Test: BIOMD0000000086.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000086.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
simulator engine: DormandPrince
generated code: BIOMD0000000086.java
results: CSV file
plots: plot
comparison: comparison with other simulators
status: Ok
simulation time: 0 s.

Parameters:
ZERO 1.0E-15
ATOL 1.0E-17
RTOL 1.0E-14
STEP 1.0E-4

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000086.gif

Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL4822989369.png

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: species_10  species_11  species_14  species_15  species_12  species_13  species_9  species_16  species_7  species_8  species_5  species_6  species_3  species_4  species_2  species_1  species_0  parameter_0  parameter_1 
Simulators: ByoDyn  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  Jarnac  SBToolbox2  VCell  Oscill8 Core  SBWOdeSolver  MathSBML  BioUML 
timeresult species_10 species_11 species_14 species_15 species_12 species_13 species_9 species_16 species_7 species_8 species_5 species_6 species_3 species_4 species_2 species_1 species_0 parameter_0 parameter_1
0.0BioUML0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-40,00000E00,00000E04,68000E-41,00000E-60,00000E01,00000E-80,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0ByoDyn0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-40,00000E00,00000E04,68000E-41,00000E-60,00000E01,00000E-80,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0Jarnac0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-40,00000E00,00000E04,68000E-41,00000E-60,00000E01,00000E-80,00000E0--
0.0MathSBML0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-40,00000E00,00000E04,68000E-41,00000E-60,00000E01,00000E-80,00000E0--
0.0Oscill8 Core0,00000E00,00000E0----0,00000E00,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-4-0,00000E04,68000E-41,00000E-60,00000E01,00000E-80,00000E0--
0.0SBToolbox20,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-40,00000E00,00000E04,68000E-41,00000E-60,00000E01,00000E-80,00000E00,00000E00,00000E0
0.0SBWOdeSolver0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-40,00000E00,00000E04,68000E-41,00000E-60,00000E01,00000E-80,00000E0--
0.0VCell0,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-40,00000E00,00000E04,68000E-41,00000E-60,00000E01,00000E-80,00000E0--
0.0copasi0,00000E00,00000E01,90444E-190,00000E0-2,04047E-19-1,76841E-190,00000E00,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-40,00000E00,00000E04,68000E-41,00000E-60,00000E01,00000E-80,00000E0--
0.0edu.kgi.roadRunner0,00000E00,00000E01,03242E-19-2,19269E-20-8,13152E-20-8,13152E-200,00000E00,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-42,19269E-200,00000E04,68000E-41,00000E-60,00000E01,00000E-80,00000E0--
0.0min 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 -2,19269E-20 -2,04047E-19 -1,76841E-19 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 4,40000E-3 1,49000E-4 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 4,68000E-4 1,00000E-6 0,00000E0 1,00000E-8 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0max 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,90444E-19 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 4,40000E-3 1,49000E-4 2,19269E-20 0,00000E0 4,68000E-4 1,00000E-6 0,00000E0 1,00000E-8 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0mean 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 4,40000E-3 1,49000E-4 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 4,68000E-4 1,00000E-6 0,00000E0 1,00000E-8 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0
0.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.2BioUML7,92337E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,99264E-96,51913E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48998E-47,74108E-115,95825E-144,67992E-49,90077E-70,00000E01,23008E-160,00000E08,00078E-11,04010E-2
0.2ByoDyn7,92337E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,99264E-96,51910E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48998E-47,74108E-115,95826E-144,67992E-49,90077E-70,00000E01,33949E-160,00000E08,00078E-11,04010E-2
0.2Jarnac7,92337E-97,00044E-211,08420E-19-1,21431E-17-8,47033E-221,99264E-96,51910E-121,21431E-174,40000E-31,48998E-47,74108E-115,95825E-144,67992E-49,90077E-71,84483E-281,33949E-161,33442E-19--
0.2MathSBML7,89469E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E02,01639E-96,60208E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48998E-48,22617E-115,94446E-144,67992E-49,90082E-70,00000E01,69520E-150,00000E0--
0.2Oscill8 Core8,65945E-91,62352E-13----5,35802E-12-5,05155E-104,40000E-31,48998E-4--6,47707E-134,67992E-49,90087E-7-1,47582E-145,09836E-127,01488E-11--
0.2SBToolbox27,92784E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E02,11295E-9-9,78151E-110,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-42,50541E-106,56448E-144,67990E-49,90060E-70,00000E0-1,93571E-100,00000E08,17839E-11,06315E-2
0.2SBWOdeSolver7,92337E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,99264E-96,51911E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48998E-47,74107E-115,95826E-144,67992E-49,90077E-70,00000E01,33948E-160,00000E0--
0.2VCell7,92337E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,99264E-96,51911E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48998E-47,74108E-115,95837E-144,67992E-49,90077E-70,00000E01,33639E-160,00000E0--
0.2copasi7,92357E-9-3,38495E-221,47304E-18-1,94275E-181,06234E-191,99243E-96,51849E-123,50204E-194,40000E-31,48998E-47,74159E-115,95871E-144,67992E-49,90077E-71,16353E-241,16010E-16-2,18403E-20--
0.2edu.kgi.roadRunner7,92337E-93,77287E-20-4,97511E-197,02983E-17-5,13727E-171,99264E-96,51910E-12-1,75442E-174,40000E-31,48998E-47,74108E-115,95822E-144,67992E-49,90077E-7-5,86077E-231,33949E-16-6,46988E-19--
0.2min 7,89469E-9 -3,38495E-22 -4,97511E-19 -1,21431E-17 -5,13727E-17 1,99243E-9 -9,78151E-11 -5,05155E-10 4,40000E-3 1,48998E-4 7,74107E-11 -6,47707E-13 4,67990E-4 9,90060E-7 -1,47582E-14 -1,93571E-10 -6,46988E-19 8,00078E-1 1,04010E-2
0.2max 8,65945E-9 1,62352E-13 1,47304E-18 7,02983E-17 1,06234E-19 2,11295E-9 6,60208E-12 1,21431E-17 4,40000E-3 1,49000E-4 2,50541E-10 6,56448E-14 4,67992E-4 9,90087E-7 1,16353E-24 5,09836E-12 7,01488E-11 8,17839E-1 1,06315E-2
0.2mean 7,92337E-9 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,99264E-9 6,51910E-12 0,00000E0 4,40000E-3 1,48998E-4 7,74108E-11 5,95826E-14 4,67992E-4 9,90077E-7 0,00000E0 1,33949E-16 0,00000E0 8,08959E-1 1,05162E-2
0.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.4BioUML8,35241E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,56076E-95,12227E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48998E-48,16544E-114,95754E-144,67992E-49,90082E-70,00000E09,73448E-170,00000E08,43407E-11,09643E-2
0.4ByoDyn8,35241E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,56076E-95,12225E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48998E-48,16544E-114,95754E-144,67992E-49,90082E-70,00000E01,05443E-160,00000E08,43407E-11,09643E-2
0.4Jarnac8,35241E-9-5,29386E-202,16840E-19-2,34188E-17-1,96935E-201,56076E-95,12225E-122,16840E-174,40000E-31,48998E-48,16544E-114,95754E-144,67992E-49,90082E-71,10172E-251,05443E-161,22970E-18--
0.4MathSBML8,30576E-9-2,60682E-31-6,62012E-30-1,92329E-28-2,79430E-311,60565E-95,26810E-12-1,82795E-274,40000E-31,48998E-48,32699E-115,06283E-144,67992E-49,90083E-7-6,65161E-36-2,97117E-17-1,26247E-27--
0.4Oscill8 Core4,80413E-9-1,80257E-12-----5,53675E-132,87730E-94,40000E-31,48999E-4-2,63206E-114,67991E-49,90292E-76,61844E-14-1,94085E-122,35082E-11--
0.4SBToolbox28,31272E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,59917E-93,13521E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-48,61606E-115,13357E-144,67990E-49,90090E-70,00000E0-1,18713E-120,00000E08,39886E-11,09180E-2
0.4SBWOdeSolver8,35241E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,56076E-95,12226E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48998E-48,16544E-114,95754E-144,67992E-49,90082E-70,00000E01,05441E-160,00000E0--
0.4VCell8,35241E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,56076E-95,12225E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48998E-48,16544E-114,95766E-144,67992E-49,90082E-70,00000E01,05528E-160,00000E0--
0.4copasi8,35376E-9-9,90145E-23-1,53672E-19-1,09496E-201,50053E-191,55941E-95,11787E-121,06376E-214,40000E-31,48998E-48,16677E-114,95441E-144,67992E-49,90082E-7-3,20384E-261,05309E-16-2,05509E-20--
0.4edu.kgi.roadRunner8,35241E-9-2,14409E-20-7,22926E-19-3,72248E-173,93935E-171,56076E-95,12225E-12-2,99644E-184,40000E-31,48998E-48,16544E-114,95751E-144,67992E-49,90082E-7-3,38048E-231,05443E-161,89060E-18--
0.4min 4,80413E-9 -1,80257E-12 -7,22926E-19 -3,72248E-17 -1,96935E-20 1,55941E-9 -5,53675E-13 -2,99644E-18 4,40000E-3 1,48998E-4 8,16544E-11 4,95441E-14 4,67990E-4 9,90082E-7 -3,38048E-23 -1,94085E-12 -2,05509E-20 8,39886E-1 1,09180E-2
0.4max 8,35376E-9 0,00000E0 2,16840E-19 0,00000E0 3,93935E-17 1,60565E-9 5,26810E-12 2,87730E-9 4,40000E-3 1,49000E-4 8,61606E-11 2,63206E-11 4,67992E-4 9,90292E-7 6,61844E-14 1,05528E-16 2,35082E-11 8,43407E-1 1,09643E-2
0.4mean 8,35241E-9 -2,60682E-31 0,00000E0 -9,61645E-29 0,00000E0 1,56076E-9 5,12225E-12 0,00000E0 4,40000E-3 1,48998E-4 8,16544E-11 4,95754E-14 4,67992E-4 9,90082E-7 0,00000E0 1,05441E-16 0,00000E0 8,41646E-1 1,09412E-2
0.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.6BioUML8,68292E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,22807E-94,04623E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48999E-48,49235E-114,18665E-144,67991E-49,90085E-70,00000E07,01668E-170,00000E08,76785E-11,13982E-2
0.6ByoDyn8,68292E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,22807E-94,04619E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48999E-48,49235E-114,18665E-144,67991E-49,90085E-70,00000E08,34849E-170,00000E08,76785E-11,13982E-2
0.6Jarnac8,68292E-9-1,25618E-200,00000E0-3,98986E-173,81165E-211,22807E-94,04619E-123,81639E-174,40000E-31,48999E-48,49235E-114,18665E-144,67991E-49,90085E-74,19658E-268,34848E-171,27214E-18--
0.6MathSBML8,56785E-9-1,60862E-30-4,08516E-29-1,18683E-27-1,72431E-301,34059E-94,41119E-12-1,12800E-264,40000E-31,48999E-48,71123E-114,45133E-144,67991E-49,90087E-7-4,10459E-35-1,44183E-16-7,79047E-27--
0.6Oscill8 Core8,61438E-9-5,41138E-14----4,12684E-125,13428E-114,40000E-31,48999E-4-2,49812E-134,67991E-49,90095E-7-1,51602E-16-2,67462E-17-4,38889E-11--
0.6SBToolbox28,66653E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,24697E-99,16827E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-47,43943E-114,08715E-144,67990E-49,90080E-70,00000E02,93540E-120,00000E08,74086E-11,13628E-2
0.6SBWOdeSolver8,68292E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,22807E-94,04621E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48999E-48,49234E-114,18666E-144,67991E-49,90085E-70,00000E08,34442E-170,00000E0--
0.6VCell8,68292E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E01,22807E-94,04620E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48999E-48,49235E-114,18659E-144,67991E-49,90085E-70,00000E08,38446E-170,00000E0--
0.6copasi8,68382E-91,29865E-232,11272E-19-2,27230E-19-1,64799E-201,22716E-94,04327E-121,88200E-204,40000E-31,48999E-48,49322E-114,18427E-144,67991E-49,90085E-71,48613E-258,34322E-17-1,69226E-20--
0.6edu.kgi.roadRunner8,68292E-9-9,23814E-206,28617E-202,55696E-17-4,75804E-171,22807E-94,04620E-121,43425E-174,40000E-31,48999E-48,49235E-114,18663E-144,67991E-49,90085E-71,36296E-238,34849E-178,22283E-18--
0.6min 8,56785E-9 -5,41138E-14 -4,08516E-29 -3,98986E-17 -4,75804E-17 1,22716E-9 4,04327E-12 -1,12800E-26 4,40000E-3 1,48999E-4 7,43943E-11 4,08715E-14 4,67990E-4 9,90080E-7 -1,51602E-16 -1,44183E-16 -4,38889E-11 8,74086E-1 1,13628E-2
0.6max 8,68382E-9 1,29865E-23 2,11272E-19 2,55696E-17 3,81165E-21 1,34059E-9 9,16827E-12 5,13428E-11 4,40000E-3 1,49000E-4 8,71123E-11 2,49812E-13 4,67991E-4 9,90095E-7 1,36296E-23 2,93540E-12 8,22283E-18 8,76785E-1 1,13982E-2
0.6mean 8,68292E-9 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 1,22807E-9 4,04620E-12 0,00000E0 4,40000E-3 1,48999E-4 8,49235E-11 4,18665E-14 4,67991E-4 9,90085E-7 0,00000E0 8,34848E-17 0,00000E0 8,75435E-1 1,13805E-2
0.6relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
0.8BioUML8,93753E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E09,71777E-103,21728E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48999E-48,74417E-113,59280E-144,67991E-49,90087E-70,00000E06,19191E-170,00000E09,02497E-11,17325E-2
0.8ByoDyn8,93753E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E09,71777E-103,21726E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48999E-48,74417E-113,59280E-144,67991E-49,90087E-70,00000E06,65693E-170,00000E09,02497E-11,17325E-2
0.8Jarnac8,93753E-9-9,66933E-214,81482E-331,73472E-18-3,59989E-219,71777E-103,21726E-12-3,46945E-184,40000E-31,48999E-48,74417E-113,59280E-144,67991E-49,90087E-7-3,95149E-276,65693E-171,48367E-18--
0.8MathSBML8,72675E-9-3,71589E-30-9,43667E-29-2,74156E-27-3,98314E-301,18128E-93,89572E-12-2,60566E-264,40000E-31,48999E-48,80396E-114,08157E-144,67991E-49,90088E-7-9,48156E-35-1,10466E-16-1,79959E-26--
0.8Oscill8 Core8,87449E-94,09812E-15----3,30006E-123,41775E-114,40000E-31,48999E-4-3,65780E-144,67991E-49,90087E-71,18258E-196,82815E-17-3,78464E-11--
0.8SBToolbox28,95487E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E09,58591E-101,14551E-110,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-47,02848E-113,31049E-144,67990E-49,90080E-70,00000E04,77890E-120,00000E09,02517E-11,17326E-2
0.8SBWOdeSolver8,93752E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E09,71780E-103,21727E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48999E-48,74417E-113,59281E-144,67991E-49,90087E-70,00000E06,65691E-170,00000E0--
0.8VCell8,93753E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E09,71777E-103,21727E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48999E-48,74417E-113,59287E-144,67991E-49,90087E-70,00000E06,59408E-170,00000E0--
0.8copasi8,93727E-96,11788E-23-3,88477E-208,33336E-20-2,21872E-209,72032E-103,21809E-12-3,59645E-204,40000E-31,48999E-48,74392E-113,59339E-144,67991E-49,90087E-7-5,19274E-266,63516E-17-1,90324E-20--
0.8edu.kgi.roadRunner8,93753E-9-5,57105E-20-5,61175E-19-8,28106E-176,48630E-179,71777E-103,21727E-129,99925E-184,40000E-31,48999E-48,74417E-113,59283E-144,67991E-49,90087E-73,87301E-236,65694E-178,60763E-18--
0.8min 8,72675E-9 -5,57105E-20 -5,61175E-19 -8,28106E-17 -2,21872E-20 9,58591E-10 3,21726E-12 -3,46945E-18 4,40000E-3 1,48999E-4 7,02848E-11 3,31049E-14 4,67990E-4 9,90080E-7 -5,19274E-26 -1,10466E-16 -3,78464E-11 9,02497E-1 1,17325E-2
0.8max 8,95487E-9 4,09812E-15 4,81482E-33 1,73472E-18 6,48630E-17 1,18128E-9 1,14551E-11 3,41775E-11 4,40000E-3 1,49000E-4 8,80396E-11 4,08157E-14 4,67991E-4 9,90088E-7 1,18258E-19 4,77890E-12 8,60763E-18 9,02517E-1 1,17326E-2
0.8mean 8,93753E-9 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 9,71777E-10 3,21727E-12 0,00000E0 4,40000E-3 1,48999E-4 8,74417E-11 3,59283E-14 4,67991E-4 9,90087E-7 0,00000E0 6,65693E-17 0,00000E0 9,02507E-1 1,17326E-2
0.8relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.0BioUML9,13366E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E07,74346E-102,57873E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48999E-48,93816E-113,13534E-144,67991E-49,90089E-70,00000E04,54423E-170,00000E09,22304E-11,19900E-2
1.0ByoDyn9,13366E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E07,74347E-102,57871E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48999E-48,93816E-113,13534E-144,67991E-49,90089E-70,00000E05,35386E-170,00000E09,22304E-11,19900E-2
1.0Jarnac9,13366E-9-1,26531E-20-1,08420E-198,67362E-18-7,62330E-217,74346E-102,57871E-12-1,04083E-174,40000E-31,48999E-48,93816E-113,13534E-144,67991E-49,90089E-71,47879E-265,35386E-171,84174E-18--
1.0MathSBML8,84249E-9-6,14080E-30-1,55948E-28-4,53063E-27-6,58245E-301,06621E-93,52308E-12-4,30606E-264,40000E-31,48999E-48,77474E-113,81295E-144,67991E-49,90088E-7-1,56690E-34-1,47605E-17-2,97396E-26--
1.0Oscill8 Core9,07670E-94,49605E-15----2,65809E-122,94803E-114,40000E-31,49000E-4-3,19244E-144,67990E-49,90089E-71,06363E-195,52002E-17-3,27919E-11--
1.0SBToolbox29,17774E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E07,34070E-109,99619E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-47,38318E-112,80359E-144,67990E-49,90080E-70,00000E04,34344E-120,00000E09,25160E-11,20267E-2
1.0SBWOdeSolver9,13366E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E07,74350E-102,57872E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48999E-48,93816E-113,13535E-144,67991E-49,90089E-70,00000E05,35710E-170,00000E0--
1.0VCell9,13366E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E07,74347E-102,57871E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,48999E-48,93816E-113,13530E-144,67991E-49,90089E-70,00000E05,35041E-170,00000E0--
1.0copasi9,13291E-9-7,51007E-232,47526E-19-1,10367E-19-1,73740E-197,75107E-102,58117E-122,30520E-204,40000E-31,48999E-48,93742E-113,13711E-144,67991E-49,90089E-79,07976E-265,31746E-17-1,95309E-20--
1.0edu.kgi.roadRunner9,13366E-9-1,01373E-19-7,55559E-19-9,84266E-175,73508E-177,74347E-102,57871E-123,14158E-174,40000E-31,48999E-48,93816E-113,13542E-144,67991E-49,90089E-71,17753E-225,35387E-171,04973E-17--
1.0min 8,84249E-9 -1,01373E-19 -7,55559E-19 -9,84266E-17 -1,73740E-19 7,34070E-10 2,57871E-12 -1,04083E-17 4,40000E-3 1,48999E-4 7,38318E-11 2,80359E-14 4,67990E-4 9,90080E-7 -1,56690E-34 -1,47605E-17 -3,27919E-11 9,22304E-1 1,19900E-2
1.0max 9,17774E-9 4,49605E-15 2,47526E-19 8,67362E-18 5,73508E-17 1,06621E-9 9,99619E-12 2,94803E-11 4,40000E-3 1,49000E-4 8,93816E-11 3,81295E-14 4,67991E-4 9,90089E-7 1,06363E-19 4,34344E-12 1,04973E-17 9,25160E-1 1,20267E-2
1.0mean 9,13366E-9 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 7,74347E-10 2,57872E-12 0,00000E0 4,40000E-3 1,48999E-4 8,93816E-11 3,13535E-14 4,67991E-4 9,90089E-7 0,00000E0 5,35386E-17 0,00000E0 9,23732E-1 1,20083E-2
1.0relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.2BioUML9,28475E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E06,22257E-102,08681E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-49,08760E-112,78294E-144,67990E-49,90091E-70,00000E03,78908E-170,00000E09,37563E-11,21883E-2
1.2ByoDyn9,28475E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E06,22258E-102,08680E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-49,08760E-112,78294E-144,67990E-49,90091E-70,00000E04,35006E-170,00000E09,37563E-11,21883E-2
1.2Jarnac9,28475E-9-4,50251E-201,08420E-19-3,03577E-17-1,88465E-206,22257E-102,08680E-122,77556E-174,40000E-31,49000E-49,08760E-112,78294E-144,67990E-49,90091E-79,86391E-264,35006E-172,24692E-18--
1.2MathSBML8,97508E-9-8,44163E-30-2,14379E-28-6,22817E-27-9,04876E-309,33855E-103,09465E-12-5,91945E-264,40000E-31,48999E-48,79315E-113,50482E-144,67991E-49,90088E-7-2,15399E-345,67311E-17-4,08824E-26--
1.2Oscill8 Core9,23370E-93,90147E-15----2,16113E-122,55391E-114,40000E-31,49000E-4-2,83643E-144,67990E-49,90090E-71,07138E-194,50145E-17-2,84068E-11--
1.2SBToolbox29,33514E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E05,73391E-104,79118E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-48,50356E-112,56645E-144,67990E-49,90090E-70,00000E01,62888E-120,00000E09,42016E-11,22459E-2
1.2SBWOdeSolver9,28475E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E06,22259E-102,08680E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-49,08760E-112,78295E-144,67990E-49,90091E-70,00000E04,35004E-170,00000E0--
1.2VCell9,28475E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E06,22258E-102,08680E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-49,08760E-112,78287E-144,67990E-49,90091E-70,00000E04,38288E-170,00000E0--
1.2copasi9,28383E-9-3,18678E-238,88949E-204,66924E-20-1,36382E-196,23189E-102,08981E-12-1,27784E-204,40000E-31,49000E-49,08669E-112,78510E-144,67990E-49,90091E-7-2,14586E-264,36135E-17-1,90681E-20--
1.2edu.kgi.roadRunner9,28475E-9-3,09949E-194,09599E-21-3,66268E-162,38454E-166,22259E-102,08680E-121,14350E-164,40000E-31,49000E-49,08759E-112,78316E-144,67990E-49,90091E-73,59045E-224,35006E-171,42207E-17--
1.2min 8,97508E-9 -3,09949E-19 -2,14379E-28 -3,66268E-16 -1,36382E-19 5,73391E-10 2,08680E-12 -1,27784E-20 4,40000E-3 1,48999E-4 8,50356E-11 2,56645E-14 4,67990E-4 9,90088E-7 -2,14586E-26 4,35004E-17 -2,84068E-11 9,37563E-1 1,21883E-2
1.2max 9,33514E-9 3,90147E-15 1,08420E-19 4,66924E-20 2,38454E-16 9,33855E-10 4,79118E-12 2,55391E-11 4,40000E-3 1,49000E-4 9,08760E-11 3,50482E-14 4,67991E-4 9,90091E-7 1,07138E-19 1,62888E-12 1,42207E-17 9,42016E-1 1,22459E-2
1.2mean 9,28475E-9 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 6,22258E-10 2,08680E-12 0,00000E0 4,40000E-3 1,49000E-4 9,08760E-11 2,78295E-14 4,67990E-4 9,90091E-7 0,00000E0 4,36135E-17 0,00000E0 9,39789E-1 1,22171E-2
1.2relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.4BioUML9,40114E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E05,05097E-101,70787E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-49,20272E-112,51147E-144,67990E-49,90092E-70,00000E03,11126E-170,00000E09,49317E-11,23411E-2
1.4ByoDyn9,40114E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E05,05097E-101,70786E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-49,20272E-112,51147E-144,67990E-49,90092E-70,00000E03,57678E-170,00000E09,49317E-11,23411E-2
1.4Jarnac9,40114E-9-4,25432E-200,00000E0-1,64799E-17-1,71524E-205,05097E-101,70786E-121,30104E-174,40000E-31,49000E-49,20272E-112,51147E-144,67990E-49,90092E-77,42288E-263,57678E-172,74974E-18--
1.4MathSBML9,14773E-9-1,02252E-29-2,59100E-28-7,53742E-27-1,09528E-297,60178E-102,53287E-12-7,15405E-264,40000E-31,48999E-48,95313E-113,10264E-144,67991E-49,90090E-7-2,63649E-345,00422E-17-5,06034E-26--
1.4Oscill8 Core9,35569E-93,37855E-15----1,77627E-122,21203E-114,40000E-31,49000E-4-2,56059E-144,67990E-49,90092E-79,27056E-203,71614E-17-2,46039E-11--
1.4SBToolbox29,43647E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E04,69641E-101,61587E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-49,22204E-112,42323E-144,67990E-49,90090E-70,00000E06,57476E-150,00000E09,52876E-11,23872E-2
1.4SBWOdeSolver9,40114E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E05,05098E-101,70786E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-49,20272E-112,51148E-144,67990E-49,90092E-70,00000E03,57629E-170,00000E0--
1.4VCell9,40114E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E05,05097E-101,70786E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-49,20272E-112,51148E-144,67990E-49,90092E-70,00000E03,58113E-170,00000E0--
1.4copasi9,40019E-9-1,79657E-234,80450E-19-4,23901E-20-4,48479E-195,06053E-101,71095E-12-3,16694E-214,40000E-31,49000E-49,20178E-112,51369E-144,67990E-49,90092E-72,36723E-263,50525E-17-1,88121E-20--
1.4edu.kgi.roadRunner9,40114E-9-5,40785E-19-4,17406E-19-3,56186E-161,76548E-165,05099E-101,70787E-121,44330E-164,40000E-31,49000E-49,20271E-112,51165E-144,67990E-49,90092E-73,72115E-223,57680E-173,62742E-17--
1.4min 9,14773E-9 -5,40785E-19 -4,17406E-19 -3,56186E-16 -4,48479E-19 4,69641E-10 1,61587E-12 -3,16694E-21 4,40000E-3 1,48999E-4 8,95313E-11 2,42323E-14 4,67990E-4 9,90090E-7 -2,63649E-34 3,50525E-17 -2,46039E-11 9,49317E-1 1,23411E-2
1.4max 9,43647E-9 3,37855E-15 4,80450E-19 0,00000E0 1,76548E-16 7,60178E-10 2,53287E-12 2,21203E-11 4,40000E-3 1,49000E-4 9,22204E-11 3,10264E-14 4,67991E-4 9,90092E-7 9,27056E-20 6,57476E-15 3,62742E-17 9,52876E-1 1,23872E-2
1.4mean 9,40114E-9 0,00000E0 0,00000E0 -3,76871E-27 0,00000E0 5,05098E-10 1,70786E-12 0,00000E0 4,40000E-3 1,49000E-4 9,20272E-11 2,51148E-14 4,67990E-4 9,90092E-7 0,00000E0 3,57680E-17 0,00000E0 9,51096E-1 1,23641E-2
1.4relative error(%) 0,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,00
1.6BioUML9,49080E-90,00000E00,00000E00,00000E00,00000E04,14843E-101,41597E-120,00000E04,40000E-31,49000E-4