-2

1,86640E-4

2,26328E-5

4,57142E0

7,16207E-2

3,97458E-2

8,46290E-3

1,83853E-1

6,53430E-2

1,38722E-1

1,54427E-2

4,89479E-5

6,31262E-3

1,68030E0

5,73444E-1

6,03901E-3

8,39867E-2

1,27371E-2

4,89201E-3

5,53916E-6

1,39991E-2

0.6

max

1,42450E0

1,78854E-1

4,77776E-4

6,59574E-2

1,57066E-2

6,60886E-1

1,09540E-2

1,95938E-3

1,92119E0

1,48652E-1

2,11751E-2

2,56439E-2

2,46845E-3

8,65697E-4

9,98811E-1

9,64486E-3

1,56599E-4

3,11403E0

4,71960E-3

2,39460E-2

1,86641E-4

2,26335E-5

4,57144E0

7,16283E-2

3,97542E-2

8,46323E-3

1,83858E-1

6,53434E-2

1,38729E-1

1,54459E-2

4,89482E-5

6,31390E-3

1,68031E0

5,73451E-1

6,03903E-3

8,39870E-2

1,27372E-2

4,89201E-3

5,53933E-6

1,39998E-2

0.6

mean

1,42448E0

1,78854E-1

4,77776E-4

6,59545E-2

1,57065E-2

6,60884E-1

1,09539E-2

1,95931E-3

1,92119E0

1,48652E-1

2,11750E-2

2,56439E-2

2,46818E-3

8,65697E-4

9,98811E-1

9,64486E-3

1,56596E-4

3,11403E0

4,71960E-3

2,39455E-2

1,86641E-4

2,26328E-5

4,57144E0

7,16207E-2

3,97542E-2

8,46290E-3

1,83853E-1

6,53434E-2

1,38723E-1

1,54459E-2

4,89482E-5

6,31389E-3

1,68031E0

5,73444E-1

6,03903E-3

8,39867E-2

1,27372E-2

4,89201E-3

5,53916E-6

1,39998E-2

0.6

relative error(%)

0,00

0,12

0,00

0,26

0,00

0,23

0,32

0,00

0,37

0,00

0,38

0,00

0.8

BioUML

1,42335E0

1,78803E-1

4,77380E-4

6,60855E-2

1,53588E-2

6,62216E-1

1,09709E-2

1,98995E-3

1,92604E0

1,48570E-1

2,11792E-2

2,50399E-2

2,48034E-3

8,58550E-4

9,98728E-1

9,63881E-3

1,56621E-4

3,11403E0

4,71646E-3

2,39252E-2

1,85695E-4

2,31781E-5

4,56622E0

7,20103E-2

3,93482E-2

8,47872E-3

1,84325E-1

6,53434E-2

1,39008E-1

1,52864E-2

4,84933E-5

6,23907E-3

1,68031E0

5,73152E-1

6,03566E-3

8,39868E-2

1,27288E-2

4,93371E-3

5,61991E-6

1,39888E-2

0.8

ByoDyn

1,42333E0

1,78832E-1

4,77391E-4

6,60832E-2

1,53749E-2

6,62139E-1

1,09706E-2

1,98976E-3

1,92616E0

1,48572E-1

2,11455E-2

2,50597E-2

2,48003E-3

8,64727E-4

9,98729E-1

9,63914E-3

1,56620E-4

3,11403E0

4,71122E-3

2,39454E-2

1,86689E-4

2,30103E-5

4,56624E0

7,20139E-2

3,93519E-2

8,47843E-3

1,84345E-1

6,53434E-2

1,38999E-1

1,52878E-2

4,89613E-5

6,24577E-3

1,68031E0

5,73051E-1

6,03576E-3

8,39869E-2

1,27147E-2

4,89068E-3

5,63307E-6

1,39736E-2

0.8

Jarnac

1,42333E0

1,78832E-1

4,77391E-4

6,60832E-2

1,53749E-2

6,62139E-1

1,09706E-2

1,98976E-3

1,92616E0

1,48572E-1

2,11455E-2

2,50597E-2

2,48003E-3

8,64727E-4

9,98729E-1

9,63914E-3

1,56620E-4

3,11403E0

4,71122E-3

2,39454E-2

1,86689E-4

2,30103E-5

4,56624E0

7,20139E-2

3,93519E-2

8,47843E-3

1,84345E-1

6,53434E-2

1,38999E-1

1,52878E-2

4,89613E-5

6,24577E-3

1,68031E0

5,73051E-1

6,03576E-3

8,39869E-2

1,27147E-2

4,89068E-3

5,63307E-6

1,39736E-2

0.8

MathSBML

1,42333E0

1,78832E-1

4,77391E-4

6,60832E-2

1,53749E-2

6,62139E-1

1,09706E-2

1,98976E-3

1,92616E0

1,48572E-1

2,11455E-2

2,50597E-2

2,48003E-3

8,64727E-4

9,98729E-1

9,63914E-3

1,56620E-4

3,11403E0

4,71123E-3

2,39454E-2

1,86689E-4

2,30103E-5

4,56624E0

7,20139E-2

3,93519E-2

8,47843E-3

1,84345E-1

6,53434E-2

1,38999E-1

1,52878E-2

4,89613E-5

6,24577E-3

1,68031E0

5,73051E-1