Test: BIOMD0000000008.xml - Ok

test: BIOMD0000000008.xml
model: xml, reaction graph
plots: plot
comparison: comparison of simulators

Reaction graph

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/publ/BIOMD0000000008.gif

Plots

Note: downloaded from http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/biomodels/models-main/simu/MODEL6614879888.png

Comparison with other simulators

Legend:

Text color indicates difference between values:
  -  no significant difference ( < 0.1%)
  -  small relative error ( > 0.1% and <50%)
  -  simulation results significantly differ ( >50%)

Variables: V3  C  V1  M  Y  X  Z 
Simulators: BioUML  ByoDyn  MathSBML  SBToolbox2  SBWOdeSolver  VCell  copasi  edu.kgi.roadRunner  jsim 
timesimulation V3 C V1 M Y X Z
var error var error var error var error var error var error var error
0.0 BioUML0,00000E00,000,00000E00,000,00000E00,000,00000E00,001,00000E00,000,00000E00,001,00000E00,00
0.0 ByoDyn0,00000E00,000,00000E00,000,00000E00,000,00000E00,001,00000E00,000,00000E00,001,00000E00,00
0.0 MathSBML - - 0,00000E00,00 - - 0,00000E00,001,00000E00,000,00000E00,001,00000E00,00
0.0 SBToolbox20,00000E00,000,00000E00,000,00000E00,000,00000E00,001,00000E00,000,00000E00,001,00000E00,00
0.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 0,00000E00,00 - - 0,00000E00,001,00000E00,000,00000E00,001,00000E00,00
0.0 VCell - - 0,00000E00,00 - - 0,00000E00,001,00000E00,000,00000E00,001,00000E00,00
0.0 copasi - - 0,00000E00,00 - - 0,00000E00,001,00000E00,000,00000E00,001,00000E00,00
0.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 0,00000E00,00 - - 0,00000E00,001,00000E00,000,00000E00,001,00000E00,00
0.0 jsim0,00000E00,000,00000E00,000,00000E00,000,00000E00,001,00000E00,000,00000E00,001,00000E00,00
0.2 BioUML1,68041E-30,003,07170E-20,006,96600E-20,005,60138E-30,001,03998E00,009,38370E-50,009,88822E-10,00
0.2 ByoDyn1,68041E-30,003,07170E-20,006,96600E-20,005,60138E-30,001,03998E00,009,38370E-50,009,88822E-10,00
0.2 MathSBML - - 3,07170E-20,00 - - 5,60139E-30,001,03998E00,009,38383E-50,009,88822E-10,00
0.2 SBToolbox21,67995E-30,003,07166E-20,006,96601E-20,005,59996E-30,001,03996E00,009,42349E-50,419,88821E-10,00
0.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,07170E-20,00 - - 5,60155E-30,001,03998E00,009,38480E-50,009,88822E-10,00
0.2 VCell - - 3,07170E-20,00 - - 5,60138E-30,001,03998E00,009,38370E-50,009,88822E-10,00
0.2 copasi - - 3,07170E-20,00 - - 5,60138E-30,001,03998E00,009,38369E-50,009,88822E-10,00
0.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,07170E-20,00 - - 5,60138E-30,001,03998E00,009,38370E-50,009,88822E-10,00
0.2 jsim1,68041E-30,003,07170E-20,006,96600E-20,005,60138E-30,001,03998E00,009,38370E-50,009,88822E-10,00
0.4 BioUML5,53020E-30,006,08428E-20,001,26460E-10,001,84340E-20,001,07913E00,006,12031E-40,009,78098E-10,00
0.4 ByoDyn5,53020E-30,006,08428E-20,001,26460E-10,001,84340E-20,001,07913E00,006,12031E-40,009,78098E-10,00
0.4 MathSBML - - 6,08428E-20,00 - - 1,84340E-20,001,07913E00,006,12032E-40,009,78098E-10,00
0.4 SBToolbox25,52675E-30,006,08433E-20,001,26457E-10,001,84228E-20,001,07912E00,006,12919E-40,149,78101E-10,00
0.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 6,08428E-20,00 - - 1,84342E-20,001,07913E00,006,12060E-40,009,78098E-10,00
0.4 VCell - - 6,08428E-20,00 - - 1,84340E-20,001,07913E00,006,12031E-40,009,78098E-10,00
0.4 copasi - - 6,08428E-20,00 - - 1,84340E-20,001,07913E00,006,12031E-40,009,78098E-10,00
0.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 6,08428E-20,00 - - 1,84340E-20,001,07913E00,006,12031E-40,009,78098E-10,00
0.4 jsim5,53020E-30,006,08428E-20,001,26460E-10,001,84340E-20,001,07913E00,006,12031E-40,009,78098E-10,00
0.6 BioUML1,05954E-20,009,03222E-20,001,73553E-10,003,53178E-20,001,11743E00,001,72191E-30,009,67838E-10,00
0.6 ByoDyn1,05954E-20,009,03222E-20,001,73553E-10,003,53178E-20,001,11743E00,001,72191E-30,009,67838E-10,00
0.6 MathSBML - - 9,03222E-20,00 - - 3,53178E-20,001,11743E00,001,72191E-30,009,67838E-10,00
0.6 SBToolbox21,05885E-20,009,03225E-20,001,73551E-10,003,52940E-20,001,11739E00,001,72226E-30,009,67840E-10,00
0.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 9,03221E-20,00 - - 3,53180E-20,001,11743E00,001,72195E-30,009,67838E-10,00
0.6 VCell - - 9,03222E-20,00 - - 3,53178E-20,001,11743E00,001,72191E-30,009,67838E-10,00
0.6 copasi - - 9,03222E-20,00 - - 3,53178E-20,001,11743E00,001,72191E-30,009,67838E-10,00
0.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 9,03222E-20,00 - - 3,53178E-20,001,11743E00,001,72191E-30,009,67838E-10,00
0.6 jsim1,05954E-20,009,03222E-20,001,73553E-10,003,53178E-20,001,11743E00,001,72191E-30,009,67838E-10,00
0.8 BioUML1,64906E-20,001,19090E-10,002,13122E-10,005,49688E-20,001,15489E00,003,47254E-30,009,58052E-10,00
0.8 ByoDyn1,64906E-20,001,19090E-10,002,13122E-10,005,49688E-20,001,15489E00,003,47254E-30,009,58052E-10,00
0.8 MathSBML - - 1,19090E-10,00 - - 5,49688E-20,001,15489E00,003,47254E-30,009,58052E-10,00
0.8 SBToolbox21,64791E-20,001,19087E-10,002,13124E-10,005,49309E-20,001,15486E00,003,47106E-30,009,58048E-10,00
0.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,19090E-10,00 - - 5,49690E-20,001,15489E00,003,47260E-30,009,58052E-10,00
0.8 VCell - - 1,19090E-10,00 - - 5,49688E-20,001,15489E00,003,47254E-30,009,58052E-10,00
0.8 copasi - - 1,19090E-10,00 - - 5,49688E-20,001,15489E00,003,47254E-30,009,58052E-10,00
0.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,19090E-10,00 - - 5,49688E-20,001,15489E00,003,47254E-30,009,58052E-10,00
0.8 jsim1,64906E-20,001,19090E-10,002,13122E-10,005,49688E-20,001,15489E00,003,47254E-30,009,58052E-10,00
1.0 BioUML2,30406E-20,001,47079E-10,002,46733E-10,007,68022E-20,001,19151E00,005,87378E-30,009,48747E-10,00
1.0 ByoDyn2,30406E-20,001,47079E-10,002,46733E-10,007,68022E-20,001,19151E00,005,87378E-30,009,48747E-10,00
1.0 MathSBML - - 1,47079E-10,00 - - 7,68022E-20,001,19151E00,005,87378E-30,009,48747E-10,00
1.0 SBToolbox22,30238E-20,001,47082E-10,002,46734E-10,007,67463E-20,001,19152E00,005,86895E-30,009,48745E-10,00
1.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,47079E-10,00 - - 7,68024E-20,001,19151E00,005,87385E-30,009,48747E-10,00
1.0 VCell - - 1,47079E-10,00 - - 7,68022E-20,001,19151E00,005,87378E-30,009,48747E-10,00
1.0 copasi - - 1,47079E-10,00 - - 7,68022E-20,001,19151E00,005,87378E-30,009,48747E-10,00
1.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,47079E-10,00 - - 7,68022E-20,001,19151E00,005,87378E-30,009,48747E-10,00
1.0 jsim2,30406E-20,001,47079E-10,002,46734E-10,007,68022E-20,001,19151E00,005,87378E-30,009,48747E-10,00
1.2 BioUML3,01469E-20,001,74225E-10,002,75542E-10,001,00490E-10,001,22729E00,008,92604E-30,009,39927E-10,00
1.2 ByoDyn3,01469E-20,001,74225E-10,002,75542E-10,001,00490E-10,001,22729E00,008,92604E-30,009,39927E-10,00
1.2 MathSBML - - 1,74225E-10,00 - - 1,00490E-10,001,22729E00,008,92604E-30,009,39927E-10,00
1.2 SBToolbox23,01240E-20,001,74229E-10,002,75539E-10,001,00413E-10,001,22728E00,008,91622E-30,119,39922E-10,00
1.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,74225E-10,00 - - 1,00490E-10,001,22729E00,008,92612E-30,009,39927E-10,00
1.2 VCell - - 1,74225E-10,00 - - 1,00490E-10,001,22729E00,008,92604E-30,009,39927E-10,00
1.2 copasi - - 1,74225E-10,00 - - 1,00490E-10,001,22729E00,008,92604E-30,009,39927E-10,00
1.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,74225E-10,00 - - 1,00490E-10,001,22729E00,008,92604E-30,009,39927E-10,00
1.2 jsim3,01469E-20,001,74225E-10,002,75542E-10,001,00490E-10,001,22729E00,008,92604E-30,009,39927E-10,00
1.4 BioUML3,77406E-20,002,00465E-10,003,00418E-10,001,25802E-10,001,26224E00,001,26313E-20,009,31594E-10,00
1.4 ByoDyn3,77406E-20,002,00465E-10,003,00418E-10,001,25802E-10,001,26224E00,001,26313E-20,009,31594E-10,00
1.4 MathSBML - - 2,00465E-10,00 - - 1,25802E-10,001,26224E00,001,26313E-20,009,31594E-10,00
1.4 SBToolbox23,77113E-20,002,00469E-10,003,00418E-10,001,25707E-10,001,26226E00,001,26149E-20,139,31587E-10,00
1.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 2,00465E-10,00 - - 1,25802E-10,001,26224E00,001,26314E-20,009,31594E-10,00
1.4 VCell - - 2,00465E-10,00 - - 1,25802E-10,001,26224E00,001,26313E-20,009,31594E-10,00
1.4 copasi - - 2,00465E-10,00 - - 1,25802E-10,001,26224E00,001,26313E-20,009,31594E-10,00
1.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 2,00465E-10,00 - - 1,25802E-10,001,26224E00,001,26313E-20,009,31594E-10,00
1.4 jsim3,77406E-20,002,00465E-10,003,00418E-10,001,25802E-10,001,26224E00,001,26313E-20,009,31594E-10,00
1.6 BioUML4,57648E-20,002,25739E-10,003,22031E-10,001,52549E-10,001,29637E00,001,69971E-20,009,23747E-10,00
1.6 ByoDyn4,57648E-20,002,25739E-10,003,22031E-10,001,52549E-10,001,29637E00,001,69971E-20,009,23747E-10,00
1.6 MathSBML - - 2,25739E-10,00 - - 1,52549E-10,001,29637E00,001,69971E-20,009,23747E-10,00
1.6 SBToolbox24,57302E-20,002,25742E-10,003,22028E-10,001,52431E-10,001,29634E00,001,69726E-20,149,23741E-10,00
1.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 2,25739E-10,00 - - 1,52550E-10,001,29637E00,001,69972E-20,009,23747E-10,00
1.6 VCell - - 2,25739E-10,00 - - 1,52549E-10,001,29637E00,001,69971E-20,009,23747E-10,00
1.6 copasi - - 2,25739E-10,00 - - 1,52549E-10,001,29637E00,001,69971E-20,009,23747E-10,00
1.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 2,25739E-10,00 - - 1,52549E-10,001,29637E00,001,69971E-20,009,23747E-10,00
1.6 jsim4,57648E-20,002,25739E-10,003,22031E-10,001,52549E-10,001,29637E00,001,69971E-20,009,23747E-10,00
1.8 BioUML5,41678E-20,002,49987E-10,003,40899E-10,001,80559E-10,001,32968E00,002,20368E-20,009,16384E-10,00
1.8 ByoDyn5,41678E-20,002,49987E-10,003,40899E-10,001,80559E-10,001,32968E00,002,20368E-20,009,16384E-10,00
1.8 MathSBML - - 2,49987E-10,00 - - 1,80559E-10,001,32968E00,002,20368E-20,009,16384E-10,00
1.8 SBToolbox25,41290E-20,002,49988E-10,003,40902E-10,001,80433E-10,001,32969E00,002,20036E-20,159,16375E-10,00
1.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 2,49987E-10,00 - - 1,80560E-10,001,32968E00,002,20369E-20,009,16384E-10,00
1.8 VCell - - 2,49987E-10,00 - - 1,80559E-10,001,32968E00,002,20368E-20,009,16384E-10,00
1.8 copasi - - 2,49987E-10,00 - - 1,80559E-10,001,32968E00,002,20368E-20,009,16384E-10,00
1.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 2,49987E-10,00 - - 1,80559E-10,001,32968E00,002,20368E-20,009,16384E-10,00
1.8 jsim5,41678E-20,002,49987E-10,003,40899E-10,001,80559E-10,001,32968E00,002,20368E-20,009,16384E-10,00
2.0 BioUML6,29003E-20,002,73151E-10,003,57434E-10,002,09668E-10,001,36219E00,002,77696E-20,009,09499E-10,00
2.0 ByoDyn6,29003E-20,002,73151E-10,003,57434E-10,002,09668E-10,001,36219E00,002,77696E-20,009,09499E-10,00
2.0 MathSBML - - 2,73151E-10,00 - - 2,09668E-10,001,36219E00,002,77696E-20,009,09499E-10,00
2.0 SBToolbox26,28592E-20,002,73162E-10,003,57436E-10,002,09534E-10,001,36218E00,002,77244E-20,169,09486E-10,00
2.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 2,73151E-10,00 - - 2,09669E-10,001,36219E00,002,77698E-20,009,09499E-10,00
2.0 VCell - - 2,73151E-10,00 - - 2,09668E-10,001,36219E00,002,77696E-20,009,09499E-10,00
2.0 copasi - - 2,73151E-10,00 - - 2,09668E-10,001,36219E00,002,77696E-20,009,09499E-10,00
2.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 2,73151E-10,00 - - 2,09668E-10,001,36219E00,002,77696E-20,009,09499E-10,00
2.0 jsim6,29003E-20,002,73151E-10,003,57434E-10,002,09668E-10,001,36219E00,002,77696E-20,009,09499E-10,00
2.2 BioUML7,19142E-20,002,95175E-10,003,71960E-10,002,39714E-10,001,39392E00,003,42190E-20,009,03086E-10,00
2.2 ByoDyn7,19142E-20,002,95175E-10,003,71960E-10,002,39714E-10,001,39392E00,003,42190E-20,009,03086E-10,00
2.2 MathSBML - - 2,95175E-10,00 - - 2,39714E-10,001,39392E00,003,42190E-20,009,03086E-10,00
2.2 SBToolbox27,18695E-20,002,95185E-10,003,71968E-10,002,39566E-10,001,39395E00,003,41632E-20,169,03068E-10,00
2.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 2,95175E-10,00 - - 2,39715E-10,001,39392E00,003,42192E-20,009,03086E-10,00
2.2 VCell - - 2,95175E-10,00 - - 2,39714E-10,001,39392E00,003,42190E-20,009,03086E-10,00
2.2 copasi - - 2,95175E-10,00 - - 2,39714E-10,001,39392E00,003,42190E-20,009,03086E-10,00
2.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 2,95175E-10,00 - - 2,39714E-10,001,39392E00,003,42190E-20,009,03086E-10,00
2.2 jsim7,19142E-20,002,95175E-10,003,71960E-10,002,39714E-10,001,39392E00,003,42190E-20,009,03086E-10,00
2.4 BioUML8,11623E-20,003,16000E-10,003,84740E-10,002,70541E-10,001,42487E00,004,14116E-20,008,97134E-10,00
2.4 ByoDyn8,11623E-20,003,16000E-10,003,84740E-10,002,70541E-10,001,42487E00,004,14116E-20,008,97134E-10,00
2.4 MathSBML - - 3,16000E-10,00 - - 2,70541E-10,001,42487E00,004,14116E-20,008,97134E-10,00
2.4 SBToolbox28,11139E-20,003,16008E-10,003,84746E-10,002,70378E-10,001,42492E00,004,13423E-20,178,97117E-10,00
2.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,16000E-10,00 - - 2,70542E-10,001,42487E00,004,14119E-20,008,97134E-10,00
2.4 VCell - - 3,16000E-10,00 - - 2,70541E-10,001,42487E00,004,14116E-20,008,97134E-10,00
2.4 copasi - - 3,16000E-10,00 - - 2,70541E-10,001,42487E00,004,14115E-20,008,97134E-10,00
2.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,16000E-10,00 - - 2,70541E-10,001,42487E00,004,14116E-20,008,97134E-10,00
2.4 jsim8,11623E-20,003,16000E-10,003,84740E-10,002,70541E-10,001,42487E00,004,14116E-20,008,97134E-10,00
2.6 BioUML9,05976E-20,003,35570E-10,003,95987E-10,003,01992E-10,001,45508E00,004,93755E-20,008,91632E-10,00
2.6 ByoDyn9,05976E-20,003,35570E-10,003,95987E-10,003,01992E-10,001,45508E00,004,93755E-20,008,91632E-10,00
2.6 MathSBML - - 3,35570E-10,00 - - 3,01992E-10,001,45508E00,004,93755E-20,008,91632E-10,00
2.6 SBToolbox29,05502E-20,003,35586E-10,003,95995E-10,003,01837E-10,001,45511E00,004,92906E-20,178,91610E-10,00
2.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,35570E-10,00 - - 3,01993E-10,001,45508E00,004,93759E-20,008,91632E-10,00
2.6 VCell - - 3,35570E-10,00 - - 3,01992E-10,001,45508E00,004,93755E-20,008,91632E-10,00
2.6 copasi - - 3,35570E-10,00 - - 3,01992E-10,001,45508E00,004,93754E-20,008,91632E-10,00
2.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,35570E-10,00 - - 3,01992E-10,001,45508E00,004,93755E-20,008,91632E-10,00
2.6 jsim9,05976E-20,003,35570E-10,003,95987E-10,003,01992E-10,001,45508E00,004,93755E-20,008,91632E-10,00
2.8 BioUML1,00173E-10,003,53827E-10,004,05872E-10,003,33911E-10,001,48456E00,005,81391E-20,008,86566E-10,00
2.8 ByoDyn1,00173E-10,003,53827E-10,004,05872E-10,003,33911E-10,001,48456E00,005,81391E-20,008,86566E-10,00
2.8 MathSBML - - 3,53827E-10,00 - - 3,33911E-10,001,48456E00,005,81391E-20,008,86566E-10,00
2.8 SBToolbox21,00124E-10,003,53844E-10,004,05881E-10,003,33739E-10,001,48458E00,005,80408E-20,178,86537E-10,00
2.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,53827E-10,00 - - 3,33912E-10,001,48456E00,005,81395E-20,008,86566E-10,00
2.8 VCell - - 3,53827E-10,00 - - 3,33911E-10,001,48456E00,005,81391E-20,008,86566E-10,00
2.8 copasi - - 3,53827E-10,00 - - 3,33911E-10,001,48456E00,005,81390E-20,008,86566E-10,00
2.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,53827E-10,00 - - 3,33911E-10,001,48456E00,005,81391E-20,008,86566E-10,00
2.8 jsim1,00173E-10,003,53827E-10,004,05872E-10,003,33911E-10,001,48456E00,005,81391E-20,008,86566E-10,00
3.0 BioUML1,09843E-10,003,70714E-10,004,14536E-10,003,66143E-10,001,51333E00,006,77294E-20,008,81918E-10,00
3.0 ByoDyn1,09843E-10,003,70714E-10,004,14536E-10,003,66143E-10,001,51333E00,006,77294E-20,008,81918E-10,00
3.0 MathSBML - - 3,70714E-10,00 - - 3,66143E-10,001,51333E00,006,77294E-20,008,81918E-10,00
3.0 SBToolbox21,09793E-10,003,70737E-10,004,14550E-10,003,65967E-10,001,51338E00,006,76120E-20,178,81889E-10,00
3.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,70713E-10,00 - - 3,66144E-10,001,51333E00,006,77299E-20,008,81918E-10,00
3.0 VCell - - 3,70714E-10,00 - - 3,66143E-10,001,51333E00,006,77294E-20,008,81918E-10,00
3.0 copasi - - 3,70714E-10,00 - - 3,66143E-10,001,51333E00,006,77293E-20,008,81918E-10,00
3.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,70714E-10,00 - - 3,66143E-10,001,51333E00,006,77294E-20,008,81918E-10,00
3.0 jsim1,09843E-10,003,70714E-10,004,14536E-10,003,66143E-10,001,51333E00,006,77294E-20,008,81918E-10,00
3.2 BioUML1,19559E-10,003,86172E-10,004,22094E-10,003,98531E-10,001,54142E00,007,81708E-20,008,77672E-10,00
3.2 ByoDyn1,19559E-10,003,86172E-10,004,22094E-10,003,98531E-10,001,54142E00,007,81708E-20,008,77672E-10,00
3.2 MathSBML - - 3,86172E-10,00 - - 3,98531E-10,001,54142E00,007,81708E-20,008,77672E-10,00
3.2 SBToolbox21,19506E-10,003,86206E-10,004,22108E-10,003,98362E-10,001,54145E00,007,80352E-20,178,77644E-10,00
3.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,86171E-10,00 - - 3,98532E-10,001,54142E00,007,81713E-20,008,77672E-10,00
3.2 VCell - - 3,86172E-10,00 - - 3,98531E-10,001,54142E00,007,81708E-20,008,77672E-10,00
3.2 copasi - - 3,86172E-10,00 - - 3,98531E-10,001,54142E00,007,81708E-20,008,77672E-10,00
3.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,86172E-10,00 - - 3,98531E-10,001,54142E00,007,81708E-20,008,77672E-10,00
3.2 jsim1,19559E-10,003,86172E-10,004,22094E-10,003,98531E-10,001,54142E00,007,81708E-20,008,77672E-10,00
3.4 BioUML1,29275E-10,004,00145E-10,004,28638E-10,004,30918E-10,001,56886E00,008,94834E-20,008,73805E-10,00
3.4 ByoDyn1,29275E-10,004,00145E-10,004,28638E-10,004,30918E-10,001,56886E00,008,94834E-20,008,73805E-10,00
3.4 MathSBML - - 4,00145E-10,00 - - 4,30918E-10,001,56886E00,008,94835E-20,008,73805E-10,00
3.4 SBToolbox21,29223E-10,004,00186E-10,004,28658E-10,004,30733E-10,001,56892E00,008,93274E-20,178,73771E-10,00
3.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,00144E-10,00 - - 4,30918E-10,001,56886E00,008,94839E-20,008,73805E-10,00
3.4 VCell - - 4,00145E-10,00 - - 4,30918E-10,001,56886E00,008,94834E-20,008,73805E-10,00
3.4 copasi - - 4,00145E-10,00 - - 4,30918E-10,001,56886E00,008,94834E-20,008,73805E-10,00
3.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,00145E-10,00 - - 4,30918E-10,001,56886E00,008,94834E-20,008,73805E-10,00
3.4 jsim1,29275E-10,004,00145E-10,004,28638E-10,004,30918E-10,001,56886E00,008,94834E-20,008,73805E-10,00
3.6 BioUML1,38943E-10,004,12575E-10,004,34244E-10,004,63143E-10,001,59568E00,001,01682E-10,008,70296E-10,00
3.6 ByoDyn1,38943E-10,004,12575E-10,004,34244E-10,004,63143E-10,001,59568E00,001,01682E-10,008,70296E-10,00
3.6 MathSBML - - 4,12575E-10,00 - - 4,63143E-10,001,59568E00,001,01682E-10,008,70296E-10,00
3.6 SBToolbox21,38894E-10,004,12631E-10,004,34266E-10,004,62980E-10,001,59573E00,001,01503E-10,188,70258E-10,00
3.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,12575E-10,00 - - 4,63143E-10,001,59568E00,001,01683E-10,008,70297E-10,00
3.6 VCell - - 4,12575E-10,00 - - 4,63143E-10,001,59568E00,001,01682E-10,008,70296E-10,00
3.6 copasi - - 4,12576E-10,00 - - 4,63143E-10,001,59568E00,001,01682E-10,008,70296E-10,00
3.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,12575E-10,00 - - 4,63143E-10,001,59568E00,001,01682E-10,008,70296E-10,00
3.6 jsim1,38943E-10,004,12575E-10,004,34244E-10,004,63143E-10,001,59568E00,001,01682E-10,008,70296E-10,00
3.8 BioUML1,48513E-10,004,23409E-10,004,38973E-10,004,95044E-10,001,62190E00,001,14775E-10,008,67121E-10,00
3.8 ByoDyn1,48513E-10,004,23409E-10,004,38973E-10,004,95044E-10,001,62190E00,001,14775E-10,008,67121E-10,00
3.8 MathSBML - - 4,23409E-10,00 - - 4,95044E-10,001,62190E00,001,14775E-10,008,67121E-10,00
3.8 SBToolbox21,48458E-10,004,23470E-10,004,38996E-10,004,94866E-10,001,62191E00,001,14575E-10,178,67077E-10,00
3.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,23409E-10,00 - - 4,95044E-10,001,62190E00,001,14775E-10,008,67121E-10,00
3.8 VCell - - 4,23409E-10,00 - - 4,95044E-10,001,62190E00,001,14775E-10,008,67121E-10,00
3.8 copasi - - 4,23410E-10,00 - - 4,95044E-10,001,62190E00,001,14775E-10,008,67121E-10,00
3.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,23409E-10,00 - - 4,95044E-10,001,62190E00,001,14775E-10,008,67121E-10,00
3.8 jsim1,48513E-10,004,23409E-10,004,38973E-10,004,95044E-10,001,62190E00,001,14775E-10,008,67121E-10,00
4.0 BioUML1,57937E-10,004,32593E-10,004,42872E-10,005,26457E-10,001,64755E00,001,28762E-10,008,64251E-10,00
4.0 ByoDyn1,57937E-10,004,32593E-10,004,42872E-10,005,26457E-10,001,64755E00,001,28762E-10,008,64251E-10,00
4.0 MathSBML - - 4,32593E-10,00 - - 5,26457E-10,001,64755E00,001,28762E-10,008,64251E-10,00
4.0 SBToolbox21,57892E-10,004,32672E-10,004,42902E-10,005,26306E-10,001,64758E00,001,28542E-10,178,64206E-10,00
4.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,32593E-10,00 - - 5,26457E-10,001,64755E00,001,28763E-10,008,64252E-10,00
4.0 VCell - - 4,32593E-10,00 - - 5,26457E-10,001,64755E00,001,28762E-10,008,64251E-10,00
4.0 copasi - - 4,32594E-10,00 - - 5,26457E-10,001,64755E00,001,28762E-10,008,64251E-10,00
4.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,32593E-10,00 - - 5,26457E-10,001,64755E00,001,28762E-10,008,64251E-10,00
4.0 jsim1,57937E-10,004,32593E-10,004,42872E-10,005,26457E-10,001,64755E00,001,28762E-10,008,64251E-10,00
4.2 BioUML1,67164E-10,004,40077E-10,004,45978E-10,005,57212E-10,001,67268E00,001,43636E-10,008,61660E-10,00
4.2 ByoDyn1,67164E-10,004,40077E-10,004,45978E-10,005,57212E-10,001,67268E00,001,43636E-10,008,61660E-10,00
4.2 MathSBML - - 4,40077E-10,00 - - 5,57212E-10,001,67268E00,001,43636E-10,008,61660E-10,00
4.2 SBToolbox21,67117E-10,004,40161E-10,004,46011E-10,005,57062E-10,001,67275E00,001,43387E-10,178,61605E-10,00
4.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,40077E-10,00 - - 5,57213E-10,001,67268E00,001,43637E-10,008,61660E-10,00
4.2 VCell - - 4,40077E-10,00 - - 5,57212E-10,001,67268E00,001,43636E-10,008,61660E-10,00
4.2 copasi - - 4,40077E-10,00 - - 5,57212E-10,001,67268E00,001,43636E-10,008,61660E-10,00
4.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,40077E-10,00 - - 5,57212E-10,001,67268E00,001,43636E-10,008,61660E-10,00
4.2 jsim1,67164E-10,004,40077E-10,004,45978E-10,005,57212E-10,001,67268E00,001,43636E-10,008,61660E-10,00
4.4 BioUML1,76142E-10,004,45814E-10,004,48316E-10,005,87140E-10,001,69731E00,001,59379E-10,008,59317E-10,00
4.4 ByoDyn1,76142E-10,004,45814E-10,004,48316E-10,005,87140E-10,001,69731E00,001,59379E-10,008,59317E-10,00
4.4 MathSBML - - 4,45814E-10,00 - - 5,87140E-10,001,69731E00,001,59379E-10,008,59317E-10,00
4.4 SBToolbox21,76102E-10,004,45914E-10,004,48356E-10,005,86999E-10,001,69737E00,001,59108E-10,178,59258E-10,00
4.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,45813E-10,00 - - 5,87141E-10,001,69731E00,001,59379E-10,008,59318E-10,00
4.4 VCell - - 4,45814E-10,00 - - 5,87140E-10,001,69731E00,001,59379E-10,008,59317E-10,00
4.4 copasi - - 4,45814E-10,00 - - 5,87141E-10,001,69731E00,001,59379E-10,008,59317E-10,00
4.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,45814E-10,00 - - 5,87140E-10,001,69731E00,001,59379E-10,008,59317E-10,00
4.4 jsim1,76142E-10,004,45814E-10,004,48316E-10,005,87140E-10,001,69731E00,001,59379E-10,008,59317E-10,00
4.6 BioUML1,84820E-10,004,49762E-10,004,49905E-10,006,16068E-10,001,72148E00,001,75962E-10,008,57191E-10,00
4.6 ByoDyn1,84820E-10,004,49762E-10,004,49905E-10,006,16068E-10,001,72148E00,001,75962E-10,008,57191E-10,00
4.6 MathSBML - - 4,49762E-10,00 - - 6,16068E-10,001,72148E00,001,75962E-10,008,57191E-10,00
4.6 SBToolbox21,84792E-10,004,49881E-10,004,49952E-10,006,15967E-10,001,72155E00,001,75669E-10,178,57126E-10,00
4.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,49761E-10,00 - - 6,16068E-10,001,72148E00,001,75963E-10,008,57191E-10,00
4.6 VCell - - 4,49762E-10,00 - - 6,16068E-10,001,72148E00,001,75962E-10,008,57191E-10,00
4.6 copasi - - 4,49762E-10,00 - - 6,16068E-10,001,72148E00,001,75962E-10,008,57191E-10,00
4.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,49762E-10,00 - - 6,16068E-10,001,72148E00,001,75962E-10,008,57191E-10,00
4.6 jsim1,84820E-10,004,49762E-10,004,49905E-10,006,16068E-10,001,72148E00,001,75962E-10,008,57191E-10,00
4.8 BioUML1,93147E-10,004,51884E-10,004,50752E-10,006,43822E-10,001,74524E00,001,93348E-10,008,55247E-10,00
4.8 ByoDyn1,93147E-10,004,51884E-10,004,50752E-10,006,43822E-10,001,74524E00,001,93348E-10,008,55247E-10,00
4.8 MathSBML - - 4,51884E-10,00 - - 6,43822E-10,001,74524E00,001,93348E-10,008,55247E-10,00
4.8 SBToolbox21,93113E-10,004,52011E-10,004,50806E-10,006,43712E-10,001,74532E00,001,93018E-10,178,55173E-10,00
4.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,51883E-10,00 - - 6,43823E-10,001,74524E00,001,93349E-10,008,55247E-10,00
4.8 VCell - - 4,51884E-10,00 - - 6,43822E-10,001,74524E00,001,93348E-10,008,55247E-10,00
4.8 copasi - - 4,51884E-10,00 - - 6,43823E-10,001,74524E00,001,93348E-10,008,55247E-10,00
4.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,51884E-10,00 - - 6,43822E-10,001,74524E00,001,93348E-10,008,55247E-10,00
4.8 jsim1,93147E-10,004,51884E-10,004,50752E-10,006,43822E-10,001,74524E00,001,93348E-10,008,55247E-10,00
5.0 BioUML2,01070E-10,004,52150E-10,004,50857E-10,006,70232E-10,001,76861E00,002,11489E-10,008,53452E-10,00
5.0 ByoDyn2,01070E-10,004,52150E-10,004,50857E-10,006,70232E-10,001,76861E00,002,11489E-10,008,53452E-10,00
5.0 MathSBML - - 4,52149E-10,00 - - 6,70232E-10,001,76861E00,002,11489E-10,008,53452E-10,00
5.0 SBToolbox22,01065E-10,004,52305E-10,004,50920E-10,006,70215E-10,001,76870E00,002,11150E-10,168,53385E-10,00
5.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,52149E-10,00 - - 6,70233E-10,001,76861E00,002,11489E-10,008,53452E-10,00
5.0 VCell - - 4,52150E-10,00 - - 6,70232E-10,001,76861E00,002,11489E-10,008,53452E-10,00
5.0 copasi - - 4,52150E-10,00 - - 6,70232E-10,001,76861E00,002,11489E-10,008,53452E-10,00
5.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,52150E-10,00 - - 6,70232E-10,001,76861E00,002,11489E-10,008,53452E-10,00
5.0 jsim2,01070E-10,004,52150E-10,004,50857E-10,006,70232E-10,001,76861E00,002,11489E-10,008,53452E-10,00
5.2 BioUML2,08539E-10,004,50537E-10,004,50214E-10,006,95132E-10,001,79164E00,002,30324E-10,008,51770E-10,00
5.2 ByoDyn2,08539E-10,004,50537E-10,004,50214E-10,006,95132E-10,001,79164E00,002,30324E-10,008,51770E-10,00
5.2 MathSBML - - 4,50536E-10,00 - - 6,95132E-10,001,79164E00,002,30324E-10,008,51770E-10,00
5.2 SBToolbox22,08543E-10,004,50718E-10,004,50286E-10,006,95131E-10,001,79173E00,002,29946E-10,168,51692E-10,00
5.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,50536E-10,00 - - 6,95132E-10,001,79164E00,002,30324E-10,008,51770E-10,00
5.2 VCell - - 4,50537E-10,00 - - 6,95132E-10,001,79164E00,002,30324E-10,008,51770E-10,00
5.2 copasi - - 4,50537E-10,00 - - 6,95132E-10,001,79164E00,002,30324E-10,008,51770E-10,00
5.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,50537E-10,00 - - 6,95132E-10,001,79164E00,002,30324E-10,008,51770E-10,00
5.2 jsim2,08539E-10,004,50536E-10,004,50214E-10,006,95132E-10,001,79164E00,002,30324E-10,008,51770E-10,00
5.4 BioUML2,15509E-10,004,47030E-10,004,48807E-10,007,18364E-10,001,81436E00,002,49784E-10,008,50163E-10,00
5.4 ByoDyn2,15509E-10,004,47030E-10,004,48807E-10,007,18364E-10,001,81436E00,002,49784E-10,008,50163E-10,00
5.4 MathSBML - - 4,47030E-10,00 - - 7,18364E-10,001,81436E00,002,49784E-10,008,50163E-10,00
5.4 SBToolbox22,15516E-10,004,47234E-10,004,48889E-10,007,18385E-10,001,81445E00,002,49375E-10,168,50073E-10,00
5.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,47029E-10,00 - - 7,18365E-10,001,81436E00,002,49785E-10,008,50163E-10,00
5.4 VCell - - 4,47030E-10,00 - - 7,18364E-10,001,81436E00,002,49784E-10,008,50163E-10,00
5.4 copasi - - 4,47030E-10,00 - - 7,18365E-10,001,81436E00,002,49784E-10,008,50163E-10,00
5.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,47030E-10,00 - - 7,18364E-10,001,81436E00,002,49784E-10,008,50163E-10,00
5.4 jsim2,15509E-10,004,47030E-10,004,48807E-10,007,18364E-10,001,81436E00,002,49784E-10,008,50163E-10,00
5.6 BioUML2,21937E-10,004,41625E-10,004,46612E-10,007,39790E-10,001,83683E00,002,69792E-10,008,48595E-10,00
5.6 ByoDyn2,21937E-10,004,41625E-10,004,46612E-10,007,39790E-10,001,83683E00,002,69792E-10,008,48595E-10,00
5.6 MathSBML - - 4,41625E-10,00 - - 7,39789E-10,001,83683E00,002,69792E-10,008,48595E-10,00
5.6 SBToolbox22,21976E-10,004,41854E-10,004,46703E-10,007,39929E-10,001,83688E00,002,69394E-10,158,48515E-10,00
5.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,41624E-10,00 - - 7,39790E-10,001,83683E00,002,69792E-10,008,48595E-10,00
5.6 VCell - - 4,41625E-10,00 - - 7,39790E-10,001,83683E00,002,69792E-10,008,48595E-10,00
5.6 copasi - - 4,41625E-10,00 - - 7,39790E-10,001,83683E00,002,69792E-10,008,48595E-10,00
5.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,41625E-10,00 - - 7,39790E-10,001,83683E00,002,69792E-10,008,48595E-10,00
5.6 jsim2,21937E-10,004,41625E-10,004,46612E-10,007,39790E-10,001,83683E00,002,69792E-10,008,48595E-10,00
5.8 BioUML2,27786E-10,004,34325E-10,004,43596E-10,007,59286E-10,001,85907E00,002,90259E-10,008,47026E-10,00
5.8 ByoDyn2,27786E-10,004,34325E-10,004,43596E-10,007,59286E-10,001,85907E00,002,90259E-10,008,47026E-10,00
5.8 MathSBML - - 4,34325E-10,00 - - 7,59286E-10,001,85907E00,002,90259E-10,008,47026E-10,00
5.8 SBToolbox22,27838E-10,004,34598E-10,004,43709E-10,007,59461E-10,001,85916E00,002,89803E-10,168,46926E-10,00
5.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,34324E-10,00 - - 7,59287E-10,001,85907E00,002,90259E-10,008,47026E-10,00
5.8 VCell - - 4,34325E-10,00 - - 7,59286E-10,001,85907E00,002,90259E-10,008,47026E-10,00
5.8 copasi - - 4,34325E-10,00 - - 7,59286E-10,001,85907E00,002,90259E-10,008,47026E-10,00
5.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,34325E-10,00 - - 7,59286E-10,001,85907E00,002,90259E-10,008,47026E-10,00
5.8 jsim2,27786E-10,004,34325E-10,004,43596E-10,007,59286E-10,001,85907E00,002,90259E-10,008,47026E-10,00
6.0 BioUML2,33028E-10,004,25147E-10,004,39718E-10,007,76761E-10,001,88113E00,003,11093E-10,008,45419E-10,00
6.0 ByoDyn2,33028E-10,004,25147E-10,004,39718E-10,007,76761E-10,001,88113E00,003,11093E-10,008,45419E-10,00
6.0 MathSBML - - 4,25147E-10,00 - - 7,76761E-10,001,88113E00,003,11093E-10,008,45419E-10,00
6.0 SBToolbox22,33090E-10,004,25456E-10,004,39852E-10,007,76962E-10,001,88124E00,003,10610E-10,168,45314E-10,00
6.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,25146E-10,00 - - 7,76761E-10,001,88113E00,003,11093E-10,008,45419E-10,00
6.0 VCell - - 4,25147E-10,00 - - 7,76761E-10,001,88113E00,003,11093E-10,008,45419E-10,00
6.0 copasi - - 4,25147E-10,00 - - 7,76761E-10,001,88113E00,003,11093E-10,008,45419E-10,00
6.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,25147E-10,00 - - 7,76761E-10,001,88113E00,003,11093E-10,008,45419E-10,00
6.0 jsim2,33028E-10,004,25147E-10,004,39718E-10,007,76761E-10,001,88113E00,003,11093E-10,008,45419E-10,00
6.2 BioUML2,37645E-10,004,14116E-10,004,34925E-10,007,92150E-10,001,90305E00,003,32195E-10,008,43733E-10,00
6.2 ByoDyn2,37645E-10,004,14116E-10,004,34925E-10,007,92150E-10,001,90305E00,003,32195E-10,008,43733E-10,00
6.2 MathSBML - - 4,14116E-10,00 - - 7,92150E-10,001,90305E00,003,32195E-10,008,43733E-10,00
6.2 SBToolbox22,37734E-10,004,14436E-10,004,35067E-10,007,92454E-10,001,90312E00,003,31743E-10,148,43646E-10,00
6.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,14115E-10,00 - - 7,92150E-10,001,90305E00,003,32195E-10,008,43733E-10,00
6.2 VCell - - 4,14116E-10,00 - - 7,92150E-10,001,90305E00,003,32195E-10,008,43733E-10,00
6.2 copasi - - 4,14116E-10,00 - - 7,92149E-10,001,90305E00,003,32195E-10,008,43733E-10,00
6.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,14116E-10,00 - - 7,92150E-10,001,90305E00,003,32195E-10,008,43733E-10,00
6.2 jsim2,37645E-10,004,14116E-10,004,34925E-10,007,92150E-10,001,90305E00,003,32195E-10,008,43733E-10,00
6.4 BioUML2,41627E-10,004,01271E-10,004,29154E-10,008,05424E-10,001,92487E00,003,53464E-10,008,41930E-10,00
6.4 ByoDyn2,41627E-10,004,01271E-10,004,29154E-10,008,05424E-10,001,92487E00,003,53464E-10,008,41930E-10,00
6.4 MathSBML - - 4,01271E-10,00 - - 8,05424E-10,001,92487E00,003,53464E-10,008,41930E-10,00
6.4 SBToolbox22,41745E-10,004,01655E-10,004,29328E-10,008,05803E-10,001,92500E00,003,52962E-10,148,41828E-10,00
6.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,01270E-10,00 - - 8,05424E-10,001,92487E00,003,53464E-10,008,41930E-10,00
6.4 VCell - - 4,01271E-10,00 - - 8,05424E-10,001,92487E00,003,53464E-10,008,41930E-10,00
6.4 copasi - - 4,01271E-10,00 - - 8,05424E-10,001,92487E00,003,53464E-10,008,41930E-10,00
6.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,01271E-10,00 - - 8,05424E-10,001,92487E00,003,53464E-10,008,41930E-10,00
6.4 jsim2,41627E-10,004,01271E-10,004,29154E-10,008,05424E-10,001,92487E00,003,53464E-10,008,41930E-10,00
6.6 BioUML2,44976E-10,003,86662E-10,004,22328E-10,008,16588E-10,001,94663E00,003,74798E-10,008,39972E-10,00
6.6 ByoDyn2,44976E-10,003,86662E-10,004,22328E-10,008,16588E-10,001,94663E00,003,74798E-10,008,39972E-10,00
6.6 MathSBML - - 3,86662E-10,00 - - 8,16588E-10,001,94663E00,003,74798E-10,008,39972E-10,00
6.6 SBToolbox22,45101E-10,003,87108E-10,124,22544E-10,008,17013E-10,001,94677E00,003,74254E-10,158,39856E-10,00
6.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,86662E-10,00 - - 8,16587E-10,001,94663E00,003,74798E-10,008,39972E-10,00
6.6 VCell - - 3,86662E-10,00 - - 8,16588E-10,001,94663E00,003,74798E-10,008,39972E-10,00
6.6 copasi - - 3,86662E-10,00 - - 8,16587E-10,001,94663E00,003,74798E-10,008,39972E-10,00
6.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,86662E-10,00 - - 8,16588E-10,001,94663E00,003,74798E-10,008,39972E-10,00
6.6 jsim2,44976E-10,003,86662E-10,004,22328E-10,008,16588E-10,001,94663E00,003,74798E-10,008,39972E-10,00
6.8 BioUML2,47702E-10,003,70353E-10,004,14356E-10,008,25674E-10,001,96837E00,003,96096E-10,008,37820E-10,00
6.8 ByoDyn2,47702E-10,003,70353E-10,004,14356E-10,008,25674E-10,001,96837E00,003,96096E-10,008,37820E-10,00
6.8 MathSBML - - 3,70353E-10,00 - - 8,25674E-10,001,96837E00,003,96096E-10,008,37820E-10,00
6.8 SBToolbox22,47838E-10,003,70775E-10,114,14566E-10,008,26121E-10,001,96845E00,003,95619E-10,128,37732E-10,00
6.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,70352E-10,00 - - 8,25673E-10,001,96837E00,003,96096E-10,008,37820E-10,00
6.8 VCell - - 3,70353E-10,00 - - 8,25674E-10,001,96837E00,003,96096E-10,008,37820E-10,00
6.8 copasi - - 3,70353E-10,00 - - 8,25673E-10,001,96837E00,003,96096E-10,008,37820E-10,00
6.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,70353E-10,00 - - 8,25674E-10,001,96837E00,003,96096E-10,008,37820E-10,00
6.8 jsim2,47702E-10,003,70353E-10,004,14356E-10,008,25674E-10,001,96837E00,003,96096E-10,008,37820E-10,00
7.0 BioUML2,49821E-10,003,52419E-10,004,05129E-10,008,32736E-10,001,99012E00,004,17260E-10,008,35437E-10,00
7.0 ByoDyn2,49821E-10,003,52419E-10,004,05129E-10,008,32736E-10,001,99012E00,004,17260E-10,008,35437E-10,00
7.0 MathSBML - - 3,52419E-10,00 - - 8,32736E-10,001,99012E00,004,17260E-10,008,35437E-10,00
7.0 SBToolbox22,49980E-10,003,52898E-10,144,05383E-10,008,33273E-10,001,99023E00,004,16768E-10,128,35351E-10,00
7.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,52418E-10,00 - - 8,32733E-10,001,99012E00,004,17259E-10,008,35437E-10,00
7.0 VCell - - 3,52419E-10,00 - - 8,32736E-10,001,99012E00,004,17260E-10,008,35437E-10,00
7.0 copasi - - 3,52419E-10,00 - - 8,32735E-10,001,99012E00,004,17259E-10,008,35437E-10,00
7.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,52419E-10,00 - - 8,32736E-10,001,99012E00,004,17260E-10,008,35437E-10,00
7.0 jsim2,49821E-10,003,52419E-10,004,05129E-10,008,32736E-10,001,99012E00,004,17260E-10,008,35437E-10,00
7.2 BioUML2,51350E-10,003,32948E-10,003,94520E-10,008,37835E-10,002,01192E00,004,38194E-10,008,32787E-10,00
7.2 ByoDyn2,51350E-10,003,32948E-10,003,94520E-10,008,37835E-10,002,01192E00,004,38194E-10,008,32787E-10,00
7.2 MathSBML - - 3,32948E-10,00 - - 8,37835E-10,002,01192E00,004,38194E-10,008,32787E-10,00
7.2 SBToolbox22,51547E-10,003,33530E-10,173,94850E-10,008,38489E-10,002,01201E00,004,37648E-10,128,32681E-10,00
7.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,32947E-10,00 - - 8,37831E-10,002,01192E00,004,38193E-10,008,32787E-10,00
7.2 VCell - - 3,32948E-10,00 - - 8,37835E-10,002,01192E00,004,38194E-10,008,32787E-10,00
7.2 copasi - - 3,32948E-10,00 - - 8,37834E-10,002,01192E00,004,38193E-10,008,32787E-10,00
7.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,32948E-10,00 - - 8,37835E-10,002,01192E00,004,38194E-10,008,32787E-10,00
7.2 jsim2,51350E-10,003,32948E-10,003,94520E-10,008,37835E-10,002,01192E00,004,38194E-10,008,32787E-10,00
7.4 BioUML2,52309E-10,003,12043E-10,003,82379E-10,008,41030E-10,002,03382E00,004,58808E-10,008,29836E-10,00
7.4 ByoDyn2,52309E-10,003,12043E-10,003,82379E-10,008,41030E-10,002,03382E00,004,58808E-10,008,29836E-10,00
7.4 MathSBML - - 3,12043E-10,00 - - 8,41030E-10,002,03382E00,004,58808E-10,008,29836E-10,00
7.4 SBToolbox22,52528E-10,003,12687E-10,213,82761E-10,008,41759E-10,002,03389E00,004,58248E-10,128,29728E-10,00
7.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,12043E-10,00 - - 8,41025E-10,002,03382E00,004,58807E-10,008,29836E-10,00
7.4 VCell - - 3,12043E-10,00 - - 8,41030E-10,002,03382E00,004,58808E-10,008,29836E-10,00
7.4 copasi - - 3,12043E-10,00 - - 8,41030E-10,002,03382E00,004,58807E-10,008,29836E-10,00
7.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,12043E-10,00 - - 8,41030E-10,002,03382E00,004,58808E-10,008,29836E-10,00
7.4 jsim2,52309E-10,003,12043E-10,003,82379E-10,008,41030E-10,002,03382E00,004,58808E-10,008,29836E-10,00
7.6 BioUML2,52708E-10,002,89823E-10,003,68529E-10,008,42360E-10,002,05583E00,004,79014E-10,008,26549E-10,00
7.6 ByoDyn2,52708E-10,002,89823E-10,003,68529E-10,008,42360E-10,002,05583E00,004,79014E-10,008,26549E-10,00
7.6 MathSBML - - 2,89823E-10,00 - - 8,42360E-10,002,05583E00,004,79014E-10,008,26549E-10,00
7.6 SBToolbox22,52962E-10,102,90356E-10,183,68872E-10,008,43207E-10,102,05586E00,004,78550E-10,008,26477E-10,00
7.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 2,89823E-10,00 - - 8,42356E-10,002,05583E00,004,79014E-10,008,26549E-10,00
7.6 VCell - - 2,89823E-10,00 - - 8,42360E-10,002,05583E00,004,79014E-10,008,26549E-10,00
7.6 copasi - - 2,89823E-10,00 - - 8,42360E-10,002,05583E00,004,79014E-10,008,26549E-10,00
7.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 2,89823E-10,00 - - 8,42360E-10,002,05583E00,004,79014E-10,008,26549E-10,00
7.6 jsim2,52708E-10,002,89823E-10,003,68529E-10,008,42360E-10,002,05583E00,004,79014E-10,008,26549E-10,00
7.8 BioUML2,52550E-10,002,66422E-10,003,52770E-10,008,41832E-10,002,07798E00,004,98731E-10,008,22897E-10,00
7.8 ByoDyn2,52550E-10,002,66422E-10,003,52770E-10,008,41832E-10,002,07798E00,004,98731E-10,008,22897E-10,00
7.8 MathSBML - - 2,66422E-10,00 - - 8,41832E-10,002,07798E00,004,98731E-10,008,22897E-10,00
7.8 SBToolbox22,52843E-10,122,67026E-10,233,53187E-10,128,42805E-10,122,07804E00,004,98266E-10,008,22828E-10,00
7.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 2,66422E-10,00 - - 8,41828E-10,002,07799E00,004,98731E-10,008,22897E-10,00
7.8 VCell - - 2,66422E-10,00 - - 8,41832E-10,002,07798E00,004,98731E-10,008,22897E-10,00
7.8 copasi - - 2,66422E-10,00 - - 8,41833E-10,002,07798E00,004,98731E-10,008,22897E-10,00
7.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 2,66422E-10,00 - - 8,41832E-10,002,07798E00,004,98731E-10,008,22897E-10,00
7.8 jsim2,52550E-10,002,66422E-10,003,52770E-10,008,41832E-10,002,07798E00,004,98731E-10,008,22897E-10,00
8.0 BioUML2,51822E-10,002,41998E-10,003,34869E-10,008,39405E-10,002,10032E00,005,17878E-10,008,18851E-10,00
8.0 ByoDyn2,51822E-10,002,41998E-10,003,34869E-10,008,39405E-10,002,10032E00,005,17878E-10,008,18851E-10,00
8.0 MathSBML - - 2,41998E-10,00 - - 8,39406E-10,002,10032E00,005,17878E-10,008,18851E-10,00
8.0 SBToolbox22,52160E-10,132,42720E-10,303,35420E-10,168,40528E-10,132,10042E00,005,17388E-10,008,18778E-10,00
8.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 2,41998E-10,00 - - 8,39402E-10,002,10032E00,005,17877E-10,008,18850E-10,00
8.0 VCell - - 2,41998E-10,00 - - 8,39405E-10,002,10032E00,005,17878E-10,008,18851E-10,00
8.0 copasi - - 2,41998E-10,00 - - 8,39406E-10,002,10032E00,005,17877E-10,008,18851E-10,00
8.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 2,41998E-10,00 - - 8,39405E-10,002,10032E00,005,17878E-10,008,18851E-10,00
8.0 jsim2,51822E-10,002,41998E-10,003,34869E-10,008,39405E-10,002,10032E00,005,17878E-10,008,18851E-10,00
8.2 BioUML2,50494E-10,002,16733E-10,003,14572E-10,008,34979E-10,002,12285E00,005,36373E-10,008,14385E-10,00
8.2 ByoDyn2,50494E-10,002,16733E-10,003,14572E-10,008,34979E-10,002,12285E00,005,36373E-10,008,14385E-10,00
8.2 MathSBML - - 2,16733E-10,00 - - 8,34979E-10,002,12285E00,005,36373E-10,008,14385E-10,00
8.2 SBToolbox22,50916E-10,172,17438E-10,323,15166E-10,198,36375E-10,172,12290E00,005,35904E-10,008,14327E-10,00
8.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 2,16734E-10,00 - - 8,34976E-10,002,12285E00,005,36373E-10,008,14385E-10,00
8.2 VCell - - 2,16733E-10,00 - - 8,34979E-10,002,12285E00,005,36373E-10,008,14385E-10,00
8.2 copasi - - 2,16733E-10,00 - - 8,34980E-10,002,12285E00,005,36373E-10,008,14385E-10,00
8.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 2,16733E-10,00 - - 8,34979E-10,002,12285E00,005,36373E-10,008,14385E-10,00
8.2 jsim2,50494E-10,002,16733E-10,003,14572E-10,008,34979E-10,002,12285E00,005,36373E-10,008,14385E-10,00
8.4 BioUML2,48514E-10,001,90847E-10,002,91609E-10,008,28380E-10,002,14561E00,005,54136E-10,008,09478E-10,00
8.4 ByoDyn2,48514E-10,001,90847E-10,002,91609E-10,008,28380E-10,002,14561E00,005,54136E-10,008,09478E-10,00
8.4 MathSBML - - 1,90847E-10,00 - - 8,28380E-10,002,14561E00,005,54136E-10,008,09478E-10,00
8.4 SBToolbox22,48981E-10,191,91472E-10,332,92195E-10,208,29929E-10,192,14568E00,005,53749E-10,008,09438E-10,00
8.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,90849E-10,00 - - 8,28377E-10,002,14561E00,005,54136E-10,008,09478E-10,00
8.4 VCell - - 1,90847E-10,00 - - 8,28380E-10,002,14561E00,005,54136E-10,008,09478E-10,00
8.4 copasi - - 1,90848E-10,00 - - 8,28380E-10,002,14561E00,005,54136E-10,008,09478E-10,00
8.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,90847E-10,00 - - 8,28380E-10,002,14561E00,005,54136E-10,008,09478E-10,00
8.4 jsim2,48514E-10,001,90847E-10,002,91609E-10,008,28380E-10,002,14561E00,005,54136E-10,008,09478E-10,00
8.6 BioUML2,45805E-10,001,64611E-10,002,65724E-10,008,19350E-10,002,16859E00,005,71082E-10,008,04114E-10,00
8.6 ByoDyn2,45805E-10,001,64611E-10,002,65724E-10,008,19350E-10,002,16859E00,005,71082E-10,008,04114E-10,00
8.6 MathSBML - - 1,64611E-10,00 - - 8,19350E-10,002,16859E00,005,71082E-10,008,04114E-10,00
8.6 SBToolbox22,46289E-10,201,65265E-10,402,66407E-10,268,20969E-10,202,16857E00,005,70735E-10,008,04091E-10,00
8.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,64613E-10,00 - - 8,19348E-10,002,16859E00,005,71082E-10,008,04114E-10,00
8.6 VCell - - 1,64611E-10,00 - - 8,19350E-10,002,16859E00,005,71082E-10,008,04114E-10,00
8.6 copasi - - 1,64612E-10,00 - - 8,19351E-10,002,16859E00,005,71082E-10,008,04114E-10,00
8.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,64611E-10,00 - - 8,19350E-10,002,16859E00,005,71082E-10,008,04114E-10,00
8.6 jsim2,45805E-10,001,64611E-10,002,65724E-10,008,19350E-10,002,16859E00,005,71082E-10,008,04114E-10,00
8.8 BioUML2,42263E-10,001,38369E-10,002,36734E-10,008,07543E-10,002,19182E00,005,87120E-10,007,98281E-10,00
8.8 ByoDyn2,42263E-10,001,38369E-10,002,36734E-10,008,07543E-10,002,19182E00,005,87120E-10,007,98281E-10,00
8.8 MathSBML - - 1,38369E-10,00 - - 8,07543E-10,002,19182E00,005,87120E-10,007,98281E-10,00
8.8 SBToolbox22,42796E-10,221,38933E-10,412,37386E-10,288,09320E-10,222,19184E00,005,86844E-10,007,98274E-10,00
8.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,38372E-10,00 - - 8,07542E-10,002,19182E00,005,87120E-10,007,98282E-10,00
8.8 VCell - - 1,38369E-10,00 - - 8,07543E-10,002,19182E00,005,87120E-10,007,98281E-10,00
8.8 copasi - - 1,38370E-10,00 - - 8,07544E-10,002,19182E00,005,87120E-10,007,98282E-10,00
8.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,38369E-10,00 - - 8,07543E-10,002,19182E00,005,87120E-10,007,98281E-10,00
8.8 jsim2,42263E-10,001,38369E-10,002,36734E-10,008,07543E-10,002,19182E00,005,87120E-10,007,98281E-10,00
9.0 BioUML2,37758E-10,001,12583E-10,002,04656E-10,007,92528E-10,002,21529E00,006,02152E-10,007,91980E-10,00
9.0 ByoDyn2,37758E-10,001,12583E-10,002,04656E-10,007,92528E-10,002,21529E00,006,02152E-10,007,91980E-10,00
9.0 MathSBML - - 1,12583E-10,00 - - 7,92528E-10,002,21529E00,006,02152E-10,007,91980E-10,00
9.0 SBToolbox22,38315E-10,231,13092E-10,452,05322E-10,337,94376E-10,232,21531E00,006,01943E-10,007,91987E-10,00
9.0 SBWOdeSolver - - 1,12586E-10,00 - - 7,92527E-10,002,21529E00,006,02151E-10,007,91980E-10,00
9.0 VCell - - 1,12583E-10,00 - - 7,92528E-10,002,21529E00,006,02152E-10,007,91980E-10,00
9.0 copasi - - 1,12584E-10,00 - - 7,92529E-10,002,21529E00,006,02151E-10,007,91980E-10,00
9.0 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 1,12583E-10,00 - - 7,92528E-10,002,21529E00,006,02152E-10,007,91980E-10,00
9.0 jsim2,37758E-10,001,12583E-10,002,04656E-10,007,92528E-10,002,21529E00,006,02152E-10,007,91980E-10,00
9.2 BioUML2,32147E-10,008,78919E-20,001,69941E-10,007,73822E-10,002,23899E00,006,16068E-10,007,85218E-10,00
9.2 ByoDyn2,32147E-10,008,78919E-20,001,69941E-10,007,73822E-10,002,23899E00,006,16068E-10,007,85218E-10,00
9.2 MathSBML - - 8,78918E-20,00 - - 7,73822E-10,002,23899E00,006,16068E-10,007,85218E-10,00
9.2 SBToolbox22,32725E-10,258,83200E-20,481,70577E-10,377,75738E-10,252,23900E00,006,15933E-10,007,85242E-10,00
9.2 SBWOdeSolver - - 8,78946E-20,00 - - 7,73822E-10,002,23899E00,006,16067E-10,007,85218E-10,00
9.2 VCell - - 8,78919E-20,00 - - 7,73822E-10,002,23899E00,006,16068E-10,007,85218E-10,00
9.2 copasi - - 8,78928E-20,00 - - 7,73824E-10,002,23899E00,006,16068E-10,007,85219E-10,00
9.2 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 8,78919E-20,00 - - 7,73822E-10,002,23899E00,006,16068E-10,007,85218E-10,00
9.2 jsim2,32147E-10,008,78919E-20,001,69941E-10,007,73822E-10,002,23899E00,006,16068E-10,007,85218E-10,00
9.4 BioUML2,25294E-10,006,52048E-20,001,33907E-10,007,50980E-10,002,26290E00,006,28752E-10,007,78025E-10,00
9.4 ByoDyn2,25294E-10,006,52048E-20,001,33907E-10,007,50980E-10,002,26290E00,006,28752E-10,007,78025E-10,00
9.4 MathSBML - - 6,52048E-20,00 - - 7,50980E-10,002,26290E00,006,28752E-10,007,78025E-10,00
9.4 SBToolbox22,25888E-10,266,55137E-20,471,34431E-10,397,52965E-10,262,26287E00,006,28687E-10,007,78058E-10,00
9.4 SBWOdeSolver - - 6,52071E-20,00 - - 7,50981E-10,002,26290E00,006,28751E-10,007,78025E-10,00
9.4 VCell - - 6,52048E-20,00 - - 7,50980E-10,002,26290E00,006,28752E-10,007,78025E-10,00
9.4 copasi - - 6,52052E-20,00 - - 7,50982E-10,002,26290E00,006,28752E-10,007,78025E-10,00
9.4 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 6,52048E-20,00 - - 7,50980E-10,002,26290E00,006,28752E-10,007,78025E-10,00
9.4 jsim2,25294E-10,006,52048E-20,001,33907E-10,007,50980E-10,002,26290E00,006,28752E-10,007,78025E-10,00
9.6 BioUML2,17133E-10,004,57795E-20,009,92962E-20,007,23777E-10,002,28694E00,006,40083E-10,007,70453E-10,00
9.6 ByoDyn2,17133E-10,004,57795E-20,009,92962E-20,007,23777E-10,002,28694E00,006,40083E-10,007,70453E-10,00
9.6 MathSBML - - 4,57795E-20,00 - - 7,23777E-10,002,28694E00,006,40083E-10,007,70453E-10,00
9.6 SBToolbox22,17752E-10,294,59503E-20,379,96167E-20,327,25831E-10,282,28695E00,006,40101E-10,007,70494E-10,00
9.6 SBWOdeSolver - - 4,57810E-20,00 - - 7,23778E-10,002,28694E00,006,40083E-10,007,70453E-10,00
9.6 VCell - - 4,57795E-20,00 - - 7,23777E-10,002,28694E00,006,40083E-10,007,70453E-10,00
9.6 copasi - - 4,57798E-20,00 - - 7,23779E-10,002,28694E00,006,40083E-10,007,70453E-10,00
9.6 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 4,57795E-20,00 - - 7,23777E-10,002,28694E00,006,40083E-10,007,70453E-10,00
9.6 jsim2,17133E-10,004,57795E-20,009,92962E-20,007,23777E-10,002,28694E00,006,40083E-10,007,70453E-10,00
9.8 BioUML2,07745E-10,003,10564E-20,007,03576E-20,006,92484E-10,002,31105E00,006,49953E-10,007,62587E-10,00
9.8 ByoDyn2,07745E-10,003,10564E-20,007,03576E-20,006,92484E-10,002,31105E00,006,49953E-10,007,62587E-10,00
9.8 MathSBML - - 3,10565E-20,00 - - 6,92484E-10,002,31105E00,006,49953E-10,007,62587E-10,00
9.8 SBToolbox22,08370E-10,303,11170E-20,197,04814E-20,186,94567E-10,302,31102E00,006,50039E-10,007,62632E-10,00
9.8 SBWOdeSolver - - 3,10573E-20,00 - - 6,92486E-10,002,31105E00,006,49953E-10,007,62587E-10,00
9.8 VCell - - 3,10564E-20,00 - - 6,92484E-10,002,31105E00,006,49953E-10,007,62587E-10,00
9.8 copasi - - 3,10567E-20,00 - - 6,92486E-10,002,31105E00,006,49953E-10,007,62587E-10,00
9.8 edu.kgi.roadRunner - - 3,10564E-20,00 - - 6,92484E-10,002,31105E00,006,49953E-10,007,62587E-10,00
9.8 jsim2,07745E-10,003,10564E-20,007,03576E-20,006,92484E-10,002,31105E00,006,49953E-10,007,62587E-10,00
Max relative error0,30 0,48 0,39 0,30 0,00 0,41 0,00