Test: BIOMD0000000084.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000084.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: DormandPrince
generated code: BIOMD0000000084.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-100
ATOL 1.0E-15
RTOL 1.0E-12
STEP 0.01

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000084.gif

Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL6623610941.JPG

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: x2p  x1p  R  x3p  x2  Rin  x3  x1 
Simulators: ByoDyn  CVODE  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  Jarnac  SBToolbox2  Oscill8 Core  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  jsim  BioUML 
timeresult x2p x1p R x3p x2 Rin x3 x1
0.0BioUML0,00000E00,00000E05,00000E-10,00000E01,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E0
0.0ByoDyn0,00000E00,00000E05,00000E-10,00000E01,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E0
0.0CVODE0,00000E00,00000E05,00000E-10,00000E01,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E0
0.0Jarnac0,00000E00,00000E05,00000E-10,00000E01,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E0
0.0MathSBML0,00000E00,00000E05,00000E-10,00000E01,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E0
0.0Oscill8 Core--5,00000E-1-1,00000E0-1,00000E01,00000E0
0.0SBToolbox20,00000E00,00000E05,00000E-10,00000E01,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E0
0.0SBWOdeSolver0,00000E00,00000E05,00000E-10,00000E01,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E0
0.0copasi0,00000E00,00000E05,00000E-10,00000E01,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E0
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner0,00000E00,00000E05,00000E-10,00000E01,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E0
0.0jsim0,00000E00,00000E05,00000E-10,00000E01,00000E00,00000E01,00000E01,00000E0
0.0min 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 5,00000E-1 0,00000E0 1,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E0 1,00000E0
0.0max 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 5,00000E-1 0,00000E0 1,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E0 1,00000E0
0.0mean 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 5,00000E-1 0,00000E0 1,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,00000E0 1,00000E0
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML7,05305E-37,36028E-23,39680E-14,38508E-49,92947E-11,60320E-19,99561E-19,26397E-1
0.2ByoDyn7,05305E-37,36028E-23,39680E-14,38508E-49,92947E-11,60320E-19,99561E-19,26397E-1
0.2CVODE7,05305E-37,36028E-23,39680E-14,38508E-49,92947E-11,60320E-19,99561E-19,26397E-1
0.2Jarnac7,05305E-37,36028E-23,39680E-14,38508E-49,92947E-11,60320E-19,99561E-19,26397E-1
0.2MathSBML7,05304E-37,36028E-23,39680E-14,38512E-49,92947E-11,60320E-19,99561E-19,26397E-1
0.2Oscill8 Core--3,39680E-1-9,92947E-1-9,99561E-19,26398E-1
0.2SBToolbox27,04808E-37,36050E-23,39674E-14,39889E-49,92953E-11,60326E-19,99561E-19,26398E-1
0.2SBWOdeSolver7,05328E-37,36020E-23,39680E-14,38565E-49,92947E-11,60320E-19,99561E-19,26398E-1
0.2copasi7,05153E-37,36042E-23,39680E-14,38860E-49,92948E-11,60320E-19,99561E-19,26396E-1
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner7,05305E-37,36028E-23,39680E-14,38508E-49,92947E-11,60320E-19,99561E-19,26397E-1
0.2jsim7,05305E-37,36028E-23,39680E-14,38508E-49,92947E-11,60320E-19,99561E-19,26397E-1
0.2min 7,04808E-3 7,36020E-2 3,39674E-1 4,38508E-4 9,92947E-1 1,60320E-1 9,99561E-1 9,26396E-1
0.2max 7,05328E-3 7,36050E-2 3,39680E-1 4,39889E-4 9,92953E-1 1,60326E-1 9,99561E-1 9,26398E-1
0.2mean 7,05305E-3 7,36028E-2 3,39680E-1 4,38508E-4 9,92947E-1 1,60320E-1 9,99561E-1 9,26397E-1
0.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML2,38339E-21,16231E-11,96398E-13,05423E-39,76166E-13,03602E-19,96946E-18,83769E-1
0.4ByoDyn2,38339E-21,16231E-11,96398E-13,05423E-39,76166E-13,03602E-19,96946E-18,83769E-1
0.4CVODE2,38339E-21,16231E-11,96398E-13,05423E-39,76166E-13,03602E-19,96946E-18,83769E-1
0.4Jarnac2,38339E-21,16231E-11,96398E-13,05423E-39,76166E-13,03602E-19,96946E-18,83769E-1
0.4MathSBML2,38339E-21,16231E-11,96398E-13,05424E-39,76166E-13,03602E-19,96946E-18,83769E-1
0.4Oscill8 Core--1,96399E-1-9,76166E-1-9,96946E-18,83771E-1
0.4SBToolbox22,38198E-21,16240E-11,96324E-13,05586E-39,76179E-13,03676E-19,96948E-18,83760E-1
0.4SBWOdeSolver2,38341E-21,16229E-11,96399E-13,05439E-39,76166E-13,03601E-19,96946E-18,83771E-1
0.4copasi2,38327E-21,16232E-11,96398E-13,05438E-39,76167E-13,03602E-19,96946E-18,83768E-1
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner2,38339E-21,16231E-11,96398E-13,05423E-39,76166E-13,03602E-19,96946E-18,83769E-1
0.4jsim2,38339E-21,16231E-11,96398E-13,05423E-39,76166E-13,03602E-19,96946E-18,83769E-1
0.4min 2,38198E-2 1,16229E-1 1,96324E-1 3,05423E-3 9,76166E-1 3,03601E-1 9,96946E-1 8,83760E-1
0.4max 2,38341E-2 1,16240E-1 1,96399E-1 3,05586E-3 9,76179E-1 3,03676E-1 9,96948E-1 8,83771E-1
0.4mean 2,38339E-2 1,16231E-1 1,96398E-1 3,05423E-3 9,76166E-1 3,03602E-1 9,96946E-1 8,83769E-1
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML4,48490E-21,34026E-18,40533E-28,92499E-39,55151E-14,15947E-19,91075E-18,65974E-1
0.6ByoDyn4,48490E-21,34026E-18,40533E-28,92499E-39,55151E-14,15947E-19,91075E-18,65974E-1
0.6CVODE4,48490E-21,34026E-18,40533E-28,92499E-39,55151E-14,15947E-19,91075E-18,65974E-1
0.6Jarnac4,48490E-21,34026E-18,40533E-28,92499E-39,55151E-14,15947E-19,91075E-18,65974E-1
0.6MathSBML4,48490E-21,34026E-18,40533E-28,92500E-39,55151E-14,15947E-19,91075E-18,65974E-1
0.6Oscill8 Core--8,40571E-2-9,55151E-1-9,91075E-18,65976E-1
0.6SBToolbox24,48149E-21,34045E-18,37823E-28,92320E-39,55185E-14,16217E-19,91073E-18,65955E-1
0.6SBWOdeSolver4,48490E-21,34024E-18,40566E-28,92524E-39,55151E-14,15943E-19,91075E-18,65976E-1
0.6copasi4,48482E-21,34027E-18,40534E-28,92499E-39,55152E-14,15947E-19,91075E-18,65973E-1
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner4,48490E-21,34026E-18,40533E-28,92499E-39,55151E-14,15947E-19,91075E-18,65974E-1
0.6jsim4,48490E-21,34026E-18,40533E-28,92499E-39,55151E-14,15947E-19,91075E-18,65974E-1
0.6min 4,48149E-2 1,34024E-1 8,37823E-2 8,92320E-3 9,55151E-1 4,15943E-1 9,91073E-1 8,65955E-1
0.6max 4,48490E-2 1,34045E-1 8,40571E-2 8,92524E-3 9,55185E-1 4,16217E-1 9,91075E-1 8,65976E-1
0.6mean 4,48490E-2 1,34026E-1 8,40533E-2 8,92499E-3 9,55151E-1 4,15947E-1 9,91075E-1 8,65974E-1
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML6,62334E-21,35552E-12,22982E-21,82380E-29,33767E-14,77702E-19,81762E-18,64448E-1
0.8ByoDyn6,62334E-21,35552E-12,22982E-21,82380E-29,33767E-14,77702E-19,81762E-18,64448E-1
0.8CVODE6,62334E-21,35552E-12,22982E-21,82380E-29,33767E-14,77702E-19,81762E-18,64448E-1
0.8Jarnac6,62334E-21,35552E-12,22982E-21,82380E-29,33767E-14,77702E-19,81762E-18,64448E-1
0.8MathSBML6,62334E-21,35552E-12,22982E-21,82380E-29,33767E-14,77702E-19,81762E-18,64448E-1
0.8Oscill8 Core--2,23025E-2-9,33767E-1-9,81762E-18,64449E-1
0.8SBToolbox26,61978E-21,35552E-12,20917E-21,82295E-29,33803E-14,77908E-19,81773E-18,64448E-1
0.8SBWOdeSolver6,62332E-21,35551E-12,23026E-21,82383E-29,33767E-14,77697E-19,81762E-18,64449E-1
0.8copasi6,62330E-21,35554E-12,22983E-21,82379E-29,33767E-14,77702E-19,81762E-18,64446E-1
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner6,62334E-21,35552E-12,22982E-21,82380E-29,33767E-14,77702E-19,81762E-18,64448E-1
0.8jsim6,62334E-21,35552E-12,22982E-21,82380E-29,33767E-14,77702E-19,81762E-18,64448E-1
0.8min 6,61978E-2 1,35551E-1 2,20917E-2 1,82295E-2 9,33767E-1 4,77697E-1 9,81762E-1 8,64446E-1
0.8max 6,62334E-2 1,35554E-1 2,23026E-2 1,82383E-2 9,33803E-1 4,77908E-1 9,81773E-1 8,64449E-1
0.8mean 6,62334E-2 1,35552E-1 2,22982E-2 1,82380E-2 9,33767E-1 4,77702E-1 9,81762E-1 8,64448E-1
0.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.0BioUML8,60290E-21,30479E-14,42215E-33,06613E-29,13971E-14,95578E-19,69339E-18,69521E-1
1.0ByoDyn8,60290E-21,30479E-14,42215E-33,06613E-29,13971E-14,95578E-19,69339E-18,69521E-1
1.0CVODE8,60290E-21,30479E-14,42214E-33,06613E-29,13971E-14,95578E-19,69339E-18,69521E-1
1.0Jarnac8,60290E-21,30479E-14,42215E-33,06613E-29,13971E-14,95578E-19,69339E-18,69521E-1
1.0MathSBML8,60290E-21,30479E-14,42213E-33,06613E-29,13971E-14,95578E-19,69339E-18,69521E-1
1.0Oscill8 Core--4,42352E-3-9,13971E-1-9,69338E-18,69521E-1
1.0SBToolbox28,59929E-21,30461E-14,36401E-33,06463E-29,14004E-14,95635E-19,69349E-18,69539E-1
1.0SBWOdeSolver8,60287E-21,30479E-14,42351E-33,06615E-29,13971E-14,95576E-19,69338E-18,69521E-1
1.0copasi8,60289E-21,30481E-14,42215E-33,06611E-29,13971E-14,95578E-19,69339E-18,69519E-1
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner8,60290E-21,30479E-14,42215E-33,06613E-29,13971E-14,95578E-19,69339E-18,69521E-1
1.0jsim8,60290E-21,30479E-14,42215E-33,06612E-29,13971E-14,95578E-19,69339E-18,69521E-1
1.0min 8,59929E-2 1,30461E-1 4,36401E-3 3,06463E-2 9,13971E-1 4,95576E-1 9,69338E-1 8,69519E-1
1.0max 8,60290E-2 1,30481E-1 4,42352E-3 3,06615E-2 9,14004E-1 4,95635E-1 9,69349E-1 8,69539E-1
1.0mean 8,60290E-2 1,30479E-1 4,42215E-3 3,06613E-2 9,13971E-1 4,95578E-1 9,69339E-1 8,69521E-1
1.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.2BioUML1,03753E-11,24138E-11,35641E-34,56890E-28,96247E-14,98644E-19,54311E-18,75862E-1
1.2ByoDyn1,03753E-11,24138E-11,35641E-34,56890E-28,96247E-14,98644E-19,54311E-18,75862E-1
1.2CVODE1,03753E-11,24138E-11,35641E-34,56890E-28,96247E-14,98644E-19,54311E-18,75862E-1
1.2Jarnac1,03753E-11,24138E-11,35641E-34,56890E-28,96247E-14,98644E-19,54311E-18,75862E-1
1.2MathSBML1,03753E-11,24138E-11,35641E-34,56890E-28,96247E-14,98644E-19,54311E-18,75862E-1
1.2Oscill8 Core--1,35666E-3-8,96247E-1-9,54311E-18,75862E-1
1.2SBToolbox21,03710E-11,24118E-11,34454E-34,56682E-28,96290E-14,98654E-19,54336E-18,75882E-1
1.2SBWOdeSolver1,03753E-11,24138E-11,35667E-34,56893E-28,96247E-14,98643E-19,54311E-18,75862E-1
1.2copasi1,03753E-11,24140E-11,35641E-34,56889E-28,96247E-14,98644E-19,54311E-18,75860E-1
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner1,03753E-11,24138E-11,35641E-34,56890E-28,96247E-14,98644E-19,54311E-18,75862E-1
1.2jsim1,03753E-11,24138E-11,35641E-34,56890E-28,96247E-14,98644E-19,54311E-18,75862E-1
1.2min 1,03710E-1 1,24118E-1 1,34454E-3 4,56682E-2 8,96247E-1 4,98643E-1 9,54311E-1 8,75860E-1
1.2max 1,03753E-1 1,24140E-1 1,35667E-3 4,56893E-2 8,96290E-1 4,98654E-1 9,54336E-1 8,75882E-1
1.2mean 1,03753E-1 1,24138E-1 1,35641E-3 4,56890E-2 8,96247E-1 4,98644E-1 9,54311E-1 8,75862E-1
1.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.4BioUML1,19469E-11,17855E-19,12609E-46,28274E-28,80531E-14,99087E-19,37173E-18,82145E-1
1.4ByoDyn1,19469E-11,17855E-19,12609E-46,28274E-28,80531E-14,99087E-19,37173E-18,82145E-1
1.4CVODE1,19469E-11,17855E-19,12610E-46,28274E-28,80531E-14,99087E-19,37173E-18,82145E-1
1.4Jarnac1,19469E-11,17855E-19,12609E-46,28274E-28,80531E-14,99087E-19,37173E-18,82145E-1
1.4MathSBML1,19469E-11,17855E-19,12609E-46,28274E-28,80531E-14,99087E-19,37173E-18,82145E-1
1.4Oscill8 Core--9,12651E-4-8,80531E-1-9,37172E-18,82145E-1
1.4SBToolbox21,19426E-11,17833E-19,10050E-46,27999E-28,80574E-14,99089E-19,37197E-18,82167E-1
1.4SBWOdeSolver1,19469E-11,17855E-19,12656E-46,28276E-28,80531E-14,99087E-19,37172E-18,82145E-1
1.4copasi1,19470E-11,17856E-19,12609E-46,28273E-28,80530E-14,99087E-19,37173E-18,82144E-1
1.4edu.kgi.roadRunner1,19469E-11,17855E-19,12609E-46,28274E-28,80531E-14,99087E-19,37173E-18,82145E-1
1.4jsim1,19469E-11,17855E-19,12609E-46,28274E-28,80531E-14,99087E-19,37173E-18,82145E-1
1.4min 1,19426E-1 1,17833E-1 9,10050E-4 6,27999E-2 8,80530E-1 4,99087E-1 9,37172E-1 8,82144E-1
1.4max 1,19470E-1 1,17856E-1 9,12656E-4 6,28276E-2 8,80574E-1 4,99089E-1 9,37197E-1 8,82167E-1
1.4mean 1,19469E-1 1,17855E-1 9,12609E-4 6,28274E-2 8,80531E-1 4,99087E-1 9,37173E-1 8,82145E-1
1.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.6BioUML1,33335E-11,11832E-18,50244E-48,16403E-28,66665E-14,99150E-19,18360E-18,88168E-1
1.6ByoDyn1,33335E-11,11832E-18,50244E-48,16403E-28,66665E-14,99150E-19,18360E-18,88168E-1
1.6CVODE1,33335E-11,11832E-18,50244E-48,16403E-28,66665E-14,99150E-19,18360E-18,88168E-1
1.6Jarnac1,33335E-11,11832E-18,50244E-48,16403E-28,66665E-14,99150E-19,18360E-18,88168E-1
1.6MathSBML1,33335E-11,11832E-18,50244E-48,16403E-28,66665E-14,99150E-19,18360E-18,88168E-1
1.6Oscill8 Core--8,50250E-4-8,66665E-1-9,18360E-18,88168E-1
1.6SBToolbox21,33296E-11,11808E-18,49509E-48,16048E-28,66704E-14,99150E-19,18395E-18,88192E-1
1.6SBWOdeSolver1,33334E-11,11832E-18,50252E-48,16405E-28,66666E-14,99150E-19,18360E-18,88168E-1
1.6copasi1,33335E-11,11833E-18,50243E-48,16403E-28,66665E-14,99150E-19,18360E-18,88167E-1
1.6edu.kgi.roadRunner1,33335E-11,11832E-18,50244E-48,16403E-28,66665E-14,99150E-19,18360E-18,88168E-1
1.6jsim1,33335E-11,11832E-18,50244E-48,16403E-28,66665E-14,99150E-19,18360E-18,88168E-1
1.6min 1,33296E-1 1,11808E-1 8,49509E-4 8,16048E-2 8,66665E-1 4,99150E-1 9,18360E-1 8,88167E-1
1.6max 1,33335E-1 1,11833E-1 8,50252E-4 8,16405E-2 8,66704E-1 4,99150E-1 9,18395E-1 8,88192E-1
1.6mean 1,33335E-1 1,11832E-1 8,50244E-4 8,16403E-2 8,66665E-1 4,99150E-1 9,18360E-1 8,88168E-1
1.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.8BioUML1,45507E-11,06090E-18,41517E-41,01750E-18,54493E-14,99158E-18,98250E-18,93910E-1
1.8ByoDyn1,45507E-11,06090E-18,41517E-41,01750E-18,54493E-14,99158E-18,98250E-18,93910E-1
1.8CVODE1,45507E-11,06090E-18,41517E-41,01750E-18,54493E-14,99158E-18,98250E-18,93910E-1
1.8Jarnac1,45507E-11,06090E-18,41517E-41,01750E-18,54493E-14,99158E-18,98250E-18,93910E-1
1.8MathSBML1,45507E-11,06090E-18,41516E-41,01750E-18,54493E-14,99158E-18,98250E-18,93910E-1
1.8Oscill8 Core--8,41518E-4-8,54494E-1-8,98250E-18,93910E-1
1.8SBToolbox21,45467E-11,06070E-18,41235E-41,01705E-18,54533E-14,99160E-18,98295E-18,93930E-1
1.8SBWOdeSolver1,45506E-11,06090E-18,41519E-41,01750E-18,54494E-14,99158E-18,98250E-18,93910E-1
1.8copasi1,45507E-11,06091E-18,41517E-41,01750E-18,54493E-14,99158E-18,98250E-18,93909E-1
1.8edu.kgi.roadRunner1,45507E-11,06090E-18,41517E-41,01750E-18,54493E-14,99158E-18,98250E-18,93910E-1
1.8jsim1,45507E-11,06090E-18,41517E-41,01750E-18,54493E-14,99158E-18,98250E-18,93910E-1
1.8min 1,45467E-1 1,06070E-1 8,41235E-4 1,01705E-1 8,54493E-1 4,99158E-1 8,98250E-1 8,93909E-1
1.8max 1,45507E-1 1,06091E-1 8,41519E-4 1,01750E-1 8,54533E-1 4,99160E-1 8,98295E-1 8,93930E-1
1.8mean 1,45507E-1 1,06090E-1 8,41517E-4 1,01750E-1 8,54493E-1 4,99158E-1 8,98250E-1 8,93910E-1
1.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.0BioUML1,56127E-11,00622E-18,40297E-41,22829E-18,43873E-14,99160E-18,77171E-18,99378E-1
2.0ByoDyn1,56127E-11,00622E-18,40297E-41,22829E-18,43873E-14,99160E-18,77171E-18,99378E-1
2.0CVODE1,56127E-11,00622E-18,40297E-41,22829E-18,43873E-14,99160E-18,77171E-18,99378E-1
2.0Jarnac1,56127E-11,00622E-18,40297E-41,22829E-18,43873E-14,99160E-18,77171E-18,99378E-1
2.0MathSBML1,56127E-11,00622E-18,40297E-41,22829E-18,43873E-14,99160E-18,77171E-18,99378E-1
2.0Oscill8 Core--8,40297E-4-8,43873E-1-8,77171E-18,99378E-1
2.0SBToolbox21,56090E-11,00602E-18,40194E-41,22766E-18,43910E-14,99160E-18,77234E-18,99398E-1
2.0SBWOdeSolver1,56127E-11,00622E-18,40295E-41,22829E-18,43873E-14,99160E-18,77171E-18,99378E-1
2.0copasi1,56128E-11,00623E-18,40297E-41,22829E-18,43872E-14,99160E-18,77171E-18,99377E-1
2.0edu.kgi.roadRunner1,56127E-11,00622E-18,40297E-41,22829E-18,43873E-14,99160E-18,77171E-18,99378E-1
2.0jsim1,56127E-11,00622E-18,40297E-41,22829E-18,43873E-14,99160E-18,77171E-18,99378E-1
2.0min 1,56090E-1 1,00602E-1 8,40194E-4 1,22766E-1 8,43872E-1 4,99160E-1 8,77171E-1 8,99377E-1
2.0max 1,56128E-1 1,00623E-1 8,40297E-4 1,22829E-1 8,43910E-1 4,99160E-1 8,77234E-1 8,99398E-1
2.0mean 1,56127E-1 1,00622E-1 8,40297E-4 1,22829E-1 8,43873E-1 4,99160E-1 8,77171E-1 8,99378E-1
2.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.2BioUML1,65327E-19,54180E-28,40126E-41,44595E-18,34673E-14,99160E-18,55405E-19,04582E-1
2.2ByoDyn1,65327E-19,54180E-28,40126E-41,44595E-18,34673E-14,99160E-18,55405E-19,04582E-1
2.2CVODE1,65327E-19,54180E-28,40126E-41,44595E-18,34673E-14,99160E-18,55405E-19,04582E-1
2.2Jarnac1,65327E-19,54180E-28,40126E-41,44595E-18,34673E-14,99160E-18,55405E-19,04582E-1
2.2MathSBML1,65327E-19,54180E-28,40126E-41,44595E-18,34673E-14,99160E-18,55405E-19,04582E-1
2.2Oscill8 Core--8,40126E-4-8,34673E-1-8,55405E-19,04582E-1
2.2SBToolbox21,65285E-19,53979E-28,40100E-41,44518E-18,34715E-14,99160E-18,55482E-19,04603E-1
2.2SBWOdeSolver1,65327E-19,54179E-28,40126E-41,44595E-18,34673E-14,99160E-18,55405E-19,04582E-1
2.2copasi1,65328E-19,54192E-28,40126E-41,44595E-18,34672E-14,99160E-18,55405E-19,04581E-1
2.2edu.kgi.roadRunner1,65327E-19,54180E-28,40126E-41,44595E-18,34673E-14,99160E-18,55405E-19,04582E-1
2.2jsim1,65327E-19,54180E-28,40126E-41,44595E-18,34673E-14,99160E-18,55405E-19,04582E-1
2.2min 1,65285E-1 9,53979E-2 8,40100E-4 1,44518E-1 8,34672E-1 4,99160E-1 8,55405E-1 9,04581E-1
2.2max 1,65328E-1 9,54192E-2 8,40126E-4 1,44595E-1 8,34715E-1 4,99160E-1 8,55482E-1 9,04603E-1
2.2mean 1,65327E-1 9,54180E-2 8,40126E-4 1,44595E-1 8,34673E-1 4,99160E-1 8,55405E-1 9,04582E-1
2.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.4BioUML1,73224E-19,04681E-28,40102E-41,66803E-18,26776E-14,99160E-18,33197E-19,09532E-1
2.4ByoDyn1,73224E-19,04681E-28,40102E-41,66803E-18,26776E-14,99160E-18,33197E-19,09532E-1
2.4CVODE1,73224E-19,04681E-28,40102E-41,66803E-18,26776E-14,99160E-18,33197E-19,09532E-1
2.4Jarnac1,73224E-19,04681E-28,40102E-41,66803E-18,26776E-14,99160E-18,33197E-19,09532E-1
2.4MathSBML1,73224E-19,04681E-28,40102E-41,66803E-18,26776E-14,99160E-18,33197E-19,09532E-1
2.4Oscill8 Core--8,40102E-4-8,26776E-1-8,33197E-19,09532E-1
2.4SBToolbox21,73204E-19,04461E-28,40100E-41,66671E-18,26796E-14,99160E-18,33329E-19,09552E-1
2.4SBWOdeSolver1,73224E-19,04681E-28,40099E-41,66802E-18,26776E-14,99160E-18,33198E-19,09532E-1
2.4copasi1,73225E-19,04692E-28,40102E-41,66803E-18,26775E-14,99160E-18,33197E-19,09531E-1
2.4edu.kgi.roadRunner1,73224E-19,04681E-28,40102E-41,66803E-18,26776E-14,99160E-18,33197E-19,09532E-1
2.4jsim1,73224E-19,04681E-28,40102E-41,66803E-18,26776E-14,99160E-18,33197E-19,09532E-1
2.4min 1,73204E-1 9,04461E-2 8,40099E-4 1,66671E-1 8,26775E-1 4,99160E-1 8,33197E-1 9,09531E-1
2.4max 1,73225E-1 9,04692E-2 8,40102E-4 1,66803E-1 8,26796E-1 4,99160E-1 8,33329E-1 9,09552E-1
2.4mean 1,73224E-1 9,04681E-2 8,40102E-4 1,66803E-1 8,26776E-1 4,99160E-1 8,33197E-1 9,09532E-1
2.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.6BioUML1,79926E-18,57618E-28,40099E-41,89239E-18,20074E-14,99160E-18,10761E-19,14238E-1
2.6ByoDyn1,79926E-18,57618E-28,40099E-41,89239E-18,20074E-14,99160E-18,10761E-19,14238E-1
2.6CVODE1,79926E-18,57618E-28,40099E-41,89239E-18,20074E-14,99160E-18,10761E-19,14238E-1
2.6Jarnac1,79926E-18,57618E-28,40099E-41,89239E-18,20074E-14,99160E-18,10761E-19,14238E-1
2.6MathSBML1,79926E-18,57619E-28,40100E-41,89239E-18,20074E-14,99160E-18,10761E-19,14238E-1
2.6Oscill8 Core--8,40099E-4-8,20074E-1-8,10761E-19,14238E-1
2.6SBToolbox21,79909E-18,57398E-28,40100E-41,89089E-18,20091E-14,99160E-18,10911E-19,14260E-1
2.6SBWOdeSolver1,79926E-18,57618E-28,40099E-41,89239E-18,20074E-14,99160E-18,10761E-19,14238E-1
2.6copasi1,79928E-18,57629E-28,40099E-41,89240E-18,20072E-14,99160E-18,10760E-19,14237E-1
2.6edu.kgi.roadRunner1,79926E-18,57618E-28,40099E-41,89239E-18,20074E-14,99160E-18,10761E-19,14238E-1
2.6jsim1,79926E-18,57618E-28,40099E-41,89239E-18,20074E-14,99160E-18,10761E-19,14238E-1
2.6min 1,79909E-1 8,57398E-2 8,40099E-4 1,89089E-1 8,20072E-1 4,99160E-1 8,10760E-1 9,14237E-1
2.6max 1,79928E-1 8,57629E-2 8,40100E-4 1,89240E-1 8,20091E-1 4,99160E-1 8,10911E-1 9,14260E-1
2.6mean 1,79926E-1 8,57618E-2 8,40099E-4 1,89239E-1 8,20074E-1 4,99160E-1 8,10761E-1 9,14238E-1
2.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
2.8BioUML1,85533E-18,12892E-28,40099E-42,11718E-18,14467E-14,99160E-17,88282E-19,18711E-1
2.8ByoDyn1,85533E-18,12892E-28,40099E-42,11718E-18,14467E-14,99160E-17,88282E-19,18711E-1
2.8CVODE1,85533E-18,12892E-28,40099E-42,11718E-18,14467E-14,99160E-17,88282E-19,18711E-1
2.8Jarnac1,85533E-18,12892E-28,40099E-42,11718E-18,14467E-14,99160E-17,88282E-19,18711E-1
2.8MathSBML1,85533E-18,12892E-28,40095E-42,11718E-18,14467E-14,99160E-17,88282E-19,18711E-1
2.8Oscill8 Core--8,40099E-4-8,14467E-1-7,88282E-19,18711E-1
2.8SBToolbox21,85537E-18,12650E-28,40100E-42,11524E-18,14463E-14,99160E-17,88476E-19,18738E-1
2.8SBWOdeSolver1,85533E-18,12891E-28,40097E-42,11718E-18,14467E-14,99160E-17,88282E-19,18711E-1
2.8copasi1,85535E-18,12902E-28,40099E-42,11719E-18,14465E-14,99160E-17,88281E-19,18710E-1
2.8edu.kgi.roadRunner1,85533E-18,12892E-28,40099E-42,11718E-18,14467E-14,99160E-17,88282E-19,18711E-1
2.8jsim1,85533E-18,12892E-28,40099E-42,11718E-18,14467E-14,99160E-17,88282E-19,18711E-1
2.8min 1,85533E-1 8,12650E-2 8,40095E-4 2,11524E-1 8,14463E-1 4,99160E-1 7,88281E-1 9,18710E-1
2.8max 1,85537E-1 8,12902E-2 8,40100E-4 2,11719E-1 8,14467E-1 4,99160E-1 7,88476E-1 9,18738E-1
2.8mean 1,85533E-1 8,12892E-2 8,40099E-4 2,11718E-1 8,14467E-1 4,99160E-1 7,88282E-1 9,18711E-1
2.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.0BioUML1,90136E-17,70403E-28,40099E-42,34080E-18,09864E-14,99160E-17,65920E-19,22960E-1
3.0ByoDyn1,90136E-17,70403E-28,40099E-42,34080E-18,09864E-14,99160E-17,65920E-19,22960E-1
3.0CVODE1,90136E-17,70403E-28,40099E-42,34080E-18,09864E-14,99160E-17,65920E-19,22960E-1
3.0Jarnac1,90136E-17,70403E-28,40099E-42,34080E-18,09864E-14,99160E-17,65920E-19,22960E-1
3.0MathSBML1,90136E-17,70403E-28,40101E-42,34080E-18,09864E-14,99160E-17,65920E-19,22960E-1
3.0Oscill8 Core--8,40099E-4-8,09864E-1-7,65920E-19,22960E-1
3.0SBToolbox21,90137E-17,70164E-28,40100E-42,33877E-18,09863E-14,99160E-17,66123E-19,22987E-1
3.0SBWOdeSolver1,90135E-17,70403E-28,40099E-42,34080E-18,09865E-14,99160E-17,65920E-19,22960E-1
3.0copasi1,90137E-17,70413E-28,40098E-42,34082E-18,09863E-14,99160E-17,65918E-19,22959E-1
3.0edu.kgi.roadRunner1,90136E-17,70403E-28,40099E-42,34080E-18,09864E-14,99160E-17,65920E-19,22960E-1
3.0jsim1,90136E-17,70403E-28,40099E-42,34080E-18,09864E-14,99160E-17,65920E-19,22960E-1
3.0min 1,90135E-1 7,70164E-2 8,40098E-4 2,33877E-1 8,09863E-1 4,99160E-1 7,65918E-1 9,22959E-1
3.0max 1,90137E-1 7,70413E-2 8,40101E-4 2,34082E-1 8,09865E-1 4,99160E-1 7,66123E-1 9,22987E-1
3.0mean 1,90136E-1 7,70403E-2 8,40099E-4 2,34080E-1 8,09864E-1 4,99160E-1 7,65920E-1 9,22960E-1
3.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.2BioUML1,93818E-17,30057E-28,40099E-42,56184E-18,06182E-14,99160E-17,43816E-19,26994E-1
3.2ByoDyn1,93818E-17,30057E-28,40099E-42,56184E-18,06182E-14,99160E-17,43816E-19,26994E-1
3.2CVODE1,93818E-17,30057E-28,40099E-42,56184E-18,06182E-14,99160E-17,43816E-19,26994E-1
3.2Jarnac1,93818E-17,30057E-28,40099E-42,56184E-18,06182E-14,99160E-17,43816E-19,26994E-1
3.2MathSBML1,93818E-17,30057E-28,40099E-42,56185E-18,06182E-14,99160E-17,43815E-19,26994E-1
3.2Oscill8 Core--8,40099E-4-8,06182E-1-7,43816E-19,26994E-1
3.2SBToolbox21,93846E-17,29780E-28,40100E-42,55931E-18,06154E-14,99160E-17,44069E-19,27019E-1
3.2SBWOdeSolver1,93818E-17,30056E-28,40100E-42,56184E-18,06182E-14,99160E-17,43816E-19,26994E-1
3.2copasi1,93820E-17,30066E-28,40098E-42,56187E-18,06180E-14,99160E-17,43813E-19,26993E-1
3.2edu.kgi.roadRunner1,93818E-17,30057E-28,40099E-42,56184E-18,06182E-14,99160E-17,43816E-19,26994E-1
3.2jsim1,93818E-17,30057E-28,40098E-42,56184E-18,06182E-14,99160E-17,43816E-19,26994E-1
3.2min 1,93818E-1 7,29780E-2 8,40098E-4 2,55931E-1 8,06154E-1 4,99160E-1 7,43813E-1 9,26993E-1
3.2max 1,93846E-1 7,30066E-2 8,40100E-4 2,56187E-1 8,06182E-1 4,99160E-1 7,44069E-1 9,27019E-1
3.2mean 1,93818E-1 7,30057E-2 8,40099E-4 2,56184E-1 8,06182E-1 4,99160E-1 7,43816E-1 9,26994E-1
3.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
3.4BioUML1,96658E-16,91760E-28,40099E-42,77909E-18,03342E-14,99160E-17,22091E-19,30824E-1
3.4ByoDyn1,96658E-16,91760E-28,40099E-42,77909E-18,03342E-14,99160E-17,22091E-19,30824E-1
3.4CVODE1,96658E-16,91759E-28,40099E-42,77909E-18,03342E-14,99160E-17,22091E-19,30824E-1
3.4Jarnac1,96658E-16,91760E-28,40099E-42,77909E-18,03342E-14,99160E-17,22091E-19,30824E-1
3.4MathSBML1,96658E-16,91760E-28,40098E-42,77910E-18,03342E-14,99160E-17,22090E-19,30824E-1
3.4Oscill8 Core--8,40099E-4-8,03342E-1-7,22091E-19,30824E-1
3.4SBToolbox21,96676E-16,91496E-28,40100E-42,77666E-18,03324E-14,99160E-17,22334E-19,30849E-1
3.4SBWOdeSolver1,96658E-16,91759E-28,40097E-42,77909E-18,03342E-14,99160E-17,22091E-19,30824E-1
3.4copasi1,96660E-16,91768E-28,40099E-42,77912E-18,03340E-14,99160E-17,22088E-19,30823E-1
3.4edu.kgi.roadRunner1,96658E-16,91760E-28,40099E-42,77909E-18,03342E-14,99160E-17,22091E-19,30824E-1
3.4jsim1,96658E-16,91759E-28,40098E-42,77909E-18,03342E-14,99160E-17,22091E-19,30824E-1
3.4min 1,96658E-1 6,91496E-2 8,40097E-4 2,77666E-1 8,03324E-1 4,99160E-1 7,22088E-1 9,30823E-1
3.4max 1,96676E-1 6,91768E-2 8,40100E-4 2,77912E-1 8,03342E-1 4,99160E-1 7,223