Test: BIOMD0000000073.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000073.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: DormandPrince
generated code: BIOMD0000000073.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-100
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000073.gif

Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL1109528188.png

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: species_10  species_11  species_14  species_15  species_12  species_13  species_9  species_7  species_8  species_5  species_6  species_3  species_4  species_2  species_1  species_0 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  SBToolbox2  VCell  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  BioUML 
timeresult species_10 species_11 species_14 species_15 species_12 species_13 species_9 species_7 species_8 species_5 species_6 species_3 species_4 species_2 species_1 species_0
0.0BioUML0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,60000E00,00000E01,40000E00,00000E01,90000E00,00000E00,00000E02,00000E09,00000E0
0.0ByoDyn0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,60000E00,00000E01,40000E00,00000E01,90000E00,00000E00,00000E02,00000E09,00000E0
0.0MathSBML0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,60000E00,00000E01,40000E00,00000E01,90000E00,00000E00,00000E02,00000E09,00000E0
0.0SBToolbox20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,60000E00,00000E01,40000E00,00000E01,90000E00,00000E00,00000E02,00000E09,00000E0
0.0SBWOdeSolver0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,60000E00,00000E01,40000E00,00000E01,90000E00,00000E00,00000E02,00000E09,00000E0
0.0VCell0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,60000E00,00000E01,40000E00,00000E01,90000E00,00000E00,00000E02,00000E09,00000E0
0.0copasi0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,60000E00,00000E01,40000E00,00000E01,90000E00,00000E00,00000E02,00000E09,00000E0
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,60000E00,00000E01,40000E00,00000E01,90000E00,00000E00,00000E02,00000E09,00000E0
0.0min 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,60000E0 0,00000E0 1,40000E0 0,00000E0 1,90000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 2,00000E0 9,00000E0
0.0max 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,60000E0 0,00000E0 1,40000E0 0,00000E0 1,90000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 2,00000E0 9,00000E0
0.0mean 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,60000E0 0,00000E0 1,40000E0 0,00000E0 1,90000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 2,00000E0 9,00000E0
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML2,53160E-27,83335E-35,48154E-21,25903E-17,41880E-17,09038E-22,38535E-21,70492E01,68564E-11,45827E05,74631E-21,74508E03,83393E-17,79851E-22,03281E08,94789E0
0.2ByoDyn2,53160E-27,83335E-35,48154E-21,25903E-17,41880E-17,09038E-22,38535E-21,70492E01,68564E-11,45827E05,74631E-21,74508E03,83393E-17,79851E-22,03281E08,94789E0
0.2MathSBML2,53160E-27,83335E-35,48154E-21,25903E-17,41880E-17,09038E-22,38535E-21,70492E01,68564E-11,45827E05,74631E-21,74508E03,83392E-17,79851E-22,03281E08,94789E0
0.2SBToolbox22,53108E-27,82990E-35,48159E-21,25909E-17,41871E-17,08986E-22,38715E-21,70490E01,68549E-11,45824E05,75005E-21,74512E03,83344E-17,79788E-22,03277E08,94785E0
0.2SBWOdeSolver2,53158E-27,83339E-35,48149E-21,25901E-17,41881E-17,09033E-22,38533E-21,70492E01,68564E-11,45827E05,74628E-21,74509E03,83392E-17,79847E-22,03281E08,94789E0
0.2VCell2,53160E-27,83335E-35,48154E-21,25903E-17,41880E-17,09038E-22,38534E-21,70492E01,68564E-11,45827E05,74627E-21,74508E03,83393E-17,79851E-22,03281E08,94789E0
0.2copasi2,53160E-27,83335E-35,48154E-21,25903E-17,41880E-17,09038E-22,38535E-21,70492E01,68564E-11,45827E05,74631E-21,74508E03,83393E-17,79851E-22,03281E08,94789E0
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner2,53160E-27,83335E-35,48154E-21,25903E-17,41880E-17,09038E-22,38535E-21,70492E01,68564E-11,45827E05,74631E-21,74508E03,83393E-17,79851E-22,03281E08,94789E0
0.2min 2,53108E-2 7,82990E-3 5,48149E-2 1,25901E-1 7,41871E-1 7,08986E-2 2,38533E-2 1,70490E0 1,68549E-1 1,45824E0 5,74627E-2 1,74508E0 3,83344E-1 7,79788E-2 2,03277E0 8,94785E0
0.2max 2,53160E-2 7,83339E-3 5,48159E-2 1,25909E-1 7,41881E-1 7,09038E-2 2,38715E-2 1,70492E0 1,68564E-1 1,45827E0 5,75005E-2 1,74512E0 3,83393E-1 7,79851E-2 2,03281E0 8,94789E0
0.2mean 2,53160E-2 7,83335E-3 5,48154E-2 1,25903E-1 7,41880E-1 7,09038E-2 2,38535E-2 1,70492E0 1,68564E-1 1,45827E0 5,74631E-2 1,74508E0 3,83393E-1 7,79851E-2 2,03281E0 8,94789E0
0.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML4,10375E-21,92854E-28,81864E-21,76980E-15,50864E-11,16919E-14,90290E-21,80597E03,27919E-11,51431E01,17792E-11,65668E07,43071E-11,36380E-12,06194E08,90232E0
0.4ByoDyn4,10375E-21,92854E-28,81864E-21,76980E-15,50864E-11,16919E-14,90290E-21,80597E03,27919E-11,51431E01,17792E-11,65668E07,43071E-11,36380E-12,06194E08,90232E0
0.4MathSBML4,10375E-21,92854E-28,81864E-21,76980E-15,50864E-11,16919E-14,90290E-21,80597E03,27919E-11,51431E01,17792E-11,65668E07,43071E-11,36380E-12,06194E08,90232E0
0.4SBToolbox24,10003E-21,92809E-28,82037E-21,77042E-15,50814E-11,16922E-14,90641E-21,80600E03,27917E-11,51429E01,17839E-11,65663E07,43042E-11,36375E-12,06195E08,90229E0
0.4SBWOdeSolver4,10377E-21,92855E-28,81858E-21,76978E-15,50866E-11,16919E-14,90286E-21,80597E03,27919E-11,51431E01,17792E-11,65668E07,43071E-11,36380E-12,06194E08,90232E0
0.4VCell4,10375E-21,92854E-28,81864E-21,76980E-15,50864E-11,16919E-14,90289E-21,80597E03,27919E-11,51431E01,17792E-11,65668E07,43072E-11,36380E-12,06194E08,90232E0
0.4copasi4,10375E-21,92854E-28,81864E-21,76980E-15,50864E-11,16919E-14,90289E-21,80597E03,27919E-11,51431E01,17792E-11,65668E07,43071E-11,36380E-12,06194E08,90232E0
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner4,10375E-21,92854E-28,81864E-21,76980E-15,50864E-11,16919E-14,90290E-21,80597E03,27919E-11,51431E01,17792E-11,65668E07,43071E-11,36380E-12,06194E08,90232E0
0.4min 4,10003E-2 1,92809E-2 8,81858E-2 1,76978E-1 5,50814E-1 1,16919E-1 4,90286E-2 1,80597E0 3,27917E-1 1,51429E0 1,17792E-1 1,65663E0 7,43042E-1 1,36375E-1 2,06194E0 8,90229E0
0.4max 4,10377E-2 1,92855E-2 8,82037E-2 1,77042E-1 5,50866E-1 1,16922E-1 4,90641E-2 1,80600E0 3,27919E-1 1,51431E0 1,17839E-1 1,65668E0 7,43072E-1 1,36380E-1 2,06195E0 8,90232E0
0.4mean 4,10375E-2 1,92854E-2 8,81864E-2 1,76980E-1 5,50864E-1 1,16919E-1 4,90290E-2 1,80597E0 3,27919E-1 1,51431E0 1,17792E-1 1,65668E0 7,43071E-1 1,36380E-1 2,06194E0 8,90232E0
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML6,12192E-23,11504E-21,09176E-11,89231E-14,05166E-11,50818E-16,77975E-21,90389E04,79842E-11,56847E01,68550E-11,60915E01,08996E01,84277E-12,08708E08,86056E0
0.6ByoDyn6,12192E-23,11504E-21,09176E-11,89231E-14,05166E-11,50818E-16,77975E-21,90389E04,79842E-11,56847E01,68550E-11,60915E01,08996E01,84277E-12,08708E08,86056E0
0.6MathSBML6,12192E-23,11504E-21,09176E-11,89231E-14,05166E-11,50818E-16,77975E-21,90389E04,79842E-11,56847E01,68550E-11,60915E01,08996E01,84277E-12,08708E08,86056E0
0.6SBToolbox26,11312E-23,11479E-21,09211E-11,89331E-14,05074E-11,50821E-16,78346E-21,90391E04,79890E-11,56844E01,68590E-11,60910E01,08998E01,84268E-12,08713E08,86053E0
0.6SBWOdeSolver6,12205E-23,11509E-21,09175E-11,89230E-14,05168E-11,50818E-16,77971E-21,90389E04,79841E-11,56847E01,68550E-11,60915E01,08996E01,84276E-12,08708E08,86056E0
0.6VCell6,12192E-23,11504E-21,09176E-11,89231E-14,05166E-11,50818E-16,77975E-21,90389E04,79842E-11,56847E01,68550E-11,60915E01,08996E01,84277E-12,08708E08,86056E0
0.6copasi6,12192E-23,11504E-21,09176E-11,89231E-14,05166E-11,50818E-16,77975E-21,90389E04,79842E-11,56847E01,68550E-11,60915E01,08996E01,84277E-12,08708E08,86056E0
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner6,12192E-23,11504E-21,09176E-11,89231E-14,05166E-11,50818E-16,77975E-21,90389E04,79842E-11,56847E01,68550E-11,60915E01,08996E01,84277E-12,08708E08,86056E0
0.6min 6,11312E-2 3,11479E-2 1,09175E-1 1,89230E-1 4,05074E-1 1,50818E-1 6,77971E-2 1,90389E0 4,79841E-1 1,56844E0 1,68550E-1 1,60910E0 1,08996E0 1,84268E-1 2,08708E0 8,86053E0
0.6max 6,12205E-2 3,11509E-2 1,09211E-1 1,89331E-1 4,05168E-1 1,50821E-1 6,78346E-2 1,90391E0 4,79890E-1 1,56847E0 1,68590E-1 1,60915E0 1,08998E0 1,84277E-1 2,08713E0 8,86056E0
0.6mean 6,12192E-2 3,11504E-2 1,09176E-1 1,89231E-1 4,05166E-1 1,50818E-1 6,77975E-2 1,90389E0 4,79842E-1 1,56847E0 1,68550E-1 1,60915E0 1,08996E0 1,84277E-1 2,08708E0 8,86056E0
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML9,25712E-24,43995E-21,21220E-11,79405E-12,93677E-11,77248E-18,15945E-21,99947E06,18414E-11,62109E02,11813E-11,58898E01,41957E02,25287E-12,10907E08,82078E0
0.8ByoDyn9,25712E-24,43995E-21,21220E-11,79405E-12,93677E-11,77248E-18,15945E-21,99947E06,18414E-11,62109E02,11813E-11,58898E01,41957E02,25287E-12,10907E08,82078E0
0.8MathSBML9,25712E-24,43995E-21,21220E-11,79405E-12,93677E-11,77248E-18,15945E-21,99947E06,18414E-11,62109E02,11813E-11,58898E01,41957E02,25287E-12,10907E08,82078E0
0.8SBToolbox29,24339E-24,44015E-21,21276E-11,79518E-12,93549E-11,77256E-18,16294E-21,99952E06,18507E-11,62109E02,11849E-11,58894E01,41962E02,25277E-12,10911E08,82076E0
0.8SBWOdeSolver9,25730E-24,43998E-21,21219E-11,79404E-12,93679E-11,77247E-18,15942E-21,99947E06,18412E-11,62109E02,11813E-11,58899E01,41957E02,25286E-12,10907E08,82078E0
0.8VCell9,25712E-24,43995E-21,21220E-11,79405E-12,93677E-11,77248E-18,15945E-21,99947E06,18414E-11,62109E02,11813E-11,58898E01,41957E02,25287E-12,10907E08,82078E0
0.8copasi9,25712E-24,43995E-21,21220E-11,79405E-12,93677E-11,77248E-18,15945E-21,99947E06,18414E-11,62109E02,11813E-11,58898E01,41957E02,25287E-12,10907E08,82078E0
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner9,25712E-24,43995E-21,21220E-11,79405E-12,93677E-11,77248E-18,15945E-21,99947E06,18414E-11,62109E02,11813E-11,58898E01,41957E02,25287E-12,10907E08,82078E0
0.8min 9,24339E-2 4,43995E-2 1,21219E-1 1,79404E-1 2,93549E-1 1,77247E-1 8,15942E-2 1,99947E0 6,18412E-1 1,62109E0 2,11813E-1 1,58894E0 1,41957E0 2,25277E-1 2,10907E0 8,82076E0
0.8max 9,25730E-2 4,44015E-2 1,21276E-1 1,79518E-1 2,93679E-1 1,77256E-1 8,16294E-2 1,99952E0 6,18507E-1 1,62109E0 2,11849E-1 1,58899E0 1,41962E0 2,25287E-1 2,10911E0 8,82078E0
0.8mean 9,25712E-2 4,43995E-2 1,21220E-1 1,79405E-1 2,93677E-1 1,77248E-1 8,15945E-2 1,99947E0 6,18414E-1 1,62109E0 2,11813E-1 1,58898E0 1,41957E0 2,25287E-1 2,10907E0 8,82078E0
0.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.0BioUML1,38913E-15,94332E-21,25938E-11,57644E-12,10140E-11,98568E-19,17993E-22,09338E07,39349E-11,67247E02,49348E-11,58764E01,72842E02,61320E-12,12870E08,78168E0
1.0ByoDyn1,38913E-15,94332E-21,25938E-11,57644E-12,10140E-11,98568E-19,17993E-22,09338E07,39349E-11,67247E02,49348E-11,58764E01,72842E02,61320E-12,12870E08,78168E0
1.0MathSBML1,38913E-15,94332E-21,25938E-11,57644E-12,10140E-11,98568E-19,17993E-22,09338E07,39349E-11,67247E02,49348E-11,58764E01,72842E02,61320E-12,12870E08,78168E0
1.0SBToolbox21,38709E-15,94460E-21,26012E-11,57746E-12,09978E-11,98574E-19,18290E-22,09343E07,39492E-11,67245E02,49384E-11,58757E01,72851E02,61310E-12,12871E08,78169E0
1.0SBWOdeSolver1,38915E-15,94335E-21,25937E-11,57643E-12,10143E-11,98568E-19,17990E-22,09338E07,39347E-11,67247E02,49347E-11,58764E01,72842E02,61319E-12,12870E08,78168E0
1.0VCell1,38913E-15,94332E-21,25938E-11,57644E-12,10140E-11,98568E-19,17993E-22,09338E07,39349E-11,67247E02,49348E-11,58764E01,72842E02,61320E-12,12870E08,78168E0
1.0copasi1,38913E-15,94332E-21,25938E-11,57644E-12,10140E-11,98568E-19,17993E-22,09338E07,39349E-11,67247E02,49348E-11,58764E01,72842E02,61320E-12,12870E08,78168E0
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner1,38913E-15,94332E-21,25938E-11,57644E-12,10140E-11,98568E-19,17993E-22,09338E07,39349E-11,67247E02,49348E-11,58764E01,72842E02,61320E-12,12870E08,78168E0
1.0min 1,38709E-1 5,94332E-2 1,25937E-1 1,57643E-1 2,09978E-1 1,98568E-1 9,17990E-2 2,09338E0 7,39347E-1 1,67245E0 2,49347E-1 1,58757E0 1,72842E0 2,61310E-1 2,12870E0 8,78168E0
1.0max 1,38915E-1 5,94460E-2 1,26012E-1 1,57746E-1 2,10143E-1 1,98574E-1 9,18290E-2 2,09343E0 7,39492E-1 1,67247E0 2,49384E-1 1,58764E0 1,72851E0 2,61320E-1 2,12871E0 8,78169E0
1.0mean 1,38913E-1 5,94332E-2 1,25938E-1 1,57644E-1 2,10140E-1 1,98568E-1 9,17993E-2 2,09338E0 7,39349E-1 1,67247E0 2,49348E-1 1,58764E0 1,72842E0 2,61320E-1 2,12870E0 8,78168E0
1.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.2BioUML2,02203E-17,56882E-21,24391E-11,30917E-11,50608E-12,16174E-19,93983E-22,18614E08,40777E-11,72287E02,82389E-11,59915E02,01526E02,93536E-12,14656E08,74237E0
1.2ByoDyn2,02203E-17,56882E-21,24391E-11,30917E-11,50608E-12,16174E-19,93983E-22,18614E08,40777E-11,72287E02,82389E-11,59915E02,01526E02,93536E-12,14656E08,74237E0
1.2MathSBML2,02203E-17,56882E-21,24391E-11,30917E-11,50608E-12,16174E-19,93983E-22,18614E08,40777E-11,72287E02,82389E-11,59915E02,01526E02,93536E-12,14656E08,74237E0
1.2SBToolbox22,01930E-17,57154E-21,24475E-11,30996E-11,50414E-12,16183E-19,94255E-22,18615E08,40967E-11,72290E02,82423E-11,59909E02,01543E02,93526E-12,14659E08,74234E0
1.2SBWOdeSolver2,02205E-17,56884E-21,24391E-11,30917E-11,50611E-12,16174E-19,93981E-22,18614E08,40774E-11,72287E02,82389E-11,59915E02,01526E02,93536E-12,14656E08,74237E0
1.2VCell2,02203E-17,56882E-21,24391E-11,30917E-11,50608E-12,16174E-19,93983E-22,18614E08,40777E-11,72287E02,82389E-11,59915E02,01526E02,93536E-12,14656E08,74237E0
1.2copasi2,02203E-17,56882E-21,24391E-11,30917E-11,50608E-12,16174E-19,93983E-22,18614E08,40777E-11,72287E02,82389E-11,59915E02,01526E02,93536E-12,14656E08,74237E0
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner2,02203E-17,56882E-21,24391E-11,30917E-11,50608E-12,16174E-19,93983E-22,18614E08,40777E-11,72287E02,82389E-11,59915E02,01526E02,93536E-12,14656E08,74237E0
1.2min 2,01930E-1 7,56882E-2 1,24391E-1 1,30917E-1 1,50414E-1 2,16174E-1 9,93981E-2 2,18614E0 8,40774E-1 1,72287E0 2,82389E-1 1,59909E0 2,01526E0 2,93526E-1 2,14656E0 8,74234E0
1.2max 2,02205E-1 7,57154E-2 1,24475E-1 1,30996E-1 1,50611E-1 2,16183E-1 9,94255E-2 2,18615E0 8,40967E-1 1,72290E0 2,82423E-1 1,59915E0 2,01543E0 2,93536E-1 2,14659E0 8,74237E0
1.2mean 2,02203E-1 7,56882E-2 1,24391E-1 1,30917E-1 1,50608E-1 2,16174E-1 9,93983E-2 2,18614E0 8,40777E-1 1,72287E0 2,82389E-1 1,59915E0 2,01526E0 2,93536E-1 2,14656E0 8,74237E0
1.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.4BioUML2,82739E-19,22324E-21,17907E-11,04216E-11,11841E-12,30966E-11,05085E-12,27812E09,22932E-11,77245E03,11812E-11,61898E02,28081E03,22708E-12,16307E08,70227E0
1.4ByoDyn2,82739E-19,22324E-21,17907E-11,04216E-11,11841E-12,30966E-11,05085E-12,27812E09,22932E-11,77245E03,11812E-11,61898E02,28081E03,22708E-12,16307E08,70227E0
1.4MathSBML2,82739E-19,22324E-21,17907E-11,04216E-11,11841E-12,30966E-11,05085E-12,27812E09,22932E-11,77245E03,11812E-11,61898E02,28081E03,22708E-12,16307E08,70227E0
1.4SBToolbox22,82388E-19,22731E-21,18017E-11,04269E-11,11599E-12,30983E-11,05115E-12,27816E09,23185E-11,77245E03,11844E-11,61885E02,28101E03,22704E-12,16309E08,70228E0
1.4SBWOdeSolver2,82741E-19,22325E-21,17907E-11,04217E-11,11844E-12,30966E-11,05084E-12,27812E09,22930E-11,77245E03,11811E-11,61898E02,28081E03,22707E-12,16307E08,70227E0
1.4VCell2,82739E-19,22325E-21,17907E-11,04216E-11,11841E-12,30966E-11,05085E-12,27812E09,22932E-11,77245E03,11812E-11,61898E02,28081E03,22708E-12,16307E08,70227E0
1.4copasi2,82739E-19,22324E-21,17907E-11,04217E-11,11841E-12,30966E-11,05085E-12,27812E09,22932E-11,77245E03,11812E-11,61898E02,28081E03,22708E-12,16307E08,70227E0
1.4edu.kgi.roadRunner2,82739E-19,22324E-21,17907E-11,04216E-11,11841E-12,30966E-11,05085E-12,27812E09,22932E-11,77245E03,11812E-11,61898E02,28081E03,22708E-12,16307E08,70227E0
1.4min 2,82388E-1 9,22324E-2 1,17907E-1 1,04216E-1 1,11599E-1 2,30966E-1 1,05084E-1 2,27812E0 9,22930E-1 1,77245E0 3,11811E-1 1,61885E0 2,28081E0 3,22704E-1 2,16307E0 8,70227E0
1.4max 2,82741E-1 9,22731E-2 1,18017E-1 1,04269E-1 1,11844E-1 2,30983E-1 1,05115E-1 2,27816E0 9,23185E-1 1,77245E0 3,11844E-1 1,61898E0 2,28101E0 3,22708E-1 2,16309E0 8,70228E0
1.4mean 2,82739E-1 9,22324E-2 1,17907E-1 1,04216E-1 1,11841E-1 2,30966E-1 1,05085E-1 2,27812E0 9,22932E-1 1,77245E0 3,11812E-1 1,61898E0 2,28081E0 3,22708E-1 2,16307E0 8,70227E0
1.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.6BioUML3,79389E-11,08260E-11,08584E-18,08922E-29,03078E-22,43559E-11,09352E-12,36953E09,87516E-11,82131E03,38255E-11,64364E02,52719E03,49377E-12,17848E08,66102E0
1.6ByoDyn3,79389E-11,08260E-11,08584E-18,08922E-29,03078E-22,43559E-11,09352E-12,36953E09,87516E-11,82131E03,38255E-11,64364E02,52719E03,49377E-12,17848E08,66102E0
1.6MathSBML3,79389E-11,08260E-11,08584E-18,08922E-29,03078E-22,43559E-11,09352E-12,36953E09,87516E-11,82131E03,38255E-11,64364E02,52719E03,49377E-12,17848E08,66102E0
1.6SBToolbox23,78990E-11,08315E-11,08668E-18,08955E-29,00600E-22,43576E-11,09380E-12,36956E09,87794E-11,82132E03,38278E-11,64358E02,52740E03,49365E-12,17849E08,66104E0
1.6SBWOdeSolver3,79392E-11,08260E-11,08584E-18,08931E-29,03103E-22,43559E-11,09352E-12,36953E09,87513E-11,82131E03,38254E-11,64364E02,52718E03,49377E-12,17848E08,66102E0
1.6VCell3,79389E-11,08260E-11,08584E-18,08922E-29,03079E-22,43559E-11,09352E-12,36953E09,87515E-11,82131E03,38255E-11,64364E02,52719E03,49377E-12,17848E08,66102E0
1.6copasi3,79389E-11,08260E-11,08584E-18,08923E-29,03078E-22,43559E-11,09352E-12,36953E09,87516E-11,82131E03,38255E-11,64364E02,52719E03,49377E-12,17848E08,66102E0
1.6edu.kgi.roadRunner3,79389E-11,08260E-11,08584E-18,08922E-29,03078E-22,43559E-11,09352E-12,36953E09,87516E-11,82131E03,38255E-11,64364E02,52719E03,49377E-12,17848E08,66102E0
1.6min 3,78990E-1 1,08260E-1 1,08584E-1 8,08922E-2 9,00600E-2 2,43559E-1 1,09352E-1 2,36953E0 9,87513E-1 1,82131E0 3,38254E-1 1,64358E0 2,52718E0 3,49365E-1 2,17848E0 8,66102E0
1.6max 3,79392E-1 1,08315E-1 1,08668E-1 8,08955E-2 9,03103E-2 2,43576E-1 1,09380E-1 2,36956E0 9,87794E-1 1,82132E0 3,38278E-1 1,64364E0 2,52740E0 3,49377E-1 2,17849E0 8,66104E0
1.6mean 3,79389E-1 1,08260E-1 1,08584E-1 8,08922E-2 9,03078E-2 2,43559E-1 1,09352E-1 2,36953E0 9,87516E-1 1,82131E0 3,38255E-1 1,64364E0 2,52719E0 3,49377E-1 2,17848E0 8,66102E0
1.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.8BioUML4,90054E-11,23259E-19,90402E-26,27321E-28,20951E-22,54391E-11,12558E-12,46046E01,03701E01,86953E03,62200E-11,67044E02,75719E03,73945E-12,19293E08,61843E0
1.8ByoDyn4,90054E-11,23259E-19,90402E-26,27321E-28,20951E-22,54391E-11,12558E-12,46046E01,03701E01,86953E03,62200E-11,67044E02,75719E03,73945E-12,19293E08,61843E0
1.8MathSBML4,90054E-11,23259E-19,90402E-26,27322E-28,20950E-22,54391E-11,12558E-12,46046E01,03701E01,86953E03,62200E-11,67044E02,75719E03,73945E-12,19293E08,61843E0
1.8SBToolbox24,89647E-11,23310E-19,90870E-26,26933E-28,18574E-22,54408E-11,12577E-12,46047E01,03730E01,86957E03,62225E-11,67035E02,75740E03,73938E-12,19297E08,61840E0
1.8SBWOdeSolver4,90057E-11,23259E-19,90405E-26,27332E-28,20970E-22,54391E-11,12558E-12,46046E01,03701E01,86953E03,62199E-11,67044E02,75719E03,73945E-12,19293E08,61843E0
1.8VCell4,90055E-11,23259E-19,90402E-26,27321E-28,20951E-22,54391E-11,12558E-12,46046E01,03701E01,86953E03,62200E-11,67044E02,75719E03,73945E-12,19293E08,61843E0
1.8copasi4,90054E-11,23259E-19,90403E-26,27321E-28,20950E-22,54391E-11,12558E-12,46046E01,03701E01,86953E03,62200E-11,67044E02,75719E03,73945E-12,19293E08,61843E0
1.8edu.kgi.roadRunner4,90054E-11,23259E-19,90402E-26,27321E-28,20951E-22,54391E-11,12558E-12,46046E01,03701E01,86953E03,62200E-11,67044E02,75719E03,73945E-12,19293E08,61843E0
1.8min 4,89647E-1 1,23259E-1 9,90402E-2 6,26933E-2 8,18574E-2 2,54391E-1 1,12558E-1 2,46046E0 1,03701E0 1,86953E0 3,62199E-1 1,67035E0 2,75719E0 3,73938E-1 2,19293E0 8,61840E0
1.8max 4,90057E-1 1,23310E-1 9,90870E-2 6,27332E-2 8,20970E-2 2,54408E-1 1,12577E-1 2,46047E0 1,03730E0 1,86957E0 3,62225E-1 1,67044E0 2,75740E0 3,73945E-1 2,19297E0 8,61843E0
1.8mean 4,90054E-1 1,23259E-1 9,90402E-2 6,27321E-2 8,20951E-2 2,54391E-1 1,12558E-1 2,46046E0 1,03701E0 1,86953E0 3,62200E-1 1,67044E0 2,75719E0 3,73945E-1 2,19293E0 8,61843E0
1.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.0BioUML6,12183E-11,36980E-19,15112E-25,01835E-28,36086E-22,63784E-11,14967E-12,55097E01,07413E01,91714E03,84020E-11,69745E02,97379E03,96716E-12,20645E08,57446E0
2.0ByoDyn6,12183E-11,36980E-19,15112E-25,01835E-28,36086E-22,63784E-11,14967E-12,55097E01,07413E01,91714E03,84020E-11,69745E02,97379E03,96716E-12,20645E08,57446E0
2.0MathSBML6,12183E-11,36980E-19,15112E-25,01835E-28,36086E-22,63784E-11,14967E-12,55097E01,07413E01,91714E03,84020E-11,69745E02,97379E03,96716E-12,20645E08,57446E0
2.0SBToolbox26,11782E-11,37038E-19,15132E-25,01088E-28,33972E-22,63802E-11,14988E-12,55100E01,07438E01,91712E03,84050E-11,69742E02,97400E03,96710E-12,20646E08,57444E0
2.0SBWOdeSolver6,12185E-11,36980E-19,15119E-25,01846E-28,36100E-22,63783E-11,14967E-12,55097E01,07412E01,91714E03,84020E-11,69745E02,97378E03,96716E-12,20645E08,57446E0
2.0VCell6,12183E-11,36980E-19,15112E-25,01835E-28,36086E-22,63784E-11,14967E-12,55097E01,07413E01,91714E03,84020E-11,69745E02,97379E03,96716E-12,20645E08,57446E0
2.0copasi6,12183E-11,36980E-19,15112E-25,01834E-28,36086E-22,63784E-11,14967E-12,55097E01,07413E01,91714E03,84020E-11,69745E02,97379E03,96716E-12,20645E08,57446E0
2.0edu.kgi.roadRunner6,12183E-11,36980E-19,15112E-25,01835E-28,36086E-22,63784E-11,14967E-12,55097E01,07413E01,91714E03,84020E-11,69745E02,97379E03,96716E-12,20645E08,57446E0
2.0min 6,11782E-1 1,36980E-1 9,15112E-2 5,01088E-2 8,33972E-2 2,63783E-1 1,14967E-1 2,55097E0 1,07412E0 1,91712E0 3,84020E-1 1,69742E0 2,97378E0 3,96710E-1 2,20645E0 8,57444E0
2.0max 6,12185E-1 1,37038E-1 9,15132E-2 5,01846E-2 8,36100E-2 2,63802E-1 1,14988E-1 2,55100E0 1,07438E0 1,91714E0 3,84050E-1 1,69745E0 2,97400E0 3,96716E-1 2,20646E0 8,57446E0
2.0mean 6,12183E-1 1,36980E-1 9,15112E-2 5,01835E-2 8,36086E-2 2,63784E-1 1,14967E-1 2,55097E0 1,07413E0 1,91714E0 3,84020E-1 1,69745E0 2,97379E0 3,96716E-1 2,20645E0 8,57446E0
2.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.2BioUML7,43207E-11,49351E-18,71690E-24,28141E-29,21927E-22,71979E-11,16775E-12,64107E01,10147E01,96415E04,04011E-11,72326E03,17973E04,17929E-12,21905E08,52916E0
2.2ByoDyn7,43207E-11,49351E-18,71690E-24,28141E-29,21927E-22,71979E-11,16775E-12,64107E01,10147E01,96415E04,04011E-11,72326E03,17973E04,17929E-12,21905E08,52916E0
2.2MathSBML7,43207E-11,49351E-18,71690E-24,28141E-29,21927E-22,71979E-11,16775E-12,64107E01,10147E01,96415E04,04011E-11,72326E