Test: BIOMD0000000082.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000082.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: DormandPrince
generated code: BIOMD0000000082.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-13
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000082.gif

Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL1166069080.png

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: DRG_GTP  GDP  Recptor  G_GTP  DR  DRG_GDP  GTP  G_GDP  DRG  agonist 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  Jarnac  SBToolbox2  VCell  Oscill8 Core  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  jsim  BioUML 
timeresult DRG_GTP GDP Recptor G_GTP DR DRG_GDP GTP G_GDP DRG agonist
0.0BioUML0,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-51,00000E-90,00000E01,00000E-8
0.0ByoDyn0,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-51,00000E-90,00000E01,00000E-8
0.0Jarnac0,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-51,00000E-90,00000E01,00000E-8
0.0MathSBML0,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-51,00000E-90,00000E01,00000E-8
0.0Oscill8 Core0,00000E0---0,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-51,00000E-90,00000E0-
0.0SBToolbox20,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-51,00000E-90,00000E01,00000E-8
0.0SBWOdeSolver0,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-51,00000E-90,00000E01,00000E-8
0.0VCell0,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-51,00000E-90,00000E01,00000E-8
0.0copasi0,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-51,00000E-90,00000E01,00000E-8
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner0,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-51,00000E-90,00000E01,00000E-8
0.0jsim0,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,00000E-51,00000E-90,00000E01,00000E-8
0.0min 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E-9 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E-5 1,00000E-9 0,00000E0 1,00000E-8
0.0max 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E-9 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E-5 1,00000E-9 0,00000E0 1,00000E-8
0.0mean 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E-9 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E-5 1,00000E-9 0,00000E0 1,00000E-8
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML1,26569E-156,38937E-169,90532E-109,68432E-199,37300E-129,44918E-141,00000E-59,99905E-10-6,27725E-169,99053E-9
0.2ByoDyn5,51400E-166,38937E-169,90532E-101,32557E-189,37300E-129,44918E-141,00000E-59,99905E-108,62069E-179,99053E-9
0.2Jarnac5,51400E-166,38937E-169,90532E-101,32556E-189,37300E-129,44918E-141,00000E-59,99905E-108,62069E-179,99053E-9
0.2MathSBML6,23845E-153,53154E-149,90706E-105,04763E-199,20594E-125,25328E-141,00000E-59,99912E-102,90764E-149,99071E-9
0.2Oscill8 Core6,41060E-16---9,34440E-129,86703E-141,00000E-59,99901E-109,05081E-17-
0.2SBToolbox26,48988E-167,36738E-169,90529E-102,30945E-189,37738E-129,36362E-141,00000E-59,99910E-108,54199E-179,99051E-9
0.2SBWOdeSolver5,51481E-166,39024E-169,90532E-101,32624E-189,37297E-129,44959E-141,00000E-59,99905E-108,62111E-179,99053E-9
0.2VCell5,55884E-166,43657E-169,90533E-101,34755E-189,37153E-129,47067E-141,00000E-59,99905E-108,64264E-179,99053E-9
0.2copasi4,91409E-147,08322E-169,90529E-10-2,21624E-179,37612E-129,38770E-141,00000E-59,99905E-10-4,84105E-149,99053E-9
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner5,51400E-166,38927E-169,90532E-101,32557E-189,37300E-129,44918E-141,00000E-59,99905E-108,62069E-179,99053E-9
0.2jsim5,51400E-166,38937E-169,90532E-101,32557E-189,37300E-129,44918E-141,00000E-59,99905E-108,62069E-179,99053E-9
0.2min 5,51400E-16 6,38927E-16 9,90529E-10 -2,21624E-17 9,20594E-12 5,25328E-14 1,00000E-5 9,99901E-10 -4,84105E-14 9,99051E-9
0.2max 4,91409E-14 3,53154E-14 9,90706E-10 2,30945E-18 9,37738E-12 9,86703E-14 1,00000E-5 9,99912E-10 2,90764E-14 9,99071E-9
0.2mean 5,53683E-16 6,39024E-16 9,90532E-10 1,32557E-18 9,37300E-12 9,44918E-14 1,00000E-5 9,99905E-10 8,62069E-17 9,99053E-9
0.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML5,59127E-154,90149E-159,82041E-102,18280E-171,75969E-113,57394E-131,00000E-59,99638E-10-7,11786E-169,98204E-9
0.4ByoDyn4,53387E-154,90149E-159,82041E-102,23567E-171,75969E-113,57394E-131,00000E-59,99638E-103,45084E-169,98204E-9
0.4Jarnac4,53387E-154,90149E-159,82041E-102,23566E-171,75969E-113,57394E-131,00000E-59,99638E-103,45084E-169,98204E-9
0.4MathSBML2,24149E-141,26889E-139,82519E-101,81363E-181,71682E-111,85500E-131,00000E-59,99688E-101,04472E-139,98252E-9
0.4Oscill8 Core4,86451E-15---1,75468E-113,64373E-131,00000E-59,99630E-103,52451E-16-
0.4SBToolbox23,64638E-153,94933E-159,82086E-10-4,72518E-171,75417E-113,67777E-131,00000E-59,99631E-103,54631E-169,98212E-9
0.4SBWOdeSolver4,53419E-154,90182E-159,82041E-102,23594E-171,75969E-113,57401E-131,00000E-59,99638E-103,45091E-169,98204E-9
0.4VCell4,54226E-154,91014E-159,82042E-102,24427E-171,75956E-113,57574E-131,00000E-59,99638E-103,45275E-169,98204E-9
0.4copasi1,16327E-144,96167E-159,82038E-102,02771E-171,75998E-113,56840E-131,00000E-59,99638E-10-6,69155E-159,98204E-9
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner4,53387E-154,90148E-159,82041E-102,23567E-171,75969E-113,57394E-131,00000E-59,99638E-103,45084E-169,98204E-9
0.4jsim4,53387E-154,90149E-159,82041E-102,23567E-171,75969E-113,57394E-131,00000E-59,99638E-103,45084E-169,98204E-9
0.4min 3,64638E-15 3,94933E-15 9,82038E-10 -4,72518E-17 1,71682E-11 1,85500E-13 1,00000E-5 9,99630E-10 -6,69155E-15 9,98204E-9
0.4max 2,24149E-14 1,26889E-13 9,82519E-10 2,24427E-17 1,75998E-11 3,67777E-13 1,00000E-5 9,99688E-10 1,04472E-13 9,98252E-9
0.4mean 4,53403E-15 4,90149E-15 9,82041E-10 2,23567E-17 1,75969E-11 3,57394E-13 1,00000E-5 9,99638E-10 3,45088E-16 9,98204E-9
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML1,58378E-141,58712E-149,74409E-101,11929E-162,48144E-117,60893E-131,00000E-59,99223E-10-7,98392E-179,97441E-9
0.6ByoDyn1,50053E-141,58712E-149,74409E-101,12346E-162,48144E-117,60893E-131,00000E-59,99223E-107,52211E-169,97441E-9
0.6Jarnac1,50053E-141,58712E-149,74409E-101,12346E-162,48144E-117,60893E-131,00000E-59,99223E-107,52211E-169,97441E-9
0.6MathSBML4,42894E-142,50718E-139,74967E-103,58353E-182,44175E-113,64581E-131,00000E-59,99385E-102,06425E-139,97497E-9
0.6Oscill8 Core1,56874E-14---2,47485E-117,69568E-131,00000E-59,99214E-107,61644E-16-
0.6SBToolbox21,46021E-141,54060E-149,74432E-105,01302E-172,47813E-117,67231E-131,00000E-59,99221E-107,58161E-169,97442E-9
0.6SBWOdeSolver1,50059E-141,58719E-149,74409E-101,12354E-162,48143E-117,60901E-131,00000E-59,99223E-107,52233E-169,97441E-9
0.6VCell1,50169E-141,58831E-149,74410E-101,12529E-162,48132E-117,61042E-131,00000E-59,99223E-107,52373E-169,97441E-9
0.6copasi1,55835E-141,60033E-149,74404E-101,17038E-162,48210E-117,59624E-131,00000E-59,99224E-103,01258E-169,97440E-9
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner1,50053E-141,58712E-149,74409E-101,12346E-162,48144E-117,60893E-131,00000E-59,99223E-107,52211E-169,97441E-9
0.6jsim1,50053E-141,58712E-149,74409E-101,12346E-162,48144E-117,60893E-131,00000E-59,99223E-107,52211E-169,97441E-9
0.6min 1,46021E-14 1,54060E-14 9,74404E-10 3,58353E-18 2,44175E-11 3,64581E-13 1,00000E-5 9,99214E-10 3,01258E-16 9,97440E-9
0.6max 4,42894E-14 2,50718E-13 9,74967E-10 1,17038E-16 2,48210E-11 7,69568E-13 1,00000E-5 9,99385E-10 2,06425E-13 9,97497E-9
0.6mean 1,50056E-14 1,58712E-14 9,74409E-10 1,12346E-16 2,48143E-11 7,60893E-13 1,00000E-5 9,99223E-10 7,52222E-16 9,97441E-9
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML3,55718E-143,61128E-149,67533E-103,46505E-163,11502E-111,28084E-121,00000E-59,98683E-101,88899E-169,96753E-9
0.8ByoDyn3,44743E-143,61128E-149,67533E-103,47053E-163,11502E-111,28084E-121,00000E-59,98683E-101,28580E-159,96753E-9
0.8Jarnac3,44743E-143,61128E-149,67533E-103,47053E-163,11502E-111,28084E-121,00000E-59,98683E-101,28580E-159,96753E-9
0.8MathSBML6,76209E-143,82796E-139,67577E-105,47134E-183,14844E-115,55454E-131,00000E-59,99062E-103,15170E-139,96758E-9
0.8Oscill8 Core3,55851E-14---3,10733E-111,29034E-121,00000E-59,98672E-101,29650E-15-
0.8SBToolbox23,67311E-143,84715E-149,67436E-104,63869E-163,12725E-111,25806E-121,00000E-59,98702E-101,26508E-159,96742E-9
0.8SBWOdeSolver3,44754E-143,61139E-149,67533E-103,47074E-163,11501E-111,28085E-121,00000E-59,98683E-101,28584E-159,96753E-9
0.8VCell3,44885E-143,61275E-149,67534E-103,47362E-163,11492E-111,28096E-121,00000E-59,98683E-101,28594E-159,96753E-9
0.8copasi3,60585E-143,62842E-149,67526E-103,56438E-163,11595E-111,27908E-121,00000E-59,98685E-10-1,36893E-169,96753E-9
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner3,44743E-143,61128E-149,67533E-103,47053E-163,11502E-111,28084E-121,00000E-59,98683E-101,28580E-159,96753E-9
0.8jsim3,44743E-143,61128E-149,67533E-103,47053E-163,11502E-111,28084E-121,00000E-59,98683E-101,28580E-159,96753E-9
0.8min 3,44743E-14 3,61128E-14 9,67436E-10 5,47134E-18 3,10733E-11 5,55454E-13 1,00000E-5 9,98672E-10 -1,36893E-16 9,96742E-9
0.8max 6,76209E-14 3,82796E-13 9,67577E-10 4,63869E-16 3,14844E-11 1,29034E-12 1,00000E-5 9,99062E-10 3,15170E-13 9,96758E-9
0.8mean 3,44819E-14 3,61139E-14 9,67533E-10 3,47053E-16 3,11502E-11 1,28084E-12 1,00000E-5 9,98683E-10 1,28580E-15 9,96753E-9
0.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.0BioUML6,55405E-146,77411E-149,61323E-108,22876E-163,67138E-111,89631E-121,00000E-59,98036E-101,36088E-159,96132E-9
1.0ByoDyn6,49742E-146,77411E-149,61323E-108,23159E-163,67138E-111,89631E-121,00000E-59,98036E-101,92683E-159,96132E-9
1.0Jarnac6,49742E-146,77411E-149,61323E-108,23159E-163,67138E-111,89631E-121,00000E-59,98036E-101,92683E-159,96132E-9
1.0MathSBML8,81688E-144,99116E-139,59877E-107,13391E-183,88997E-117,23799E-131,00000E-59,98777E-104,10940E-139,95988E-9
1.0Oscill8 Core6,65635E-14---3,66295E-111,90594E-121,00000E-59,98025E-101,93815E-15-
1.0SBToolbox27,00337E-147,31428E-149,61071E-101,19398E-153,70150E-111,84017E-121,00000E-59,98084E-101,87540E-159,96103E-9
1.0SBWOdeSolver6,49756E-146,77425E-149,61323E-108,23199E-163,67137E-111,89632E-121,00000E-59,98036E-101,92684E-159,96132E-9
1.0VCell6,49905E-146,77579E-149,61324E-108,23613E-163,67129E-111,89641E-121,00000E-59,98036E-101,92695E-159,96132E-9
1.0copasi6,52008E-146,78148E-149,61319E-108,34259E-163,67191E-111,89535E-121,00000E-59,98037E-101,76200E-159,96132E-9
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner6,49742E-146,77411E-149,61323E-108,23159E-163,67138E-111,89631E-121,00000E-59,98036E-101,92683E-159,96132E-9
1.0jsim6,49742E-146,77411E-149,61323E-108,23159E-163,67138E-111,89631E-121,00000E-59,98036E-101,92683E-159,96132E-9
1.0min 6,49742E-14 6,77411E-14 9,59877E-10 7,13391E-18 3,66295E-11 7,23799E-13 1,00000E-5 9,98025E-10 1,76200E-15 9,95988E-9
1.0max 8,81688E-14 4,99116E-13 9,61324E-10 1,19398E-15 3,88997E-11 1,90594E-12 1,00000E-5 9,98777E-10 4,10940E-13 9,96132E-9
1.0mean 6,49831E-14 6,77425E-14 9,61323E-10 8,23159E-16 3,67138E-11 1,89631E-12 1,00000E-5 9,98036E-10 1,92683E-15 9,96132E-9
1.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.2BioUML1,08883E-131,12481E-139,55699E-101,65309E-154,16008E-112,58920E-121,00000E-59,97298E-101,90403E-159,95570E-9
1.2ByoDyn1,08128E-131,12481E-139,55699E-101,65347E-154,16008E-112,58920E-121,00000E-59,97298E-102,65871E-159,95570E-9
1.2Jarnac1,08128E-131,12481E-139,55699E-101,65347E-154,16008E-112,58920E-121,00000E-59,97298E-102,65871E-159,95570E-9
1.2MathSBML-2,35681E-105,40332E-139,54579E-101,22619E-134,35216E-111,48172E-121,00002E-59,97978E-102,36099E-109,95458E-9
1.2Oscill8 Core1,10224E-13---4,15122E-112,59844E-121,00000E-59,97287E-102,67015E-15-
1.2SBToolbox21,14510E-131,19419E-139,55362E-102,24040E-154,20102E-112,51369E-121,00000E-59,97365E-102,58912E-159,95534E-9
1.2SBWOdeSolver1,08130E-131,12483E-139,55699E-101,65354E-154,16008E-112,58921E-121,00000E-59,97298E-102,65872E-159,95570E-9
1.2VCell1,08146E-131,12500E-139,55700E-101,65409E-154,16001E-112,58928E-121,00000E-59,97298E-102,65881E-159,95570E-9
1.2copasi1,08059E-131,12490E-139,55697E-101,66532E-154,16036E-112,58876E-121,00000E-59,97299E-102,72294E-159,95570E-9
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner1,08128E-131,12481E-139,55699E-101,65347E-154,16008E-112,58920E-121,00000E-59,97298E-102,65871E-159,95570E-9
1.2jsim1,08128E-131,12481E-139,55699E-101,65347E-154,16008E-112,58920E-121,00000E-59,97298E-102,65871E-159,95570E-9
1.2min -2,35681E-10 1,12481E-13 9,54579E-10 1,65347E-15 4,15122E-11 1,48172E-12 1,00000E-5 9,97287E-10 2,58912E-15 9,95458E-9
1.2max 1,14510E-13 5,40332E-13 9,55700E-10 1,22619E-13 4,35216E-11 2,59844E-12 1,00002E-5 9,97978E-10 2,36099E-10 9,95570E-9
1.2mean 1,08128E-13 1,12483E-13 9,55699E-10 1,65354E-15 4,16008E-11 2,58920E-12 1,00000E-5 9,97298E-10 2,65872E-15 9,95570E-9
1.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.4BioUML1,65229E-131,71721E-139,50592E-102,96282E-154,58952E-113,34388E-121,00000E-59,96484E-103,44246E-159,95059E-9
1.4ByoDyn1,65205E-131,71721E-139,50592E-102,96283E-154,58952E-113,34388E-121,00000E-59,96484E-103,46698E-159,95059E-9
1.4Jarnac1,65205E-131,71721E-139,50592E-102,96283E-154,58952E-113,34388E-121,00000E-59,96484E-103,46698E-159,95059E-9
1.4MathSBML6,43087E-135,77469E-139,49754E-109,94305E-154,73461E-112,33312E-121,00000E-59,97090E-10-7,58697E-149,94975E-9
1.4Oscill8 Core1,67817E-13---4,58046E-113,35233E-121,00000E-59,96473E-103,47815E-15-
1.4SBToolbox21,70342E-131,77406E-139,50304E-103,53050E-154,62454E-113,28011E-121,00000E-59,96546E-103,40789E-159,95033E-9
1.4SBWOdeSolver1,65207E-131,71723E-139,50592E-102,96292E-154,58951E-113,34389E-121,00000E-59,96484E-103,46699E-159,95059E-9
1.4VCell1,65226E-131,71743E-139,50593E-102,96371E-154,58945E-113,34395E-121,00000E-59,96484E-103,46707E-159,95059E-9
1.4copasi1,65010E-131,71685E-139,50591E-102,97529E-154,58963E-113,34378E-121,00000E-59,96485E-103,61214E-159,95059E-9
1.4edu.kgi.roadRunner1,65205E-131,71721E-139,50592E-102,96283E-154,58952E-113,34388E-121,00000E-59,96484E-103,46698E-159,95059E-9
1.4jsim1,65205E-131,71721E-139,50592E-102,96283E-154,58952E-113,34388E-121,00000E-59,96484E-103,46698E-159,95059E-9
1.4min 1,65010E-13 1,71685E-13 9,49754E-10 2,96283E-15 4,58046E-11 2,33312E-12 1,00000E-5 9,96473E-10 -7,58697E-14 9,94975E-9
1.4max 6,43087E-13 5,77469E-13 9,50593E-10 9,94305E-15 4,73461E-11 3,35233E-12 1,00000E-5 9,97090E-10 3,61214E-15 9,95059E-9
1.4mean 1,65206E-13 1,71721E-13 9,50592E-10 2,96292E-15 4,58952E-11 3,34388E-12 1,00000E-5 9,96484E-10 3,46698E-15 9,95059E-9
1.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.6BioUML2,37228E-132,46558E-139,45941E-104,88460E-154,96703E-114,14689E-121,00000E-59,95607E-104,28155E-159,94594E-9
1.6ByoDyn2,37171E-132,46558E-139,45941E-104,88463E-154,96703E-114,14689E-121,00000E-59,95607E-104,33905E-159,94594E-9
1.6Jarnac2,37171E-132,46558E-139,45941E-104,88463E-154,96703E-114,14689E-121,00000E-59,95607E-104,33905E-159,94594E-9
1.6MathSBML6,11336E-136,36763E-139,45302E-101,58174E-145,08732E-113,20409E-121,00000E-59,96160E-109,00703E-159,94530E-9
1.6Oscill8 Core2,40297E-13---4,95795E-114,15426E-121,00000E-59,95596E-104,34964E-15-
1.6SBToolbox22,41131E-132,51152E-139,45677E-105,50581E-154,99845E-114,09101E-121,00000E-59,95658E-104,28672E-159,94565E-9
1.6SBWOdeSolver2,37173E-132,46561E-139,45941E-104,88476E-154,96702E-114,14690E-121,00000E-59,95607E-104,33907E-159,94594E-9
1.6VCell2,37194E-132,46583E-139,45942E-104,88575E-154,96696E-114,14695E-121,00000E-59,95607E-104,33913E-159,94594E-9
1.6copasi2,37202E-132,46482E-139,45942E-104,89723E-154,96698E-114,14710E-121,00000E-59,95607E-104,21686E-159,94594E-9
1.6edu.kgi.roadRunner2,37171E-132,46558E-139,45941E-104,88463E-154,96703E-114,14689E-121,00000E-59,95607E-104,33905E-159,94594E-9
1.6jsim2,37171E-132,46558E-139,45941E-104,88463E-154,96703E-114,14689E-121,00000E-59,95607E-104,33905E-159,94594E-9
1.6min 2,37171E-13 2,46482E-13 9,45302E-10 4,88463E-15 4,95795E-11 3,20409E-12 1,00000E-5 9,95596E-10 4,21686E-15 9,94530E-9
1.6max 6,11336E-13 6,36763E-13 9,45942E-10 1,58174E-14 5,08732E-11 4,15426E-12 1,00000E-5 9,96160E-10 9,00703E-15 9,94594E-9
1.6mean 2,37184E-13 2,46558E-13 9,45941E-10 4,88476E-15 4,96703E-11 4,14689E-12 1,00000E-5 9,95607E-10 4,33905E-15 9,94594E-9
1.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.8BioUML3,25459E-133,37841E-139,41693E-107,55750E-155,29903E-114,98665E-121,00000E-59,94676E-104,53794E-159,94169E-9
1.8ByoDyn3,24732E-133,37841E-139,41693E-107,55786E-155,29903E-114,98665E-121,00000E-59,94676E-105,26398E-159,94169E-9
1.8Jarnac3,24732E-133,37841E-139,41693E-107,55786E-155,29903E-114,98665E-121,00000E-59,94676E-105,26398E-159,94169E-9
1.8MathSBML7,05560E-137,42455E-139,41633E-102,36935E-145,35344E-114,11491E-121,00000E-59,95144E-101,19040E-149,94163E-9
1.8Oscill8 Core3,28357E-13---5,29007E-114,99273E-121,00000E-59,94666E-105,27378E-15-
1.8SBToolbox23,28027E-133,42055E-139,41398E-108,43071E-155,33424E-114,92579E-121,00000E-59,94729E-105,20604E-159,94144E-9
1.8SBWOdeSolver3,24735E-133,37844E-139,41693E-107,55803E-155,29902E-114,98665E-121,00000E-59,94676E-105,26399E-159,94169E-9
1.8VCell3,24757E-133,37866E-139,41694E-107,55920E-155,29897E-114,98669E-121,00000E-59,94676E-105,26404E-159,94169E-9
1.8copasi3,24494E-133,37735E-139,41694E-107,57015E-155,29886E-114,98710E-121,00000E-59,94675E-105,38054E-159,94169E-9
1.8edu.kgi.roadRunner3,24732E-133,37841E-139,41693E-107,55786E-155,29903E-114,98665E-121,00000E-59,94676E-105,26398E-159,94169E-9
1.8jsim3,24732E-133,37841E-139,41693E-107,55786E-155,29903E-114,98665E-121,00000E-59,94676E-105,26398E-159,94169E-9
1.8min 3,24494E-13 3,37735E-13 9,41398E-10 7,55786E-15 5,29007E-11 4,11491E-12 1,00000E-5 9,94666E-10 5,20604E-15 9,94144E-9
1.8max 7,05560E-13 7,42455E-13 9,41694E-10 2,36935E-14 5,35344E-11 4,99273E-12 1,00000E-5 9,95144E-10 1,19040E-14 9,94169E-9
1.8mean 3,24734E-13 3,37841E-13 9,41693E-10 7,55803E-15 5,29903E-11 4,98665E-12 1,00000E-5 9,94676E-10 5,26398E-15 9,94169E-9
1.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.0BioUML4,27833E-134,46202E-139,37801E-101,11249E-145,59114E-115,85323E-121,00000E-59,93701E-106,77306E-159,93780E-9
2.0ByoDyn4,28374E-134,46202E-139,37801E-101,11246E-145,59114E-115,85323E-121,00000E-59,93701E-106,23225E-159,93780E-9
2.0Jarnac4,28374E-134,46202E-139,37801E-101,11246E-145,59114E-115,85323E-121,00000E-59,93701E-106,23225E-159,93780E-9
2.0MathSBML8,26269E-138,67899E-139,38287E-103,24698E-145,58393E-115,04079E-121,00000E-59,94093E-106,99310E-159,93829E-9
2.0Oscill8 Core4,32475E-13---5,58242E-115,85788E-121,00000E-59,93692E-106,24110E-15-
2.0SBToolbox24,31012E-134,50124E-139,37458E-101,23056E-145,63180E-115,78450E-121,00000E-59,93770E-106,16570E-159,93744E-9
2.0SBWOdeSolver4,28377E-134,46206E-139,37801E-101,11248E-145,59113E-115,85323E-121,00000E-59,93701E-106,23225E-159,93780E-9
2.0VCell4,28399E-134,46229E-139,37801E-101,11262E-145,59109E-115,85326E-121,00000E-59,93701E-106,23230E-159,93780E-9
2.0copasi4,28516E-134,46073E-139,37803E-101,11355E-145,59087E-115,85389E-121,00000E-59,93701E-105,94575E-159,93780E-9
2.0edu.kgi.roadRunner4,28374E-134,46202E-139,37801E-101,11246E-145,59114E-115,85323E-121,00000E-59,93701E-106,23225E-159,93780E-9
2.0jsim4,28374E-134,46202E-139,37801E-101,11246E-145,59114E-115,85323E-121,00000E-59,93701E-106,23225E-159,93780E-9
2.0min 4,28374E-13 4,46073E-13 9,37458E-10 1,11246E-14 5,58242E-11 5,04079E-12 1,00000E-5 9,93692E-10 5,94575E-15 9,93744E-9
2.0max 8,26269E-13 8,67899E-13 9,38287E-10 3,24698E-14 5,63180E-11 5,85788E-12 1,00000E-5 9,94093E-10 6,99310E-15 9,93829E-9
2.0mean 4,28388E-13 4,46202E-13 9,37801E-10 1,11248E-14 5,59114E-11 5,85323E-12 1,00000E-5 9,93701E-10 6,23225E-15 9,93780E-9
2.0relative error(%) 0,130,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.2BioUML5,48328E-135,72092E-139,34223E-101,57281E-145,84830E-116,73815E-121,00000E-59,92690E-107,29721E-159,93422E-9
2.2ByoDyn5,48390E-135,72092E-139,34223E-101,57280E-145,84830E-116,73815E-121,00000E-59,92690E-107,23562E-159,93422E-9
2.2Jarnac5,48390E-135,72092E-139,34223E-101,57280E-145,84830E-116,73815E-121,00000E-59,92690E-107,23562E-159,93422E-9
2.2MathSBML9,38740E-139,90041E-139,34848E-104,13031E-145,82489E-115,95712E-121,00000E-59,93056E-106,95476E-159,93485E-9
2.2Oscill8 Core5,52938E-13---5,83988E-116,74130E-121,00000E-59,92682E-107,24340E-15-
2.2SBToolbox25,50103E-135,75358E-139,33860E-101,71297E-145,89134E-116,66714E-121,00000E-59,92761E-107,16578E-159,93384E-9
2.2SBWOdeSolver5,48393E-135,72096E-139,34223E-101,57283E-145,84829E-116,73815E-121,00000E-59,92690E-107,23562E-159,93422E-9
2.2VCell5,48415E-135,72119E-139,34224E-101,57299E-145,84825E-116,73817E-121,00000E-59,92690E-107,23566E-159,93422E-9
2.2copasi5,48175E-135,71966E-139,34225E-101,57369E-145,84802E-116,73882E-121,00000E-59,92690E-107,31062E-159,93423E-9
2.2edu.kgi.roadRunner5,48390E-135,72092E-139,34223E-101,57280E-145,84830E-116,73815E-121,00000E-59,92690E-107,23562E-159,93422E-9
2.2jsim5,48390E-135,72092E-139,34223E-101,57280E-145,84830E-116,73815E-121,00000E-59,92690E-107,23562E-159,93422E-9
2.2min 5,48175E-13 5,71966E-13 9,33860E-10 1,57280E-14 5,82489E-11 5,95712E-12 1,00000E-5 9,92682E-10 6,95476E-15 9,93384E-9
2.2max 9,38740E-13 9,90041E-13 9,34848E-10 4,13031E-14 5,89134E-11 6,74130E-12 1,00000E-5 9,93056E-10 7,31062E-15 9,93485E-9
2.2mean 5,48392E-13 5,72092E-13 9,34223E-10 1,57283E-14 5,84830E-11 6,73815E-12 1,00000E-5 9,92690E-10 7,23562E-15 9,93422E-9
2.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.4BioUML6,84261E-137,15802E-139,30925E-102,15108E-146,07481E-117,63418E-121,00000E-59,91651E-108,92195E-159,93092E-9
2.4ByoDyn6,84916E-137,15802E-139,30925E-102,15105E-146,07481E-117,63418E-121,00000E-59,91651E-108,26694E-159,93092E-9
2.4Jarnac6,84916E-137,15802E-139,30925E-102,15105E-146,07481E-117,63418E-121,00000E-59,91651E-108,26694E-159,93092E-9
2.4MathSBML1,08741E-121,15286E-129,31891E-105,29899E-146,01426E-116,87065E-121,00000E-59,91981E-108,01687E-159,93189E-9
2.4Oscill8 Core6,89878E-13---6,06676E-117,63579E-121,00000E-59,91644E-108,27359E-15-
2.4SBToolbox26,85564E-137,17953E-139,30608E-102,28489E-146,11213E-117,57423E-121,00000E-59,91712E-108,20720E-159,93062E-9
2.4SBWOdeSolver6,84919E-137,15806E-139,30925E-102,15108E-146,07480E-117,63418E-121,00000E-59,91651E-108,26695E-159,93092E-9
2.4VCell6,84945E-137,15834E-139,30925E-102,15128E-146,07476E-117,63419E-121,00000E-59,91651E-108,26698E-159,93092E-9
2.4copasi6,84455E-137,15724E-139,30926E-102,15163E-146,07469E-117,63452E-121,00000E-59,91651E-108,63933E-159,93093E-9
2.4edu.kgi.roadRunner6,84916E-137,15802E-139,30925E-102,15105E-146,07481E-117,63418E-121,00000E-59,91651E-108,26694E-159,93092E-9
2.4jsim6,84916E-137,15802E-139,30925E-102,15105E-146,07481E-117,63418E-121,00000E-59,91651E-108,26694E-159,93092E-9
2.4min 6,84455E-13 7,15724E-13 9,30608E-10 2,15105E-14 6,01426E-11 6,87065E-12 1,00000E-5 9,91644E-10 8,01687E-15 9,93062E-9
2.4max 1,08741E-12 1,15286E-12 9,31891E-10 5,29899E-14 6,11213E-11 7,63579E-12 1,00000E-5 9,91981E-10 8,63933E-15 9,93189E-9
2.4mean 6,84918E-13 7,15802E-13 9,30925E-10 2,15108E-14 6,07480E-11 7,63418E-12 1,00000E-5 9,91651E-10 8,26694E-15 9,93092E-9
2.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.6BioUML8,36636E-138,77492E-139,27873E-102,86128E-146,27444E-118,53517E-121,00000E-59,90589E-101,06353E-149,92787E-9
2.6ByoDyn8,37952E-138,77492E-139,27873E-102,86122E-146,27444E-118,53517E-121,00000E-59,90589E-109,32002E-159,92787E-9
2.6Jarnac8,37952E-138,77492E-139,27873E-102,86122E-146,27444E-118,53517E-121,00000E-59,90589E-109,32002E-159,92787E-9
2.6MathSBML1,24982E-121,33055E-129,29116E-106,56909E-146,18416E-117,78411E-121,00000E-59,90891E-108,99184E-159,92912E-9
2.6Oscill8 Core8,43292E-13---6,26679E-118,53524E-121,00000E-59,90583E-109,32551E-15-
2.6SBToolbox28,37450E-138,78535E-139,27596E-102,99433E-146,30748E-118,48400E-121,00000E-59,90643E-109,26794E-159,92763E-9
2.6SBWOdeSolver8,37956E-138,77496E-139,27873E-102,86125E-146,27444E-118,53517E-121,00000E-59,90589E-109,32004E-159,92787E-9
2.6VCell8,37981E-138,77524E-139,27873E-102,86147E-146,27440E-118,53517E-121,00000E-59,90589E-109,32005E-159,92787E-9
2.6copasi8,37849E-138,77469E-139,27873E-102,86151E-146,27451E-118,53512E-121,00000E-59,90589E-109,39292E-159,92787E-9
2.6edu.kgi.roadRunner8,37952E-138,77492E-139,27873E-102,86122E-146,27444E-118,53517E-121,00000E-59,90589E-109,32002E-159,92787E-9
2.6jsim8,37952E-138,77492E-139,27873E-102,86122E-146,27444E-118,53517E-121,00000E-59,90589E-109,32002E-159,92787E-9
2.6min 8,37450E-13 8,77469E-13 9,27596E-10 2,86122E-14 6,18416E-11 7,78411E-12 1,00000E-5 9,90583E-10 8,99184E-15 9,92763E-9
2.6max 1,24982E-12 1,33055E-12 9,29116E-10 6,56909E-14 6,30748E-11 8,53524E-12 1,00000E-5 9,90891E-10 9,39292E-15 9,92912E-9
2.6mean 8,37952E-13 8,77492E-13 9,27873E-10 2,86125E-14 6,27444E-11 8,53517E-12 1,00000E-5 9,90589E-10 9,32002E-15 9,92787E-9
2.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.8BioUML1,00631E-121,05721E-129,25041E-103,71705E-146,45051E-119,43594E-121,00000E-59,89509E-101,14599E-149,92504E-9
2.8ByoDyn1,00738E-121,05721E-129,25041E-103,7