Test: BIOMD0000000077.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000077.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: Imex
generated code: BIOMD0000000077.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-100
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-7
STEP 1.0E-4

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000077.gif

Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL3092061764.png

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: species_2  species_1  species_0  species_8  species_5  species_6  species_3  species_4 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  SBToolbox2  Oscill8 Core  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  BioUML 
timeresult species_2 species_1 species_0 species_8 species_5 species_6 species_3 species_4
0.0BioUML1,00000E-20,00000E01,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-10,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0ByoDyn1,00000E-20,00000E01,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-10,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0MathSBML1,00000E-20,00000E01,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-10,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0Oscill8 Core1,00000E-20,00000E0---0,00000E00,00000E0-
0.0SBToolbox21,00000E-20,00000E01,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-10,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0SBWOdeSolver1,00000E-20,00000E01,00000E0-1,00000E-10,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0copasi1,00000E-20,00000E01,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-10,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner1,00000E-20,00000E01,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-10,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0min 1,00000E-2 0,00000E0 1,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E-1 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0max 1,00000E-2 0,00000E0 1,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E-1 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0mean 1,00000E-2 0,00000E0 1,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E-1 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML7,04554E-31,55105E-39,97046E-12,76308E-19,95383E-24,36133E22,39984E-44,61718E-4
0.2ByoDyn7,04551E-31,55107E-39,97046E-12,76328E-19,95383E-24,36111E22,39988E-44,61724E-4
0.2MathSBML7,04551E-31,55107E-39,97046E-12,76327E-19,95383E-24,36110E22,39987E-44,61723E-4
0.2Oscill8 Core7,04553E-31,55106E-3---4,36124E22,39985E-4-
0.2SBToolbox27,04529E-31,55165E-39,97042E-12,76140E-19,95386E-24,35602E22,39926E-44,61594E-4
0.2SBWOdeSolver7,04553E-31,55106E-39,97046E-1-9,95383E-24,36126E22,39985E-44,61720E-4
0.2copasi7,04551E-31,55107E-39,97046E-12,76328E-19,95383E-24,36111E22,39988E-44,61724E-4
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner7,04551E-31,55107E-39,97046E-12,76906E-19,95383E-24,36110E22,39988E-44,61724E-4
0.2min 7,04529E-3 1,55106E-3 9,97042E-1 2,76140E-1 9,95383E-2 4,35602E2 2,39926E-4 4,61594E-4
0.2max 7,04553E-3 1,55165E-3 9,97046E-1 2,76906E-1 9,95386E-2 4,36126E2 2,39988E-4 4,61724E-4
0.2mean 7,04551E-3 1,55107E-3 9,97046E-1 2,76328E-1 9,95383E-2 4,36111E2 2,39987E-4 4,61724E-4
0.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML5,49031E-31,51151E-39,95490E-14,21826E-19,90075E-21,49037E35,06571E-49,92519E-4
0.4ByoDyn5,49000E-31,51150E-39,95490E-14,21902E-19,90074E-21,49053E35,06624E-49,92626E-4
0.4MathSBML5,49000E-31,51150E-39,95490E-14,21902E-19,90074E-21,49053E35,06624E-49,92626E-4
0.4Oscill8 Core5,49002E-31,51150E-3---1,49052E35,06619E-4-
0.4SBToolbox25,48957E-31,51150E-39,95492E-14,21870E-19,90069E-21,49011E35,06669E-49,92775E-4
0.4SBWOdeSolver5,49002E-31,51150E-39,95490E-1-9,90074E-21,49052E35,06620E-49,92617E-4
0.4copasi5,49000E-31,51150E-39,95490E-14,21902E-19,90074E-21,49053E35,06624E-49,92627E-4
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner5,49000E-31,51150E-39,95490E-14,17552E-19,90074E-21,49053E35,06624E-49,92627E-4
0.4min 5,48957E-3 1,51150E-3 9,95490E-1 4,17552E-1 9,90069E-2 1,49011E3 5,06619E-4 9,92617E-4
0.4max 5,49002E-3 1,51150E-3 9,95492E-1 4,21902E-1 9,90074E-2 1,49053E3 5,06669E-4 9,92775E-4
0.4mean 5,49000E-3 1,51150E-3 9,95490E-1 4,21902E-1 9,90074E-2 1,49053E3 5,06624E-4 9,92626E-4
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML4,51171E-31,47032E-39,94512E-13,92951E-19,86689E-22,32267E36,77907E-41,33108E-3
0.6ByoDyn4,51039E-31,47026E-39,94510E-13,92990E-19,86685E-22,32374E36,78137E-41,33154E-3
0.6MathSBML4,51039E-31,47026E-39,94510E-13,92990E-19,86685E-22,32374E36,78136E-41,33154E-3
0.6Oscill8 Core4,51042E-31,47026E-3---2,32372E36,78132E-4-
0.6SBToolbox24,50884E-31,47020E-39,94512E-13,93013E-19,86678E-22,32454E36,78388E-41,33209E-3
0.6SBWOdeSolver4,51042E-31,47026E-39,94510E-1-9,86685E-22,32372E36,78132E-41,33153E-3
0.6copasi4,51039E-31,47026E-39,94510E-13,92990E-19,86685E-22,32375E36,78137E-41,33154E-3
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner4,51039E-31,47026E-39,94510E-13,85275E-19,86685E-22,32375E36,78137E-41,33154E-3
0.6min 4,50884E-3 1,47020E-3 9,94510E-1 3,85275E-1 9,86678E-2 2,32372E3 6,78132E-4 1,33153E-3
0.6max 4,51042E-3 1,47026E-3 9,94512E-1 3,93013E-1 9,86685E-2 2,32454E3 6,78388E-4 1,33209E-3
0.6mean 4,51039E-3 1,47026E-3 9,94510E-1 3,92990E-1 9,86685E-2 2,32374E3 6,78137E-4 1,33154E-3
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML3,89136E-31,44388E-39,93891E-13,46216E-19,84546E-22,87243E37,86979E-41,54540E-3
0.8ByoDyn3,89020E-31,44383E-39,93890E-13,46140E-19,84542E-22,87345E37,87182E-41,54580E-3
0.8MathSBML3,89020E-31,44383E-39,93890E-13,46140E-19,84542E-22,87345E37,87182E-41,54580E-3
0.8Oscill8 Core3,89022E-31,44383E-3---2,87343E37,87178E-4-
0.8SBToolbox23,88698E-31,44369E-39,93892E-13,46189E-19,84527E-22,87613E37,87741E-41,54692E-3
0.8SBWOdeSolver3,89022E-31,44383E-39,93890E-1-9,84542E-22,87343E37,87178E-41,54580E-3
0.8copasi3,89020E-31,44383E-39,93890E-13,46140E-19,84542E-22,87345E37,87182E-41,54580E-3
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner3,89020E-31,44383E-39,93890E-13,42424E-19,84542E-22,87345E37,87182E-41,54580E-3
0.8min 3,88698E-3 1,44369E-3 9,93890E-1 3,42424E-1 9,84527E-2 2,87343E3 7,87178E-4 1,54580E-3
0.8max 3,89022E-3 1,44383E-3 9,93892E-1 3,46189E-1 9,84542E-2 2,87613E3 7,87741E-4 1,54692E-3
0.8mean 3,89020E-3 1,44383E-3 9,93890E-1 3,46140E-1 9,84542E-2 2,87345E3 7,87182E-4 1,54580E-3
0.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.0BioUML3,49818E-31,42707E-39,93498E-13,11541E-19,83189E-23,22343E38,56283E-41,68110E-3
1.0ByoDyn3,49720E-31,42702E-39,93497E-13,11448E-19,83186E-23,22430E38,56454E-41,68143E-3
1.0MathSBML3,49721E-31,42702E-39,93497E-13,11448E-19,83186E-23,22430E38,56454E-41,68143E-3
1.0Oscill8 Core3,49722E-31,42703E-3---3,22428E38,56451E-4-
1.0SBToolbox23,49417E-31,42687E-39,93492E-13,11479E-19,83175E-23,22691E38,56975E-41,68246E-3
1.0SBWOdeSolver3,49722E-31,42703E-39,93497E-1-9,83186E-23,22428E38,56451E-41,68143E-3
1.0copasi3,49721E-31,42702E-39,93497E-13,11448E-19,83186E-23,22430E38,56454E-41,68143E-3
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner3,49721E-31,42702E-39,93497E-13,05540E-19,83186E-23,22430E38,56454E-41,68143E-3
1.0min 3,49417E-3 1,42687E-3 9,93492E-1 3,05540E-1 9,83175E-2 3,22428E3 8,56451E-4 1,68143E-3
1.0max 3,49722E-3 1,42703E-3 9,93497E-1 3,11479E-1 9,83186E-2 3,22691E3 8,56975E-4 1,68246E-3
1.0mean 3,49721E-3 1,42702E-3 9,93497E-1 3,11448E-1 9,83186E-2 3,22430E3 8,56454E-4 1,68143E-3
1.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.2BioUML3,24814E-31,41635E-39,93248E-12,90139E-19,82327E-23,44679E39,00425E-41,76733E-3
1.2ByoDyn3,24805E-31,41635E-39,93248E-12,90128E-19,82326E-23,44688E39,00443E-41,76736E-3
1.2MathSBML3,24805E-31,41635E-39,93248E-12,90128E-19,82326E-23,44688E39,00443E-41,76736E-3
1.2Oscill8 Core3,24806E-31,41635E-3---3,44687E39,00441E-4-
1.2SBToolbox23,24499E-31,41625E-39,93241E-12,90157E-19,82315E-23,44963E39,00979E-41,76839E-3
1.2SBWOdeSolver3,24806E-31,41635E-39,93248E-1-9,82326E-23,44687E39,00441E-41,76736E-3
1.2copasi3,24805E-31,41635E-39,93248E-12,90128E-19,82326E-23,44688E39,00442E-41,76736E-3
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner3,24805E-31,41635E-39,93248E-12,87630E-19,82326E-23,44688E39,00442E-41,76736E-3
1.2min 3,24499E-3 1,41625E-3 9,93241E-1 2,87630E-1 9,82315E-2 3,44687E3 9,00441E-4 1,76736E-3
1.2max 3,24806E-3 1,41635E-3 9,93248E-1 2,90157E-1 9,82326E-2 3,44963E3 9,00979E-4 1,76839E-3
1.2mean 3,24805E-3 1,41635E-3 9,93248E-1 2,90128E-1 9,82326E-2 3,44688E3 9,00442E-4 1,76736E-3
1.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.4BioUML3,09069E-31,40959E-39,93091E-12,78194E-19,81784E-23,58738E39,28252E-41,82161E-3
1.4ByoDyn3,09003E-31,40956E-39,93090E-12,78129E-19,81782E-23,58798E39,28369E-41,82184E-3
1.4MathSBML3,09003E-31,40956E-39,93090E-12,78129E-19,81782E-23,58798E39,28369E-41,82184E-3
1.4Oscill8 Core3,09003E-31,40956E-3---3,58797E39,28368E-4-
1.4SBToolbox23,08708E-31,40944E-39,93090E-12,78152E-19,81773E-23,59060E39,28883E-41,82281E-3
1.4SBWOdeSolver3,09003E-31,40956E-39,93090E-1-9,81782E-23,58797E39,28368E-41,82183E-3
1.4copasi3,09003E-31,40956E-39,93090E-12,78129E-19,81782E-23,58798E39,28369E-41,82184E-3
1.4edu.kgi.roadRunner3,09003E-31,40956E-39,93090E-12,76067E-19,81782E-23,58798E39,28368E-41,82183E-3
1.4min 3,08708E-3 1,40944E-3 9,93090E-1 2,76067E-1 9,81773E-2 3,58797E3 9,28368E-4 1,82183E-3
1.4max 3,09003E-3 1,40956E-3 9,93090E-1 2,78152E-1 9,81782E-2 3,59060E3 9,28883E-4 1,82281E-3
1.4mean 3,09003E-3 1,40956E-3 9,93090E-1 2,78129E-1 9,81782E-2 3,58798E3 9,28369E-4 1,82184E-3
1.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.6BioUML2,99045E-31,40529E-39,92990E-12,71783E-19,81438E-23,67685E39,45978E-41,85615E-3
1.6ByoDyn2,98979E-31,40526E-39,92990E-12,71727E-19,81436E-23,67745E39,46096E-41,85638E-3
1.6MathSBML2,98979E-31,40526E-39,92990E-12,71727E-19,81436E-23,67745E39,46095E-41,85638E-3
1.6Oscill8 Core2,98979E-31,40526E-3---3,67744E39,46094E-4-
1.6SBToolbox22,98722E-31,40513E-39,92990E-12,71747E-19,81432E-23,67974E39,46558E-41,85728E-3
1.6SBWOdeSolver2,98979E-31,40526E-39,92990E-1-9,81436E-23,67744E39,46095E-41,85638E-3
1.6copasi2,98979E-31,40526E-39,92990E-12,71727E-19,81436E-23,67744E39,46095E-41,85638E-3
1.6edu.kgi.roadRunner2,98979E-31,40526E-39,92990E-12,70289E-19,81436E-23,67744E39,46094E-41,85638E-3
1.6min 2,98722E-3 1,40513E-3 9,92990E-1 2,70289E-1 9,81432E-2 3,67744E3 9,46094E-4 1,85638E-3
1.6max 2,98979E-3 1,40526E-3 9,92990E-1 2,71747E-1 9,81436E-2 3,67974E3 9,46558E-4 1,85728E-3
1.6mean 2,98979E-3 1,40526E-3 9,92990E-1 2,71727E-1 9,81436E-2 3,67744E3 9,46095E-4 1,85638E-3
1.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.8BioUML2,92683E-31,40255E-39,92927E-12,68485E-19,81219E-23,73362E39,57233E-41,87807E-3
1.8ByoDyn2,92619E-31,40252E-39,92926E-12,68440E-19,81217E-23,73419E39,57346E-41,87830E-3
1.8MathSBML2,92619E-31,40252E-39,92926E-12,68440E-19,81217E-23,73419E39,57346E-41,87830E-3
1.8Oscill8 Core2,92620E-31,40252E-3---3,73419E39,57346E-4-
1.8SBToolbox22,92363E-31,40242E-39,92922E-12,68462E-19,81212E-23,73642E39,57793E-41,87916E-3
1.8SBWOdeSolver2,92619E-31,40252E-39,92926E-1-9,81217E-23,73419E39,57346E-41,87829E-3
1.8copasi2,92619E-31,40252E-39,92926E-12,68440E-19,81217E-23,73419E39,57346E-41,87830E-3
1.8edu.kgi.roadRunner2,92620E-31,40252E-39,92926E-12,68365E-19,81217E-23,73419E39,57345E-41,87829E-3
1.8min 2,92363E-3 1,40242E-3 9,92922E-1 2,68365E-1 9,81212E-2 3,73419E3 9,57345E-4 1,87829E-3
1.8max 2,92620E-3 1,40252E-3 9,92926E-1 2,68462E-1 9,81217E-2 3,73642E3 9,57793E-4 1,87916E-3
1.8mean 2,92619E-3 1,40252E-3 9,92926E-1 2,68440E-1 9,81217E-2 3,73419E3 9,57346E-4 1,87830E-3
1.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.0BioUML2,88636E-31,40081E-39,92886E-12,66834E-19,81080E-23,76973E39,64396E-41,89202E-3
2.0ByoDyn2,88584E-31,40079E-39,92886E-12,66805E-19,81078E-23,77019E39,64487E-41,89220E-3
2.0MathSBML2,88584E-31,40079E-39,92886E-12,66805E-19,81078E-23,77019E39,64487E-41,89220E-3
2.0Oscill8 Core2,88584E-31,40079E-3---3,77018E39,64486E-4-
2.0SBToolbox22,88362E-31,40070E-39,92880E-12,66822E-19,81070E-23,77220E39,64884E-41,89298E-3
2.0SBWOdeSolver2,88584E-31,40079E-39,92886E-1-9,81078E-23,77018E39,64486E-41,89220E-3
2.0copasi2,88584E-31,40079E-39,92886E-12,66805E-19,81078E-23,77018E39,64486E-41,89220E-3
2.0edu.kgi.roadRunner2,88585E-31,40079E-39,92886E-12,66662E-19,81078E-23,77018E39,64486E-41,89220E-3
2.0min 2,88362E-3 1,40070E-3 9,92880E-1 2,66662E-1 9,81070E-2 3,77018E3 9,64486E-4 1,89220E-3
2.0max 2,88585E-3 1,40079E-3 9,92886E-1 2,66822E-1 9,81078E-2 3,77220E3 9,64884E-4 1,89298E-3
2.0mean 2,88584E-3 1,40079E-3 9,92886E-1 2,66805E-1 9,81078E-2 3,77018E3 9,64486E-4 1,89220E-3
2.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.2BioUML2,86056E-31,39970E-39,92861E-12,66029E-19,80991E-23,79273E39,68961E-41,90091E-3
2.2ByoDyn2,86024E-31,39969E-39,92860E-12,66015E-19,80990E-23,79302E39,69018E-41,90102E-3
2.2MathSBML2,86024E-31,39969E-39,92860E-12,66015E-19,80990E-23,79302E39,69018E-41,90102E-3
2.2Oscill8 Core2,86024E-31,39969E-3---3,79302E39,69018E-4-
2.2SBToolbox22,85862E-31,39962E-39,92860E-12,66027E-19,80982E-23,79440E39,69300E-41,90153E-3
2.2SBWOdeSolver2,86024E-31,39969E-39,92860E-1-9,80990E-23,79302E39,69018E-41,90102E-3
2.2copasi2,86024E-31,39969E-39,92860E-12,66015E-19,80990E-23,79302E39,69017E-41,90102E-3
2.2edu.kgi.roadRunner2,86024E-31,39969E-39,92860E-12,65895E-19,80990E-23,79302E39,69017E-41,90102E-3
2.2min 2,85862E-3 1,39962E-3 9,92860E-1 2,65895E-1 9,80982E-2 3,79302E3 9,69017E-4 1,90102E-3
2.2max 2,86024E-3 1,39969E-3 9,92860E-1 2,66027E-1 9,80990E-2 3,79440E3 9,69300E-4 1,90153E-3
2.2mean 2,86024E-3 1,39969E-3 9,92860E-1 2,66015E-1 9,80990E-2 3,79302E3 9,69018E-4 1,90102E-3
2.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.4BioUML2,84416E-31,39900E-39,92844E-12,65652E-19,80934E-23,80736E39,71864E-41,90656E-3
2.4ByoDyn2,84399E-31,39899E-39,92844E-12,65646E-19,80934E-23,80751E39,71894E-41,90662E-3
2.4MathSBML2,84399E-31,39899E-39,92844E-12,65646E-19,80934E-23,80751E39,71894E-41,90662E-3
2.4Oscill8 Core2,84399E-31,39899E-3---3,80751E39,71893E-4-
2.4SBToolbox22,84234E-31,39890E-39,92840E-12,65655E-19,80930E-23,80898E39,72194E-41,90715E-3
2.4SBWOdeSolver2,84399E-31,39899E-39,92844E-1-9,80934E-23,80751E39,71893E-41,90662E-3
2.4copasi2,84399E-31,39899E-39,92844E-12,65646E-19,80934E-23,80751E39,71893E-41,90662E-3
2.4edu.kgi.roadRunner2,84399E-31,39899E-39,92844E-12,65563E-19,80934E-23,80751E39,71893E-41,90662E-3
2.4min 2,84234E-3 1,39890E-3 9,92840E-1 2,65563E-1 9,80930E-2 3,80751E3 9,71893E-4 1,90662E-3
2.4max 2,84399E-3 1,39899E-3 9,92844E-1 2,65655E-1 9,80934E-2 3,80898E3 9,72194E-4 1,90715E-3
2.4mean 2,84399E-3 1,39899E-3 9,92844E-1 2,65646E-1 9,80934E-2 3,80751E3 9,71893E-4 1,90662E-3
2.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.6BioUML2,83388E-31,39855E-39,92834E-12,65484E-19,80899E-23,81653E39,73684E-41,91010E-3
2.6ByoDyn2,83368E-31,39855E-39,92834E-12,65479E-19,80898E-23,81671E39,73719E-41,91017E-3
2.6MathSBML2,83368E-31,39855E-39,92834E-12,65479E-19,80898E-23,81670E39,73719E-41,91017E-3
2.6Oscill8 Core2,83368E-31,39855E-3---3,81670E39,73718E-4-
2.6SBToolbox22,83260E-31,39850E-39,92830E-12,65490E-19,80893E-23,81770E39,73912E-41,91055E-3
2.6SBWOdeSolver2,83368E-31,39855E-39,92834E-1-9,80898E-23,81670E39,73718E-41,91017E-3
2.6copasi2,83368E-31,39855E-39,92834E-12,65479E-19,80898E-23,81670E39,73718E-41,91017E-3
2.6edu.kgi.roadRunner2,83368E-31,39855E-39,92834E-12,65428E-19,80898E-23,81670E39,73718E-41,91017E-3
2.6min 2,83260E-3 1,39850E-3 9,92830E-1 2,65428E-1 9,80893E-2 3,81670E3 9,73718E-4 1,91017E-3
2.6max 2,83368E-3 1,39855E-3 9,92834E-1 2,65490E-1 9,80898E-2 3,81770E3 9,73912E-4 1,91055E-3
2.6mean 2,83368E-3 1,39855E-3 9,92834E-1 2,65479E-1 9,80898E-2 3,81670E3 9,73718E-4 1,91017E-3
2.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.8BioUML2,82735E-31,39827E-39,92827E-12,65412E-19,80877E-23,82235E39,74840E-41,91235E-3
2.8ByoDyn2,82714E-31,39826E-39,92827E-12,65409E-19,80876E-23,82254E39,74877E-41,91242E-3
2.8MathSBML2,82714E-31,39826E-39,92827E-12,65409E-19,80876E-23,82254E39,74877E-41,91242E-3
2.8Oscill8 Core2,82714E-31,39826E-3---3,82254E39,74877E-4-
2.8SBToolbox22,82598E-31,39820E-39,92830E-12,65420E-19,80870E-23,82354E39,75076E-41,91277E-3
2.8SBWOdeSolver2,82714E-31,39826E-39,92827E-1-9,80876E-23,82254E39,74877E-41,91242E-3
2.8copasi2,82714E-31,39826E-39,92827E-12,65409E-19,80876E-23,82254E39,74877E-41,91242E-3
2.8edu.kgi.roadRunner2,82714E-31,39826E-39,92827E-12,65378E-19,80876E-23,82254E39,74876E-41,91242E-3
2.8min 2,82598E-3 1,39820E-3 9,92827E-1 2,65378E-1 9,80870E-2 3,82254E3 9,74876E-4 1,91242E-3
2.8max 2,82714E-3 1,39826E-3 9,92830E-1 2,65420E-1 9,80876E-2 3,82354E3 9,75076E-4 1,91277E-3
2.8mean 2,82714E-3 1,39826E-3 9,92827E-1 2,65409E-1 9,80876E-2 3,82254E3 9,74877E-4 1,91242E-3
2.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.0BioUML2,82315E-31,39809E-39,92823E-12,65383E-19,80862E-23,82610E39,75584E-41,91380E-3
3.0ByoDyn2,82299E-31,39809E-39,92823E-12,65381E-19,80861E-23,82624E39,75612E-41,91385E-3
3.0MathSBML2,82299E-31,39809E-39,92823E-12,65381E-19,80861E-23,82624E39,75612E-41,91385E-3
3.0Oscill8 Core2,82299E-31,39809E-3---3,82624E39,75612E-4-
3.0SBToolbox22,82223E-31,39803E-39,92820E-12,65390E-19,80860E-23,82697E39,75751E-41,91410E-3
3.0SBWOdeSolver2,82299E-31,39809E-39,92823E-1-9,80861E-23,82624E39,75612E-41,91385E-3
3.0copasi2,82299E-31,39809E-39,92823E-12,65381E-19,80861E-23,82624E39,75611E-41,91385E-3
3.0edu.kgi.roadRunner2,82299E-31,39809E-39,92823E-12,65364E-19,80861E-23,82624E39,75611E-41,91385E-3
3.0min 2,82223E-3 1,39803E-3 9,92820E-1 2,65364E-1 9,80860E-2 3,82624E3 9,75611E-4 1,91385E-3
3.0max 2,82299E-3 1,39809E-3 9,92823E-1 2,65390E-1 9,80861E-2 3,82697E3 9,75751E-4 1,91410E-3
3.0mean 2,82299E-3 1,39809E-3 9,92823E-1 2,65381E-1 9,80861E-2 3,82624E3 9,75612E-4 1,91385E-3
3.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.2BioUML2,82048E-31,39798E-39,92820E-12,65373E-19,80853E-23,82848E39,76056E-41,91472E-3
3.2ByoDyn2,82035E-31,39797E-39,92820E-12,65372E-19,80852E-23,82859E39,76078E-41,91476E-3
3.2MathSBML2,82035E-31,39797E-39,92820E-12,65372E-19,80852E-23,82859E39,76078E-41,91476E-3
3.2Oscill8 Core2,82035E-31,39797E-3---3,82859E39,76078E-4-
3.2SBToolbox22,81973E-31,39790E-39,92820E-12,65380E-19,80850E-23,82917E39,76184E-41,91497E-3
3.2SBWOdeSolver2,82035E-31,39797E-39,92820E-1-9,80852E-23,82859E39,76078E-41,91476E-3
3.2copasi2,82036E-31,39797E-39,92820E-12,65372E-19,80852E-23,82859E39,76078E-41,91476E-3
3.2edu.kgi.roadRunner2,82036E-31,39797E-39,92820E-12,65371E-19,80852E-23,82859E39,76077E-41,91476E-3
3.2min 2,81973E-3 1,39790E-3 9,92820E-1 2,65371E-1 9,80850E-2 3,82859E3 9,76077E-4 1,91476E-3
3.2max 2,82036E-3 1,39797E-3 9,92820E-1 2,65380E-1 9,80852E-2 3,82917E3 9,76184E-4 1,91497E-3
3.2mean 2,82035E-3 1,39797E-3 9,92820E-1 2,65372E-1 9,80852E-2 3,82859E3 9,76078E-4 1,91476E-3
3.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.4BioUML2,81879E-31,39790E-39,92819E-12,65371E-19,80847E-23,82999E39,76356E-41,91530E-3
3.4ByoDyn2,81868E-31,39790E-39,92819E-12,65371E-19,80847E-23,83008E39,76374E-41,91533E-3
3.4MathSBML2,81868E-31,39790E-39,92819E-12,65371E-19,80847E-23,83008E39,76374E-41,91533E-3
3.4Oscill8 Core2,81868E-31,39790E-3---3,83008E39,76374E-4-
3.4SBToolbox22,81803E-31,39790E-39,92820E-12,65380E-19,80840E-23,83067E39,76487E-41,91557E-3
3.4SBWOdeSolver2,81868E-31,39790E-39,92819E-1-9,80847E-23,83008E39,76374E-41,91533E-3
3.4copasi2,81868E-31,39790E-39,92819E-12,65371E-19,80847E-23,83008E39,76374E-41,91533E-3
3.4edu.kgi.roadRunner2,81868E-31,39790E-39,92819E-12,65370E-19,80847E-23,83008E39,76374E-41,91533E-3
3.4min 2,81803E-3 1,39790E-3 9,92819E-1 2,65370E-1 9,80840E-2 3,83008E3 9,76374E-4 1,91533E-3
3.4max 2,81868E-3 1,39790E-3 9,92820E-1 2,65380E-1 9,80847E-2 3,83067E3 9,76487E-4 1,91557E-3
3.4mean 2,81868E-3 1,39790E-3 9,92819E-1 2,65371E-1 9,80847E-2 3,83008E3 9,76374E-4 1,91533E-3
3.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.6BioUML2,81769E-31,39786E-39,92818E-12,65372E-19,80843E-23,83096E39,76549E-41,91568E-3
3.6ByoDyn2,81762E-31,39785E-39,92818E-12,65372E-19,80843E-23,83103E39,76562E-41,91570E-3
3.6MathSBML2,81762E-31,39785E-39,92818E-12,65372E-19,80843E-23,83103E39,76562E-41,91570E-3
3.6Oscill8 Core2,81762E-31,39785E-3---3,83103E39,76562E-4-
3.6SBToolbox22,81710E-31,39780E-39,92820E-12,65380E-19,80840E-23,83150E39,76656E-41,91590E-3
3.6SBWOdeSolver2,81762E-31,39785E-39,92818E-1-9,80843E-23,83103E39,76562E-41,91570E-3
3.6copasi2,81762E-31,39785E-39,92818E-12,65372E-19,80843E-23,83103E39,76562E-41,91570E-3
3.6edu.kgi.roadRunner2,81762E-31,39785E-39,92818E-12,65371E-19,80843E-23,83103E39,76561E-41,91570E-3
3.6min 2,81710E-3 1,39780E-3 9,92818E-1 2,65371E-1 9,80840E-2 3,83103E3 9,76561E-4 1,91570E-3
3.6max 2,81762E-3 1,39785E-3 9,92820E-1 2,65380E-1 9,80843E-2 3,83150E3 9,76656E-4 1,91590E-3
3.6mean 2,81762E-3 1,39785E-3 9,92818E-1 2,65372E-1 9,80843E-2 3,83103E3 9,76562E-4 1,91570E-3
3.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.8BioUML2,81696E-31,39783E-39,92817E-12,65374E-19,80841E-23,83162E39,76679E-41,91593E-3
3.8ByoDyn2,81695E-31,39783E-39,92817E-12,65374E-19,80841E-23,83163E39,76681E-41,91593E-3
3.8MathSBML2,81695E-31,39783E-39,92817E-12,65374E-19,80841E-23,83163E39,76681E-41,91593E-3
3.8Oscill8 Core2,81695E-31,39783E-3---3,83163E39,76681E-4-
3.8SBToolbox22,81664E-31,39780E-39,92820E-12,65380E-19,80840E-23,83190E39,76736E-41,91600E-3
3.8SBWOdeSolver2,81695E-31,39783E-39,92817E-1-9,80841E-23,83163E39,76681E-41,91593E-3
3.8copasi2,81695E-31,39783E-39,92817E-12,65374E-19,80841E-23,83163E39,76681E-41,91593E-3
3.8edu.kgi.roadRunner2,81695E-31,39783E-39,92817E-12,65373E-19,80841E-23,83163E39,76681E-41,91593E-3
3.8min 2,81664E-3 1,39780E-3 9,92817E-1 2,65373E-1 9,80840E-2 3,83163E3 9,76681E-4 1,91593E-3
3.8max 2,81695E-3 1,39783E-3 9,92820E-1 2,65380E-1 9,80841E-2 3,83190E3 9,76736E-4 1,91600E-3
3.8mean 2,81695E-3 1,39783E-3 9,92817E-1 2,65374E-1 9,80841E-2 3,83163E3 9,76681E-4 1,91593E-3
3.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
4.0BioUML2,81657E-31,39781E-39,92817E-12,65375E-19,80839E-23,83197E39,76748E-41,91606E-3
4.0ByoDyn2,81652E-31,39781E-39,92817E-12,65375E-19,80839E-23,83201E39,76756E-41,91608E-3
4.0MathSBML2,81652E-31,39781E-39,92817E-12,65375E-19,80839E-23,83201E39,76756E-41,91608E-3
4.0Oscill8 Core2,81652E-31,39781E-3---3,83201E39,76756E-4-
4.0SBToolbox22,81630E-31,39780E-39,92820E-12,65380E-19,80840E-23,83220E39,76800E-41,91620E-3
4.0SBWOdeSolver2,81652E-31,39781E-39,92817E-1-9,80839E-23,83201E39,76756E-41,91608E-3
4.0copasi2,81652E-31,39781E-39,92817E-12,65375E-19,80839E-2